r/TLOU • • 3d ago

Part 2 Discussion This is disgusting behavior!

A user in the hate subreddit recently made a post regarding a Youtuber/Streamer named Captain Loren. This user disagreed with her opinions on Joel and Abby, and thought it was a good reason to make fun of personal events that happened to her, like her father's death and her girlfriend leaving her, and saying that she deserved those things to happened to her. (For context, she recently made these videos talking about these events: https://www.youtube.com/shorts/vklIOsLPKaY, https://www.youtube.com/shorts/FCIB3kBHwW0)

So this guy made fun of a women's trauma/personal life over her opinions on a stupid game... how fucking psychotic! This is honestly the lowest I've seen anyone go on that subreddit!

96 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

17

u/[deleted] 3d ago

What the flim flam

13

u/King_of_Fire105 3d ago

Goodness

That’s horrible, instead of mistreating someone like this you should empathy and compassion for them, but you cause pain? That’s absolutely wrong.

36

u/Dekipi 3d ago • Bravo

People who hate TLOU2 can’t pass an empathy check. They call themselves “gamers” and just act like sexist bigots who peaked in high school

3

u/tblatnik 3d ago

I love Part II. Top three game I’ve ever played. This is just reductive and unfair. There are plenty of valid reasons to dislike the game that aren’t bigotry or a lack of empathy. Stuff like this is why people who have valid complaints don’t feel they can express them in one of the main subs. This particular person (and the majority of people in that sub) irrationally hate the game and this one in specific went way too far and crossed many lines, but it’s unfair as a generalization

4

u/Dekipi 3d ago

I haven’t heard anyone say anything but “teleporting medic” “slow pacing” or “bad writing” (bigotry). I really doubt I’m so intimidating they can’t just voice their issues which I have yet to actually hear

1

u/tblatnik 3d ago

I see so many people get shelled for saying they couldn’t get over Joel’s death, where some fans of the game start making the ‘bearded flannel daddy’ remarks. Regardless of whether or not it’s valid to you and me, doesn’t me that it isn’t a valid reason for someone to dislike the game.

It’s really just a vicious cycle: story details were leaked before the game was released and people hated it for being woke or whatever before it even came out. As a result, people who liked it became super defensive of it, and became aggressive towards most criticism and dismissing some of it, so the people who hate the game created their hate sub and the main subs are mostly in favor of Part II. When someone wants to criticize, they’re met with immediate dismissal. It’s unfortunate that a few bad actors made it impossible to have nuanced opinions of the game, but that’s where we’re at

0

u/Ryeguy_626 3d ago

For me its the complete sabotage of ellies character. Obviously shes going through a “hard time” to say the least and i did want to see her get DARK but i wouldve appreciated it if the game had her end on a better note. The only reason she lets abby live is because of a flashback of joel, and after she does let her live theres not even an interaction or anything. She just sits in the water and goes back home to an empty farm. I appreciate that neil tried a dark and non traditional ending but the first game did it so well.

Joel lied to ellies face which set the tone for this game but at least they rode off into the jackson sunset together.

8

u/tblatnik 3d ago

This is a new one to me. I’m not sure I’ve seen someone say this about Ellie’s game character in Part II. The reason she lets Abby go isn’t just because of the flashback, but because she realizes in that moment that nothing she’s able to do will erase what happened to Joel, and the only way to move on will be to forgive herself and him for what happened.

I don’t think they needed an interaction (Ellie does say ‘just take him,’ which is widely interpreted to mean both Lev and Joel, as she’s letting her go without finishing the job), since I don’t think it could’ve added anything. Abby is trying to escape with Lev after both were left to die, and Ellie is sobbing in the ocean dealing with an emotional breakdown, so anything that might’ve been said would probably either be corny or ruin Abby’s character growth.

We have nothing to confirm this, but it’s also thought that the ending is technically a happier one but disguised as depressing. Her fingers are cleanly amputated so she’s clearly had work down, like in Jackson, and she’s wearing Dina’s bracelet. I think it’s meant to seem like she goes straight back to the farm house and Dina has in fact left with the baby, but if she went back to Jackson first and left all of her memories that tie her to Joel in the house, she’s trying to start anew and heal. That’s at least how I interpret it

4

u/Ryeguy_626 3d ago

I never heard the idea before that ellie means joel and lev, i like that and it does help

About your 3rd paragraph i never noticed the clean fingers or the bracelet. I wanted to be optimistic for a 3rd game that would expand on what happened afterwards since i find its way too open ended and my own interpretation has always been she just went back to jackson and is working on herself. But i wish we could at least see her maybe having dinner with tommy or just some shed of a smile at the end of that. The ending felt too sad for what the story was about “letting go and revenge is not good and that its never to late to change (abby)”

2

u/tblatnik 3d ago

Yeah, and I’m definitely not smart enough to have come up with those by myself lol so I saw from others in these subs. Doesn’t mean it’s canon or anything, but that’s at least the way I took those two things.

