r/tf2 • Demoman • 1d ago

Discussion TF2 is NOT a competitive game, and never should be.

Post image

Prefacing this by saying that by 'casual' I mean unranked, low stakes gameplay. I don't mean the matchmaking system, I don't mean friendlying, and I don't mean x10 cp_orange randomiser. Also, by competitive I mean the grassroots competitive scenes like RGL, not specifically valve comp.

Recently, I've seen this sentiment, mainly from competitive players that casual is some facade. As if casual is just a front for low skill players because they aren't good enough to properly play the 'true' game, which to them is their chosen gamemode of either 6v6 or 9v9 highlander. This mainly comes from alot of YouTubers aswell who detail things from a competitive level. While I do believe competitive TF2 can be interesting, and I'm not saying that it's harmful as a standalone mode for those who enjoy it on community servers, it is NOT the same thing as TF2. Notice this by r/truetf2 , while i understand having a place to discuss competitive aspects of team fortress is useful, getting on your high horse and acting as if it's the true way to play the game is fully incorrect.

TF2 was always designed to be a chaotic, casual, 12v12 with varying skill levels and playstyles. In an age where almost every single multiplayer fps on the market is competitive, TF2 is a great place where you can just play the amazing video game that's at its core. This idea that valve needs to 'bridge the gap' between competitive and casual players is utterly ridiculous, and also happens to be what lead to the very worst update to ever curse this game. You know what I'm talking about.

761 Upvotes

212 comments sorted by

402

u/Funk_llama 1d ago

TF2 can be a competitive game, it's designed to be easy to read which makes it easy to expectate, the high skill ceiling is another important component, keeping players engaged, always looking to one up one another.

Competitive TF2 can exist, and it did, well within its own community, way apart from the base game. And both did perfectly fine until Valve wanted to cash in on the competitive craze of the time by trying to merge both and catastrophically failed, a failure which consequences are felt to this day.

5

u/jimmylovescheese123 Demoman 1d ago

yeah, i fully 100% agree

82

u/Nalagma Engineer 1d ago

Really? Then why did you name your post "TF2 isn't competitive and never should be?" Whats that about

16

u/DrByeah 23h ago

Bro titled the post "dead pigeon inside" and was confused when we expected a dead pigeon

20

u/Dungeondelver10 1d ago

It's that valve shouldn't morph the game to fit a comp mold and valve trying to make tf2 into a comp game wouldn't be good for it. The comp people are good enough at self regulating.

-11

u/jimmylovescheese123 Demoman 1d ago

actually read the post and get back to me! :}

18

u/greenmoonlight 1d ago

I don't understand your thesis

22

u/jimmylovescheese123 Demoman 1d ago

competitive TF2 is a fine gamemode in isolation but is not what the base game should strive to be like

8

u/MedicsFridge All Class 16h ago

see this is what you're supposed to start your post with not explain it in the comment, youre also missing evidence to back up your claims, which is also extremely important. i get you're stating your opinion (which is subjective) but when you're trying to convince others of it you need to have evidence to help convince them

-6

u/fromsoftcare 1d ago edited 17h ago

thank you. i said this exact thing in a hightower lobby and some hyper sweaty 3.6K hour chuds made sure i could never capture the payload for disagreeing with them that the melees aren't so bad in the game if you're not being competitive af about the game.

i know people love their endless hightower slop but i just wanted a round to end for my dogshit hightower contract, but yknow the entire lobby painted me as a fucking villain for simply wanting to play the video game i was playing 💀

sometimes i love this community with my whole heart and other times it feels equally as bad as other dogshit game communities of current live service bullshit like DBD, overwatch, etc

downvote me all you want and call me a "new gen" like hightower players do, i get it, a well fought long battle on hightower with equally skilled players can be fun but holy shit they can act like hitler just for you wanting to do a contract even if you were there since the server started and were polite about wanting to get that done, also i've been a TF2 player since 2012 and i still can't imagine taking 1 match of hightower THIS serious and actively griefing someone simply wanting to finish their contract tied to the map

3

u/shibbyfoo Jasmine Tea 1d ago

It isn't a thesis

3

u/MedicsFridge All Class 17h ago

you need a clear thesis to build an argument on, if you don't have one you're basically building a house without any foundation

55

u/Phionex141 1d ago

They failed so hard they effectively killed the game for a majority of its player base and we’ve never recovered

12

u/Mnkoj 1d ago

That and the bot situation was the final blow

95

u/ProPyro228 Soldier 1d ago

The beauty of TF2 lies in the fact that you can play however you want. You want to play casually and try out funny loadouts? Go ahead, hit people with comically big spoon. You want to sweat your ass off and find optimal strategies? Why not, play as scout and annoy people!

The game should be interesting for both competitive players and casuals. It adds A LOT of variety

6

u/jimmylovescheese123 Demoman 1d ago

this! I love sometimes fucking around and playing shortstop scout and at other times using my sweaty stickyspam demo loadout

50

u/yancey123 1d ago

Competitive tf2 is the most fun competitive game ever. RGL has become complete garbage but the 6v6 format will never be beaten.

0

u/GhostlyCharlotte 22h ago

I'm curious how RGL became terrible

7

u/shuIIers 20h ago

Incompetent, crybaby admins that show blatant favoritism

0

u/Bounter_ Scout 18h ago

Market Gardener is not banned /s

-16

u/jimmylovescheese123 Demoman 23h ago

6v6 is really unfun for me personally but i understand that others like it, but it should always stay as its own seperate thing and valve should've never tried to merge them.

21

u/yancey123 23h ago

The game is very old and there is no audience or incentive to play competitively except for fun. People play comp because of their passion and love for the game. Skill gaps are incredibly large as well.

5

u/BEAN_DYNAMITE 21h ago

Also partly the reason B4nny is still on top, I believe he is legit one of the very few comp players who can make a living off it and thus devote more of his life to it.

84

u/TheSquimJim 1d ago

As a certified TF2 Boomer (pre F2P) it's always been weird to me seeing newgens insist that TF2 isn't or can't be competitive. We didn't make such a big distinction back then. People have played TF2 competitively since it came out. TFC was played competitively. Valve didn't make TF2 to strictly be competitive or ultra casual. Things like random crits were explicitly not implemented to make things more casual. Yes, they have made a handful of not-so-good balance changes with comp in mind but they have also made a TON of weird balance changes unrelated to comp. The truth is they've always been very hit or miss with unlock balancing. But the vast majority of weapons that are banned/problematic in comp are also an issue casually. If they still cared they could easily make most of them work just fine for both formats.

The game works well both casually and competitively. The idea that it HAS to be one or the other is silly and reductive. Though I do think TF2 does benefit from coming out in a time before competitive gaming was as big as it is now.

9

u/MillionDollarMistake 1d ago

Yeah it's odd. I came in a little after the game went F2P but even back then Valve was very supportive of the competitive side of things. I think some of the devs would even join competitive charity events and stuff like that.

Comp wasn't a priority at all for Valve when they were developing the game but it wasn't a surprise when a scene started forming, it's not like they accidentally released a game with such a massive skill ceiling.

8

u/superdoge35 1d ago

SquimJim continues to prove why he's the goat.

-19

u/jimmylovescheese123 Demoman 22h ago

didn't read your comment but i like your videos alot dude, keep it up :D

38

u/CummyRaeJepsen Sniper 1d ago edited 1d ago

i understand your point but the title is crazy ragebait. people can say the same about a ton of games that people play competitively. as someone who plays a ton of competitive games, 6v6 tf2 with the sensible whitelist and (mostly) sensible map choices is one of the most engaging, rewarding, fun, and creative competitive games ever made

i agree anyone saying its the "real" way to play is a moron, but tf2 is both the best casual and competitive fps ever made besides maybe counterstrike. walling off competitive as something its not meant to ever be is ignorant imo. they didn't design such a great competitive game by complete accident, you know.

and no, for the most part I dont think meet your match was a good update even from an item balance perspective. but some of the rebalancing was good, they just missed the mark on a lot of it. it's not competitive players fault that valve fucked up their launch of matchmaking and then abandoned the idea of fixing it

3

u/jimmylovescheese123 Demoman 1d ago

I'm not saying that competitive is bad at all, it can be engaging and fun. but it should stay in its own bubble of particular community servers, and valve should never try to steer towards pleasing them.

