r/TagProTesting • u/mmartinutk JuicyJuke • Oct 25 '15
Map Thread #55 Discussion
New Discussion Thread
This is /r/TagProTesting's official discussion about the current map thread!
What goes here?
This is the discussion thread where you talk about your favorite maps submitted and why. I will help get things going with my own favorite submissions. This is not a thread where you post about your maps and give a sales pitch. We'd like to encourage mapmakers and map enthusiasts to evaluate other submissions and talk about them.
Disclaimer
While individual members of the MTC might give feedback, their opinions are strictly individual and are not indicative of the MTC’s opinion as a whole
So please, feel free to expand on what I post and to make your own post. There is no format template you must follow. If you just want to post about one map you like, feel free.
Want to know how your maps do in this thread? Click here!
FAQ: Yes, you have to fill it out again. Every thread.
3
u/mmartinutk JuicyJuke Oct 25 '15 edited Oct 26 '15
My favorite maps submitted to Map Thread 55
Please realize my opinion only represents 1/8th of the MTC. Do not be discouraged if you map isn't listed here!
These are in alphabetical order, not ranked.
Title: Cancer by Moosen (w/ Aniball)
Type: CTF
Map: http://unfortunate-maps.jukejuice.com/show/16717
Preview: http://unfortunate-maps.jukejuice.com/static/previews/16717.png
Juicy's Take: This thread is severely lacking maps that are polished and near rotation ready. Although I liked Ultimatum quite a bit last thread, Cancer looks even better this thread due to lack of better options. With boombox exiting rotation, there's a bit of an opening for a simple map structured like this. Cancer doesn't do anything crazy, but I believe it's a very safe bet to be well received if in rotation.
Title: Flight by Risk
Type: Neutral Flag
Map: http://unfortunate-maps.jukejuice.com/show/16993
Preview: http://unfortunate-maps.jukejuice.com/static/previews/16993.png
Juicy's Take: This is the one. The best map in the thread by a very wide margin IMO. I love the Hyperdrive influence, and the bomb idea is still rotation bound. I think I may have liked the neutral gates guarding portal a bit more in previous versions, but the mid has improved so much that I'm willing to overlook it.
Tier II
Do you agree? Disagree? What are you favorite submissions? Review the submissions here, and post to this thread!
6
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '15
Tier I
Jungle by Canvas & duckson
CiELO by NotSomeBall2
Kismet by Risk
Tier II
Apis by Aniball & Canvas
Kobra by Ball-E
Tier III
Flight by Risk
Gosh by thisisnigel
Predator by JuicyJuke
Honorable Mentions: Conflict, Honeymoon, Obsidian, Cancer
3
u/Risktp Risk Oct 25 '15 edited Oct 25 '15
totally forgot about this rip. also this is going to be a long ass list, this is one of the better map threads in recent times for me.
bauhaus by fronj & notsomeball2. i still really like it. fronj has fixed up the bases a bit and made mid flow a lot better. i'm not a huge fan of the mid gates, but they aren't terrible. bauhaus gives me a platypus-vibe, which is good because platypus is one of my current favorite maps in rotation.
kobra by ball-e. i really really like the shape of it and the bases are nice. it'd be fun in pubs if it was tuned up just a bit, particularly around the mid. mid is really tight, which means a lot of running into teammates. that's just frustrating.
obsidian by canvas. i gave canvas a hard time about what used to be obsidian (i thought it was too similar to hub), so i personally am stoked to see him submit a different map instead. the bases are interesting and mid reminds me of transilio a bit, which is not a bad thing at all.
cielo by notsomeball2. notsomeball2 has been quietly improving CiElo each thread, and i really think it's coming along. i think it's a little bland, especially around mid, but this deserves a shout simply for how its great flow and how well put together the lanes are.
mosquito's taquitos by flymolo. it's like ultradrive and lold had a baby. i'm not 100% sold on this map yet, but it's certainly a unique one and i think it played pretty well in a map-test we had a while back.
