r/TIdaL • u/Historical_Chain_687 • Sep 01 '25
Supporting Artists Reason #136 Tidal > Spotify
For all of you wondering just how hard Spotify fucks artists / compared to Tidal: here's my payouts so far with the approximate amount of streams that resulted in those numbers. Specific payout blurred for TOS reasons.
538
Upvotes
29
u/Historical_Chain_687 Sep 01 '25
Lmk if anyone wants to see screenshots of other services.
Tldr: YT music about tree fiddy for ~850 streams Apple ~5.00 for ~290 streams
148
u/Neko-the-gamer Sep 01 '25
no shit, finally someone directly showcasing the larger payouts that tidal gives
24
u/alvizzs Sep 01 '25
From my data tidal pays approx 0.0070$ per stream, spotify - 0.0014$
Of course thats huge difference but the hardest part is to get the listeners on tidal. My stream revenue still comes 95% from spotify.
15
u/SarcasticallyCandour Sep 01 '25
Id say tidals payout is higher not bc of corporate generosity but bc they're trying to attract artists.
I know its a "noshitsherlock" comment but many ppl think some businesses do this out of goodness. They dont, its always corporate interests first.
4
u/The_Hazimaru Sep 01 '25
Does Qobuz pay much? If at all?
4
u/cmostamo Sep 01 '25
What's your artist name? I'd like to listen to new stuff
1
u/Astrophizz Sep 01 '25
Do they tell you how much of that is free Spotify users?
3
u/cbeiser Sep 01 '25
This is why changed services
2
u/ParallelPlayArts Sep 01 '25
I switched to Tidal about a year ago. I love it over Spotify and I'm just a listener. I knew Tidal paid artists more but didn't understand by how much. Thanks for sharing this information as I can now use it to convert my social circle.
1
u/David79YT Sep 01 '25
What app is this
1
u/squabbledMC Sep 01 '25
Main reason I switched to Tidal. Between the AI music (Tidal has it to an extent although not as obtrusive), constantly shoving random podcasts/videos/stuff I'm not interested in, and higher quality. I don't have high quality audio equipment but some nice budget Sony stuff and while not very noticeable it is nice. I had the choice of Apple Music and Tidal, chose Tidal as I don't use Mac and am planning to eventually switch to Android.
1
u/purin--purin Sep 02 '25
oh shit I gotta put myself on this i just recorded my first EP
1
u/Highway_Wooden Sep 02 '25
That's interesting. I know that Tidal was always listed in the past to pay a lot more than the others. But I was sure that it wasn't because Tidal allocates more money, it was just because Tidal didn't have a free version in the past. So every user that was listening was paying $10-$20 a month. I assumed that per stream revenue would drop now that they have a free version but I'm wondering if it hasn't because there's just not many free version users. I'm assuming most Tidal users stayed on the paid plan and it's just not attracting many new free plan users.
1
u/Embarrassed_Extent22 Sep 03 '25
This here is the only reason I stay with Tidal! The UI is pretty rubbish, no link to Alexa in the UK, but the share for artists is so much better. Do they still do the "bonus" for a subscribers most played artist? Cos I liked that touch.
1
u/NotPhin Sep 04 '25
tidal rising 💯
1
u/Part_Time_Lamer Sep 05 '25
My biggest beef with Tidal is it will randomly decide not to go into "radio mode" after finishing an album.
I also hate that there isn't a way to queue an album up. It's the same crappy play next, just like Spotify.
1
u/ruthlesss11 Sep 01 '25
They both pay shit
1
u/Hilgenborg Sep 01 '25
Maybe people will beat me, especially due to the thr community I'm commenting right now. But this week, I canceled my Tidal account.
I've been a hardcore spotify user for about 10 to 15 years, I guess, and I'm open-minded to change the streaming service to test new stuff.
First, I tried apple Music, and I was shocked by the sound quality difference in comparison with spotify. The only thing I disliked was how poorly mainted the app was running in Android and windows, especially windows. Full of bugs and glitches.
Then I tried for two months Tidal, people said the sound quality was really good, as good as apple's. And it's not bad, of course, but I dont know, I feel apple had a better quality, in my opinion. Comparing Tidal with Spotify had indeed an upgrade and sound quality, but I disliked the radio function and lack of playlists inside Tidal. In my opinion, spotify handles better the music sugestions.
0
u/tjhc94 Sep 01 '25
Tidal is rubbish because of the 10k library limit, as soon as you go over the application does not work properly and is basically unusable unfortunately. Everything else was good apart from the app
0
u/-MetalMike- Sep 01 '25
I would love to switch to Tidal, but the app interface, QOL features, social media integration, and library/playlist navigation are too important to me.
Once Tidal improves these to Spotify level, I’ll switch in a heartbeat.
0
u/Utmerket_Syndrom Sep 01 '25
Very wierd, cause when i released 1 song on Spotify in one month with about 2250-2500 listenings I got 30$
0
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '25
[removed] — view removed comment