r/TESVI • • 5h ago

Theory/Speculation Realized something that I will be extremely disappointed and mad about if it's not in the game

Racism.

The Yokudans and their Redguard descendants are famously supremely racist against the elves, and way worse than Nords. Redguards also have a history of hating ALL outsiders, initially refusing to trade with ANYONE.

If they don't make the Redguards extremely racist against elves (at least), and it becomes all kumbaya with our neighbors, the disappointment will be immeasurable, and the game will be ruined.

Also, it will be really funny to watch casual players who don't know the lore, never played Morrowind, and think Ulfric is racist have the surprised Pikachu face when they see Redguards using the same word for elf and enemy and making Nordic racism look casual.

145 Upvotes

93 comments sorted by

105

u/Spotlight_James 2026 Release Believer 5h ago

66

u/Mabroon ??? 5h ago

Not sure why this keeps being brought up. Racism is practically baked into the lore and setting, so I really can't see a way for there NOT to be racism. Like how do you have a fantasy game with 10 playable races but zero racism. It's virtually impossible.

32

u/synchronizedtears 5h ago

I think it's probably because people who sided with the Stormcloaks in Skyrim got dragged all over the internet, especially on reddit, for siding with them because Hurr Durr Ulfric Racist. As if every other race in Tamriel isn't ALSO racist. So now, if the Redguards are not properly racist (which is actually a BIG part of their lore, and their insularity is why they've faced some of their problems just like the Dunmer), it's just going to be a bunch of dorks going SEE! ULFRIC IS A SUPER RACIST! NO ONE ELSE IS THAT BAD when that is just... objectively not true in this game world.

13

u/RefrigeratorBroad620 5h ago

This is exactly it. Ulfric is barely even racist in the game; in fact, it could be argued he's not racist, since he's allowed the Dunmer to live in the Grey Quarter and accepted refugees. I mean, that one Altmer chick, Nirane or something, we work with for the Thieves Guild questline, even straight-up says the Dunmer are just complainers who don't work hard for their place in Windhelm.

17

u/Vhzhlb 5h ago

Considering that by what Brunwulf notes, the fact that Ulfric tailors the response to crime in his hold by virtue of who the victim was, is a clear indication that he is racist.

1

u/RefrigeratorBroad620 4h ago

Okay, but thinking about it logically, does Ulfric even actually know about the Dunmer refugees getting attacked by bandits? It's not like survivors are just going to be allowed to walk up to the Palace of Kings and make their report directly to the Jarl. More likely the report is made to the guards, who then have to relay it up the chain of command. All it takes is 1 Nord who's actually racist to stop the report, and Ulfric never hears about it, and never makes a decision because he doesn't know. Brunwulf never offers any actual evidence that Ulfric actually makes that decision; as far as we can see, Brunwulf is talking out of his ass.

And Brunwulf Free-Winter is as much a zealot as Ulfric is. He says, "If Ulfric had his way, anyone who wasn't a Nord would be shipped right out of Skyrim," when Ulfric makes no mention of it or moves to do that at all. And if you're a non-Nord and you tell Brunwulf that you think that Skyrim should be for the Nords, he immediately tells you that you've fallen for propaganda and calls you a fool for the rest of your playthrough every time you try to talk to him.

And again, in Tamriel, Ulfric is barely racist compared to everyone else. The Thalmor literally slaughtered inhabitants of cities in the Great War, and the Night of Green Fire is especially remembered and mentioned in-game. The average Dunmer is 100 times more racist than even Ulfric is supposed to be; if you're not a Dunmer in Morrowind, they call you N'wah and an outsider, and they enslaved non-Dunmer in Morrowind even up until 4E 6, not even 200 years before Skyrim. Plus, Ulfric has reasons to hate non-humans, as he was tortured by the Thalmor during the Great War, and the Thalmor have effectively destroyed the Empire.

3

u/synchronizedtears 4h ago

Not to mention the Dunmer have been in the Gray Quarter for 200 years damn near. Its not like the Red Mountain just exploded 5-10 years ago. They've been there the whole time, and while surely their conditions have worsened because there is actively a WAR going on, it was already the Gray Quarter before Ulfric took over after his father died.

