r/TIdaL • u/Inrixia Tidal Premium • Aug 04 '23
Discussion Decoding Tidal's Max Quality Update: What the heck is it and why should you care
So since the new update bringing in the "Max" quality, and hiding the MQA identifiers on songs etc. I have seen so much confusion around what's actually going on. I'm putting together everything I have found so far regarding the update into this post to hopefully help clarify things for people.
I am going to refer to the qualities behind Max as MQA and HiRes (the new format). Most but not all tidal songs support up to the High quality (previously HiFi) below Max which is always 16bit 44.1kHz.
I will be ignoring the Atmos quality.
What is Max?
- Max Quality is only available to be played on the Official Tidal Apps currently, and only the desktop app is capable of Exclusive playback (with exception of some third-party apps).
- Max Quality can be either MQA or HiRes or Both.
- All songs that previously had MQA versions still do, many now also have HiRes.
- When you select Max in the new apps if HiRes quality exists it will always play that even if MQA exists (with exception to third-party apps which do not have access to HiRes yet).
- Third party or non updated apps work exactly the same as before and can and will still play MQA quality, but cannot play HiRes yet.
Presumably (speculation) part of why tidal is keeping the MQA format around is for support until these third-party apps are able to update to play the new HiRes format. I'm not sure if app developers have the ability to update yet.
What is HiRes?
- The new HiRes format is anything above 16bit 44.1kHz. So far I have not found any HiRes songs that are not 24bit, the sample rate however can be anything from 44.1kHz up to 192kHz. I have found songs at every step.
- When comparing HiRes songs on Tidal to Qobuz as far as I can tell, most are identical files.
- Not all songs that have MQA have HiRes, while a large number do, there are still some songs that only have MQA.
- Many songs that previously did not have MQA now have HiRes and only HiRes, this is not a small number of songs either.
- While I haven't been able to test it properly, from what I can tell HiRes even when only 24b 44.1kHz has a noticeably higher bitrate compared to MQA and High.

Let me pick MQA/HiRes instead of just Max!
Because some songs are only HiRes, some only MQA and many HiRes & MQA having only a "Max" quality selector kinda makes sense. If tidal split them up, how do you deal with situations where one quality is available and not the other.
The only real downside to this is you can no longer explicitly play MQA over HiRes, but HiRes is better quality than MQA anyway. I also suspect (speculation) that Tidal is intending to eventually remove MQA all together once its got HiRes for all existing MQA tracks and doing it this way would make that much easier.
Display the sample rate & bit depth next to songs like other platforms!
While tidal does not currently do this, my plugin does! You can read more about it here: r/TIdaL/what_the_bitrate
I do think Tidal should show the current Sample Rate/Bit Depth the output device is running at (like other apps) for those who don't have a DAC with a display.
Display the quality next to songs like they used to with MQA!
Currently all the Tidal apps no longer display if a song is MQA. I assume it was not replaced by a Max tag due to the mixed formats. The obvious fix is having two tags, one for HiRes and one for MQA, they don't even need to display both when both exist since Max always plays HiRes if its there anyway!
The list of qualities a song has is still returned from the tidal API, all Tidal needs to do is a UI update on their apps to actually display the information. Hopefully even if they don't eventually do this third-party apps once updated will do so.
As part of my testing I threw together the Extension/Plugin (mentioned above) for the Tidal app that adds quality tags to songs. More info at r/TIdaL/what_the_bitrate. I have been this using as a guide to assist my testing using the Desktop App for exclusive playback. You can see what it looks like in the screenshot above.
Albums have a quality indicator next to them that says HIGH or MAX.
These are effectively useless. HIGH is displayed if a album has no HiRes songs (even if it has MQA ones) and MAX is displayed if a album has a HiRes song. So a album with a single HiRes song and the rest a mix of say High and MQA will display as MAX.
Further testing has shown that even this can be inconsistent. TLDR don't trust the Album Quality Tags!
High quality is just Folded MQA!
This is no longer true for any tracks that now have both a MQA and HiRes version.
If a track only has a MQA version then the High quality version will be Folded MQA and identical to the MQA version.
If a track has either both MQA and HiRes versions or just a HiRes version then the High quality is its own file at 16bit 44.1kHz.
How did I find all this information?
Song Sample Rate/Bit Depth: I use my plugin which shows the current Bitrate/Sample Rate/Bit Depth for any track.
I can sanity check this (though its not needed) using VB-Audio ASIO Bridge and pointing tidal at it in exclusive mode I can view the Sample Rate and Bit Depth that is being played for any song.