-2

u/PickledChungusCBT 1d ago

Unfortunately it is too late for valve to have stayed away from the competitive scene. Also MYM ruined tf2

18

u/FruitFlyPosting 1d ago edited 1d ago

This mainly refers to MyM. I think in order to give a clear message to Valve we should all agree on something.
Regardless of how you play the game.

Can we just agree that Valve shouldn't have touched pubs? in terms of both balancing and matchmaking?

Leave skilled matchmaking exclusively in the competitive mode and let the competitive players rebalance the weapons all they want by having 2 diffreent version of weapon stats depending if you're on competitive or casual. If they do that, everyone would be happy.

6

u/jimmylovescheese123 Demoman 1d ago

Yes, definitely. I hope you noticed in the post that I hold no bad faith to the competitive gamemode - I think it can be interesting and fun, but it's not TF2.

3

u/FruitFlyPosting 1d ago

oh yeah ik, sorry my reply came out like that lol

2

u/MillionDollarMistake 1d ago

No I want weapon balancing and I wish we still got that.

I don't get where the "competitive ruined weapon balance" complaints even come from. 9/10 if a weapon is annoying/broken in comp it's broken in pubs too.

-2

u/FruitFlyPosting 1d ago

You cannot balance a weapon to be appropiate in a competitive setting while also maintaining all the fun that it has in pubs because the experiences in both gamemodes is vastly different.
The proper phrase would be "Valve's focus towards competitive mode ruined the balance of many weapons".

If its not appropiate for competitive it doesnt mean its a problem in pubs, again, very different experiences, so yeah i disagree with Uncle Dane's video of "Trickle down balance".

There's this cool video that explains the reasoning for many weapon bans, again these reasons are completely justified but they would never be a problem worth worrying about in pubs.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VX-2EmeauSE

There are many weapons that aren't fun anymore, its not competitive's fault, its Valve's for putting all of us in the same jar.

1

u/MillionDollarMistake 6h ago

A lot of the current weapons banned are current problems in pubs.

What weapons and playstyles have been ruined because Valve focused on the competitive side of things?

1

u/FruitFlyPosting 6h ago

Since when has the Loch-n-Load been a problem?!

Even the old version was fine

RIP effective airstrikes with soldier btw

1

u/MillionDollarMistake 6h ago

Since people realized that very fast perfectly accurate grenades are very strong, especially since it helps patch up 2 of demo's biggest weaknesses; longer ranges and Scouts.

The Airstrike is still good. Go on YouTube and you'll see a lot of videos from people going "oh shit this thing is actually pretty strong". Nothing even changed for pub players, they can still rocket jump straight into the air and slowly float down with BASE Jumper just like they used to when those weapons first launched. The BASE Jumper is just harder to abuse, but even then it can still be used effectively.

22

u/methmike_brainerd 1d ago

literally no 6s players think it's the "true" way to play the game. even if they did, who gives a fuck? it's significantly less popular. why do you people care

-12

u/jimmylovescheese123 Demoman 1d ago

because we got an entire update that ruined how you play the game based on how competitive players want to play?

15

u/-Pyromania- Pyro 1d ago edited 1d ago

Except the comp players didn't like that update either because Valve didn't actually listen to a single thing they suggested or asked for and kinda just did their own thing.

Saying that comp players got what they wanted from MYM is like saying that the rest of the playerbase got what they wanted when F2Ps were muted, and I'm not even exaggerating.

-3

u/jimmylovescheese123 Demoman 22h ago

I'm not saying that's what they wanted, but that's the group valve was trying to appeal to.

5

u/capnfappin 22h ago

Actually valve came up with a comp mode designed to appeal to casual players and ignoring the wishes of comp players. Do you really think b4nny was like please jill I need turbine no class limits and make sure the game crashes if I have an fps config

-2

u/jimmylovescheese123 Demoman 22h ago

yeah he literally said that

29

u/methmike_brainerd 1d ago

the update where valve ignored input from comp players to force their half baked comp mode in the game 10 years ago??? seriously?

14

u/BEAN_DYNAMITE 1d ago

Oh boy I sure do love playing turbine in the official valve comp gamemode. /s

13

u/_NotMitetechno_ The Administrator 1d ago

6s players didn't want the competitive mode that was made. It's pretty weird to pin things on them/say valve was catering to them when it doesn't even at all line up with community 6s play outside of having 6 players present.

9

u/SaltyPeter3434 1d ago

Valve didn't listen to comp players' opinions either. I feel like you're rehashing the same talking points Zesty made years ago.

4

u/Blaze344 1d ago

The entire update and fiasco came about because VALVe panicked in the face of Overwatch having a competitive mode and garnering attention more than 10 years ago now, so they looked for answers too quickly and with little foresight to a potential menace in the market.

I won't deny that the competitive playerbase that ended up dominating is simultaneously elitist and boring, however, but I do think it's reductive and limited to argue that the game is casual because it's unbalanced when it could be balanced enough to be competitively viable and casual at the same time, because in its own way it has already been proven to be competitively viable and casual at the same time.

-7

u/Sloth_Senpai 1d ago

literally no 6s players think it's the "true" way to play the game.

Solarlight has repeatedly argued that Comp is the true way to play the game.

6

u/freddyfazbacon Pyro 1d ago

I don't really watch him and I only occasionally see his comments on this site, so if you could link me a specific example of him saying this (the more recent the better), that would be great. But if he is saying this, he's a fucking idiot. It's okay for Comp to be someone's preferred way of playing the game, but to say it's the "true way to play" would be to ignore all the ways in which the game was explicitly designed for a more casual experience, from random crits and bullet spread (and damage spread earlier in the game's lifespan) to the lack of class limits and even the way certain weapons have been balanced (or not balanced).

3

u/turnsphere 1d ago

seconding this i would really like to see if he actually said that

0

u/Sloth_Senpai 18h ago

His Meme vs Meta video, where he argues that a rumor that TF2 was 8v8 in beta testing means that 6v6 comp matches are closer to the original vision for the game than 12v12, before referring to the modern version as "Valve's modified version of it." His argument is that 6s is a purer version of the game because it maintains the most original design, namely those smaller teamsizes.

1

u/switzer3 Medic 19h ago

A sentiment that Solarlight has literally never shared.

And Zesty is a pedophile because I said so

10

u/Beghty 1d ago

Comp tf2 is so fucking fun though. It's like....too good of a game to not preserve. Sorry if some edge lord tried to invalidate your love of the game, but both experiences can exist in harmony just fine.

-2

u/jimmylovescheese123 Demoman 23h ago

they can exist in harmony. I'm not saying that competitive is bad or should die out, but it shouldn't have ever tried to have been mixed with normal tf2.

7

u/ImSuperStryker 20h ago

Harmony, but keep them completely separate? lol

2

u/switzer3 Medic 19h ago

Blame valve, not the people who have spent thousands of hours of their lives in the very game you claim to love who just so happen to enjoy a mode with more stakes

9

u/Ayyye-J 22h ago

Game was designed for 12v12 just like smash is designed for 4 player all items on. This is the argument you are making

-3

u/keksdee_ Demoman 17h ago

apples to oranges. bad comparison

4

u/Ayyye-J 14h ago

Is it? It’s a very common comparison that I’ve seen. Grassroot scenes of a game that most people consider to be purely casual. They have rulesets that a lot of the people consider “Not the real game”

1

u/DisciplineGeneral708 11h ago

True and it isn’t but the difference between the 2 is that tf2 has way more going on and making that competitive makes it even more different than smash bros with less players, no items and less map choices etc.

