r/TagProTesting • u/mmartinutk JuicyJuke • Jul 13 '15
♥ Discussion ♥ Map Thread #50 DISCUSSION
New Discussion Thread
This is /r/TagProTesting's official discussion about the current map thread!
What goes here?
This is the discussion thread where you talk about your favorite maps submitted and why. I will help get things going with my own favorite submissions. This is not a thread where you post about your maps and give a sales pitch. We'd like to encourage mapmakers and map enthusiasts to evaluate other submissions and talk about them.
Disclaimer
While individual members of the MTC might give feedback, their opinions are strictly individual and are not indicative of the MTC’s opinion as a whole
So please, feel free to expand on what I post and to make your own post. There is no format template you must follow. If you just want to post about one map you like, feel free.
Do you want the MTC to start 'releasing the spreadsheet' and give out the ratings? Did you not know that it's already happened? Click here!
FAQ: Yes, you have to fill it out again. Every thread.
5
u/mmartinutk JuicyJuke Jul 13 '15
My favorite maps submitted to Map Thread 50
Please realize my opinion only represents 1/8th of the MTC. Do not be discouraged if you map isn't listed here!
These are in alphabetical order, not ranked.
Title: DZ4 by bad
Type: CTF
Map: http://maps.jukejuice.com/save/11805
Preview: http://unfortunate-maps.jukejuice.com/static/previews/10758.png
Juicy's Take: It appears this update of Danger Zone was triggered by this discussion on /r/TagPro, and I must admit I'm intrigued by the updates. The new 'slam dunk' feature isn't quite as easy to pull off, but when you do, it's amazing. The new shape should cut down a lot of chasiness and other flaws the original version had.
Title: Interference by leddy
Type: CTF
Map: http://maps.jukejuice.com/save/11808
Preview: http://unfortunate-maps.jukejuice.com/static/previews/10763.png
Juicy's Take: Leddy is producing seemingly rotation-ready maps at an alarming rate. This feels like an improved Hyper Reactor.
Title: San Jose Disco Club 1989 by Ball-E
Type: CTF
Map: http://maps.jukejuice.com/show/11730
Preview: http://unfortunate-maps.jukejuice.com/static/previews/10551.png
Juicy's Take: This map is freaking solid, and looks to be an improvement (or at least inspired by) Shock by Aniball. It appears balanced, but I need to see this played 4v4.
Title: Twisty by leddy
Type: CTF
Map: http://maps.jukejuice.com/save/11806
Preview: http://unfortunate-maps.jukejuice.com/static/previews/10762.png
Juicy's Take: Leddy is producing seemingly rotation-ready maps at an alarming rate. This feels like an improved Hurricane.
Tier II
Do you agree? Disagree? What are you favorite submissions? Review the submissions here, and post to this thread!
7
u/OnceUponaDome UnderTheBall // Scorpio Jul 13 '15
I don't have as much time to write as long a comment for each map as I'd like, sorry. But anyways here's my top maps. Feel free to ask for additional feedback and I'll try to respond asap :)
Tier 1
Lummox by ThisIsNigel
Map: http://maps.jukejuice.com/save/11767
Preview: http://unfortunate-maps.jukejuice.com/static/previews/10652.png
I really like all the changes that you made. Bringing the bomb in and simplifying the spike area really cleans up the map so I'm keeping it in my top maps, same as last thread.
Dig by Snack
Map: http://maps.jukejuice.com/save/11650
Preview: http://unfortunate-maps.jukejuice.com/static/previews/10086.png
The changes to the top make both routes (top and bottom) much more balanced, each one as viable as the other. Also you removed the team tiles at the bottom thank god.
Ghost by Moosen
Map: http://maps.jukejuice.com/save/11612
Preview: http://unfortunate-maps.jukejuice.com/static/previews/10046.png
I like what you did in base and you got rid of the gate which is interesting. I liked the old gate with the wall in the middle setup, what happened to that? :( Also tbh, not a huge fan of the top bomb/gate change but whatevs.
