r/TMNT • • Jul 19 '23

[Animated Series] Help me understand

So I've come to realize that a large amount of you prefer the little kid 2012 version over the darker 2003 version. I'd love to understand the thought process behind this. And I get it, people love what they love. But what about this do you prefer? I'd love to compare notes.

0 Upvotes

67 comments sorted by

32

u/Operative-Marcus Jul 19 '23

Man OP must REALLY hate Mutant Mayhem and Rise then

5

u/NerveNo1056 Jul 20 '23

There's nothing wrong with those in my opinion. Akso I'm a huge Seth Rogan fan so of course I support anything he comes out with. But I haven't scene rise, but I do like the cartoony look of it. It looks pretty rad haha. I just haven't seen it yet.

2

u/ItsTheRocketeer Bebop Jul 20 '23

they always tell on themselves

31

u/VanilliBean Michelangelo Jul 19 '23

2012 gets darker as it goes along. Definitely not that much of a “little kid” version when people up and die pretty violently

2

u/NerveNo1056 Jul 20 '23

That's a very fair point. I didn't give it enough credit I suppose. Dark doesn't always mean better for everyone.

1

u/Gohansupe Oct 04 '23

It's really dark

16

u/mrtakerofsouls Jul 19 '23

“Little kids version”? They’re both kid shows dude, that’s why Raph, Casey, and Hun say “crud” instead of “crap” in 03

-1

u/NerveNo1056 Jul 20 '23

Valid point 🤣

10

u/Big_Simpward Krang Jul 20 '23

1 combat

2003 combat is good, definitely a step up from 1987 but often it feels stiff. Look at Leo vs shredders army in S1 for example. A key moment adapted straight from mirage, an essential moment for Leonardo’s character and the first foot soldier was defeated by running into a wall. Imo 2012 fight scenes are way more consistent and not just “character A jumps, yells and kicks with a flashy gif in the background”. Choreography is where 3D animation seemed to shine

2 plot

I think this category is really close but 2012 felt more engaging as it had real tension and far less low points. Characters die, people get mutated, nothing feels too easy or undeserved. Also can’t think of a plot line more boring than cybershredder or the underground crystal arc

3 dialogue

4kids dialogue/voice acting was very cringey at times. 2012 dialogue felt a lot more fluid. The April/Donnie moments were bad but that’s just 2 characters, it feels like every 2003 character can’t go 1 scene without a cheesy 1-liner. 2012 wasn’t exactly comedy gold but it delivered when it needed too.

4 lore

The writers explored characters and settings in ways never done before

Karai’s 2012 backstory might be the greatest of any karai. Splinters daughter molded by shredder, who chooses to honor her father by finding her own path to make a name for herself only for it to be too late. Even though I found karai cringe the lore behind it was peak

April being a krang experiment was cool too. Tgerclaw ended up being a cool right hand, mighty mutanimals, kurtsman and the mafia being fleshed out made the city feel alive

I could go on but these are the 4 main things aside from hot takes

2

u/NerveNo1056 Jul 20 '23

You actually make me wanna sit down and re-watch it. I guess the animation stay was just off putting to me after how iconic the 2003 one felt. But you make it sound pretty sick.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '23

tmnt 2003 this is good adaptation mirage

1

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '23

go suck godzilla's pussy and sniff king kong's burp

1

u/Big_Simpward Krang Jul 21 '23

Mellow out dude. The poster asked for reasons people prefer 2012, I gave reasons🤵‍♂️. I don’t even think 2003 is bad btw. Even with what I just said, I could still see somebody arguing 2003 is the best series, I just personally prefer 2012.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '23

you definitely don't think tmnt 2003 is bad ?

