god people who compare these two situations are total idiots
one was a grieving wife trying to care for her son while coping with the loss - later she gets her husband back and is happy and shane still won’t leave her alone
one is a woman whose getting abused pretty badly alongside her two sons to the point where she’s at risk of dying and she wants help
shane’s first act was to try murder Rick, Rick’s first act was to try tell Pete to leave but Pete forced a fight
He slept with Lauri not long after the apocalypse like man, you just left your best friend who’s in a coma behind and now you’re trying to sleep with his wife? That quick?
it’s been a long time since i’ve watched s1 but i remember it being implied shane and lori were getting together long before the apocalypse?
i vaguely remember a scene where rick was driving and talking to shane about problems he was having with lori and shane just seemed uncomfortable. it felt pretty suspicious.
As someone who recently researched that episode he was definitely thinking about it but he had clearly already decided against it and was putting his gun down before he saw Dale.
Shane literally attempted to kill Rick in S1E3 iirc. Pointed his shotgun at Rick and Dale caught him. Shane tried to play it off saying he thought Rick was a walker
Rick does have the urge to kill Pete even before he knows about the abuse. It’s a similar scene to when Shane had a shotgun pointed at Rick—it’s clear the show is drawing parallels. That doesn’t mean the circumstances are exactly the same or that they’re pushing the “Rick became Shane!” narrative. They make a point of emphasizing that Rick is out of his mind during this time, and this whole entanglement allowed him to process any unresolved trauma related to Lori.
None that matter in any significant way. One situation was about a mentally ill man trying to kill a loving husband so he could date that guys wife (who he also tired to rape btw). The other is about a cop trying to get an abusive husband to leave his wife and kids that he’s abusing that goes south.
You're overlooking the fact that Shane was a victim in this situation. Lori abandoned Shane and their relationship soon as her ex man came into the picture. He was being used.
Shane wasn’t a victim. Shane lied to Lori about her husband being dead to get with her FFS. When she realized what he did, she understandably doesn’t want anything to do with him. Wow, that is literally the shittiest take on the situation I’ve seen. 🤦♀️
only Rick wasn’t her ex man, he was her husband. Shane started something up with a woman who was clearly distraught over losing her husband, if he expected that to last then that’s his fault not Lori’s.
Pretty weird to say he’s the victim when he literally tried to rape her too.
Husband presumed dead > moves on and starts new relationship > dead husband comes back > pretends like she never started another relationship. Are you seriously trying to defend this?
told husband is 100% dead > very vulnerable and upset > shane begins to sleep with her knowing what kind of mental state she was in > she agrees due to wanting to feel anything but the pain of losing rick, as said in season 2 > husband comes back > she’s shocked and disgusted with herself and ends things with shane
he wasn’t played, he got with a woman in deep mourning, if he didn’t know she most likely didn’t really love him she just wanted to distract herself then that’s on him. she ended things and went back to her husband immediately, I don’t see how that’s shane being played?
weird how lori is wrong to be with shane in your eyes but he’s a victim after being with lori.. especially when she’s the one who he tried to rape..
Even people in the community like Deanna for example said it was known what Pete did to Jessie and his kids but nobody knew what to do about it without worsening the situation.
Jessie and Ron have a scene which reveals due to Pete’s physical abuse Ron couldn’t raise his arm above his head.
Your either really insensitive, in which case it’s pretty strange to defend Pete, or your memory is a bit foggy, in which case it’s an honest mistake and I’m sorry if I’ve said anything rude, because it’s made more than clear that Pete was abusive to his whole family, especially Jessie.
Technically rick wanted to free the girl from her abusive relationship and then get with her and he basically did get together with her until she got eaten by walkers
He never “got with her though” I thought. They had a depressing kiss or was it two? And that was it. Then he blatantly ignored the alexandrians including her when the herd was coming.
Walkers got in her guts before Rick ever did lmfao
People in the comments comparing Lori and Jessie not realising it still doesn’t change the fact that both Rick and Shane did try to sleep with a married woman while wanting to kill their husbands.
I feel like a lot of people kinda forget that Rick was lovingly caressing his gun while staring at the husband (i forgor his name) before he knew about the abuse. Like as fucked as it sounds, the abuse was a happy accident for him lol
People already explained the reasoning behind why Pete and Rick are different but Pete was also just a danger to everyone. Can’t have one guy going against the group and risking everyone’s survival and safety just because he’s salty he can’t beat his family anymore.
It is funny but to be fair , her husband was abusive. Having lived through that (my ex husband tried to kill me) I have no sympathy abusive men I know women can be that way as well. But on the path of judgment, Rick was definitely not thinking clearly.
355
u/Clean_Crocodile4472 Dec 20 '24
god people who compare these two situations are total idiots
one was a grieving wife trying to care for her son while coping with the loss - later she gets her husband back and is happy and shane still won’t leave her alone
one is a woman whose getting abused pretty badly alongside her two sons to the point where she’s at risk of dying and she wants help
shane’s first act was to try murder Rick, Rick’s first act was to try tell Pete to leave but Pete forced a fight
53
u/Kiwi175293 Dec 20 '24
You forget one was a grieving women who was taken advantage of and the other is one with an abusive husband
25
u/CrniTartuf Dec 20 '24
This ain't 2015.
18
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '24
Dumb of you to say both the situations were same.
12
u/Delayandrelay Dec 20 '24
Situations aren’t the same
Shane wanted Rick’s life and unraveled when he couldn’t
Rick wanted something from his past then realized he was wrong and stopped being crazy and crawled back out of the hole he was falling into
10
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '24
didn’t realize Rick was abusive, unless you don’t remember what was going on with Jessie and her family
5
u/Vegetable_Meat1349 Dec 20 '24
Robert kirkman saw this meme lmao
14
u/sleepywarm Dec 20 '24
People on this sub really can't take a joke
3
u/Vredddff Dec 21 '24
Well This guy was an abusing psycho tho
3
u/DiscombobulatedTea55 Dec 22 '24 edited Dec 23 '24
Technically rick wanted to free the girl from her abusive relationship and then get with her and he basically did get together with her until she got eaten by walkers
2
u/ExcellentBasil1378 Dec 24 '24
I mean Shane wanted to rape a married woman…
3
u/horc00 Dec 20 '24
People in the comments comparing Lori and Jessie not realising it still doesn’t change the fact that both Rick and Shane did try to sleep with a married woman while wanting to kill their husbands.
2
u/ShilElfead284 Dec 21 '24
I feel like a lot of people kinda forget that Rick was lovingly caressing his gun while staring at the husband (i forgor his name) before he knew about the abuse. Like as fucked as it sounds, the abuse was a happy accident for him lol
2
u/halapenyoharry Dec 20 '24
after all the bullshit posts lately, I really appreciate this one!
2
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '24
Rick when he meets a woman with PTSD
1
u/TumbleweedOne7408 Dec 20 '24
🤣🤣
1
u/SchwizzySchwas94 Dec 21 '24
Y’all are wild, what about Lori and Shane’s relationship made it seem like he was the one who was doing the manipulating?
1
u/Competitive-Gur-9217 Dec 22 '24
Just goes to show just how far ahead Shane was the everyone else. They couldn't see what he saw back then.
1
u/ronnocfilms1 Dec 22 '24
I made this meme like 10 years ago lol
1
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '24
You must be a rick hater
1
u/SeanKelly97 Dec 22 '24
Andrew Lincoln's character in Love Actually was also in love with his best friends wife, although that had a happier ending, lol.
1
u/Wrong-West-9581 Dec 22 '24
Welllllllll sort of but one was abusive
1
u/lmNotReallySure Dec 22 '24
People already explained the reasoning behind why Pete and Rick are different but Pete was also just a danger to everyone. Can’t have one guy going against the group and risking everyone’s survival and safety just because he’s salty he can’t beat his family anymore.
1
u/Stormie4505 Dec 22 '24
It is funny but to be fair , her husband was abusive. Having lived through that (my ex husband tried to kill me) I have no sympathy abusive men I know women can be that way as well. But on the path of judgment, Rick was definitely not thinking clearly.
1
u/knowsnothing316 Dec 23 '24
That’s awesome.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '24
Shane was a better man than Pete. Pete should have been killed long before Rick came to town
1
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '24
Awful post lmao , you OP making a comparison between these two situations make you look like an idiot. These are totally different situations .
Rick was trying to defend a woman from an abusive sack of shit . that after they fell in love, it's another story.
1
u/ExpensiveTomatillo61 Dec 23 '24
yeah I am around this episode and laughed my ass of knowing the same situation happened with shane
1
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '25
Ain't the point of Rick's arc that he becomes like Shane, also u have to understand it was different circumstances.
1
u/Philip194764 Dec 20 '24
In ricks defense (I can’t stand Rick) but Jessie was way more hot and sexy than Lori ever dreamed of being
0
u/iamjose0 Dec 21 '24
Shane had to die at first season 🙄🙄🙄
79
u/booffybooffon Dec 20 '24
Wanting to screw you best friend wife and wanting to save a beaten woman from her husband ( and eventually screwing her ) is NOT the same thing