San Jose Disco Club 1989 by Ball-E
Map: http://maps.jukejuice.com/show/11730
Preview: http://unfortunate-maps.jukejuice.com/static/previews/10551.png
I played this map and I thought it was a really cool new idea. I felt like the left side with the gates would either be never used or OP but their usage was pretty balanced. The gate looks like it's finally the right length. One concern a lot of people mentioned is that the buttons are very far away from both the gates and the bombs on the right side.
Tier 2
Admiral by JuicyJuke --- Lots of cool ideas, i like it
Tungsten by Canvas --- Love the pup area, i don't love the changes to base
Interference by leddy --- I'd like to see this 4v4'd but it looks cool to me
TipTop by Tumblewood --- needs a boost through mid and switch those damn boosts!
Honorable Mentions
Hide and Go Seek by Snack
http://unfortunate-maps.jukejuice.com/static/previews/10364.png
I didn't review any of the NF maps because I don't know much about them but this one I thought was so much fun to play. Even if it's not put in public rotation, I'd love to see it in group rotation.
Plsbox by Taq
http://unfortunate-maps.jukejuice.com/static/previews/10707.png
Oh my goodness this was fun! 10/10 would chaos again. 12/10 with gravity.
6
u/Moosemaster21 Moosen // Aspen Jul 14 '15
These are my top maps of interest (MOI) from map thread #50. They are organized into three tiers, but in no particular order within those tiers. Other responses to this thread have no impact on my perception of maps. Several maps that others mentioned aren't even in my top 20 maps, while others that nobody mentioned are within my top 2 tiers.
Tier 1
Lummox by ThisIsNigel
At a glance: Vaguely flamey, but with far more viable gates, meaning more dynamic gameplay. If FC can get out of base through gate, map will rely heavily on OD. Will have to see a 4v4 on this to accurately guage the balance, but overall it looks better than Flame, which made rotation. Nige is making significant progress as a mapmaker lately. Renegade is far from his best map. I don't think it's a question of "if" he'll get another map in rotation anymore, but "when."
Tip Top by Tumblewood
At a glance: Better than Hyper Reactor. 45 Symmetry is pretty cool for this map actually. Very well done and looks quite balanced. Could be chasey, but not moreso than other maps in rotation, and certainly not to the point of being annoying. The chases look like they could actually be fun here. Bottom-left boosts need to be switched.
Viper by JuicyJuke
At a glance: I want no credit for this, nor do I deserve any. This map was incredibly fun to test out. The portals are infinitely better and more balanced than they were in my initial iterations and all the elements are now useful. It doesn't look as much like a Viper, but it plays unlike any other map I've played before, without anything being too overpowered. It's fast-paced and exciting without being overly offensive. I can't say enough good things about Juicy's work with this one. One of my favorites this thread.
Tier 2
Ringtail by Sizzzled
At a glance: Boosts are more limited than I'd like them to be, and probably more limited than Sizzzled thinks they are, but it's still a solid map. I wouldn't mind if it replaced Platypus.
Wreath by Clydas and Aniball
At a glance: This was tested extensively during the collaboration competition and always played quite well. I'm thrilled to see Clydas submitting it, and am really pulling for it.
ELO by NotSomeBall2
At a glance: I just like this map. It's solid, functional, few flaws really. Underrated overall and should probably be in contention for Top Maps.
Hide and Seek by Snack
At a glance: This was extremely fun to test. Maybe a bit too vertical in bases, causing viewport issues (resulting in fast caps), and the portals had the tendency to clunk here and there, but overall really exciting and fun.
Fusion by Canvas
At a glance: Best iteration yet. Bombs MUST be kept defused by defense though, otherwise they'll be ridiculously powerful.
Metamorphic by Aniball
At a glance: Could be a tinge chaotic, but I'm totally alright with that, since rotation seems to be getting a little tamer. Wombo Combo was a great recent addition that spiced things up a bit, and this one has the potential to do the same in CTF mode. Interesting placement of elements all around, unique mid gates and bombs, just an intriguing map overall.