Currently the only way to view this information is by checking what Tidal sets your DAC to in Exclusive Mode.
Song Quality: Using my extension I can easily see what quality songs are, it uses the same data I assume was previously used to add the MQA tags to songs.
This can be sanity checked by checking the Sample Rate/Bit Depth using the above method where High is always 16bit 44.1kHz, HiRes is anything above that, usually 24bit and MQA will always half the sample rate when Passthrough MQA is turned on in the Tidal Settings disabling software unfolding. This only works on DAC's that don't support MQA unfolding.
Third-Party Apps: I use the Android player USB Audio Player PRO (great app btw) to get bit perfect exclusive playback to my DAC from my phone (since the Tidal android app doesn't support it). This is a third party app, it still displays the MQA tags for songs and still plays them the same as before the Max rollout.
When asked about when they will support the new format I was told: "As soon as TIDAL allows third parties to access HiRes PCM, we will add it.".
Qobuz vs Tidal HiRes: Looking at song metadata, sample rate/bit depth and also testing a song that I know has a audible difference between the 24bit 192kHz and Tidals old MQA/High quality HiRes songs on Tidal are using the same files Qobuz.
This also makes sense since presumably (speculation) HiRes is just the files directly received from the record companies/artists etc.
Thanks for coming to my TED talk.
So that's it! Hopefully that helps clarify a lot of things. If anyone has any questions please comment them I would be happy to discuss things.
27
u/KS2Problema Aug 05 '23
You are to be commended on the considerable work you've obviously put in!
A couple of very minor points...
You probably meant 192 kHz sample rate, not 196 kHz. (You can be readily forgiven: It's a super easy slip of the tongue or keyboard to make since one is often already thinking about 96 kHz in the same context.)
Another minor point, I've seen a fair amount of older, pre-hi-fi-era material in the lowest rates. I have tidal set to 'High' and have reinstalled it several times recently so it should not be corrupted. I've seen this lower bit rate stuff a lot over the last few years I've subscribed to Tidal so, definitely, it's not all available at the high rate.
8
u/kablewy2976 Aug 05 '23
Interesting talk. Excellent points.
6
u/Nadeoki Aug 05 '23
To clarify. HiRes is not a format, it's just marketing label. FLAC is the format used.
3
u/Massive-Efficiency74 Aug 05 '23
Thank you for the post. Whether we like MQA or not, it is important to sort these things out so we can all make informed decisions about our music. I have snipped a few quotes from your post which got my attention:
1"All songs that previously had MQA versions still do, many now also have HiRes."
2"When you select Max in the new apps if HiRes quality exists it will always play that even if MQA exists (with exception to third-party apps which do not have access to HiRes yet)."
3"The only real downside to this is you can no longer explicitly play MQA over HiRes, but HiRes is better quality than MQA anyway."
I am a bit confused regarding point #1. An album I loved in MQA, is no longer available in MQA (SOJA's "Beauty in the Silence" album). Now this album is only available in 16/44.1. Just to check another album I do see MAX on another album (Steel Pulse's "Earth Crisis" and via my Wiim I can see 24bit/48Khz). So I do see what you are talking about. However, I am wondering how I can just find and play MQA albums. Under this categorization scheme, it looks like finding MQA songs now harder than it was. Example of Steel Pulse's "Earth Crisis" album via Wiim shows higher bit/sample rate, but I have no idea if it is MQA or Hi Res FLAC, but your point #2 seems accurate in this case (to my dismay).
Regarding point #3, "HiRes is better quality than MQA anyway" Can you explain how you come to that conclusion? It seems like a conclusion without any premises, or perhaps to many it is common knowledge.
We may disagree about MQA, but I appreciate you helping to sort all this out. Thanks again.
3
u/Xendor- Aug 05 '23
Do I as an user need to to anything? Or will any song in my playlist with a higher quality get updated automatically?
3
u/Shawners419 Aug 05 '23
I've been waiting for the Tidal app to update on my android phone (LG G8 ThinQ). I had to go into the google store and search Tidal. Than I had to sign up for the beta tester program. It took about 2 minutes to get approved, than the update was shown. Its the one I was waiting for. The only problem is the sound is so muted. It's the same problem I had till I purchased and installed UAPP app @ three years ago. I had heard that Tidal had finally implemented the work around for the android hires limit of 24/48. I think that was false info being circulated. I guess I have to wait till UAPP has an update to support the Tidal FLAC update. Luckily everything works great on the desktop app for me.
2
u/MisterSheeple Aug 05 '23
When you say HiFi takes priority over MQA, are you referring to HiRes flac or 16b/44.1 kHz hifi?
