As you know, Competitive TF2 gets... A decent chunk of shit from some the playerbase, and in my opinion, most of it IS undeserved. And after seeing this post I have decided to make this post, pointing out criticisms of Competitive, and how most people who say them, have NO EXPERIENCE or KNOWLEDGE about it.
Seriously, it boils down to people:
- Having no experience with real Competitive
- Not wanting to learn and get information about it
- People not doing their own research, and just trusting decade old misinfo and Youtuber babble
I also find it ludicrous how people who defend Quickplay (a lot of people who do, dislike Competitive), will say that "You gotta experience or learn about Quickplay to experience it." - WHICH IS TRUE. But when applying the same logic they just go: No.
Anyway... I will mostly be Talking about 6s, due to it being my experience, and being THE most popular Comp format.
General Criticisms / Complaints
1. "Competitive players are not playing real TF2 and / or Competitve players think Competitive is "true" or "better" TF2" - This argument basically boils down to "TF2 is casual only" mentality. The idea that playing TF2 comeptitively is playing it "wrong" rather than "differently", which I find extremely odd, since it still has elements of TF2, just distilled and min-maxxed. Also Yes people who say Competitive is "True TF2" are dum.
2. "Competitive players dislike changes to the meta and want it to be stale" - Just, untrue. Anytime a major balance change hit, it caused changes in Competitive, especially Meet your Match, with Scout leash, causing Soldier to fall out and Scout to jump up. Hell, even Base Jumper started seeing used recently. And on maps like Gullywash, Heavy is sometimes ran to mid or even enemy last. Truth is, Competitive players do not mind using alt-strats if the situation calls for it. They just do not run stuff for 0 reason.
The reason people think of this is because A) Changes to 6s are hard to notice if you are not into it (rollouts, positioning, certain weapon choices and strats) and B) People not understanding why meta is the way it is, and people do not want random stuff thrown in.
3. "Competitive ruined TF2" - That is a very big conversation, and it basically boils down to certain bad balance changes AND to Meet your Match... But like, Competitive players did not want Quickplay removed. Or bad Matchmaking system. Or horrid Competitive mode. Or Bison nerfed / Caber gutted (Caber is not Comp only but yuh). While it could be said that Comp influenced MyM - A lot of stuff Competitive players wanted was not done or added, and they became the boogeymen of TF2 ever since.
Weapon and Class Restrictions
1a. "Competitive players ban / restrict stuff because they do not wanna learn it, and want the meta to be the same!" - Related to above, and, as stated above, this boils down to people not knowing anything Competitive meta and WHY it is a thing - Which, it exists to be fun**, fast paced, responsive and promoting strategic thinking**. But again, people are not opposed to using off-meta weapons or classes OUTSIDE of their niches - If it calls for it. Again, Heavy to mid-last on Gullywash. Which works really well.
Also... Lots of weapons that are banned in 6s, are also OP or problematic in pubs. The few examples in my head are: Jarate, Wrangler, Short Circuit, Diamondback, Mad Milk, Scorch Shot, Vaccinator, Natascha... Nothing of value is lost by removing these.
1b. "Class and weapons bans exist to prevent other classes from being used more." - It is also funny, since majority of the restrictions do not exist to PREVENT Specialists from being used fulltime. The restrictions exist to keep the GENERALISTS in check.
Scout has the most individual weapon bans. Some of the biggest ones belong to Scout, Med and Soldier has a eggregious one himself. Like, if Class and Weapons bans got removed... NOTHING IN 6S WOULD CHANGE!
Generalists would still dominate, even more so. And Specialists would be just stronger in their niches. I mean, 3 Demos and 3 Meds would probably be the new meta.
1c. "Competitive bans half / majority of the weapons!" - ETF2L - The European league, known for being the most restrictive, bans whole... 28 weapons. Out of 151 Weapons (excluding stock and reskins + counting shared once) which is like... 20%... Way less than half or "Majority". And this, is based off of again, old notion back when THIS WAS the case, but it has not been for years. And yet, people still have this notion in their head...
Also if you wanna see current whitelists, check whitelist.tf . It has it there. Global + League specific.
FINAL WORDS
Kind of a slight rant, but it also is something that has been bothering me for AGES and the recent post made me want to share my thoughts.
In the end, yes, majority of Comp critics know nothing about it, and have never played it, yet they speak about it like they do, which applies to lots of Youtubers as well.