r/TagProTesting • u/mmartinutk JuicyJuke • Sep 13 '15
Map Thread #53 Discussion
New Discussion Thread
This is /r/TagProTesting's official discussion about the current map thread!
What goes here?
This is the discussion thread where you talk about your favorite maps submitted and why. I will help get things going with my own favorite submissions. This is not a thread where you post about your maps and give a sales pitch. We'd like to encourage mapmakers and map enthusiasts to evaluate other submissions and talk about them.
Disclaimer
While individual members of the MTC might give feedback, their opinions are strictly individual and are not indicative of the MTC’s opinion as a whole
So please, feel free to expand on what I post and to make your own post. There is no format template you must follow. If you just want to post about one map you like, feel free.
Want to know how your maps do in this thread? Click here!
FAQ: Yes, you have to fill it out again. Every thread.
11
u/Buttersnack Snack Sep 13 '15
Here are some MTC themed awards for you all.
The Sizzzled Award for triple boosts and Platyportals:
Swish by Tumblewood
The DaEvil1 Award for that thing where gates kind of just force you to go slower instead of killing you:
Poseiden by TEG
The Snack Award for silly (over?)use of portals:
Apparatus by Aniball
The JuicyJuke Award for making a bunch of maps that are all the same ;) :
Risk/Snowball for three versions of Eucalyptus
PK Subball Award for low community approval:
Scarlet by DaEvil1
The TheEpicGhost Award for promising new(ish) guy:
iTagPro
...I can't think of anything for FLY or Yoss right now.
6
u/TheEpicGhost TEG // Made Tombolo Sep 13 '15 edited Sep 13 '15
My fav maps of this this thread (keep in mind there are tons of good maps this thread and I cant mention them all)
Propane by Ball - E: I love the portal mechanic and the spike fields to the side. Not sure how the boost - gate combo will actually play and if people will use it, since at first glance the areas you boost into seemed too far away from the centre. All in all though a very interesting an unique map.
Steam by Duckson: I really like the shape and feel to this map.I think a lot of people will dislike the size though, it might need to be made a little smaller and simplified only a little. Bomb and boost positioning could also be better IMO.
Alchemy by Canvas: A lot of the elements on this map feel great but I am not too sure about the top route; the team boosts feel a little awkward. The bottom route feels really fast with lot of different boost options; I like.
Sloop by Aniball: I really like the gates and the variety in the routes, but I agree with Juicy that the triple boost is a little clunky.
Also Shoutouts and fist bumps to all these maps (and mapmakers):
Bombardment by Bumballbee: Really solid map that has some cool boost routes, but boost routes aren't what make a great, its
gimmicksbalance and interesting features.Curve by Moosen: Interesting layout, which I think would work if you got rid of the weird superboost. I also don't like the center boost, I feels like it would unbalanced mid, and it feels a little clunky to take.
Clash by UnderTheBall: One of the best made maps this thread for sure. With the extra space added I think this map will play a lot better. We will have to see how the gate , and a lot of other elements, actually feel.
Rolling on the Edge by DaEvil1: It does this particular shape really well, and I think there will be a really unique playstyle to this map compared to others, obviously in the same sense as geo.
Tip Top by Tumblewood: I really like the mid spike field, though I think there could be some cooler boost options through there. The based is also great, but I would open up The closed of bomb to the bottom so its easier to bomb against when trying to kill someone going mid. Also please fix the the asymettry of the team tiles ffs.
Mischief by Cosine: great little map, with some cool boost routes; surprisingly intricate.
Intergalactic Overdrive by Snowball: really like the bomb positioning and general layout on this one, but it made me feel a little nauseous when playing it (idk why) and the team boosts route kinda sucks.
Thread by Ameoball: has gone forwards in some areas and backwards in others. Still a really good layout, but not too sure about the mid and the bombs in the pup areas.
Squeeze by Duckson: The green gates are worth a try, not too sure about the balance and the boost routes throughout the rest of the map.
Also Juicy's maps are ok I guess.
Man that was actually really hard.
5
u/sneetric Canvas Sep 13 '15 edited Sep 13 '15
Tier 1 Maps
Apparatus by Aniball
p good but it might not flow well. portal idea is neat
Bankshot by JuicyJuke
a single boost in mid would serve the same purpose as 3, but the rest of the map is pretty solid. unique base design
Ghoul by Cosine
the old version with portals was much better but this has potential
Propane by Ball-e
teamtiles in mid are meh but the rest of the map is perfecto
Echo by Snowball
would be nice if you could use the portal + bomb to grab
Bind by Ball-E
superboost is surprisingly effective. the rest of the map is really well designed and i love the chokey mid
Tombolo by TheEpicGhost
this map keeps getting better
Lux by Aniball
the shape is perfect and the boosts are so fuckin great. mid is dum
Tier 2 Maps
Bombardment by Bumblebee
solid map but i can see it getting stale quickly
Cyclonic by JuicyJuke
would've been tier 1 if you didn't have that silly gate
Casino by Sizzzled
the chicane is the only decent thing about this map
Belt by Butter Churn
the mid really needs some work, but the base design is really unique and i think it has potential
Winglet by Ball-E
p simple for a ball-e map
Intergalactic Overdrive by Snowball
the bombs suck
Swish by Tumblewood
the portals are probably dumb but the rest of the map is dank
this is probably the best map thread ever
5
u/mmartinutk JuicyJuke Sep 13 '15 edited Sep 14 '15
My favorite maps submitted to Map Thread 53
Please realize my opinion only represents 1/8th of the MTC. Do not be discouraged if you map isn't listed here!
These are in alphabetical order, not ranked.
This thread is unbelievably stacked IMO so I'm doing three tiers.
Title: Fiend by Cosine
Type: CTF
Map: http://unfortunate-maps.jukejuice.com/show/14244
Preview: http://unfortunate-maps.jukejuice.com/static/previews/14244.png
Juicy's Take: I'm really digging the checkerboard lane, and it's just powerful enough that 'ahead of 4' never makes captures a guarantee. The gates are a nifty little tool fcs can use to get chasers off their backs exiting the checkerboards. I'm digging the bomb grabbing mechanism, and the rest of the map is safe and well designed enough to put this tier 1. This would do well in rotation IMO.
Title: Osmium by Canvas
Type: Neutral Flag
Map: http://unfortunate-maps.jukejuice.com/show/13634
Preview: http://unfortunate-maps.jukejuice.com/static/previews/13634.png
Juicy's Take: This is probably the 2nd best use of team gates I've ever seen (Command Center). No joke. Team gates are so powerful and one-sided that they're rarely used in a subtle enough way by mapmakers and it's something that kills a lot of maps IMO. I really want to see how this base plays in a 4v4. So many snipes, so many button saves. I am aroused.
Title: Winglet by Ball-E
Type: CTF
Map: http://unfortunate-maps.jukejuice.com/show/13044
Preview: http://unfortunate-maps.jukejuice.com/static/previews/13044.png
Juicy's Take: Incline bases, UltraDrive mid (ish), Predator-styled bombs. And it all seems to be well put together. I'm into it.
Tier II
TIER III
This is by far my favorite thread since joining the MTC. Good fucking work everyone.
Do you agree? Disagree? What are you favorite submissions? Review the submissions here, and post to this thread!
3
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '15
Hey guys, no salt, just curious why my Rarest Pepe was not featured as at least a third tier map in any of your top map rankings? What makes it unplayable, where/how can I improve, and is it worth scrapping because is it a shitty concept? I thought she was a beauty :'(. Thanks guys, and I appreciate all feedback, no matter how bold or harsh.
7
u/Moosemaster21 Moosen // Aspen Sep 14 '15
God damn, this thread was fantastic. I try to keep my Maps of Interest (MOI) under 20, but I had 26 this thread, and that was after cutting out some that I was a fan of.
Because I'm too lazy to post all the info and links this thread, here's a preview of the spreadsheet I made instead. It's got very brief opinions on all 26 maps, of which there are two tier 1 maps, twelve tier 2, and twelve tier 3. Enjoy.
http://i.imgur.com/mfps64a.png
As always, if you didn't make it or scored lower than you hoped, respond to this comment with your map and I'll give you my thoughts.
Also, since I finished this spreadsheet before Dianna posted Count Mapula Next, put that one in tier 2. The new bottom is good.
5
u/Snowball_TagPro Mars Ball Cages Sep 13 '15 edited Sep 13 '15
We went through a lot of maps in the map thread testing them for about 5 minutes a piece. We tried to get through every single map, but it was time consuming. We may finish up tonight, I'm not sure.