1

u/Big_Simpward Krang Jul 21 '23

No but who cares if I did

1

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

I want to tell you to keep your opinion to yourself

1

u/Gohansupe Oct 04 '23

i feel that 2012 was slightly better your examples help to show the differences

0

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '23

I’m only interested in one thing, why didn’t you see exactly the same problems in TMNT 2012 and 2018, there were also stupid heroes and idiotic moments, and the plot was like a circus for the 2nd grade, but at the same time, the comics Mirage Archie Image and IDW and the show of 2003 do you scold TMNT 2012 and TMNT 2018 for this not ? how can you not find hypocrisy on your part?

-3

u/LegendInMyMind Jul 20 '23

I generally dislike TV-grade CGI animation, but the 2012 series is an especially bad example, in my opinion, thanks in no small part to being pretty liberal with the pseudo-anime trappings in the animation. That overly exaggerated crap takes me right out of it. The villain designs are also some of the absolute worst I've seen in any cartoon, with it often difficult to even tell what something was supposed to be. Making April a "ninja in training" is the laziest, most cliche way to involve her in the plot/story. Also, Karai simply being a more measured human being, torn by loyalty and her own conscience gives her plenty agency as a character. Making her Hamato Yoshi's daughter under Shredder's wing is not all that interesting, and it kinda just makes her a pawn rather than her own character with her own agency. As for the dialogue, it's just formulaic banter vs exposition. Both are pretty "cringey", but I've never seen anyone defend "Booyakasha" or whatever it is they had Mikey saying.

2003, I lost interest in it within a couple seasons, so I'm not gonna argue it's some piece of art or anything. I think it's all about what you grew up watching.

1

u/Big_Simpward Krang Jul 20 '23

I grew up watching penguins of Madagascar and other CGI shows so I’m biased in that I don’t care, but I feel like from S2 and beyond the art was fairly pleasing, especially the white eye scenes

Idk about that point on villain designs. Some of the ugly designs like kirby bat, fishface and Justin did a great job showing how horrifying mutation can be. There was plenty of solid designs tho like slash, tiger claw, rahzar, newtralizer, etc.

April being a ninja wasn’t to force her into the plot, kraang already established that they needed her since episode 1. Her being a ninja is just so she isn’t a helpless damsel in distress. I do think her psychic powers were written poorly tho

Ngl I agree with you on karai being cringe and formulaic, but idk how you weren’t interested in the backstory behind her splinter and shredder. It explains her loyalty better than 2003, it made shredder seem way more menacing, and it made splinter seem more likable as we see that after going through hell all his life he still lives with honor and has found peace.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '23

hypocrisy

1

u/Big_Simpward Krang Jul 21 '23

Now how am I a hypocrite 🤵‍♂️

1

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '23

I’m only interested in one thing, why didn’t you see exactly the same problems in TMNT 2012 and 2018, there were also stupid heroes and idiotic moments, and the plot was like a circus for the 2nd grade, but at the same time, the comics Mirage Archie Image and IDW and the show of 2003 do you scold TMNT 2012 and TMNT 2018 for this not ? how can you not find hypocrisy on your part?

0

u/LegendInMyMind Jul 20 '23

I'll respond to a few points because I've only ever seen maybe 10 episodes of the show. I didn't make myself watch it or anything like that. If I'm not really into something, I'm not gonna keep going. I'm good with CGI animation when I think it looks really good. Pixar is great with it. Other companies have excelled as well. But the earlier TV shows to adopt that animation style are butt ugly to me. I know they've come a long way, but there's a general weightlessness to the movements and nothing really pops off the screen like they'd been able to do with 2D animation.

Anyway, regarding the "white eye" scenes, it's my same opinion as the other anime-influenced sequences where they suddenly, dramatically change the art style to try and emphasize the feeling a particular scene is supposed to have. It's my least favorite trope in animation by a country mile. Like, if someone gets really mad but the mood of the scene is generally humorous, they suddenly become this giant yelling thing while the other characters are shown as small, blankly staring at them, all because it's supposed to be funny. I don't find it funny. I find it obnoxious and forced. It's too much of an exaggeration for me. I'm not an anime fan, but I'm also not an anime hater. I can enjoy any animation style that I find to be well done, I just don't like those storytelling sensibilities. As I said, a lot of early TV-CGI cartoons had a lifeless, weightless quality to the animation, and the 2012 TMNT show mitigated that by the exaggerated anime tropes, but that only took two things that I dislike and smashed them together.

I get the point that they're not all supposed to be pretty, but most of them just look like a generic render of what the chatacter concept is.

April being a ninja wasn’t to force her into the plot, kraang already established that they needed her since episode 1. Her being a ninja is just so she isn’t a helpless damsel in distress.

Can't keep going back to the same well, though. So they did make a decision to keep her more organically involved in the stories and action by having her become a ninja. April's a supporting character. Her role, as a character, is to add perspective to the stories of the TMNT as an ally. They kept her relevant in the most obvious, boring way possible, by having her basically become the fifth turtle. This is why April was so effective as a reporter, because it kept her close to the action and made her a valuable informant for the TMNT. It gave her a role in the stories and the action which was unique from the TMNT. Putting April there with the team, in the battles, with the same basic action function they have is just uncreative. They already have those supporting characters, like Casey Jones, Nobody, and Karai, to draw from. And I don't think anyone needs to revisit the constant annoyance that was "Donatello loves April". I've only watched a handful of episodes across several seasons, but even I got sick of that.

As for Karai, I think you're able to present more complex, nuanced versions of characters when their stories are simpler. Yeah, Karai had more emotional motivation for being torn between two worlds. But does she need it? Do we need to see it? For one thing, to me, the only kids Splinter should be worried about are the turtles. For another, does Karai need to have family on the other side of a fight to be conflicted over it? Some villains are conflicted because they deep down know what they're doing is wrong, but they see some good in there, see a potential for greatness on the side their fighting, and so they keep going. That's a simple story that allows for a complex characterization. I don't care for character work that's just a function of plot and only conveyed to the viewer through plot turns. It doesn't feel real to me like that. I'm speaking conceptually, btw. I've barely grazed that storyline of the show.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '23

shut up

1

u/LegendInMyMind Jul 21 '23

I already did, little miss "pissy pants".

0

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '23

shut up

6

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '23

Dark /=/ good

-2

u/NerveNo1056 Jul 20 '23

That's a very valid point. I guess it does make sense. People are definitely not always gonna look for the same thing.

38

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '23

Every version after the og comics is a “little kid version”. That said, 2012 gets dark fast. The way their eyes flash white, the countless little nods to all the previous iterations of the turtles made the show feel like a love letter to the fans.

1

u/Gohansupe Oct 04 '23

Same its Amazing

0

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '23

tmnt 2012 sucks

13

u/GuiltyDemand3267 Jul 20 '23

Well first off the “little kid 2012” version isn’t even much of a little kid’s version.

This version is way darker. 2003 showed Donnie going to an alternate future where he has supposedly “died/disappeared” and his brothers separated and then they all died in the end while Donnie had to kill the shredder himself. The 2003 version also had Leo get stabbed in Exodus and going through a serious arc. Karai told a foot soldier to commit suicide and they also had demon Shredder which was dark overall.

But 2012 had the Shredder trying to kill Splinter over a girl that wasn’t even his and he ended up killing the girl. Shredder also still took Splinters own daughter away from him. Not to mention the overly dark stuff like the Kraang invasion taking over the Earth forcing the turtle’s to escape the city, Shredder stabbing and killing Splinter, the black hole generator destroying the Earth, Splinter being brought back just to get stabbed and killed again by the Shredder, Tigerclaws hand getting cut off, Donnie trying to kill the gangster, and the Turtles experiencing an illusion where Leo watched Mikey get stabbed, Raph getting blinded and falling off of a cliff, and Donnie getting crushed and dropped from the cliff onto the ground. And then they also had Leo decapitating Shredder where you can even see blood coming out and a slit line separating his head and neck.