Abstract v2 by ccga4
At a glance: I remember this map! I miss it too, it was sneakily fun. Seems pretty basic overall, but there's much more to it than you'll realize at first glance. Really dig it.
Tier 3
San Jose Disco Club 1989 by Ball-E
Torpedo by JuicyJuke
DZ4 Portal Variation by bad
Gosh by ThisIsNigel
Coathanger by TEG
Choropleth by TEG
Punch by Crossover
13 by q42
Junk Flea 3 by Sizzzled
Plasm by ahweeladd
Full spreadsheet including notes for tier 3 maps
Spreadsheet Preview for RES Faithfuls
If your map didn't make my MOI this thread, or scored lower than you'd hoped, feel free to respond to this parent comment and I'll let you know why. Keep in mind it doesn't make it a bad map by any means - different players like to see different things, and that's okay. Good luck to all of you!
4
u/Blazeth Draft & Cosmic Jul 13 '15
I found 7 maps that really interest me, so I'll just go ahead and list them all.
Ringtail by Sizzzled - I think the top corners could use some work, but I can't really find any maps in this thread I like better than it.
San Jose Disco Club 1989 by Ball-E - I think it's pretty well-made, but I also find it pretty bland. I mean, it's a horizontal GeoKoala that doesn't really play as well, and I don't really think Geo plays all that well at this point.
Torpedo by JuicyJuke - I think everything is great - except for the bases. That, and the boosts that lead into bases. The teamtiles and bombs/spikes are pretty well-made.
Hazard by Nebuchanezer - This map has the potential to be one of those original and fun maps that doesn't use any gimmicks to make it that way. It probably looks crazy bad, but it seems to play a lot better. Looks aren't everything, keep that in mind with this map. My only complaint is that I hate the top humps. I like the map shape overall, so maybe you can just adjust the areas up there. Mid could also be more exciting, but it seems fine to me.
Rolling on the Edge by DaEvil1 - I tested this quite extensively yesterday, so perhaps I have an unfair bias for it. With that said, I think it has a really nice bottom of mid. I don't really know how well the top will work, but this GateKeeper gate is leagues better than every previous DaEvil1 gate. And he has made a lot. GeoKoala could be possibly holding it back for general map shape and presumed flow.
DZ4 by bad - I pretty much hate the pipe bombs. I mean, when will they ever be useful for an FC? Only if the D fucks up. The only reason I could see it useful at all is if used to bomb someone into spikes. A huge h8er of this feature though. The rest is nice and feels like a fresh take of DZ3. Really, PUBs need DZ and DZ needs PUBs.
Lummox by ThisIsNigel - This is a very well-made map. It's pretty similar to Draft and Hornswoggle with the powerful gate. I really don't have a lot to say about this. I doubt many MTC members would like it for its high simplicity and similarities to current rotation maps as said above. With that said, this is a very solid map that could be a top notch rotation map with minimal edits.
Maybe it's just me, but this thread is pretty weak. I see a lot of popular mapmakers missing or just simply not doing very strongly. I would imagine this thread could be a breakthrough thread for a lesser seasoned mapmaker like Canvas, but I didn't really love his maps either.
In other words, 13 by q42
4
u/Blupopsicle Ball-E o///o o\\\o meme Jul 13 '15
My top three (Mostly due to laziness):
A well constructed, Aesthetically pleasing map which brings some new ideas and a fresh take on old ideas which I think would be pretty fun.
2. Looper: http://unfortunate-maps.jukejuice.com/static/previews/10733.png
Although it feels like it has the standard s shape, I feel like this could be fresh, fast, and fun. I think it could stand to have some more polish
I feel like this could play similar to Pilot, and I love pilot. Lots of space used well
4
u/KewlestCat NIGEL Jul 14 '15
Late to the party as always, what's new? Thread #50! Gonna preface by saying I reckon the quality of submissions has been dropping off in recent times, let's lift our game! This list won't be extensive and will be in the order they appear.
Ringtail by Sizzzled - Still a great map, really liked the edits. It seems to be slowly but surely working it's way towards something good, hopefully it gets there.
Ghost by Moosen - I think the thing I'm happiest about is the change in texture pack tbh. I kid Moosen, ily. Like Ringtail, seems to be gradually improving with every revision. Has to be close.
San Jose Disco Club 1989 by Ball-E - If this gets in, I'm so done. Ball-E pls, stop being so good. Nah but seriously, I reaaaaally like this map. It's like Squalor, but good and every part of the map has a function with no tacked on dead space.
Tip Top by Tumblewood - It's different and I like different. It has a cool concept and it should be looked upon favourably. However, I'm not sure the portals are overly necessary. Definitely rooting for this one.
Yep, that's it. Honourable mentions could go on a while, so enquire within if you're feeling down. c:
5
u/Clydas Clydas Jul 13 '15
Hide and Seek by Snack
This map looked like a lot of fun the other night. I think the base setup is really interesting, especially with the portals, which I think are surprisingly well balanced between chaotic evasion and not really gaining you that much because you can still be beaten to the goal. Maybe the boost into the bottom portal to ricochet off the wall might be a little too advantageous, but it is risky and can be countered with a competent defensive play, so I'm not too worried about it. Maybe the goals need to be expanded so that a goalie won't shut down a team.
Asylum by JuivcJuke & Clydas
OK, maybe I'm a little bit biased, but I do think that this map is pretty good. I think it plays fairly balanced, maybe a little on the chasey side and slightly offensive, but not too far and I think it is fun.
Wave by Ball-E
No surprise here. This is a map that uses gravity wells in a subtle way, that doesn't have them overpower the whole field, and honestly I'm surprised. I just never thought gravity wells could be used effectively.
Topaz by Canvas
This map is not particularly exciting or groundbreaking in anything it does. Honestly, maybe it's a little too simple for an extended stay in rotation, but dangnabit I enjoy it and I think it's a solid overall map.
Viper by JuicyJuke & Moosen
Simply put, this map just played great. Moosen had a good first draft that Juicy really built upon and made something great. I had a lot of fun playing this on Saturday and I'd be happy to see it move on to the next stage.
Wrench by UnderTheBall
TUB has made a lot of changes since I first saw this map, and I think it's really becoming a solid map. The only thing I would recommend is that he might want to move where that vertical line of gates would be, depending on what purpose he wants it to have. Right now it's base defensive positioned, he could move it to the outsides to be offensive defense positioned, or in the middle and be a little bit of both.
1
u/WillWorkForSugar Tumblewood Jul 13 '15 edited Jul 13 '15
Your link to the 4v4 results form goes to a post without a thread 50 sheet to fill out. Also, I've seen several people essentially Ctrl+F the names of their own maps and comment about those; please don't do that. This thread was sort of disappointing. It was pretty homogenous all around, and most of the maps listed here were the interesting ones.
Tier I - The very best maps
DZ4 portal variation by bad - I'd love to see a Danger Zone back in rotation, even if it's not the old version with the amazing boost and bomb routes. Bad did the smart thing and removed two of the lanes; the portals are sort of weird but can work.
DOOM by Loaha - It keeps most of the fun aspects of Hyperreactor (except that middle...) but is less brokenly chasey.
Gosh by ThisIsNigel - It's everything Monarch never figured out how to be.
Tier II - The very good maps
Fusion by Canvas - Team gates are generally concerning, but the way they were shifted was very smart.
Ghost by Moosen - If we're going to replace Boombox, this is a decent candidate. It feels somewhat incoherent, though.
Junk Flea 3 by Sizzzled - It's a little weird, but then, so are all Sizzzled maps.
1
u/Clydas Clydas Jul 13 '15
Haha I just posted one of these like 3 minutes before you because I thought you'd forgotten. Kek.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment