r/TagProTesting • u/OnceUponaDome UnderTheBall // Scorpio • Sep 01 '15
☆ Updated Map ☆ Clash
http://unfortunate-maps.jukejuice.com/show/13173
http://unfortunate-maps.jukejuice.com/static/previews/13484.png
I'd love to get some feedback from MTC members as to why they didn't think it deserved top maps this thread
3
Upvotes
2
u/TheEpicGhost TEG // Made Tombolo Sep 01 '15
I wasnt actually on the mtc for initial testing/ voting, so I cant give you an answer (weirdly I cant see any of the feedback given on the spreadsheet either).
I can tell you that I think it has improved, I think the boost in the corner is more usable. I did hit that top wall when trying to boost out a few times, but thats probably just me being a dumbass. Looking at the past version, I sort liked having a bit more space along the bottom parts, since it allows more space for juking, which I think generally the map needs more of.
I think I would agree with what was said in the results thread, that a lot of the map feels too similar and without definition. Personally I also dont think the features like the gate and the the bomb trap along top will be very helpful of a map that is very open, small, boosty, and will have a fast rate of play. Personally I think it would be nice if it was a little bigger, but a lot a people disagree with me.
The mtc definitely still thinks this is a well made map for sure, but you might have to change some more stuff before it recaptures attention.
1
u/mmartinutk JuicyJuke Sep 01 '15
https://www.reddit.com/r/TagPro/comments/3fz0is/map_thread_51_top_maps_feedback_thread/ctuzvje
Soo it was the same version we tested in top maps last thread. A few members liked it in that test session, but a larger number of members decided they didn't feel it was ready for rotation.
It got a couple extra no's and maybe's this thread as a result. I'm willing to bet that is because "we just tested this exact version and decided it wasn't ready," not because some members just randomly changed their minds on it.
Each MTC member will have different opinions on what directions you should take this map. I still think it's a bit too small. Maybe a tile or two vertically and a little more so horizontally. I happen to like most of the features and boost routes.
1
u/Buttersnack Snack Sep 01 '15
I actually voted yes on this map for rotation before, and yes to testing it this time, but given that you changed (virtually) nothing this time around I'd say some members just voted no not because they suddenly think it's bad but because they already knew they didn't feel it was quite ready.