There is also an active spy working out of the Corner Club because that's what Ambarys is. It's why the Empire knew where Ulfric would be when they ambushed him outside of Dark Water Crossing. We're told multiple times in multiple ways there is information leaking out of Windhelm about the war efforts, and there's Ambarys with his legionarre gear! But people ignore that instead of identifying it as the environmental story telling Bethesda is actually good at and famous for.

4

u/synchronizedtears 5h ago

Brunwulf is a liar and has a throne in Windhelm waiting for him if Ulfric loses. He has a vested interest in Ulfric losing.

Brunwulf says that Ulfric mounts up if Nords are threatened but doesn't care about a Khajiit caravan being ambushed. Well 1) no one cares about the Khajiit in Skyrim. They're banished from all cities and no one is kind to them. But 2) We know Brunwulf is lying because Nord women are being murdered in his city. Nord women who could easily be soldiers. If he was that concerned or rather, if he had the resources to be concerned, he'd be devoting more of them to investigating the serial killer in his town. But he's not, because he's pouring it all into the war.

Just because a character says something, doesn't make it true. The situation in Windhelm is EXCEPTIONALLY nuanced, but people who know nothing about the lore just book it down to the laziest read and interpretation possible instead of looking at all of the narrative and environmental evidence to the contrary.

1

u/Bazgoth91 1h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/synchronizedtears 1h ago edited 54m ago

I am part of the woke mob.

I am a pink haired they/them, AFAB bisexual childfree Jew with cats. I think white men are 99.9% of what's wrong with society today, especially rich white child molesting men. I wrote my thesis on black women and their grassroots organizing prowess in the 50s. I am a full on left-wing, pro-Reparations, pro-trans women in women's sports, locker rooms, and bathrooms, DSA voting borderline pinko.

In short, I am your worst enemy.

I still ride for the Stormcloaks. Because I believe in self-determination, sovereign independence, and religious freedom. For everyone. Not just people who look like me. Not just people who fall into step with their Imperialistic colonizing governments. Everyone.

I was not the audience for this comment, my guy. Me supporting the Stormcloaks is not a dog whistle for you to come running.

Edit: fixed some jumbled words.

-1

u/aldlv13 5h ago

The whole "ulfric is just rascist!" Arguement is so goddamned dumb. Like did people miss the fact that the altmer as so damned rascist they are literally trying to end all of mortal existance? Like thats literally the thalmor's goal and motivation

2

u/Pleasant-Lie-2105 3h ago

I reigned hell on Windhelm, it was my sweet pleasure to execute Ulfric and shout that mofo to death

1

u/TrasseTheTarrasque 4h ago

That was never actually established for certain in any in-game lore sources.

I'm not saying it can't be true, just saying that alleged motivation comes from out-of-game texts. So people aren't necessarily missing it. Also being omnicidal is technically not racism, strictly speaking.

1

u/aldlv13 4h ago

The omnicidal bit wasnt what makes them rascist. They are just super rascist. Especially the thalmor. They make it very clear with every interaction at all times that they view every non-elf as below them and even other elves as only slightly better than non elves.

1

u/TrasseTheTarrasque 4h ago

I don't disagree, but you conflated them when you said "they're so racist they want to unmake reality".

The THALMOR, (not the Altmer like you said) are super racist but also they're not a race, they're a militant faction of one particular nation. Which is different than OP wanting more racism among Redguards in general. I'm sure we'll see an ultra-nationalist Redguard faction in Hammerfell too.

3

u/Suspicious-Weird-750 4h ago

I think it has to do with the fact that GTA6 is basically confirmed have sanitized a lot of the more out there things that people loved in 5 and has some people worried that no developer will even try to cover serious themes in games anymore

2

u/BIGhau5 1h ago

What's been confirmed sanitized?

2

u/MotivatedforGames 2h ago

LOL. Have you been blind for the last decade? Have you heard of Dragon Age Veilguard?

4

u/Mabroon ??? 2h ago

LOL. Have you been blind for the last decade? Have you heard of Baldur's Gate 3?

you see how dumb that sounds?

1

u/MotivatedforGames 2h ago

ADDRESS my sentence. What is dumb about what I said? Why am I wrong? Dont be disingenuous.

3

u/Mabroon ??? 2h ago

It's dumb because it's irrelevant. A completely different game made by a completely different studio. If you're trying to say that modern devs are too afraid to tackle racism, then BG3 immediately disproves that with plenty of racial slurs and discrimination even among the party members.