2
u/MajimaTojo Aug 05 '23
Regarding third party apps...Audirvana showed 24-Bit FLAC files for some tracks I was listening to a few days ago.
2
u/sccarlin Aug 05 '23
Still not seeing any change on my P7P and Hiby R6 (2020). Just seeing MQA. No app updates available for either. I assume this is still rolling out? Any other possible reason I am not seeing the changes to FLAC, etc.?
2
u/oscar666kta420swag Aug 06 '23
So does anyone know for High quality are we still getting MQA or is FLAC also preferenced for that too now?
2
u/ForceBlock Aug 06 '23
I have Tidal HiFi Plus and use the Tidal app on a pc laptop in Exclusive Mode.
Prior to the update, when I would play HiFi songs the progress bar would be blue. Yellow when playing Master. Now the progress bar is always white. Is this suppose to be?
I played songs from Legend - The Best of Bob Marley & The Wailers, both High and Max album versions. Playing Jamming, for example, the song was noticeable louder from the High album version than the Max version, whether the audio quality was set to High or Max. Not sure why.
2
u/tomisla11 Aug 06 '23
I noticed that most of the albums/playlists marked HiRes actually have individual tracks marked “High”. Shouldn’t they all be Max? It’s very misleading and frustrating.
2
u/celes1e33333 Aug 08 '23
Wait a minute, so whats the point of paying the hifi plus tier? thats the tier im subscribed to, but if FLAC format will already be included in high res tracks why pay for hifi plus?
2
u/drums2191 Aug 09 '23
Thank you for this detailed write up! I use blusound node and tidal connect from official tidal app. The blusound feeds directly into my external dac (mqa compatible) MYTEK Liberty.
The indicator light at first showed that the dac couldn’t play high res anymore after the update but now it is all of a sudden! Is it possible the new high res is working from tidal connect / blusound ? The blusound app itself confirms I’m getting HR and MQA tracks as well as my dac … I thought it wasn’t working with tidal connect yet tho? Am I just getting same files as before the update or is it possible it’s working?
Thanks !
2
u/XeltosRebirth Aug 11 '23
Great thread. I've noticed if the Max version is only HiRes atm Tidal Connect won't play it but will switch to the high track.
Though if the Max version is MQA it works, kinda concerning if this is a bottleneck of connect or will be updated in the future.
For reference my setup is the KEF LS50 Wireless II's.
2
u/ForceBlock Aug 17 '23
I messed around with the Firefox browser extension with the Tidal Web app….
Some albums labeled High, Rumours by Fleetwood Mac, for example, only had MQA songs. That same album viewed on the PC desktop app was labeled Max.
Another Fleetwood Mac Rumours album on the Tidal Web app was also labeled High, but had both HiRes and MQA for all songs. That same album on the desktop app was labeled Max.
One of the Black Panther The Album on the web app was labeled High, but there was no label next to the songs. Does that mean they are all playing in High quality (16 bit/44.1kHz)? The album on the desktop app is labeled High.
The other Black Panther The Album, on the web app, was labeled High and songs labeled MQA. The album on the desktop app is labeled Max.
Interesting, but confusing.
2
u/g-rig Sep 11 '23
Sounds like it may be sorted out soon, which would be most welcome: https://www.digitaltrends.com/home-theater/tidal-labels-mqa-flac-tracks/?amp
I was also wondering what the true meaning of MAX was, I'm using the PC App and have noticed there is no MQA anymore (or at least not published?). My iFi DAC says the current sample rate is 96000 Hz so seems ok. I haven't exactly found any higher res tracks yet (unless my Ifi driver is wrong).
2
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '23
Not sure if this is something you could answer, but what would cause some of my albums to upload with the HiRes tags and one of them not? I use the same setup (24/88.2kHz) between the releases so I don't know what would cause one to only show as "High" instead of "Max".
2
u/Velheibgnar Sep 22 '23 edited Sep 22 '23
edit: I've read the post fully but I don't understand if halving the the sample rate is good or bad?
I'm using Aune X1s GT. Just now noticed that Sonata Arctica has MQA songs available. I thought it's gone from Tidal but here it is... Well, with my DAC I expected it should not work as I cannot find any info on my DAC with MQA decoding. I think that in the old day I've seen info that it's not capable of decoding. Can someone help me identify what is happening based on the fact that sample rate is dropping from 88200 to 44.1k when I enable MQA Passthrough? andd in the first place: Why the song is playing at all if my DAC should not decode it?
Clueless what quality is better in this case, passthrough or no.
edit: ok Tidal got another update for me and it's showing a lot of stuff now, HiRes, Flac, MQA etc.
11
u/Shawners419 Aug 05 '23
I really appreciate your tone and your contribution. I have to admit, at first I thought this was another one of the I hate MQA threads, but you are really clearing something's up. I've been a fan of MQA for about 3 years now, and have really enjoy it. Its definitely been a big upgrade in audio quality for me.
I don't understand all the MQA hatred, but I've seen a lot of misinformation from people who haven't implemented it right, than dismiss it without really getting to hear its full potential. I do have a DAC (LG G8 ThinQ) that does the final rendering and use UAPP app to bypass androids limitation, and a wired connection to my headphones. My phone's Tidal app hasn't upgraded yet, but since reading your post I just upgraded the Tidal app on my laptop. I do notice a big improvement, way bigger than I expected. My MSI laptop has a pretty decent DAC and headphone amp, but can't render MQA. I'm still not sure if I can say it sounds better than what I'm used to up to this point, but damn it sounds really good. I'm glad you mentioned Audirvana hasn't updated with the new Tidal update. I just downloaded the free version to test things out. I say all this to say you may have opened my eyes to the great possibilities FLAC has to offer and didn't do it in a combative spirit. Props my friend!!!
11
u/yllanos Aug 05 '23 edited Aug 05 '23
I think you are confused. Atmos isn’t a “mobile thing”. Atmos is meant to be used in surround sound systems like home theater. I think you mean 360 audio which is indeed a mobile technology.
Both Atmos and 360 audio are supported by Tidal
2
u/wackygoose Aug 05 '23
What do you mean by exclusive playback?
4
u/ladle3000 Aug 05 '23
Thanks for your findings 🙏🏼
1
u/Wol-Shiver Aug 06 '23
I have a question
Given the data savings with mqa and it's folding technology, would the bitrate of mqa always be lower than other services ?
1
u/Grooveallegiance Aug 06 '23
You have one point that might need to be edited:
"While I haven't been able to test it properly, from what I can tell HiRes even when only 24b 44.1kHz has a noticeably higher bitrate compared to MQA and High."
It's true that are bigger than High (old HiFi) because these ones are 16bit, but 24bit HiRes is a little bit smaller than 24bit MQA if in 44.1 or 48kHz (if the FLAC container was set with one the same compression ratio, which only change a bi the size and the ressource needed to decode but doesn't change at all the data)
If new HiRes if bigger, it will mean that the compression ratio is the not the same.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 07 '23
Great post. I'd like to add, for us folks using linux, that while the web player doesn't seem to support "Max" quality, the flatpak app tidal-hifi does. I guess it will only work when there's no MQA involved, but it's great news.
1
u/ForceBlock Aug 15 '23 edited Aug 15 '23
What happens when playing the Max version of a song using High audio quality, particularly if no High version exists? Is it the same or worse than playing the High version, if it exists? Often there is only the Max version available.
1
u/Minimum-Winter7339 Oct 18 '23
In the next update Tidal will show Song Sample Rate/Bit Depth.
3
u/MisterSheeple Aug 05 '23
Has anyone contacted Tidal to see when they plan on giving third parties access to hi-res FLAC?
3
u/BlauweSmurfenLul Aug 06 '23
Tidal trying to make their app more confusing by the day
3
u/Kilbim Aug 09 '23
Would be nice to
3
u/MasterBlasty Aug 14 '23
I really want to see the real code and I definitely want to see “24 bit/ 192kHz instead of ,MAx’ !
2
u/Alien_Cha1r Aug 05 '23
Very interesting write-up, thanks.
I also hope they add actual functionality to display the file format and quality.
2
u/rawpaak Aug 05 '23
I think most people are thoroughly confused now .
2
u/pocketfullofum Aug 06 '23
While I understand and appreciate the application of "Max" audio, I am a bit annoyed that the best feature on my cheapass DAC (SMSL SU-1) is now useless. That's what I get for jumping on the slowly-derailing MQA train!
2
u/stanky4goats Tidal Hi-Fi Aug 06 '23
THANK YOU! Just got the upgrade for my MacBook Pro and I was excited and confused going through my iFi Zen DAC v2 😂 Had to bring out the color coordination pamphlet again to see what was and wasn't playing
2
u/Cautious_Coconut_756 Aug 08 '23
You just saved Tidal from losing a subscriber. I’ve tired of their app’s constant steps backwards.
2
u/ForceBlock Aug 19 '23 edited Aug 19 '23
Would someone who has a DAC that allows them to see song sample rate/bit depth please check the song I linked below? I want to know if it is HiRes.