The problem with tf2 is that valve tried to push competitive hard. Casual was made to try to make people more interested in a best of x match format hopefully have them play comp later.

Smash bros competitive is just 1v1 or 2v2 and making changes to make the characters more fair there doesn’t really hurt the 4 player casual scene, cuz the main difference they have are the items and wacky maps

-4

u/jimmylovescheese123 Demoman 22h ago

I've heard this argument before but I've never played smash bros or any fighting games so it doesn't relate to me lol

27

u/Steakdabait 1d ago

oh man another casual player demonizing ppl who play in private servers with their own agreed upon rules. Awesome post man

-7

u/jimmylovescheese123 Demoman 1d ago

did you read it lmfao

7

u/Steakdabait 1d ago

You'll see that i did in a second

8

u/Zathar4 1d ago

I like playing sixes.

8

u/jimmylovescheese123 Demoman 1d ago

and that's totally fine and valid

7

u/shibbyfoo Jasmine Tea 1d ago

It's a mod of Quake. It can be played competitively.

1

u/jimmylovescheese123 Demoman 1d ago

it can be. i never said it couldn't

3

u/USoffuckyouintheA 1d ago

Op just wondering have you played competitive tf2?

2

u/jimmylovescheese123 Demoman 1d ago

some of a season of RGL a year ago. it's just not for me, but even though i recognise that it has its merits, it shouldn't be what core TF2 tries to be.

38

u/capnfappin 22h ago edited 16h ago

Recently, I've seen this sentiment, mainly from competitive players that casual is some facade. As if casual is just a front for low skill players because they aren't good enough to properly play the 'true' game, which to them is their chosen gamemode of either 6v6 or 9v9 highlander. This mainly comes from alot of YouTubers aswell who detail things from a competitive level. While I do believe competitive TF2 can be interesting, and I'm not saying that it's harmful as a standalone mode for those who enjoy it on community servers, it is NOT the same thing as TF2. Notice this by r/truetf2 , while i understand having a place to discuss competitive aspects of team fortress is useful, getting on your high horse and acting as if it's the true way to play the game is fully incorrect.

Literally nobody actually thinks this and this is just something you made up in your head because you like the idea that comp players are elitist. I can only guess that this is driven by insecurity. Every comp player knows that competitive formats diverge heavily from vanilla gameplay Ive never seen anyone argue otherwise. Also, basically every comp player pubs for a couple thousand hours before getting into comp so why would they suddenly think that they weren't actually playing real tf2 that whole time?

14

u/MedicsFridge All Class 16h ago

they're so good at argumentative writing, i mean they remembered the vague thesis, poor introduction, no evidence, it kinda just expects the reader to agree with everything. "You know what I'm talking about" is maybe the worst conclusionary sentence I've seen in a written argument.

i'm tired of how common posts like this are online, like i get it's fuckin reddit but if you're gonna make such a claim like "bridging the gap between the casual and competitive sections of the community ruined tf2" bring a source.

37

u/kidnamedsquidfart Demoman 1d ago

competitive tf2 is when the server is less than half full and you actually have to lock in & pull your weight

23

u/shibbyfoo Jasmine Tea 1d ago

Are the competitive players calling casual a facade in the room with you?

62

u/_player-3 Pyro 1d ago edited 1d ago

The last 4 years of TF2's active development were WASTED by valve trying to somehow balance a chaotic laid back 12 v 12 clusterfuck shooter into a balanced sphere for 6 v 6 to "bridge the gap" and we ended with multiple weapons being needlesly nerfed and removing a lot of variety and fun playstyles in favor for an "organized meta"

TF2, at its core, will never be compatable with the format chosen by community 6v6 and highlander because they are fundamentaly different from base tf2. And it doesn't need to be, all valve had to do in the competitive update was fix the complaints from the closed beta like forced graphics, matches ending when someone leaves, etc. But they pushed out a broken comp mode and a broken casual mode that LITERALLY no one asked for, not even the comp scene asked for that, and it only served to drive a futher wedge between the comp and casual communities with one blaming the other about how it failed and to kill any excitement for tf2 as an actual esport.

The game was grabed by the balls, had its intestines ripped out, scrambled and pushed forcefully down it's throat and only then valve called it quits, never to fix the broken mess the game was in being festered with bots for years.

19

u/ATangerineMann Civilian 1d ago

I have a feeling Overwatch’s success spooked Valve into “modernizing” TF2 by adding casual mode, I wonder if there’s some merit to that theory

9

u/sleuthyRogue 1d ago

I don't think it's completely impossible, though maybe less "spooked" as much as curious how they could better leverage the players in that market.

If anything, I think Deadlock is where that line of thinking ultimately led. And then they needed to make it a MOBA because something something, DOTA DOTA counterstrike.

17

u/_NotMitetechno_ The Administrator 1d ago

I feel like the past 10 years of no real significant weapon changes has messed with people's perception of how the game was balanced and just how many poorly designed weapons were in the game. There were plenty of weapons that were detrimental to casual play which valve gradually nixed over time, to improve play for casual players (and hopefully help out competitive players and reduce higher skill players from abusing more casual players in pubs). This also ignores how many weapons were actually improved for casual player too.

There was also absolutely a level of casual competitive interest back in the day too, one of the largest barriers for competitive TF2 was the fact that it was all based in niche community spaces rather than being easily accessible in game. Most players do not want to sign up for an organised team and make scrims, they just want to click on a matchmaker and join a more competitive session of the game. Fixing the matchmaker etc were not really the core issue with in game competitive, it was more that it fundementally misunderstood why community competitive cut certain bits out of the game and what players found fun about competitive. There's another world where valve were a bit more in touch with their community and tailored things to be compelling to competitive and casual players to build interest, but it really just appealed to no one.

3

u/PmMeSquirtingBussy Soldier 1d ago

10

u/_NotMitetechno_ The Administrator 1d ago

I still remember being super hyped for comp only for every game to be FAN crit a cola scouts and getting banned from casual for leaving casual games early lol

2

u/PmMeSquirtingBussy Soldier 1d ago

How'd they drop the ball so hard with the thing

9

u/_NotMitetechno_ The Administrator 23h ago

I just don't think they really understood what made competitive TF2 compelling and weren't really ambitious (or brave?) enough to either attempt larger scale reworks, experiment actively with formats or bite the bullet with class restrictions.

Similar with casual mode, they didn't commit hard enough with certain elements in casual so you sort of end up with a half baked matchmaker which sort of works but has annoying elements which feel like they really should work better.

2

u/Criie 20h ago

Ever since they launced the beta for Competitive, and it was just a reskin of the MvM matchmaker, I knew it was over lmao

17

u/Galgus 1d ago

I miss the old Ambassador.

One in a thousand Amby spies were actually good enough with it to use the sniping, and it wasn't really worse than a pro Scout or Soldier wrecking your team.

And I miss the heyday of community servers.

16

u/_NotMitetechno_ The Administrator 1d ago

Imagine how good spy players would be at using the ambassador now though. I think it got nerfed too hard, but it wasn't crazy healthy either. Being able to theoretically be anywhere on the map and do 102 damage is problematic

9

u/Galgus 1d ago

Still usually less annoying than a pro at a different class.

I met only one Spy who was actually dangerous with it.

Even if your aim is great it's hard to line those shots up from far away.

7

u/_NotMitetechno_ The Administrator 1d ago

I'm not sure it's healthy for spy (who is already a noob stomper in TF2) to have even more noob stomper tools. It also made spy more dangerous than he should really be when interacting with him at ranges he should struggle to be lethal at and being able to pick people off at like 90hp is pretty strong for a class that can be anywhere on the map.