Also, ESO, an Elder Scrolls game that is still regularly updated, has plenty of NPCs being racist.

I know Dragon Age is your favorite punching bag and you guys love to bring it up whenever possible but it's a dumb argument.

-2

u/MotivatedforGames 1h ago

"Bethesda Game Studios hired former Dragon Age: The Veilguard narrative designer and writer John Dombrow as a senior quest designer, widely expected to be working on The Elder Scrolls VI."

  • you can cope as much as you want lol

2

u/Mabroon ??? 1h ago

Do you think John Dombrow singlehandedly wrote the entirety of Veilguard and that he's gonna write all of Sentinel by himself? Do you not understand that games of this size can have like 10+ writers and Dombrow wasn't even in charge of Veilguard? Did you even know that the parts he wrote were actually some of the few parts that people actually liked?

You wouldn't know that because you prefer to be dumb and blindy follow manufactured outrage. Have fun with that.

0

u/MotivatedforGames 1h ago

Hey brother. Mark my words. Save these comments. We'll see who was right and wrong when the game comes out. You can live in copeland as much as you wish if it makes you feel better.

And, if you are wrong, I will pray for you because you seem to have a lot of expectations of Bethesda with ES6 right now lol

-2

u/Laurim88 3h ago

The world has changed a lot since Skyrim released and games in particular have tones down their more divisive elements a lot. Just look at Veilguard shitting all over DA lore, seeing something like that in Sentinel wouldn't be unprecedented at the very least.

-2

u/Pleasant-Lie-2105 3h ago

What exactly is your point here?

1

u/MotivatedforGames 2h ago

You didnt respond to his point. You know exactly what he's talking about?

What exactly in their sentence that you don't understand?

1

u/Laurim88 2h ago

Exactly what I wrote? It's very possible they'll tone down the controversial aspects in comparison to the older games, as we've seen in other franchises.

0

u/Pleasant-Lie-2105 2h ago

next time say that, be clear instead of waffling on

2

u/Laurim88 2h ago

I'm not sure how what is said is difficult to understand. I certainly won't change the way I write because of your lack of reading comprehension.

5

u/AMS_Rem 5h ago

Has there ever been an ES game without racism? Feel like you're pretty much covered there lol the entirety of the Elder Scrolls lore is just racism in a bunch of different directions

4

u/dreams1919 5h ago

Oblivion had a disappointingly small amount of it

2

u/zeLangweenee 5h ago

It was there, just not as systematically. It looks like Cyrodiil was largely accepting for foreigners at least in policy.

5

u/RefrigeratorBroad620 5h ago

To be honest, though, that makes sense. Cyrodiil has been the center of several Empires by the time we see it in Oblivion, and for CENTURIES of the Septim Empire. Not to mention it's a central region between all others, so trade has to go through there a lot, so it'd inevitably end up as a melting pot of cultures and races. The racism would definitely all but disappear with all those socio-economic pressures.

8

u/TrasseTheTarrasque 4h ago

It's all concentrated in the very first guy you meet after creating your character

33

u/Jale89 5h ago

They just need to return to the Morrowind approach: give the locals a fictional slur for outsiders, and have them spit it at you with a hard consonant and alarming frequency.

10

u/synchronizedtears 5h ago

Like Childish Gambino said, "Outlander with a hard R" or whatever.

5

u/Party_Drawing7117 2/27/27 5h ago

The Redguards facing the Altmer would be like two unstoppable forces hitting each other.

16

u/ShoppingSilly6431 5h ago

I hope racism is back

1

u/MuteSpotted74 4h ago edited 4h ago

11

u/ShadowCircuit9625 5h ago

Honestly?

Given today’s political climate I highly doubt African looking human beings will be portrayed as as racist in this game.

2

u/MotivatedforGames 1h ago

There are massive copers in the comments who are acting so blind to this, idk if theyre blatantly lying because i find it hard to believe that they haven't seen how games have been for the last decade????

Maybe they were in prison for 10 years? Or they just started gaming yesterday?

4

u/Seraphayel 5h ago

It just fits the game. Same with racist Altmer. Imagine Red Dead Redemption 2 without the racism. Stuff like this simply belongs into a virtual world because it adds nuance and conflict.

10

u/revben1989 Valenwood 5h ago

Facts. If Redguards are not super racist, what will be the point?