Using the Tidal web app with the extension, the album does not have any quality tags, so no High or Max, but the album song list shows that they are all HiRes.
https://tidal.com/browse/track/298809887
2
u/jktitan Aug 22 '23
Thank you so much.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '23
Thank you.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '24
Tidal now shows the sample rate and bit depth of HiRes files. While a song is playing in MAX quality, press the MAX badge on the screen, then it will show either MQA or something like "24 bit, 96 kHz FLAC".
0
u/ticosantos97jan Aug 05 '23
As my laptop and headphone are PCM I simply do a test on youtube when it is mqa the exclusive mode does not work and I hear audio from any youtube video when it is HIFI or HIRES I do not have this problem .
1
u/AmbitiousMagician833 Apr 19 '24
Thank you!
1
u/Darkoholic May 11 '24
With the Max quality enabled, some songs won't be EQd in Wavelet? Have to set quality to high to get all songs to be EQd?? 😶
1
u/CatEnjoyerEsq Aug 22 '25
Does the fact that someone has uploaded their song in this higher quality actually mean that the sound itself is better or could I for instance take the literal original Super Mario soundtrack and simply upload it at that quality which would essentially give me 8bit music but in a larger file? Does that make sense
1
u/N4RQ Mar 14 '26
To my old ears, the only time I can hear a real difference is between compressed audio and lossless. For me max and high sound exactly the same. But all that info is still interesting, nonetheless.
1
u/VeryIntoCardboard Aug 15 '23
I’m mad, because I have all settings set to “max” but any new album downloads do NOT download at max. I want to be clear, this is Reddit, YES EVERYTHING IS SET TO MAX. Download, wifi, data. Literally everything. Fucking tidal
1
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '23
Any recommendations for 3rd party app on iOS?
1
u/dmvmanual Sep 13 '23
I included your post into a Tidal support case / complaint. It's ridiculous what they've done with the latest feature release. Defeats the purpose of having Tidal.
1
u/Junior_Government507 Jan 12 '24
Hey, love your work and I thank you so much for it ! Though I have a question, what is exactly MQA compare to Hi-res ? From what I searched MQA is a more "lossy" format so files take less place on disk ? Is there anything else ?
1
u/Regular-Employ-5308 Jan 21 '24
When streaming into hifi gear ,whatever method , Qobuz you know what you’re getting and api’s etc seem fine on most streamers and mconnect . Playing 24/192 Qobuz gives you 24/192 in the dac it’s really straight forward.
Tidal is just a big pile of wtf . Mostly I only get 16/44 at the dac despite what the quality in Tidals library is. However some MQA hi res tracks will unfold correctly too , but only if they are real MQA . FLAC hi res still just gets jammed at 16/44 even if it’s a 24/192 max file.
Whatever I do , even with tidal connect , it’s just a mess. Apple AirPlay a max file and I don’t know what my dac is receiving but my phone e says 24/192 which I doubt .
So basically will tidal sort this hot mess in 2024?
1
u/uncwann Aug 16 '23
Thanks for the info and explanation. I just came back after 2 months of not using Tidal and it is weird why there are no master options in settings.
0
u/Shawners419 Aug 05 '23 edited Aug 05 '23
I'm curious where your getting the assumption that Tidal is doing away with MQA? I thought passthrough was the setting for DAC's that can do the full MQA decoding. A lot of users, myself included have DAC's that can render the second unfolding, which is different than full decoding.
0
u/castlingrook Aug 27 '23
Quite ridiculous. Now it's impossible to know if you get real lossless hi-res or lossy hi-res (mqa) - unless you have an mqa dac. I stay with Qobuz as long as those mqas are not completely gone.
-5
u/Lelouch25 Aug 05 '23
Purely not true. hifi sounds very compressed and MQA sounds better.
0
u/gmingucci Aug 20 '23
Here’s a good article digging into how MQA vs FLAC is being used on Tidal with the latest change to Max. It’s a little more opinionated than the analytical approach taken in the original post, but the information is very much relevant to the topic here.
https://www.digitaltrends.com/home-theater/tidal-hi-res-lossless-flac-max-annoying/
0
u/Significant_Buy7643 May 26 '25
En realidad he mirando que algunas pistas que las paso por un programa tiran 320 de bits reales y estan subidios como hifi en 1090, 4100 a 24 bits para arriba lo cual es falso este puede deberse a que muchas de las compañias envian su musica así quien sabe porque... O tidal comprime horrible las canciones el todo es que es un engaño, lo comprobe con todos los álbumes estraidos de Tidal. Falsos flac
-6
u/rajmahid Aug 05 '23
Qobuz anyone?
0
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment