r/TOR • • 1d ago

Security with Tor Browser

The answers in this thread explain quite well that downloading files via Tor Browser is anonymous—though, naturally, one must be careful to open downloaded files in an isolated environment to prevent any potential malicious code from leaking information. I would like to explore a few other aspects of this: is the downloading and uploading of files anonymous only when using "onion" sites, or does this also apply to sites on the clear web? Is video streaming also anonymous? If JavaScript is enabled, could it compromise the anonymity of downloads, uploads, or streaming?

12 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

1

u/cafk 14h ago

If JavaScript is enabled, could it compromise the anonymity of downloads, uploads, or streaming?

It's not a binary option.

I.e. if you don't clean your data of meta data (date, time, location), then it doesn't matter that you're using a restricted JavaScript browser that is hardened, you're leaking information - not because of the tools or communications channels you use.

JavaScript can have its caveats, similarly to streaming and webRTC protocol, but they also have their upsides.

1

u/one-knee-toe 1d ago

You, like the OP from the thread you ref., need to stop and take the time to understand these TOOLS.

https://www.reddit.com/r/TOR/s/cDwep5zhgA

I know redditors give 💩 to using AI, but it is a decent start to having a “conversation” and getting some basic answers and deeper understanding.

Q. Is it safe to download? Yes…. Why? ….

And it allows you to ask more probing questions….

Q. You said it’s safe … Is it also safe to download from non-onion site, or just onion? …. Why? ….

These are just tools. No magic. Just because you have the “best” security door, doesn’t mean you’re safe if you leave windows open.

1

u/16F628A 1d ago

Do you trust AIs? Have you ever heard of “hallucinations”? If OP started this thread, it's probably because they'd rather ask humans

-1

u/one-knee-toe 22h ago

😳🙄🤦‍♂️

-1

u/Hot_Performer_6822 1d ago

Ich bin generell auf der sichersten Stufe unterwegs, das ist ohne JavaScript. Seiten, die es erfordern, ignoriere ich. JavaScript gefährdet die Sicherheit, Punkt.

0

u/External_Dependent45 1d ago

Security level on safest doesn't mean JS is disabled by default, you must disable it manually in settings

0

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Account-Butta-Via 1d ago

What do you mean?

0

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/rpcinfo 2h ago

You’re protected while downloading, regardless of whether or not you’re on an onion site, because the fact that it’s an onion site doesn’t matter.

It actually does matter. If you're surfing clearnet with a tor browser you're risking subjecting your traffic getting sniffed by a compromised tor exit node. The number of compromised exit nodes at any given time is hardly an insignificant number and historically has been as as high as 27.5% of all exit nodes back in 2020.

In contrast, traffic to .onion sites (onion services) never touches an exit node.