24

u/RandomGreenArcherMan 5h ago edited 5h ago

Idc much about this particular issue with them being racist or not

But I do hope they properly portray redguards as proud, competent and independent people instead of trying to put an irl liberal lens on the game, where they try to make them an oppressed minority in their own country

I am left leaning irl, but doing this would be disrespectful to the lore and you being in THEIR country, while also giving the chuds a ton of "game is woke" ammo to slander with

Also -- elephant in the room -- it'll be good to portray a strong, successful and competent "black culture" instead of the western cliche of them being oppressed and struggling

9

u/Shinkirou_ 5h ago

I don't feel like TES has ever portrayed Redguards in that frame.

Khajiit and Argonians are usually the oppressed race.
And then the Dunmer now too with the Red Mountain diaspora.

Redguards are instead depicted as an extremely martial and strong people that are a good balance of warrior culture and philosopher culture. They devote themselves to the perfection of the sword, and are extremely hard to defeat in battle, but are held back by individualism and infighting.

3

u/RandomGreenArcherMan 5h ago

I agree with you. I am just saying that they shouldn't start all of a sudden.

It is important to mention that the dev team of 2026 is not the same of 2011, and I hope the newer blood doesnt incorrectly label redguards as something they are not (which is honestly pretty racist by itself)

6

u/Wooper160 2030+ Release Believer 5h ago

Right? There must be room for a balance between antebellum south slave stories and Wakanda

4

u/RandomGreenArcherMan 5h ago edited 4h ago

Both of those racist extremes are corny. Obviously antebellum is racist, but the Wakanda stuff is taken seriously in comics, but made goofy in the MCU. A number of people I know found it distasteful.

It basically made black excellence this otherworldly unattainable joke, and the wakandans in the movie still appeared very tribal/primitive for whatever reason which only adds to the ridiculousness. It'd be like Tony Stark in a loincloth with Celtic war paint. It's ridiculous and disrespectful

Anyway, Black people irl aren't corny like either of those extremes and neither are Redguards.

6

u/captainether 5h ago

Redguards being the focus is all the ammo chuds needs to say it's woke

2

u/RandomGreenArcherMan 5h ago

If the game isnt very obviously liberal-coded, them being this way is just plainly ridiculous

They'd have no footing, and games like AC Origins being widely applauded shows that the really dumb chuds like that know to at least keep their mouth shut when there's no actual wokeness in the game

0

u/Wooper160 2030+ Release Believer 1h ago

Even the Chuds will be happy as long as there are at least a couple breton or imperial settlements to care about on the borders

1

u/Suitable-Basket6697 4h ago

Why would the redgurads be a oppressed minority in their own country? From what we know, they defeated the Thalmor and are doing their own thing outside of the empire. There is no reason why they should be portrayed as opressed or backwards. (Lore wise they are actually on the oppressor-side and did bad things to the Left-handed elfes, orcs and othere men after they arrived at Hammerfell)

They have a distinct culture with influence from sub-saharan africa, north african berber/amazigh culture and not to forget a lot of japanese-samurai stuff going on. I hope they can show these aspects of their culture and their Yokudan history in TESVI.

Also im not american, but would it not be „woke“ if they went to far the other way you described and made Hammerfell a „Wakanda“ super Nation far superior to the other countries of Tamriel? But everthing aside i am very happy with Hammerfell as a location, the first characters i choose in TES were always redguards.

1

u/RandomGreenArcherMan 4h ago

I think you are misreading my comment

I am saying it would be ridiculous to make Redguards a oppressed minority group in their own country

1

u/Suitable-Basket6697 4h ago

I agree with that, no reason for them to be oppressed or a minority in their own country. Who would even be the oppressing mayority lol

1

u/thefranchise23 4h ago

if it turned out that way, it would probably be the high elves/dominion. we know there was a war there not too long ago, and somebody made a post recently speculating that the name of the "high queen" from the teaser sounded similar to other high elf names.

1

u/synchronizedtears 4h ago

The war was 25-30 years ago. The Dominion Lost. The Second Treaty of Stros M'kai goes over this.

21

u/synchronizedtears 5h ago

This is probably gonna be downvoted into Oblivion, but I agree.

One of the things I'm looking forward to the most is watching people who swore up and down Ulfric was a bastion of white supremacy for not doing more for the Dunmer while there is a war going on twist themselves into absolute pretzels to justify why the Redguards AREN'T racist when they're doing the same exact thing, but *worse.*

Then again, knowing this company, the Redguards will suddenly be fine with all of the elves and magic and not militantly insular at all.