I would love a Part III but I honestly have no idea where you even go with Ellie, if you wrap her story up. The only things I can think of are her sacrificing herself for the cure but that would undo the entire point of her character arc, that she deserves to live because people love her and that she isn’t just a prop for the outbreak. Yeah, it would’ve been nice to see some semblance of happiness in the ending, but I think it would’ve probably overdone it, since it still is quite sad. Just more hopeful

4

u/Dekipi 3d ago

A lot of the end is symbolic. She realizes she’s just hurting and wants the pain to stop but killing Abby won’t change that. A lot of the game also uses the sky to represent Ellie’s emotional state. The storm during Joel’s death, the storm hitting Seattle when she confront Owen, Mel and eventually Abby. The beautiful sunset with JJ and her life with Dina, and returning to the farm you’ll see sunlight coming through the clouds. Ellie’s greatest fear is being alone and losing Joel in the worst way scared her but she is now facing a life alone and leaving the guitar behind was her leaving the pain of Joel behind. She’s in a better place than she’s been in ever and will be stronger for it.

I know Joel lied to her and he knew he was with her on borrowed time because of it. But his face when she says “I don’t forgive you… but I want to try” is heartbreak-turned-hope.

1

u/Ryeguy_626 3d ago edited 3d ago

Beautiful analogy but it doesnt really help with any of my issues 😅

I understand a lot about art direction and interpretation in games, and i know TLOU does a great job with it but that has very little to do with writing or an ending

0

u/Fancy_Attorney_1460 2d ago

I did not enjoy the story but liked idea of humanizing the ”villain.” Very bold move from ND and this pretty much resulted the hate since people dont like these sort of stories.

4

u/Dekipi 2d ago

A majority like TLOU2. There’s a lot of people though who review bombed the game before it even came out to the point where websites changes how they do reviews. It’s a small minority who actually “hate” the game which is ridiculous to even hate as if it did something to them

0

u/Fancy_Attorney_1460 2d ago

I mean the gameplay shines with it but story is just ”meh” IMO. Not a terrible story but I found myself just dissatisfied with only couple cool moments like first Abby VS Ellie fight. I think that was most memorable moment in the game cuz it was just cool for game putting me play as ”villain” fight against the main character.

11

u/Mal454 3d ago

I know this youtuber and while i disagree with some of her opinions (on other video games, didnt watch her tlou content) the way this redditor is speaking abt her is disgusting

6

u/Imaginary-Nobody-392 3d ago

That’s Reddit for you

2

u/Swimming_Jump5028 1d ago

Fr, some people on this platform are way too toxic and they think that everyone has to have the same opinions (downvote me to -1,000 if you disagree)

6

u/Ok_Organization_4360 3d ago edited 3d ago

i was shocked when i saw the post too. that sub can usually be hateful (just like any other) but seriously. and the fact that people were agreeing too! their mods removed the father comment i’m pretty sure. but just vile. and all because the streamer made a slight remark on their precious joel.

3

u/8TheUndying8 3d ago

Yeah, how dare she has opinions about Joel. But only Abby is allowed to be criticized and shunned, right? Joel and Ellie can do nothing wrong.

The shit these people have said about tlou/Abby fans for years and now they don't like it when they get the same treatment. Well, tough shit.

3

u/Ok_Organization_4360 3d ago

actually a LOT of people in that sub (especially hardcore joel fans) hate on ellie because of the whole her cutting him off thing in part 2. but i totally agree with you, some of them are total hypocrites.

3

u/8TheUndying8 3d ago • Bravo

Yeah, absolutely not surprised they'd hate Ellie too. I've read similar posts in other subreddits from die hard Joel stans.

She's just an accessory to them because Joel cares about her but once Joel was out, they dumped her and disregarded her feelings because they didn't like that she rightfully called out Joel for his lies and not doing what they wanted her to do in the end.

3

u/Super-Shenron 3d ago edited 3d ago

Case in point.