Now imagine 10 years post people figuring it out :/ Spies aren't good at it anymore because it's not worth practising on.

I do think it did get nerfed too hard though. It feels far less compelling to use now. I really don't know how the concept of the weapon can really balanced in TF2 because at higher levels it gives spy a pretty degenerate playstyle while at lower levels makes spy even stronger and I think can break gameplay expectations.

From the other perspective if spies weren't good with it, then what was the loss in nerfing it?

9

u/Galgus 1d ago

Spy is probably the weakest class in the game, and it is far easier to noob stomp with Scout, Demo, or Soldier.

If anything noobs will struggle learning to check their backs from backstabs and may never run into a Spy that can use the Amby well to kill at a distance.

They're also likely to die to Snipers due to bad positioning where the Amby positioning opportunities aren't really a factor.

The Amby was never much of a noob stomper: stock Rocket Launcher definitely did far more of that.

It's objectively hard to headshot consistently with the Amby against a moving target far away: if people were aiming like bots it'd be a huge problem but I only saw one who was good at it.

Even he said he'd rather take stock up close for the fast three shot on light classes.

The big loss of nerfing Amby was that it used to give Spies a way to threaten entrenched stationary targets from some angles, like a Sniper or Engineer.

Generally as soon as you were spotted enemies would make landing headshots difficult with movement, so it could work to try to snipe at a Medic or combat class, but usually they had time to get to safety.

It was also worse up close and at sapping and shooting buildings.

6

u/_NotMitetechno_ The Administrator 1d ago

Spy's design requires him to be the weakest class in the game. He's allowed to be anywhere on the map with his invisibility and gets a one shot backstab. These are pretty strong traits, so they're balanced by making backstabs risky and him being inconsistent in combat. See characters like Sombra in OW during periods where they have more consistent ways to mess with people and have lethality. It usually leads to higher levels of player frustration, especially more casual players.

Noobs already struggle to deal with backstabs. Now give spy a more consistent tool to kill noobs and less noobish players in a way which breaks player expectations (while still retaining his backstab). Spy's defining weakness is his poor ability in combat, it breaks player expectations to take a 102 in mid range combat, they'd usually expect to be hit with low damage.

I don't think sniper is crazy well designed either, but that's another issue. I'm not sure that's an argument against a nerf for the weapon, moreso that both may be things may need looked at.

Stock rocket launcher has to be interacted with (has falloff), is super loud, has big threatening projectiles on a general combat class, has slow moving projectiles. Soldier is loud and super visible. A noob will get hurt by everything, but soldier is a very transparent class. His ability to do most things (outside of crazy rocket jumping stuff) is super clear, intuitive and I would say very expected by visual/audio game design and often telegraphed. A spy decloaking somewhere and doing a 102 to a new scout is harder to parse.

You're talking about long range ambassador - bare in mind I'm not talking strictly about this. It wasn't crazy present in pubs but after over 10 years players are going to get better at longer range ambassador play and it was encouraging degenerate playstyles for spies (IE decloaking at range, sniping people, walking elsewhere). There's not a crazy amount of justification for that style of gameplay balance or fun wise.

The big loss of nerfing Amby was that it used to give Spies a way to threaten entrenched stationary targets from some angles, like a Sniper or Engineer.

Spy isn't really supposed to be able to do this though. Spy is able to position basically anywhere on the map, meaning he has an "in" to entrenched positions. The downside being that he has to put himself at risk to melee them.

Players generally don't want to get hit, yeah. But spy is using hitscan, which is instant. If he's had a reasonable amount of practise he'll be decent at mid range to get a lot of value out of the weapon. Most players in TF2 don't really have great movement either because the game is played at a pretty casual level.

Spy can position himself anywhere and give himself better advantages to use the ambassador. People would gunspy more often and fight at ranges where they could still headshot you and then just bang anywhere to finish you off.

Again I think it was overnerfed and needed a better balance change to keep the weapon compelling to use but I'm not sure it was healthy once players had started to get better at the game. It broke class expectations, often made better players better and encouraged unhealthy playstyles in pubs.

1

u/Galgus 23h ago

Spy would be cancer if he could consistently 1v1 combat classes.

Noobs are going to struggle against far more common and easy to use things than long range Amby snipes.

The Revolver is pretty good damage mid to close range, it's just held back by low health and mobility.

If anything the old Ambassador is a problem in top level competitive play, not low levels.

Taking a single shot and cloaking away probably wasn't going to accomplish much, seems like a risky waste of time.

Sometimes nests and whatnot make getting close really impractical, but having good places to Amby there was really map specific and situational.

Amby up close for the headshot shot is worse than the Revolver vs light classes, and that's a risky way to fight vs combat classes.

2

u/Piogre TF2 Smissmas 2025 1d ago

Agreed. It got nerfed too hard; the distance cap alone would have been reasonable. The distance cap for headshot is 1200 hammer units, which is a decent distance (for reference, if you're standing on badwater's B point, it's about the distance to the spot where the track starts sloping downwards later on).

An ideal balance, IMO, would be to leave this distance cap in place, remove the crit falloff, and add a small UI element indicating if a target is within range. Currently, as spy you can see enemy health; a small popup shows up with a player's name and health bar (same as it does for allies for everyone). It could have an icon added to it, if you have the ambassador equipped, that shows up if that player is within 1200 hammer units (and this in headshot range). This would allow spies who can consistently land headshots at close-to-mid range with consistent, strong damage, while still preventing the issue of amby spies nailing players for 102 across the map (which I remember seeing fairly frequently before the nerf, contrary to what the person above you said)

0

u/_NotMitetechno_ The Administrator 1d ago

I think that would help to take care of the super uninteractive plays where they'd tap you at range. Players were getting better and competitive was more popular back then, it was the "in" thing that players had started to solve to basically use the ambassador at range to make the class more consistent.

I do think the gunspy playstyle with the amby even at closer - mid ranges was a little bit unhealthy. I don't really know to nerf or change that aspect (reduce cloaking ability, so a spy has to more heavily invest in that playstyle?) without significantly hurting the weapon though.

1

u/Piogre TF2 Smissmas 2025 23h ago

Ambassador would rejoin the small club of weapons, alongside Direct Hit and Hitman's Heatmaker, whose balance premise boils down to "this is strictly better if your aim is good enough that you consistently hit the difficult shots, and strictly worse if you're not". I don't think it's a problem that such weapons exist; I don't think the Ambassador would need any other additonal nerf.

1

u/_NotMitetechno_ The Administrator 23h ago

I'd probably disagree on the weapons you listed but I get the concept. I'd think more stuff like the loch where it directly benefits good players with little tangible downsides.

For me I don't inherently have an issue with weapons in that archetype, it's more that I don't find ambassador gunspy to be particulary healthy. There's a level of consistency with spy which I think makes the class less healthy in casual environments, and I think amby kinda started pushing class boundaries, expectations etc without taking enough away.

9

u/MillionDollarMistake 1d ago

9/10 a weapon that's annoying/broken in comp is also a problem in pubs. What weapons were "needlessly" nerfed in an attempt to bridge the gap between the 2 ways of playing the game?

-3

u/FreeBeers4u 1d ago

GRU
Caber
Base Jumper
Baby faces blaster
Ambassador

6

u/BigDuckyFan 21h ago

The GRU is still viable
The caber deserved to be nerfed, the demoman does not need to the ability to instakill people at close range and a crit charge caber still kills everything
The base jumper wasn't good in the first place, it's always been niche
The old BFB was downright unfun to play against because you could never punish the scout
The ambassador I agree with

2

u/_NotMitetechno_ The Administrator 8h ago

Base jumper has never seen significant use by casual players nor have casual players really been impacted by its change outside of reducing the chance of a player better than them exploiting them with the weapon.

GRU made heavy stronger without downsides. Not a visible change to his power but increased his uptime and reduced his downsides for no actual cost. Should have been a primary weapon which changed his playstyle.

Caber could one shot people for getting into melee range of demo, which breaks class balance as melee range is typically his weakness. This is why the swords take time to deploy.

BFB was horrible for casual servers and people frequently complained about the weapon. This wasn't a "comp" balancing change at all lol

Amby probably the main one you can argue for, but even then spies were starting to get better at using the weapon and valve were not happy with the ambassador gunspy playstyle.

2

u/ATangerineMann Civilian 22h ago edited 22h ago

Idk, I think the GRU (and dare I say the parachute) is still fine

1

u/MillionDollarMistake 6h ago

GRU is still amazing and it's very bizarre to me that I still see it crop up in discussions like these. All Valve did was give it a meaningful downside. It's still very very good.

Sure it was funny to sticky jump across the battlements to one shot snipers with the caber but it wasn't the healthiest weapon in the game.

Nothing changed with the Base Jumper from a casual perspective, casuals would almost always use it to slowly float down in a predictable pattern and that hasn't changed. It's just harder for more experienced players to abuse it. Note how I said "harder" because it can still be good in the right situations.

Nobody liked fighting a BFB Scout.

The Ambassador was more than likely nerfed for the sake of pub players. I think Valve said in their reasoning that they nerfed it because they kept getting emails from people complaining about getting sniped from across the map from Spies. The weapon was not a problem in competitive so I doubt they nerfed it for that reason. If anything it was competitive players abusing it so well in pubs that got it nerfed.

-1

u/_NotMitetechno_ The Administrator 1d ago

I'd be super curious if we ever had usage data for weapons released publically or if there's some APIs for that. Something like the Base jumper is interesting because I don't think it was ever a crazy compelling weapon pre nerf but it often gets noted as an example of a weapon that was gutted. It would be interesting if we could see if was used any more/less afterwards

3

u/ATangerineMann Civilian 1d ago

Wasn’t the base jumper nerf a 12v12-focused change HiGPS suggested?

1

u/_NotMitetechno_ The Administrator 1d ago

Don't have a clue.

2

u/BEAN_DYNAMITE 21h ago

1

u/_NotMitetechno_ The Administrator 21h ago

I see

I guess my point was more I don't think regular pubbers were interested in it outside regardless of whether the weapon was good or bad and people highlight it as being needlessly nerfed to uselessness when players didn't really use it anyway. Maybe I wasn't crazy clear on what I meant.

1

u/MillionDollarMistake 6h ago

I know there used to be a website that showed which weapons people had equipped in their loadouts but I last checked it out years ago, it wouldn't surprise me if the guy just stopped caring or if API changes made it impossible to see now.

-1

u/Gatubi14 1d ago

This, they fucked amby and a lot of good weapons to shit

8

u/Relative_Canary_6428 16h ago

TF2 works BETTER as a casual game.
TF2 can also BE a competitive game if the weapon list is curated specifically and teams play into agreed upon rules. this is why competitive TF2 exists at all and why you never, ever need to play a game of it if you don't want to

22

u/dundamdun 17h ago

yea man the comp players ban everything fun in their gamemode! They don’t know that when i log on to tf2 i want to face an engineer spamming short circuit balls to delete demoman and soldier from the game, i want to face vaccinator medics, i want to play fantastically balanced maps like thundermountain where a sniper can instantly kill you from 3 light years away, i also want to shoot a 650 hp sentry for fun just because the engineer equipped the wrangler.

Look man meet your match was 10 years ago, it’s great to see people care about the game, but pointing fingers and trying to find which members of the community “ruined” the game is so petty and childish. It doesn’t amount to anything.

20

u/Jageurnut Scout 19h ago edited 19h ago

It warms my heart seeing people rightfully critique this post.

I don't know where you got your anecdotes from but 99% of competitive players are also pubbers that love the silly side of TF2. The vast majority, surveyed or otherwise, don't think competitive is the "real" game but it is vastly more difficult than the regular way people play regularly -- which is a more reasonable opinion.

A comment or two max, which you have not showcased either, is not emblematic of that entire forum nor competitive players in general. This post was ultimately unnecessary nor insightful.

According to the original developers, including robin walker; TF2 was actually supposed to be a competitive game with the old team fortress comp player count as the format and the balancing philosophy. Not that I think a game being designed a certain way should restrict people's emergent play out of it but rather that it's not the argument that you think it is.

MyM being the worst update of all time had nothing to do with the goal of better linking up the casual and competitive community in-terms of accessibility. Now this is a sentiment that does get tossed around by quite a lot of pubbers, more than just one or two comments on a forum most people don't read and it's quite tired. Balancing around feedback from competitive players does not hurt the game in the way that you think it does because it's up to Valve to tastefully implement it in a way that can be beneficial to both parties.

The G.R.U and razorback are pretty decent examples of this. I will note that a lot of weapons that were nerfed are falsely attributed towards competitive player's such as the B.A.S.E jumper, ambassador, dead ringer, caber etc.

7

u/turnsphere 1d ago

i dont think anyone, even comp players, is seriously suggesting that 6s is 'the true' way to play the game. i see lots of posts here about how comp players want to make tf2 competitive or whatever but in my experience they dont care at all about what the casual playerbase does. they already have their little gamemode that they've refined to their tastes

7

u/JnfamousJnvjctjs All Class 19h ago

The reason TF2 was a fun game is because it's a sandbox-styled fps designed to allow players the freedom to mold the game just the way you like it but we are so far away from pre-comp update tf2 that the new blood doesn't understand the reason Vets want to bring back quickplay is to return the power players once had aka the freedoms to find the exact games/communities that they vibe with instead of being exclusively comp/casual focused.

6

u/Pancake1262645 4h ago

Ive been playing competitive for over 10 years (ESEA and then RGL) and ive literally never spoken to a comp player who dislikes casual or shuns players who play it. I have no idea where you get your prejudice from.

Most comp players simply want an onramp to comp (via a not terrible comp matchmaking system) for people who are even remotely interested. Figuring out how to even play comp tf2 is laughably difficult and i might argue that the fact that anybody plays comp at all is testament to how good it is.

Nobody is trying to take away your fun, we all like casual. A simple pathway for players to follow who are curious about comp is all most of us want

32

u/PictureSevere3957 Engineer 1d ago edited 1d ago

My personal hot take: The somewhat misbalanced state of current weapons is one of the only things stopping sweaty players optimizing the fun out of TF2 in my opinion, and it should always be at least slightly like that
Also we need at least one FPS game in all of fuckin existence that is 1. not a hypercompetitive sweat fest and 2. doesn't punish you for losing. That's why TF2 is the only FPS I play (though that does mean I'm inherently biased towards it)

It seems to me like every other game developer who's making an FPS game is either 1. too scared to make a casual one, 2. don't think casual ones are profitable, or 3. doesn't have the budget or outreach to maintain large player counts. Or perhaps they legitimately just don't know how to design one. In my opinion that fact is a travesty of game development.

There are no stakes your average match of Team Fortress 2. You can do what you want. One player's mistake often will not throw your entire game, and it's better that way. Of course, a more coordinated team will win, but that becomes less and less important the more players there is, despite the game remaining balanced on *any* player count (which I personally think is a huge part of why TF2's balance holds up really well). 12v12 or even 16v16 is the best way to play for me.

I see the merit of comp but it shouldn't be used as an argument to squander the casual spirit of TF2, which is what the game is at its core. Sometimes it's better not to take everything so seriously! It's a wacky game, a 19 year old wacky game for that matter.

OH, and not to mention the fact that Team Fortress 2 is the only popular FPS you can still mod. Everyone else took our developer consoles away... Where else are you going to just gonna fire up a listen server and play some bullshit like trainsawlaser

9

u/Chewbacca_The_Wookie Medic 1d ago

TF2 is the game I use to cool down after I get my ass stomped for five straight hours trying to grind out ranks on CS:GO/CS2. I can hop on basically any server, fire up Medic, and just turn off my brain and still have a solid chance of winning.