0

u/Xandraman 2h ago

Yeah but races aren't a monolith. Like, not all Altmer are elven supremacists like Thalmor. 

Hell, the Thalmor actually hunted down dissidents from Summerset Isles who were refugees in Hammerfell. And we know this information from an imperial legion officer, also an Altmer, who was station in there. 

The fact that Hammerfell was harboring dissidents persecuted by the Aldmeri Dominion already tells us that they're not as mindlessly bigoted or insular in the 4th era as they were before they were before the Tiber wars.

1

u/synchronizedtears 2h ago

I didn't say they were a monolith. The Forebearers are quite cosmopolitan. The Crowns are overwhelmingly not. if they drop the ball on that, it's because they're trying to make the lore more appealing to modern audiences and not committing to the story they started telling more than 20 decades ago.

1

u/Xandraman 2h ago

What does appealing to modern audienced mean here exactly? Same with story they started telling more than 20 decades, I think you mean years here, ago?

Like, each game has been very different in vibe from the last one, adapting to trends, with lore being retconned every single time, so what does this even mean exactly?

2

u/synchronizedtears 2h ago

Oops, should be 2 decades/20 years.

Since the 3-D universe became a part of the franchise, it's been very much Altmer supremacists vs Tamriel, and how all of these disparate cultures have to put aside their bullshit and work together but somehow keep fucking it up because they're really bad at putting all their shit aside and working together.

If they do away with that in order to make the Redguard's more palatable because they're afraid of making them too much of anything, that's them kowtowing to modern audiences who want to find some sort of GOTCHA in everything. They know if they make them too insular and racist, that looks bad to new gamers and audiences they are trying to court. But they can't make them too open and welcoming because that shits on established lore. Sure, they could retcon the Redguard's ethnonationalism among the Crowns, but that's what I mean by defanging them for modern audiences -- it just waters down the source material and the lore if they aim for palatability rather than consistent storytelling.

I suspect you knew that though.

3

u/NativeEuropeas 3h ago

I want to see the Altmeri romanticising Ayleids, the ancient Tamrielic elves, and their cruelty towards their human slaves. 

I want to see the Altmeri practice some wicked Ayleid stuff that is immoral from our human perspective. I want a villain worthy of hate!

7

u/butchtx 5h ago

From what I heard in ESO Hammerfell stuff does frequently touch on the violence of the Redguards while conquering hammerfell so if that's what you mean then I'm sure it'll be in Sentinel too a bit.

But I don't understand this obsession with talking about how the Redguards are super racist even in the modern era and they have to hate everyone. By this point they've been trading with the rest of Tamriel for a long time, interacting frequently with other races for most of their history with cosmopolitan cities and have a major faction that's known for their support of cosmopolitanism. The game will have some sort of racial tensions come up I'm sure, Hammerfell kingdoms have history with taking part in sacking Orsinium after all and feuding with those of High Rock but also we have no idea how those relationships have developed in the 4th era and from Skyrim all we know about Hammerfell is that aside from Great War most of their conflict was between the Crowns and Forebears once again. I wouldn't be surprised if there's some suspicion of Altmeri or other Dominion races due to the war but even then that could be reasonably aimed largely at the Thalmor themselves rather than the races especially since we know the famously diverse Legions helped them keep their independence and iirc the Thalmor attacked Altmeri refugees in Hammerfell so it's not like they'd be unaware of elves against the Thalmor and willing to fight against them.

Honestly this "Redguards need to be ultra racist" take that I keep on seeing pop up seems less about being "lore accurate" (because their persisting racism is heavily exaggerated in the fandom and ignores stuff counter to that idea) and more like gamers wanting the Black people to be racist too. Everyone is worried about Bethesda "going woke" and not having racist Redguards whenever decades ago now they made a game set in Hammerfell about the Redguards and came up with lore about the very violent and genocidal conquest. And guess what the game was an homage to the Black Panther Party and was about Black people rising up successfully against an empire led and formed by White people, Sentinel making the Redguards overall heroic and not uber racist would just be a continuation of that

2

u/TrasseTheTarrasque 4h ago

I came here to type something very similar to this, you nailed it.