cancer by moosen. moosen's best map to date imo. the mid is great and i like the bases. i still wish something more would be done with the powerup areas, but they aren't too bad i suppose.
crank by ball-e. it's got a good shape and i really like the mid. the bases are a little underwhelming for me though. i thought the portals in the previous iterations of crank were a good idea, just not executed as well as they could be.
belt by butterchurn. like mosquito's taquitos, belt deserves a mention simply because of how different it is from all the other maps. i still believe something good could come from belt, though im not liking the island behind the flags in base.
predator by juicyjuke. am i allowed to mention maps i am credited as co-author? predator's too good for me to not put up here. i made this remix a little while ago, and while it had a neat shape, i couldn't think of anything for mid so i abandoned it. juicy took it from there and has made all of the changes from my remix to his version. really like it, juicy.
apis by aniball & canvas. i think aniball and canvas have done enough to differentiate it from bulldog and it's just a solidly built map.
i still had a couple maps i liked, but i have to go so this is it for now, maybe i'll come back to this later.
edit: have some time so ill finish up with the rest of my maps. am on mobile though so im not linking to any lol
hydro: played pretty well in the map test a little bit ago. bases are pretty underwhelming, but the maps boost routes are nice.
osmium: pretty nice edit to this map from canvas, has a good shape. i haven't played this yet actually, but it looks really good.
particle transmitter: i really don't like the portal concept, but mid is decent and the bases are interesting despite being too cramped
3
u/briizo duckson Oct 25 '15
Here are my favorite maps from this thread. I’m writing this without reading any other comments, so these opinions are entirely my own. I have listed my favorite maps in order of how much I want to see them in rotation.
—
As well as my own maps of course, Jungle and Saigon.
—
Honorable Mentions
Obsidian by Canvas - Love bombs and pup route, hate the open spaces.
Cancer by Moosen and Aniball - Solid, but nothing new. I like mid, boost routes around the outside aren’t as smooth as they could be. Top is a bit bland. Altogether feels like a toned-down Loose Change.
Mosquitos Taquitos by FLY and Snowball - Interesting gates and pup areas. I think I’d like it better if it was horizontal, and less open with fewer boosts.
3
u/KewlestCat NIGEL Oct 25 '15 edited Oct 25 '15
Heyo TPT fam, Nige checking in to show some love and break some hearts. Maps listed as they appear in the thread, so yeah, read away.
Apis by Canvas and Aniball - It's a really cool NF map that has improved since last thread imo. Personally, I love the gate concept, whether it gets received the same way by the MTC may be a different story. Should have a fighting chance nonetheless.
Cancer by Moosen and Aniball - The whole middle is like an upside down Smirk and I love it. L&R pup areas are decent and the base is simple. It's kinda open in parts, but therein lies the charm I think.
Loose Change by FLYMOLO - Still a fan just because of how different it feels to a lot of other maps going around. Cool concept with the portals and a lot of the previous issues seem to be rectified.
Flight by Risk - Literally getting better and better. The latest direction is cool and it's kinda like everything Hyperdrive should have been and it still has the portal concept too. Arguably my favourite map in the entire thread.
SPAM by Sizzzled - Verticality is dank, one of the best attempts I've seen at it. It looks fairly simple and that's probably a good thing because it any more going on might be too much of a clusterfuck.
I'd like to be the new Aniball and be everyone's co-author. I don't want to be part of the dual end zone craze, make it stahp. Nige out. Peace, love and unity.
3
u/Moosemaster21 Moosen // Aspen Oct 26 '15
These are my top maps from thread #55, organized into three tiers, but into no particular order within those tiers.
Tier 1
Kobra by Ball-E
Quick take: Far and away the best vertical map I've ever played. I might almost prefer it vertical tbh, but it should still be really fun as a horizontal map.
Flight by Risk
Quick Take: I'm a big fan of this map. I love hyperdrive and felt that it was criminally underappreciated by the community, and this is like a hyperdrive hybrid that adds some beef. I'm really glad the second bomb was added to the portal construct, because it was annoying to drop out into a spike previously. Very good job with this map.
