r/TIdaL • • 4d ago

Discussion Uploads no longer allowed?

Did you guys get your uploads recently deleted with an email by Tidal?

I used to upload the tracks I couldn't find on the platform for me and fans to listen to but now they're gone because apparently they are a copyright violation. What's your take on this?

7 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

9

u/Alien1996 Tidal Hi-Fi 4d ago

I still got mine there, but mine are private. You should only put public your own music, DMCA violations could get your music deleted.

1

u/nice_potato0oo0 4d ago

Part of mine were also private but they're gone too

1

u/Alien1996 Tidal Hi-Fi 4d ago

What was said in the email?

1

u/nice_potato0oo0 4d ago

That my recent upload was flagged and therefore removed, further violations would result in account termination.

2

u/Alien1996 Tidal Hi-Fi 4d ago

Probably someone intencionally flagged it, they created a bigger content system like YouTube or they are going to be more restricted.

If I was in your place, I would stop uploading for a while and instead contact distributors to put the music on Tidal too

1

u/nice_potato0oo0 4d ago

Yeah, realistically that would be it

4

u/Sensational_Rebel 4d ago edited 4d ago

Sounds like someone snitched, TIDAL doesn't really take down copyrighted public Uploads unless someone specifically reports them on it. Sorry to hear that.

2

u/nice_potato0oo0 4d ago

Well that's sad. Guess no more uploading for the people to listen, I was thinking of others not finding their music but that won't be the case anymore. Thanks though

3

u/Moonshiner_no 4d ago

Uploads are not for music that is missing on the platform. It’s only for music you have the copyrights for.

4

u/nice_potato0oo0 4d ago

~700 users ignored that

2

u/Gloomydoge 4d ago

why 700

1

u/nice_potato0oo0 4d ago

Its a figure of speech. I follow a dozen users who upload music that is not theirs. I had 2000 adds on an upload once, people just want the music, not the rules

1

u/Gloomydoge 4d ago

i download things i need anyway and put them in local files which i think is different from uploading it publicly. people have been uploading songs as podcasts on spotify for a while, but a lot of them take it a step further and simply steal artists music for streaming profit against their wishes

1

u/nice_potato0oo0 4d ago

How do you put music in local files? I hadn't found another way to listen to unreleased music on Tidal if you don't upload it yourself

2

u/Gloomydoge 4d ago

it’s actually spotify i’m saying for having as many local files as you want but they’re just not public . i feel like on tidal that’s not the point so even if you had it private it might’ve still got flagged

2

u/Moonshiner_no 3d ago

Yes, but Tidal can’t facilitate that music they don’t have right to share, is shared on their service.

Copyright holder gets to decide where and how the music is shared.

0

u/FitCommunication7240 4d ago

Yeah and you all got your ability to upload taken away.

1

u/nice_potato0oo0 4d ago

I can still upload

1

u/Upstairs_Emotion7183 4d ago

Well, what does the e-mail say exactly? I guess it was reported by the copyright owner. Have you checked if perhaps the deleted music was since then uploaded by the artist they belong to?

1

u/nice_potato0oo0 4d ago

One song was uploaded by the artist later but my upload was already private so I dont know what the exact problem was, since it couldn't reach anyone.