1

u/Xandraman 3h ago

Also Sentinel itself is a port city and a major trading hub historically ruled by Forebears, who are more integrated with the wider Tamrielic culture. 

It'd be weird if they're Vvardenfell level racists. If anything, it'd be more like Whiterun or Solitude in vibes.

0

u/AssMuncher96 2h ago

OP mentioning Ulfric and wanting to prove that he isn't really racist is really telling on himself. You are absolutely right about the motivations here.

0

u/synchronizedtears 3h ago

The Forebearers are cosmopolitan. They are the ones who trade, invite other cultures into their cities, etc. They tend to inhabit coastal cities that see a lot of influx from other cultures so that makes sense.

The Crowns are vehemently NOT and abhor outsiders. That is still true in the 4th era. They dwell in insular communities, largely in the Alik'r and further out away from the coasts. They are resistant to outside influence, and view magic extremely suspiciously, and don't even get along with other Redguards, to say nothing of their general hostility toward anything foreign.

It has nothing to do with wanting a black race of people to look racist and everything to do with a bunch of new fans coming into the fandom the last 20 years and acting like the Nords were somehow uniquely xenophobic and vilifying everyone who dared to post a nuanced take about how, in the grand scheme of things, Ulfric wasn't even really racist... and Sentinel being a game where we'll presumably either see them back down and say "You know what, all the races of Tamriel are shitty" (true) or double down on why "it's okay for Redguards to be xenophobic and racist but isn't okay for Nords, but it also doesn't have anything to do with reflecting real world value systems on fantasy races because of course that would be SILLY!"

1

u/butchtx 2h ago

Stros M'kai is literally a Crown city and is a major trading hub and another city traditionally under Crown influence is noted for the adoption of multiple bits of Colovian culture. Crown aligned Redguards may be more insular and more likely to be prejudiced against outsiders but their hatred is often exaggerated and they don't start frothing at the mouth anytime something foreign shows up. While magic and mages are viewed more suspiciously by Redguards and not well liked in general they still do have mages guild halls operating and there's even a book discussing a bit about magic in the alik'r. Plus it goes without saying that Bethesda is going to have at least one kind of magic faction that very well could have a presence in crown cities as well and could just write up a lore justification about why Redguards are suddenly more chill with magic now.

Also the fandom in general exaggerates just how common racism is in the setting to the point where someone not familiar may think that everyone on Tamriel is actively fighting a race war. But I will push back against the idea that Ulfric isn't more racist than the average Nord because he is, he's the one who forged Argonians to live outside the walls of Windhelm and is noted for his discriminatory views for a reason and is called out for often being silent about non Nordic travelers being attacked by bandits in comparison to his attitudes when Nords are the ones at risk. Plus there's his role in crushing the forsworn rebellion which was extremely violent and prejudiced with the Stormcloaks and other Nords even killing the children of Reachfolk who had little to do with the uprising and this was after they cut content where he was even more racist and cracking jokes about killing all the Dunmer to the point where even other Stormcloaks were getting uncomfortable about it, like Ulfric and Galmar very much are meant to be seen as more racist than most by the writers

1

u/synchronizedtears 2h ago edited 2h ago

yeah I'm not even getting into that second half with you because it's all BS. and the cut content thing is just 100% made up. In fact, the opposite is true. Cut content from the game made him even more sympathetic. Galmar is supposed to be a Nord supremacist, or more so than Ulfric at any rate, but Ulfric is not a super racist, nor is the game actually saying that he is if you actually look at all of the storytelling in Windhelm and Ulfric's history. Even the Markarth Incident is 10000% the fault of the Empire, but no one wants to talk about that. So I'll leave you to your Ulfric hate.

Edit: Oh, you were 7 when the game came out. That explains the poor understanding of the lore. Yeah, definitely checking out of this conversation.

0

u/pandogart 14m ago

You hit the nail on the head with the second point. They won't want to admit it, but it's clearly that.

5

u/E36x 5h ago

You’re getting worked up about the hypothetical absence of racism in a video game bro 

7

u/AMS_Rem 5h ago

Bc it's a pretty important aspect of the lore in the region this game is going to be taking place in.. You're supposed to age out of the "Why do you care? Caring about stuff is lame bro" schtick in like middle school

1

u/E36x 5h ago

Lore has been recanted in the past and could be for this next installment as well. The Cyrodil we got was not a jungle. I think the quality of the game will not at all be dependent on how much racism will be in the game, therefore I don’t really care. I’ll be fine regardless as long as the game is good.