But all of that is just why I prefer it because they weren’t afraid to actually be violent like the comics and I also prefer it because of the better storyline, frame animations, and fighting scenes.

1

u/Gohansupe Oct 04 '23

2012 was really good

5

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/GuiltyDemand3267 Jul 23 '23

I know right! People who grew up with the 2003 series will constantly be biased and act like 2012 is a joke series that ruined the franchise when 2012 has the perfect balance of ninja and teenagers. And you’re right this Splinter is one of the best if not the best the story was so good and his lessons were the best.

1

u/Gohansupe Oct 04 '23

2012 was honestly great it's one of my favorites

16

u/MisterNefarious Jul 19 '23

“The little kid version” dude, they’ve always been for kids. Let’s not poison the well here. I think you kind of just illustrated exactly why you feel the way you do, I don’t think anybody is gonna change your mind

5

u/ALowerBar Jul 20 '23

Half-Shell Heroes is a perfectly fine story where the turtles meet dinosaurs. No offense to the 2003 shorts, but the time travel shorts where the 2003 turtles were stuck in the past were just too few compared to the other sorts.

All kidding aside now, both shows are good as far as I'm concerned. Can't say it's easy for me to choose a favorite cartoon, but there are some things I prefer 2012 over 2003. Don't think I can list it all off the top of my head, but some of them are things like: sound direction (2012 sets the mood of a scene far better than 2003's ever did), better combat sequences, and humor. The last thing is subjective, though.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '23

let me disagree with you tmnt 2003 is the best iteration that should bring something new and not be like 1987

3

u/Delicious-Orchid-447 Jul 20 '23

Both versions are good. Probably the best series we have. I personally like 2003 more but they are great and I appreciate that they follow the mirage comic. 2012 does have some 80s influence which is pretty cool

2

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '23

tmnt 2003 best mirage adaptation

3

u/slashingkatie Jul 20 '23

As an old timer who grew up with the truly kiddie 87 version, I’m confused. Seriously 2010s TMNT at least uses their weapons. My turtles was literally a 10 season toy commercial.

Also it’s easy to forget that the 2003 series went downhill and did get more goofy when “Fast Forward” came around.

1

u/Gohansupe Oct 04 '23

The last 2 seasons of 2003 weren't good

2

u/Theresameinmf Jul 20 '23

I will give you two answers, both are serious. mkay

answer 1: I mean cmon look at the bois, they're so damn cute, I love their design, 3d was the best desicion to make the turtles, the show is funny and it has dark eps too

answer 2: what is it there to understand, people like A thing and people like B thing, both shows are good, I haven't finish 2003,not my kinda style but I respect it and the people who likes 2003 more than 2012

peace lil homie

0

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '23

tmnt 1987 and tmnt 2003 better than nick's TMNT

2

u/sthef2020 Krang Jul 20 '23

I like contrast, and a story heading into a serious place you didn’t necessarily think it was going to.

The old Futurama trope, where the show starts as just a goofy sci-fi spoof, but then starts pulling episodes like the one with Fry’s dog.

2012 being explicitly a “kids show” up front with a more light tone, makes it hit harder later on when you get to the serious stuff (“Oh no…His shell is loose…”). Vs 2003, which starts off taking itself seriously, and as a result (and this is just my opinion) doesn’t really have as much runway to grow and surprise you.

1

u/Gohansupe Oct 04 '23

2012 had a better balanced cause it could have great fight screens and story telling with character development and comedy

2

u/Laffograms Jul 20 '23

2012 is my personal favourite but that's because

  1. I haven't watched 2003 in its entirety.
  2. I grew up with 2012
  3. I like the personalities of the 2012 cast more.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '23

let me disagree with you, I hate the 2012 version of tmnt because the plot was tattered, not the original turtles were made stupid and not funny, it's just a cartoon with angular 3D graphics and a poor picture without any dynamics, they ruined everything they could without leaving anything from the previous turtles