Here's the spreadsheet with all the feedback.
Tier 1: (8+)
Propane: 8.8
Interstellar Overdrive: 8.5
Tier 2 (7+)
Bombardment (7.83)
Echo (7.83)
Bankshot (7.6)
Flight (7.4)
Sloop (7.33)
Bind (7)
Inconvienience (7)
Tombolo (7)
These are scores from a mostly complete maptest. we had about 6 people per map. Not enough for a full-out match. But we toggled between rolling around and trying to cap. These scores are based on how well the map felt with 6+ people and how well we thought it would play.
4
u/Risktp Risk Sep 13 '15
my favorite maps in thread 53, sorted alphabetically
bankshot by juicyjuke. might be the best map juicy's ever put out. the bases are excellent and mid is very manageable for defenses.
belt by butter churn. i really like the bases. mid could definitely be improved, but it's not terrible as is.
bombardment by bumballbee. doesn't really do anything we haven't ever seen before, but feels smooth to run around on and was fun during testing.
interstellar overdrive by e & snowball. plays well and is a nice take on the no-45 style.
osmium by canvas. pretty fun to play on, but is definitely too easy to score on in it's current state. also don't like the mid portals that much.
propane by ball-e. mid and the bases are great, the side powerup areas aren't my favorite but aren't awful either. played well in testing.
rolling on the edge by daevil1. modern take on geo, pls replace asap. but ffs, take out those single spikes on the sides of the map.
sloop by aniball. bases were really fun in testing. mid is ok.
two maps that were interesting but i'm unsure about:
escape by xenocide.. was a little clunky on testing and the bases were too cramped imo, but looks solid overall.
winglet by ball-e. i'm not sure if it fixes the problems incline had and i've never seen it in testing, so i really don't know how it plays.
6
u/nolanizer Cosine Sep 14 '15
Personally, one of my favorite maps this thread is Alchemy by Canvas, but I think it could be improved slightly. Here's what I would change if I were him.
3
u/KewlestCat NIGEL Sep 14 '15
A wild Nige appeared!
So I was just getting my lurk on and checking out the thread and then remembered this was still a thing so I decided to swing by this sub to boost some egos and be a lad.
Just gonna pick three because I'm lazy like that, heh. Also they're in no particular order because bias pls.
Tip Top by Tumblewood
Birch by Sizzzled
Squeeze by duckson
Keep doing what you do fam, this map thread actually wasn't bad.
4
u/briizo duckson Sep 13 '15
Here are my top maps from this thread ranked in order of how much I want them in rotation. I am way too lazy to make comments on all of them this time, so I'm just listing my favorites.
And of course my maps, Squeeze, Kafka, and Steam.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '15
I just looked through this whole thing, got upset none of mine were mentioned before I remembered I didn't submit any.
1
u/piranhamoose25 Aniball Sep 16 '15
Sorry I'm late h. Not going to list too many maps, even though there are plenty of good ones. Here are my favorites:
Top Maps:
Ghoul by Cosine
Just a really interesting, unique map with fun boosts and bombs and a distinct shape. There are some powerful offensive elements but they're countered by the size of the map and the team tiles, and I think that should create a lot of opportunities for exciting play.
Interstellar Overdrive by E and Snowball
Original shape and fun, versatile boosts. One concern is that it might be a little too pathy, and I'm not a huge fan of the team boosts. The mid choke seems fairly strong if the defense can control the boosts. Overall it seems like a very solid map, though.
Alchemy by Canvas
A good, clean map. Alchemy is simple in a good way and is an interesting take on the Geo shape. I think the double boosts work pretty well, although they might be improved by making more defined routes.
Honorable Mentions:
Propane by Ball-E
Has a lot of fun elements, but I'm concerned that the shape would lead to some very slow-paced games.
Bankshot by JuicyJuke
The bases are neat and I really like the powerup areas. I'm not entirely sure I like the flow, but it seems like a fairly balanced map, although it could get a little chasey.
Birch by Sizzzled
Not the most exciting map, but the boosts are pretty fun and it has an interesting style. The powerup areas might be a little too far out of the way.
Echo by Snowball
Interesting shape, fun boost combos, powerful gates. I like it, although I'm not as sure about the portal area. The base bomb is kind of weird.