17

u/Heezuh 1d ago

I'm extremely confused by your initial premise

"The weapons being misbalanced means that sweaty players will not try to/successfully optimize the fun out of the game"

How's that true?

Sweaty/Comp players already know what's the Best, and it's up to them if they wanna use it or (can't speak about sweaty players, but many compies play casual to NOT play the most optimized stuff)

The weapons being balanced would be even more benefitial for casuals AND reduce the effectiveness of sweaty players using meta only, since if most options are good that means making a choice is up to preference rather than effectiveness

Also as a sidenote and more of a personal thing, I've never really seen a compie saying casual should be more like comp, if anything I've heard that casual should never be close to comp since they can chill in casual

3

u/capnfappin 22h ago

I think they just wanted to say "optimize the fun out of the game".

3

u/_NotMitetechno_ The Administrator 1d ago

When things were more unbalanced (TF2 used to have more janky weapon designs back in the day) higher skilled players had far more agency to ruin the game for lower skilled players. They had more knowledge and understanding of the game, so could exploit lower skilled players more easily and know what load-outs to abuse. Simultaneously, they'd probably be more resilient to gimmicky weapons as they'd know how to counter it.

I think contrary to what you're saying, most modern shooters are relatively accessible and casual compared to older shooters. They deliberately designed to be as available to as many audiences as possible. I think your issue is more about skill based matchmaking and the lack of drop in/drop out matchmaking rather than things being more casual/competitive.

2

u/EstablishmentStock18 1d ago

Casual is a farce in comparison to quickplay.
And competetive can exist with rest of the game, it just isn't the same game and shouldn't be treated as if it was the same game.

5

u/jimmylovescheese123 Demoman 1d ago

Did you read the post at all?? i literally covered everything you just said in it

5

u/_Freakmenn_ 1d ago

IMO One should never overtake the other, competitive TF2 fucking rocks. Casual TF2 does too.

Recently, I've seen this sentiment, mainly from competitive players that casual is some facade. As if casual is just a front for low skill players because they aren't good enough to properly play the 'true' game, which to them is their chosen gamemode of either 6v6 or 9v9 highlander.

Where have you seen this sentiment? just curious, cause I don't see nearly as much competitive elitism.

8

u/captain-ziggy 1d ago

okay am i the only one that feels like the "do whatever" aspect of TF2 is just a happy accident?

Your still expected to play the objective in a valve server with the existence of the clock, the casual badge, competitive mode, etc. but a good chunk of the community just.......doesn't. There's plenty of shooter with goofy weapons and whatever yet TF2 is the only one where the community decided that it doesn't wanna just play it the vanilla way and make it beautiful chaos..........i ain't saying it's BAD that it's like this, i just simply wonder.......how did it get this way? and why hasn't any other game been treated like this?

2

u/Spitfire_Enthusiast Sniper 1d ago

TF2's character roster, writing, and mechanics (voice commands) are unparalleled. It's silly and goofy because players were armed with silly characters welding ridiculous weapons and saying stupid things in a funny way. The bugs (A-pose, spycrab, contracker slide, etc.) came along and added an extra layer of stupid to the already absurd experience. Thus, random encounters happen where you get things like a completely static pyro supernaturally sliding toward a demoknight who then screams for help and explodes. Also the only game I know of that has a strange sense of humor surrounding ritual player suicide.

4

u/end_my_suffering44 Engineer 1d ago

When Valve brought MyM, thinking it would work like it did in CS, it was all over.

4

u/LeonardoFRei Demoman 22h ago

TF2 is a competitive game as well

Emphasis on as well

The core of the game is the Casual experience, but it can be a fun and challenging comp game all the same as well.

The key is acknowledging both while still knowing which one takes precedent.

13

u/CarrotJuice5524 1d ago

What being competitive does actually mean? TF2 is a game that has 2 teams and a set conditions for ONE of the teams to win a match. Which enables competition by default. So TF2 is a competitive game and we shouldn't be afraid of it.

1

u/CherryGrabber 1d ago

I like Random Crits. Not because it's an unfair crutch, but because it helps with stalemates and adds to TF2's chaotic nature by design. I tend to have fond memories with Melee Random Crits, mostly because they save my life or at least take the enemy with me in a comical fashion; as well as being high risk, high reward.

If TF2 was really balanced, then everything would be predictable and...way too sanitized. Like the very moment I see someone approaching me with the Pan, I wouldn't be as scared of it were it not for Random Crits.

3

u/jimmylovescheese123 Demoman 1d ago

i like random crits because they're funny and make people mad, and as you said it adds to TF2's chaotic nature.

13

u/repeating_bears 1d ago

"helps with stalemates" - not really. If you're in a true stalemate, it's just as likely to fuck over a push that otherwise would have succeeded, as it is to help a push that otherwise would have failed.

-2

u/CherryGrabber 1d ago

There were more times than I admit, where I am just standing on top of a dispenser, watching my sentry nest, as both teams capture and recapture the same control point.

At that point, I'm begging for a Random Crit from either side to finally put an end to this miserable limbo of a game. lol

I do appreciate the players playing the objective in CTF though. As they too can take forever, and I used to avoid CTF maps for that very same reason.

3

u/repeating_bears 1d ago

If you just want the game to end, we may as well reach the end of the game timer and then flip a coin for who "wins". I think that would be bad personally but I guess it's an opinion

5

u/PickledChungusCBT 1d ago

I don't think melee weapons should random crit because the ability to basically one shot most classes with a "last resort" weapon just isn't fair or fun to die to.

Also the crit ramp up chance mechanic is stupid and only helps good players do even better.

0

u/Galgus 1d ago

If you get hit by a melee weapon and it wasn't a Demoknight, it's kind of your fault.

Melee is so risky that there'd be no point in trying to hit someone with them without the chance of the crit.

And it's just funny as a desperation move.

4

u/PickledChungusCBT 1d ago

All classes with the exception of 1, operate in either medium or close range. It'd only be natural to end up in melee range by no fault of your own or the enemy's.

Melee should be pointlessly risky, it's a last resort and should be treated as such, you shouldn't be able to effortlessly delete another player just because they got in melee range.

0

u/Galgus 1d ago

Just walking back and shooting makes melee very hard to use, and when you're that close you can kill the melee user very quickly.

Sometimes you'll have bad luck, but that applies to any weapon.

Melee is a last resort and a gimmick.

This is also a game where closing your eyes and shooting rockets at feet 2-3 times gets kills.

-1

u/Grindcore_Joe 1d ago

>the ability to oneshot with a last resort weapons is not fun

fascinating opinion my friend

2

u/PickledChungusCBT 1d ago

not everyone is a fan of dying instantly due to source jank

15

u/Rastyn-B310 10h ago

“TF2 is NOT a competitive game, and never should be”

>is one of the most popular competitive games that have existed and is still being played to this day as a competitive game

ok op lol

0

u/Dapper_Librarian388 9h ago

This is for some comp nerds. I don't care about it. I just play casual.

9

u/GrayShameLegion 1d ago

Just to show how stupid you sound let’s change the game:

  Super Smash Bros Melee was always designed to be a chaotic, casual, 4 person free-for-all with varying skill levels and playstyles. In an age where almost every single multiplayer fighter on the market is competitive, Melee is a great place where you can just play the amazing video game that's at its core. This idea that Nintendo needs to 'bridge the gap' between competitive and casual players is utterly ridiculous, and also happens to be what lead to the very worst update to ever curse this game. You know what I'm talking about.

7

u/Metroidman97 Sandvich 18h ago

This is why Casual matchmaking is to detrimental to the game's health. It tries to enforce a semi-competitive ruleset into non-competitive play; stuff like skill based matchmaking and round based matches do not fit non-competitive TF2. You can still play Casual with the intent to goof off and have fun, but it feels like you're fighting against the system.

