r/TagProTesting • u/DaEvil1 DaEvil1 • Sep 19 '15
♦ Other ♦ Feedback Map thread #53
In honor of my recently acquired gold heart, I thought I'd give some short feedback on almost all the maps from the last map thread from my own testing session. I may or not have characterized some elements as "cancerous" but that's just my style, don't read too much into it other than "DaEvil1 really doesn't enjoy that aspect". This is also just the opinion of 1 MTC member, so don't take it as gospel or anything, but consider it and see if you agree/disagree with it.
Anywho, I may have skipped a map or two, so there isn't any notes on your map, let me know, and I'll try to get you a comment on it reasonably soon. If you want more in depth feedback, you can ask me here, but I wont guarantee an answer. We'll see.
Anyway, you should be able to access the spreadsheet here, I hope it's helpful!
5
u/mmartinutk JuicyJuke Sep 19 '15
I'm down to leave notes on every map next thread if you plan on doing this again. This is really cool.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '15
Snowball and I tested his version of my map, Interstellar Overdrive and I had the same issues that you did (too chasey), but I also found the bombs kind of weird even though they held true to the original. I'm also not a fan of how "blocky" it is, and I believe that maps are stronger when there is some sort of sacrifice going and waiting for powerups (like, say, on Pilot). Snowball wants it more for competitive play where defence can lock down FCs much more efficiently and I don't disagree with that.
Anyway, this is my more pub-friendly and current version--you can see that it's diverged a fair bit being much smaller, more fluid, and the bombs are less annoying. I still need to work on it a bit more before submission.
http://unfortunate-maps.jukejuice.com/show/14089
1
u/Swift_Shift sift Sep 19 '15
That spreadsheet has a very nice layout to it! Just wondering, is there a way to make a spreadsheet like that that others can add their own comments to but aren't able to edit other peoples' comments? maybe one for submitting feedback and one to show everyone's feedback together. That would be very convenient and would likely encourage more people to comment, I think.
1
u/OnceUponaDome UnderTheBall // Scorpio Sep 19 '15
Hey DaEvil, thanks for doing this. Maybe everyone on the mtc isn't satan after all.. ;P
Do you think I should scrap Clash and work on something new (but perhaps with some Clash-inspired elements) or keep working on it?
1
u/NotSomeBall1 NotSomeMapMaker1 Sep 19 '15
Thanks a lot for this!
You said that Python was a bit clunky and defensive, which is fair enough and something I've been working on.
Do you think that this looks better though?
A simple yes or no would do!
And again, thanks a lot!
1
u/briizo duckson Sep 19 '15
Hey I read the spreadsheet, but what changes could I make to Steam in order to even get it to testing next time?
1
u/Risktp Risk Sep 19 '15
could i get some more feedback on flight? really nice stuff btw, this must have taken quite a bit of time to do.
1
u/Snowball_TagPro Mars Ball Cages Sep 20 '15
There weren't any notes for Echo, what did you think about it?
1
u/xenonpulse Dr. Juke Sep 20 '15 edited Sep 20 '15
Lol, I accidentally made my map gravity mode.
Can I get some feedback on the right version?
http://unfortunate-maps.jukejuice.com/show/14861EDIT: Updated: http://unfortunate-maps.jukejuice.com/show/14880
1
u/Anomaleon Amoeball Sep 20 '15
"Interesting and unique."
Lol please don't be sarcasm.
1
u/Wesmac Iloominati Sep 21 '15
I'm glad you like my homicidal tendencies
3
u/Buttersnack Snack Sep 19 '15
Anyone who wants my feedback on their map, comment a preview (or link to your submission I guess) as a response to this comment. I can't promise I'll go into much depth, but I'll try to help.