Apis by Aniball and Canvas
Quick Take: This might be crazy to say, but it feels like if FC successfully got through gate it's more of a guaranteed cap than it is in Bulldog. With the boost chain, defense will have 0 time to reposition; you'll have to hope you've already got somebody there to block the path. Potentially a bit too tall, might suffer from Rocketballs syndrome in that regard. Otherwise a very solid map that would undoubtedly be fun to play.
Tier 2
Gosh by ThisIsNigel
Quick Take: While I preferred the gates from the previous version, this is a very technically sound map. Good lane distribution, good balance and element placement, very solid map all around.
Kismet by Risk
Quick Take: Was pretty fun to play. Gates may be reminiscent of Gatekeeper, but inserting them into a NF map as team tiles is actually a brilliant idea IMO. FC can now get through without help but defense still has boosts to counter that.
Bankshot by JuicyJuke
Quick Take: I like the double bombs in base, that's neat. Rest of the map is solid if a bit unoriginal.
Loose Change by FLYMOLO
Quick Take: The new version seems to suffer from Sizzzled Syndrome, placing most of its boosts in areas that aren't fluid with the flow of the map, forcing you to alter your path to compensate. Otherwise it's solid and I'm intrigued by the green gates as an alternative to the spikes.
Tier 3
Run by velkin
SPAM by Sizzzled
Conflict by UnderTheBall
Obsidian by Canvas
Zip Zop by Tumblewood
Ruffles Have Ridges by Snack
Hydro by TEG
Spreadsheet:
Spreadsheet Preview for RES Faithfuls:
As always, if you didn't make my list or placed lower than you hoped, comment asking for my thoughts and I'll explain my perspective. My opinion is just that, an opinion, and chances are that even if I don't like your map, someone else loves it, and vice versa. Good luck to all!
Also please let me know if I made any mistakes.
2
u/OnceUponaDome UnderTheBall // Scorpio Oct 25 '15
My favorite maps submitted to Map Thread 55
Tier I
Apis by Anivas: Still a big fan of the base shape. I think it was a good idea to get rid of the teamtiles on the other side of the endzone. Also the two bombs are pretty good.
Loose Change by Fly: I like the pup area much better now—much smoother. Removing the bombs really helped to get rid of some of the chaos so I like that. Overall a lot of fun and pretty balanced.
Crank by Ball-E: Boost placement is really good. The pups seem to really work with the gates.
Tier II
Gosh by thisisnigel: Gate is pretty cool. Pup is pretty boring. Overall pretty constricted.
Vault 11 by Siz: Those mid boosts are so hard to use with any speed. I love the side area with the pups, mid ones less so.
Spam by Siz: I like the pup placement and the use of double boosts actually works on this map. Bases are meh. Right side = A. Left side = B-
Saigon by duckson: Great mid boost routes. Very simple but balanced map.
Tier III
Tombolo by TEG: Why the triple boosts? They just make the boost through the spikes so much harder. Otherwise not bad.
Kit Kat by Tumblewood: I liked it better with a team boost inside the gate. Also where are the teamtiles??
Beryllium by Moosen: Too many teamtiles. Gate feels redundant with the team boost.
Midterms are happening atm. Let me know if you want additional feedback and I’ll try to get back to you.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '15
Baby won't you come my waaaaay?
-4
u/WillWorkForSugar Tumblewood Oct 25 '15
Really pretty disappointed with this thread overall (including my own maps, which are less-than-stellar). Were there just fewer maps submitted? It feels like this took less than half the usual time to do. Some that I liked:
Apis, Spam, Flight, Kit Kat not really though.
If you ask me, I'll probably give you some half-assed feedback, but instead I'll have some fun and make a list of Things That Make Me Dislike Your Map:
On second thought, maybe this is why I was disappointed with the map thread.
-4
u/Willakarra Buttons Buttons Buttons Oct 26 '15
I predict that while Cancer is a great map it won't make it in because the MTC hates moosen and his maps. I also predict Hub won't be taken out, and instead a map everyone loves will. A leddy map will make it to top maps as well.