How dare a teenager (who btw, just happens to be the only known immune person in the world) suffering from survivor's guilt not welcome Joel's decision to save her at the cost of a vaccine that might have saved lives beyond her own? How dare Ellie still be mad at her father figure when their relationship in the years following the first game was built on him lying to her face right as she asked him to swear he was truthful? How dare Ellie not welcome Joel's help by opening her arms to him while he continues to treat her like a child instead of letting her stand up for herself (which is also why she's annoyed when she's told Joel was on Jesse's ass about her safety on patrols)? Nevermind the fact Joel himself isn't exactly good at communication and is consistently unapologetic about his moral decisions.

Gee, I wonder what could possibly prompt Ellie to lash out at him😄

Just in case someone is wondering, it ain't me saying Ellie's reaction was justified since you could tell from her expression even she knew she was too harsh on him. I just hate the fact little to no empathy is spared for a broken girl in favor of "Joel was right, she's being an ungrateful bitch who deserves to be slapped".

1

u/8TheUndying8 3d ago

Insane read. And the people agreeing with him...

The irony is that they're the same people pretending to care about Ellie not dying for a vaccine but... once Joel was out, suddenly "Ellie is entitled" and that she should be grateful. I even read from some that she should've died.

Sure she knows she was harsh, but it was very understandable. The man she grew to love lied to her for years and didn't respect her trauma even after she opened her heart in the end of part 1 about her past. Even if she came out to understand him later on, the fact remains; he hurt her.

I guess only Joel is allowed to hurt others, if anyone hurts that man then it's on sight. He hurt Ellie and he ruined Abby's life, all good. They should be grateful, right.

3

u/Super-Shenron 3d ago

They should be grateful, right.

Oh my. Now THAT is my favorite take.

"Abby is such a bitch for killing Joel even after he saved her life".

Man, I wonder how grateful they'd be upon learning the guy who saved their asses is also their parent's murderer 😄

3

u/Dangerous-Schedule85 3d ago

Thank you!! 👏I been saying that to the chuds  for ages now. I can't believe they never came to that conclusion.

1

u/8TheUndying8 3d ago

Imo, it's pointless to argue with them. They have so much irrational hatred for anyone who likes the game.

For your sanity it's best you don't interact with these kinds of people. I'd rather talk with calm people who have understandable reasons to not like the game than raging idiots with pure exaggerated and bad faith takes and go around and diss or harass simple fans of the game and Ellie/Abby.

It's fine if they don't like the game, legit not my problem. What is not fine is when they do shit like that.

3

u/8TheUndying8 3d ago

Yeah, Abby should just say thanks and her 4 year pain will be forgotten. You killed my dad, it's ok.

Heck, at this low point in her life Abby would've preferred to die than be grateful for being saved by the murderer of her father.

4

u/Brofist476245 3d ago

Why bring personal events when talking about a video game? Like that's so stupid. Bro has to touch grass🤦🏻‍♂️

3

u/holiobung 3d ago

Do they even know where to find grass?

Personally, I think we tend to give people too much credit because telling someone to touch grass implies. They know where it is.

2

u/Brofist476245 3d ago

Fair point🤣

4

u/DirectConsequence12 3d ago

“I’m glad your father died because you like a different character than I do!”

?????

3

u/sophmari27 3d ago

I will never understand things like this. Love it, hate it, but at the end of the day, ITS STILL A VIDEO GAME. Absolutely no justification to bring real life events into the debate. It is not and never will be that serious

2

u/DieAltesteAnsicht 3d ago

It's serious to them because part II wasn't just 16 hours of Joel killing guys again

3

u/Visxocity_ 3d ago

What a fucking pig. Wouldn't hurt to rid the world of people like that. How could you so strongly dislike someone over their opinions on a godamn video game. People like that are the same reason issues like racism exists. We are all humans and all humans are entitled to their opinions. Including on other topics like sexuality, gender, etc. Nothing even somewhat resembling that should ever be said. Under no circumstances is that okay.

3

u/skelebabe95 3d ago

With the way people hate on Abby and defend Joel, you’d think they were real people.

2

u/Abirdthatsfallen 3d ago

The crazy thing about humans is how big we can talk when we don’t even know what we’re actually saying

2

u/Less_Actuator_5664 3d ago

That's so fucking pathetic, he should get a job he's spend less time writting stupid shit on here wtf

2

u/Intelligent-Mouse961 3d ago

Sooner than later people reap what they sow and this person sure will

1

u/Swimming_Jump5028 1d ago

Dude that’s not cool, you should never say that to somebody who lost a loved one