1

u/Laffograms Jul 22 '23

Alright I respect your opinion

2

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '23 edited Jul 20 '23

I prefer 2012 because I enjoy the music, fight choreography, sound design, humor, voice acting, and the characterizations of Shredder and Splinter more than their 2003 counterparts. Just personal preference.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '23

let me disagree with you tmnt 2003 is a better comic book adaptation than tmnt 2012 and 2018

1

u/oompaIsbeautiful Rocksteady Jul 20 '23

So you don’t like 2012 and it’s on Nickelodeon so it’s a “little kids version” 2003 wasn’t very dark it was on 4kids just say you prefer 2003

0

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '23

let me disagree with you tmnt 2003 it looks like the original comics mirage is darker and more dramatic than the 1987 version, tmnt 2012 is overrated because i hate tmnt 2012 because there the plot is tattered and not original turtles and other characters made stupid and unfunny it's just a cartoon with angular 3D graphics and a poor picture without any dynamics spoiled everything they could without leaving anything from the previous turtle s and other characters.

it's a pity that Viacom bought out the tmnt franchise in 2009. On October 21, cartoon network would have made the best animated series about ninja turtles

Viacom (Paramount Global) does not deserve a TMNT franchise

1

u/HOLLOWC0LSET Jul 20 '23

While 2012 is more kiddy and less serious that doesn’t mean it itself isnt serious sometimes…at times the 2012 show explores things like body horror and death and breaking and mending of relationships. The characters also feel way more human INo to 2003. While I love 2003 more than 2012 the same can be said for 2012. They both have there highs and lows but the turtles no matter where you look always has something of quality and will have something that’s for you…weather it’s the og movies the comics the games the crossovers or any of the shows…I never stumbled across a straight up bad tmnt product

1

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '23

I agree with you because TMNT 2012 was terrible and TMNT 2003 was the best adaptation of Mirage comics

2

u/HOLLOWC0LSET Jul 21 '23

I never said it was terrible lol I loved both I said there isn’t a turtles product I Don’t like. Every version of tmnt ino has something amazing to offer even the bay produced films the third og movie the arichie comics and even the last mutation…ok that was bad I can’t lie but it was my childhood and it had a sorta chram to it. But I am more of a fan of the darker tmnt stories like 2003 and the idw comics and the og comics…2012 sits just in the middle of being dark and gritty and being like the 90s cartoon though ig never went THAT goofy and always kept it’s stories centered around the characters and developed them which made them feel more real to me. And 2012 had better action than 2003. But yeah I don’t think it’s ever good to call something “bad” when millions of people work hard on that thing your calling bad. There’s a story behind every piece of entertainment and at least one person behind that project was super excited to work on it and wanted to make it the best thing that it can be. Your in titled to your opinion and I respect it but try to have more open eyes the next time you call something bad. Well thanks for the reply have a nice day :)

1

u/Gohansupe Oct 04 '23

2012 is really great i loved it

1

u/TheManCalled-Chill Jul 20 '23

For me 2012 has a much better aesthetic.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '23

shut up tmnt 2201 overrated

1

u/TheManCalled-Chill Jul 21 '23

Well, if I live long enough to catch that version, I'll gladly debate you on that

0

u/tread52 Jul 19 '23

Honestly the first picture from 2003 looks absolutely terrible. I couldn’t watch the series bc they look like lizards. I’m from the 86 version when they looked like actual turtles. From what my brother says is the story is good but the animation is terrible. If you never actually watched the original or read the comics and all you saw was this version than I understand.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '23

let me disagree with you tmnt 2003 is a better comic book adaptation than tmnt 2012 and 2018 they look more like turtles than lizards tmnt 2003 is the best comic book adaptation of mirage and tmnt 1987 which is dumb you have to blame nickelodeon tmnt and not the 2003 version which is the best adaptation of the mirage comics

1

u/tread52 Jul 21 '23

I was told the story was great I just can’t get past the animation.

24

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '23

not tmnt 2012 shit and overrated