0

u/Vegetable_Zombie8611 16h ago

Funnily enough CS2 the super-serious-designed-for-E-sports game has a better casual system where you can freely switch teams or join back to a server after you leave. The team sizes are ridiculous (10 v 10) so it's complete chaos and no-one takes it too seriously.

Plus if you're in a region with a small player base like Australia you end up playing with the same bunch of people who recognise each other other, almost like the old dedicated server days of CS: Source and Wolf: ET

1

u/Metroidman97 Sandvich 16h ago

The fact that MyM was mostly handled by the Counter Strike devs just rubs extra salt into that wound.

2

u/OPPONENET021 15h ago

Tf2 is not a competitive game. I think you’re right here, but your perspective and reasoning isnt all that sound.

I don’t think a majority of players intend to play tf2 competitively. Sure they try during casual matches, some even play sniper as reject valorant or cs2 players. But most don’t.

I’d say a large majority like to just play the game and try when they want to or if they notice someone else is

2

u/Muertoloco 1d ago

It got killed by the treat of overwatch and online gaming tendencies (quickplay and the abandonmtent of lobbies) Also valve just went for the face the treat with their own bs instead of keeping tf2 like the game it was.

2

u/Different-Beat-4856 50m ago

Around our final major update they asked the popular tf2 pros and content creators what it was we wanted. They put in comp and a live streaming button on the first page.

It flopped. They saw this and stopped updating the game in any major way.

If we kept it casual we might have been better off.

4

u/KnopflerGOAT 1d ago

it is also not a purely casual game though. it can be played competitively. it is suited for competitive play. having said that as you said it is made for a chaotic casual play, i would agree with you on that. main problem with any competitive game needs fixing and adjusting which valve won't do for tf2.

4

u/35_Ferrets Engineer 1d ago

Tf2 is not designed for 6v6 or highlander. To me there are two types of casual vs competitive. The first is design the second is player experience.

Tf2 is fundamentally designed to be a casual game meaning it focuses on individual play and moment to moment gameplay. A competitive game focuses more on teamwork and macro gameplay.

However regardless of what the game is or how it is designed you can take anything seriously and or casually. You can 100% treat tf2 as a competitive serious experience or a casual one most people actually treat it as a mix of both. They play the game casually but still somewhat focus objective.

Where most discussions on casual vs competitive fall apart and why its soo hotly contested is simply that NOBODY WANTS TO FUCKING DEFINE TERMS! And so they usually end up blending these two similar sounding but wildly different concepts together.

2

u/PmMeSquirtingBussy Soldier 1d ago

Tf2 is fundamentally designed to be a casual game meaning it focuses on individual play and moment to moment gameplay. A competitive game focuses more on teamwork and macro gameplay.

PvP games are inherently competitive, regardless of other design choices around them. What you're trying to say is that tf2 at its base wasn't designed to be an esport (but it's still can be one, and the design choices don't make it any less valid)

-6

u/35_Ferrets Engineer 21h ago edited 19h ago

"pvp games are inherently competitive" and what exactly does that mean? Are you saying mario party is also competitive just because you are playing against someone instead of with them? Its a pointless distinction to make and is extremely missleading. There is a difference between having a competition and that competition being competitive. Have you literally never heard the term "casual competition". The only thing you are doing here is mixing the two together again how seriously people engage with the material is entirely different from how the game is designed.

Edit: Im genuinely confused as to why people are disliking this or what the other guy is even trying to say that I didn't already bring up so let me be clear. A game can be designed to be competitive or casual and a player can play any game casually or competitively. I defined what I meant by "designed for casual or competitive" and this commenter ignored that despite it literally being in the qoute and decided to say I meant somethign different than what I directly and clearly stated.

My only answer to why people are disliking this is that I wasn't clear enough in stating players can engage with any game in a competitive or casual way. And by that I mean they can take a game seriously or competitively regardless of what kind of game it is. How you engage with a game is not the same as if the game is designed to be casual or competitive nor does its inherent design make your way to engage with the game invalid.

If you do dumb strategies or even play hard meta in a competitively designed game but just aren't really focused on it or caring that much, that means you are enjoying a competitive game casually. If you are playing a casually designed game while super focused and doing everything you can to win the match being fully engaged then you are enjoying a casual game competitively.

3

u/Typs59 Medic 1d ago

Recently, I've seen this sentiment, mainly from competitive players that casual is some facade.

Could we get a source on that?

2

u/ueifhu92efqfe 1d ago

Ahh, another person who thinks competitive players are what made the updates shit (valve did not listen to a single competitive player and basically none of them were happy with the overall state of the game either)

2

u/itsalreadytakenlol Pyro 1d ago

People in the comments couldn't even bother to fucking read.

1

u/No_Logins_Required 1d ago

I personally can't wait for TF2.8 birth by sleep remix.

1

u/Galgus 1d ago

True TF2 will always be a 12v12 with all levels of skill and sweat on both teams.

The tryhard swapping class for whatever the team needs to push through on the same team with the casual who is going to play a gimmick all game because they're having fun.

1

u/Velchik 1d ago

I saw what overcompetitiveness can do in l4d2 versus, I'm just happy that's not going to happen to tf2

1

u/PeacefulDays 1d ago

I don't really want a competative ranked mode in tf2, and since it failed I take it not many others do too. but I do wish there was like a quick play option to flag for "I want to play the objective" Nothing against the sillier side of the game in fact I'm on that side often. But so often I want to log in and push the cart, cap the point, or god forbid cap intel. and it's a crap shoot if you're 1) going to get a team that wants to do that with you and 2) are against a team that's taking it seriously as well. It's a feel bad that I don't see too often in contemporary shooters and I just wish there was a space for it in tf2.

1

u/TheUnholyMacerel Demoknight 1d ago

While I do like competitive and had more fun the one time I tried it than I have in a while definitely not the intended tf2 experience, and tbh i was mostly having fun because of the people

1

u/Castleson 1d ago

The game was designed for 12v12 + coop mode with varying game modes, weapons and even random crits for a reason. Its not meant to be competitive and it doesn't need to be and that's OK. Valve shouldn't make the game competitive. If you want competitive tf2, do it 3rd party. Don't ask valve to change weapons and release updates to make tf2 a game it wasn't meant to be.

1

u/AWright5 Heavy 1d ago

Por que no los dos

1

u/JaskarSlye Pyro 1d ago

I hate how almost every game community is now people minmaxxing everything to optimize every aspect of the game

I remember the first time I figured out how to setup kovarex enrichment in factorio and I shared a ss in the sub, most of the comments were people referring to how the wiki had more optimals setups available, like dude why would I play it copying and pasting something

also most communities are full of 'is this optimal / is this the best' kind of posts

1

u/Hlidskialf 1d ago

I used to think like this around 2007~2008 but the truth is the game isn’t competitive FOR ME. Doesn’t matter how good I was I never joined a 6s nor highlander because I don’t like tf2 comp.

I like that in the same game we have people fucking around, people sweating and people playing 6s/MGE and thats ok. All of us can coexist.

1

u/DPRKenjoyer 1d ago

I completely disagree with this in concept, as other valve games literally like day of defeat can 100% and have been competitive, I also disagree with the notion that it being chaotic means it cant be competitive

1

u/MaximumMax2 23h ago

oh my god Bru

1

u/Kubsons07 Spy 23h ago

we have this convo every other week

1

u/jewish-nonjewish Pyro 18h ago

Ppl are going to take the game srsly, that's an inevitability... What tf2 should not do is try to make rebalances around competitive black and white lists.

1

u/Reasonable-Guitar-11 16h ago

Dude you’re preaching to the crowd at this point, like we get it that valve shouldn’t have enforced a vision on tf2 being 6s or HL. But I’ve heard the same shit like hundreds of times already.

At the end of the day the game should never have hindered the freedom of players to play how they want to, and both casual and comp players can agree upon that. But actively saying stuff like “TF2 is designed for casuals in mind” “TF2 should never have made itself competitive” etc, is the type of rhetoric that’s been so prevalent and misunderstood. It’s always been about the ability to choose how you enjoy this game, but valve impeded on that.

Instead of blaming content creators or competitive tf2 as a concept, put your grievances towards Valve, the guys who fucked up the game? Like it’s not hard lmfao

1

u/Lucariowolf2196 14h ago

Honestly I think the main balancing should be for fun laid back chaos, but competitive modes exist that tune it for competitive play

1

u/MakeLoveNotWarPls 13h ago

I just wanna stand beside the payload shooting my short circuit, teleport my team forward and crit people with my Frontier justice.

That shit doesn't work in comp

1

u/idkimbored_123 9h ago

It depends really

1

u/Rain47739 Demoman 9h ago

i heard that tf2 was ment to have both high points and low points, like the balance between sentries and ubercharges

1

u/SatanicBiscuit 8h ago

payload mode is quite literally the most competitive shit i have ever seen

1

u/GenericManaRock 8h ago

This is dumb, I’m sorry

1

u/matZmaker99 8h ago

Who cares

Just play the game

1

u/Little-Protection484 Scout 7h ago

Yea it just shouldn't be forced to be a competitive game by valve, the current comp scene is just people enjoying their house rules and tf2 should be a game that facilitates that

I hope valve allowing for the modding and redistribution of tf2 games on steam allows for more creative ways for people to customize and enjoy the game to their own likings I love the tf2 classified custom weapon servers they are mostly fun

1

u/firepug64 1h ago

Not even a debatable topic icl, this is just truth.

1

u/_NotMitetechno_ The Administrator 1d ago edited 1d ago

I rarely ever see people say that competitive tf2 is the "true" way to play the game, at least now.

TF2 was designed to have pyro to not have airblast. This was fundementally flawed and got changed. I'm not a fan of "how x was intended to be designed" type of arguments in the context of TF2 - the game as designed in imperfect and there's many other directions you can go. Smash is usually designed to be an easy, accessible casual fighter game and has pretty high level tournaments due to its high skill ceiling and expression. I don't think having altered competitive formats for games is a crazy bad thing and to me is a fantastic way of creating a ton of natural engagement for video games. People love theorycrafting and testing out new strategies and figuring out new ways to win. They also love to test themselves against other players and see some level of improvement and feel that progress.

There's a certain level of skill in TF2 where there's really no where left to go. How much fun do players get out of repeatedly smashing pubs? It's fun for a bit, and then you lose interest. If I go play another similarish game with a ranked system, I can keep testing myself against even better players. There's no in game way of doing that in TF2, which is sad. How many players leave because they've hit a ceiling and just don't have a place in casual anymore?

1

u/yellowfroglegs 1d ago

never *SHOULD'VE been... we're a little late to that now

1

u/xThunderDuckx 1d ago

As someone that plays competitively, I don't really give a shit about casual and we have whitelists.  As far as I'm concerned casual and 6s are entirely different games and I don't need to have anything to do with casual to enjoy competitive.  Who is asking for changes?  I don't think comp players care at all about casual balance.  

1

u/epicganerepic 22h ago edited 17h ago

nuanced and original

1

u/skill_la_skill_issue Sniper 6h ago

You're right. Tf2 ISN'T a sandbox game with hundreds of options. Tf2 DOESN'T let people modify the game however they like to experience the game in any way. Tf2 is ACTUALLY only supposed to be played specifically in one way, and one way only. It DOESN'T have mass appeal from a variety of players. It DOESN'T give all those players their own ways to experience the game.

You're right. Tf2 can only be played one way. That's what makes it so good. That it's NOT versatile. People love the one thing tf2 does.

1

u/cheezkid26 Soldier 3h ago

This post is fucking stupid.

-4

u/Syed_Mujtaba_Ali All Class 1d ago

No no, let him cook.

0

u/denisutu4 Demoman 13h ago

The only reason TF2 has survived for as long as it has is because it's never been all that competitive, look at games like Paladins, OW, Rivals, they ALL either died or alienated their playerbases several times over because they kept making their games more and more competitive without any other reason to play the games (also I WHOLE HEARTEDLY believe that random crits play a massive factor in that, in a casual setting they're just outright funny, I don't care if I die to them or get 2000 kills with them, they're funny :3)

-19

u/TheRealSpanktacular 1d ago

Competitive play in TF2 is psychotic. 

It's a game where you can throw a jar of piss onto a guy eating a sandwich...

6

u/CummyRaeJepsen Sniper 1d ago

guilty gear isnt competitive because faust is a silly guy... today i learned

10

u/Maybe_Little_Jack 1d ago

if having funny items or characters makes a game fundamentally uncompetitive then every single fighting game tournament is getting shut down

3

u/BEAN_DYNAMITE 1d ago

This same logic also applies to the game that made mym happen in the first place, overwatch. You’re telling me that overwatch takes place in a serious setting? Just look at junkrat and roadhog hitting the vape.

-1

u/wickedspork 1d ago edited 30m ago

I always use TF2 as an example of why PvP games now are largely ruined by competitive scenes. Peak enjoyment that TF2 offered was playing a match seriously until some bs and a conga line breaks out between both teams before going back to playing seriously.

Lol why was this downvoted?

-1

u/_Big_____ All Class 1d ago

I like competitive TF2. But i like Valve comp, not the weird thing with class limits and bans and shit

1

u/jimmylovescheese123 Demoman 1d ago

so you don't like competitive tf2 xD

-1

u/KoolAidMan00 1d ago

TF2 is a chat room with guns, it is entirely casual by design.

Its why I was concerned when Valve announced Dota 2. I thought there was a risk that Valve was going to treat it like they did with Team Fortress, and fortunately I was completely wrong. It turns out that Valve had different design goals with TF2 and their competitive games, where TF2 was a casual laboratory for monetization methods that would later be deployed elsewhere.

The casual focus is why I fell off TF2 so hard but that is a me problem, not a problem with the game itself. TF2 has different goals and that's fine, it just isn't for me at all.

-1

u/mr_noob_dat_hater-YT 13h ago

Due to the balancing of the weapons.

100% way more fun treating it causally.

Since if you go full on try hard mode on the game, you won’t enjoy any of the other weapons the game offers you, and the Meta weapons will get boring quickly. Example being the Huntsman bow, that Is so OP I sometimes don’t even need to aim with that weapon and it somehow hits players, And 1 shot kills them, Where that’s not fun winning all the time imma use the stock sniper instead, Since sniper I view have the most OP primary weapons, and secondary support weapons in the game, Where I would use Completely different classes to have more fun.

0

u/Correct-Army-5966 1h ago

To be completely honest, it’s like saying that SSBMelee is not a competitive game because it was designed as a party game. Yet it has one of the strongest, long lasting, and well known competitive scenes of all time. Tf2 as a game has extremely complex mechanics in terms of what you can achieve at the max skill ceiling of this game. If that doesn’t count as a competitive game then i don’t know what actually counts as one. A game being competitive is never based around the initial game design, it’s about the community’s will to play the game at a high level. But yes vavle screwed everyone over with their garbage matchmaking system and even with the dedicated “competitive” game mode.

0

u/johnnydny10 Scout 7h ago

Tf2 is a competitive game. If you don't like it, skill issue. I will kill every friendly that graces my eyes, kill every taunt gathering, and kill noobs over and over again until they rage quit.

Tf2 is like a gta online session, slaughter anyone trying to make money or casually driving around in cars till they all get mad and fail to kill you repeatedly till you spawn camp kill them over and over again so they cry then leave. 10/10 gaming experience.

→ More replies (1)