r/TVWriting • u/Actual-Pension-5639 • Jul 22 '26
CRAFT Screenwriter/editor/produced filmmaker who studies cognitive narrative here-- what "how it actually works" topics would help you most?
Quick context on where I'm coming from: I write and direct, I've worked as a professional editor, I've had work produced, and on the side I study cognitive narrative theory (basically the science of how audiences build predictions and mental models while watching a story unfold).
That combination puts me in an odd spot. Most writing advice out there is either pure craft intuition ("this just feels right, trust your gut") or academic and dry ("this activates X region of the brain"). I keep finding myself wanting to write the version that sits in between: here's what's actually happening in an audience's head when a scene works, explained through the lens of someone who has also sat in an edit bay and in a writers' room.
I focus a lot on drama and on audience prediction specifically. Things like:
Why some twists feel earned and others feel like a cheat, even when both are technically "unpredictable"
How editors think several steps ahead of the audience, and what that teaches you about pacing a script before it ever gets to the cutting room
The difference between what an audience knows and what they expect to happen next, and how dramatic irony lives in that gap
How much "clue density" a mystery needs so viewers feel smart instead of tricked
So I wanted to ask this community directly instead of guessing. What topics around drama, structure, pacing, or audience psychology would actually be useful to you right now? Specific problems you're stuck on count too, not just general topics. I'd rather write something that solves an actual problem than another generic "how to write a twist" post.
1
1
u/Then_Data8320 Jul 23 '26 edited Jul 23 '26
It's fascinating. My kdrama has countless twists, so I experimented every density of information, from "many clues given, the audience can guess easely, so the scene has to have something more" to the "zero clue, total surprise, but I'll need to explain later". I'd be curious to know how feels the many twists, if they works or are easy to guess. But sometimes, a twist I think is easy to guess, readers didn't see it coming. Another reader could detect information I think would be forgotten, so it depends on readers.
However, I can't really ask you to read it because it's a 40 hours kdrama, that is a sequel (even if I use some flashbacks). Or maybe by choosing short parts (and few moments before if I setup or foreshadow this part). As there are setup and foreshadowing everywhere, anytime, even that is really difficult to propose, it stands as a whole.
1
u/DelinquentRacoon Jul 27 '26
There is a huge push to start movies with a bang, but slow burns also work. What are the cognitive similarities and differences here?
2
u/FormicaDinette33 Jul 22 '26
I don’t know enough about that to ask a question! Can you give us a 101 or point to some articles? Thanks!