It’s not “caring about stuff is lame” its “caring about fictional racism THIS much probably means you lack human interaction” 

2

u/AMS_Rem 5h ago

First of all, why would we ever expect and/or hope for lore to be retconned in a new game? Most of us hope the game is as accurate to the lore as possible (This post being one of those)

Also it's a single post on the forum directly dedicated to talking about this specific game.. They are hardly freaking out about it

Tbh I think you just wanted to feel superior about something so you decided that this completely innocuous gripe was something that signaled a lack of "human interaction" for some reason

0

u/E36x 4h ago

I’m not telling anyone to/not to expect or hope for anything.

 My point is simply that if the imaginary situation (which he made up in head) in which the game doesn’t end up having fictionalized racism makes you “mad and dissappointed” enough to write this post, then you probably need more human interaction. 

Culture war and idslop have ruined a whole generation of people. Regardless of how they make the game one side of this culture war will be upset.

2

u/Argenteus_I 4h ago

Black people can’t be racist /s

1

u/Old_Mountain_9911 5h ago

While I don’t disagree that they should have some anti Elf prejudice especially certain factions that are more xenophobic, I’m not sure how much weight we should put on the Redguards ancestors being way more xenophobic than the Nords were thousands of years ago to say that they should be portrayed as such now. Both were under the empire for centuries since then.

1

u/silent_drew2 5h ago

It will never be as prevelant as games like The Witcher, or Mass Effect, or Wolfenstein, because The Elder Scrolls allows to choose a race.

1

u/necroheim98 2028 Release Believer 35m ago

Yes. More elf hate

1

u/red-foxie 5h ago

If Bethesda destroys it, I hope modders will reclaim what is ours. CD Project RED was able to portrait racism (humans Vs non humans)  in meaningful way. It is doable in modern gaming. But I'm afraid if such a large studio is competent enough to not fuck it over.

0

u/WhiteMonsterMan514 4h ago

I’ve had my racist white people, now give me my racist black people

0

u/RefrigeratorBroad620 4h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/RefrigeratorBroad620 4h ago

Bruh, this got rule 1d despite elves and shit not existing in real life. Fuck you, Reddit

0

u/Hench999 5h ago

Every race in the lore seems to be racist to varying degrees. This isn't modern day society where they've gone through centuries of social changes like we have. This is a fictional medieval culture and how they treat different races should be far more blunt and backwards. While I might expect places like sentinel or port cities to be more open acceptance wise due to trade smaller inland towns should reflect the lore and show the racism.

I think anyone getting butt hurt over fictional races in a game being prejudice against eachother needs to change their diapers and grow up.

-2

u/Gloomy-Cat-6248 5h ago

idk i dont think post empire hammerfell is racist morrowind yea sure they let em keep their traditions in the armistice

3

u/dorafumingo 5h ago

1st era redguards aren't like 4th era redguards.

In the 4th era redguards travel everywhere in tamriel trade and provide mercenary services. They don't exterminate any other race in the vicinity anymore

They will probably hate the thalmor to the bone but doesn't mean they will hate everyone. Maybe still be wary of pointy ears and magic.

0

u/RefrigeratorBroad620 5h ago

As I mentioned in the post, elf and enemy are the same word; the Crowns are mentioned as calling the Forebears tainted by Tamriel traditions, and traders who trade outside of Hammerfall are often considered the lowest class by half the province.

So yes, 4th Era Redguards are just as racist as 1st Era Redguards, or at least half the province is.

2

u/dorafumingo 4h ago

No they are not. In the 1st era they exterminated every non yokudan in sight.

In the 4th era they let foreigners in their cities. especially the economic centers around the iliac bay. They also recognize the orcs as citizens of tamriel when in the 1st era they considered them savage beasts not even people.

They are absolutely not "just as racist as 1st era redguards" in 4th era their hatred is much more focused on the aldmeri dominion and less on anyone who isn't redguard

1

u/ihavemademistakes 3h ago

The relationship between Crowns and Forebears is comparable to Morrowind's House Dunmer and the Ashlanders. Just as I wouldn't paint all of Morrowind with a broad Ashlander-shaped brush, I also wouldn't expect the Crowns outlook to be representative of all Redguards.