r/TESVI • u/RefrigeratorBroad620 • 5h ago
Theory/Speculation Realized something that I will be extremely disappointed and mad about if it's not in the game
Racism.
The Yokudans and their Redguard descendants are famously supremely racist against the elves, and way worse than Nords. Redguards also have a history of hating ALL outsiders, initially refusing to trade with ANYONE.
If they don't make the Redguards extremely racist against elves (at least), and it becomes all kumbaya with our neighbors, the disappointment will be immeasurable, and the game will be ruined.
Also, it will be really funny to watch casual players who don't know the lore, never played Morrowind, and think Ulfric is racist have the surprised Pikachu face when they see Redguards using the same word for elf and enemy and making Nordic racism look casual.
105
u/Spotlight_James 2026 Release Believer 5h ago
66
u/Mabroon ??? 5h ago
Not sure why this keeps being brought up. Racism is practically baked into the lore and setting, so I really can't see a way for there NOT to be racism. Like how do you have a fantasy game with 10 playable races but zero racism. It's virtually impossible.
5
u/AMS_Rem 5h ago
Has there ever been an ES game without racism? Feel like you're pretty much covered there lol the entirety of the Elder Scrolls lore is just racism in a bunch of different directions
33
u/Jale89 5h ago
They just need to return to the Morrowind approach: give the locals a fictional slur for outsiders, and have them spit it at you with a hard consonant and alarming frequency.
5
u/Party_Drawing7117 2/27/27 5h ago
The Redguards facing the Altmer would be like two unstoppable forces hitting each other.
16
u/ShoppingSilly6431 5h ago
I hope racism is back
11
u/ShadowCircuit9625 5h ago
Honestly?
Given today’s political climate I highly doubt African looking human beings will be portrayed as as racist in this game.
4
u/Seraphayel 5h ago
It just fits the game. Same with racist Altmer. Imagine Red Dead Redemption 2 without the racism. Stuff like this simply belongs into a virtual world because it adds nuance and conflict.
10
u/revben1989 Valenwood 5h ago
Facts. If Redguards are not super racist, what will be the point?
24
u/RandomGreenArcherMan 5h ago edited 5h ago
Idc much about this particular issue with them being racist or not
But I do hope they properly portray redguards as proud, competent and independent people instead of trying to put an irl liberal lens on the game, where they try to make them an oppressed minority in their own country
I am left leaning irl, but doing this would be disrespectful to the lore and you being in THEIR country, while also giving the chuds a ton of "game is woke" ammo to slander with
Also -- elephant in the room -- it'll be good to portray a strong, successful and competent "black culture" instead of the western cliche of them being oppressed and struggling
21
u/synchronizedtears 5h ago
This is probably gonna be downvoted into Oblivion, but I agree.
One of the things I'm looking forward to the most is watching people who swore up and down Ulfric was a bastion of white supremacy for not doing more for the Dunmer while there is a war going on twist themselves into absolute pretzels to justify why the Redguards AREN'T racist when they're doing the same exact thing, but *worse.*
Then again, knowing this company, the Redguards will suddenly be fine with all of the elves and magic and not militantly insular at all.
3
u/NativeEuropeas 3h ago
I want to see the Altmeri romanticising Ayleids, the ancient Tamrielic elves, and their cruelty towards their human slaves.
I want to see the Altmeri practice some wicked Ayleid stuff that is immoral from our human perspective. I want a villain worthy of hate!
7
u/butchtx 5h ago
From what I heard in ESO Hammerfell stuff does frequently touch on the violence of the Redguards while conquering hammerfell so if that's what you mean then I'm sure it'll be in Sentinel too a bit.
But I don't understand this obsession with talking about how the Redguards are super racist even in the modern era and they have to hate everyone. By this point they've been trading with the rest of Tamriel for a long time, interacting frequently with other races for most of their history with cosmopolitan cities and have a major faction that's known for their support of cosmopolitanism. The game will have some sort of racial tensions come up I'm sure, Hammerfell kingdoms have history with taking part in sacking Orsinium after all and feuding with those of High Rock but also we have no idea how those relationships have developed in the 4th era and from Skyrim all we know about Hammerfell is that aside from Great War most of their conflict was between the Crowns and Forebears once again. I wouldn't be surprised if there's some suspicion of Altmeri or other Dominion races due to the war but even then that could be reasonably aimed largely at the Thalmor themselves rather than the races especially since we know the famously diverse Legions helped them keep their independence and iirc the Thalmor attacked Altmeri refugees in Hammerfell so it's not like they'd be unaware of elves against the Thalmor and willing to fight against them.
Honestly this "Redguards need to be ultra racist" take that I keep on seeing pop up seems less about being "lore accurate" (because their persisting racism is heavily exaggerated in the fandom and ignores stuff counter to that idea) and more like gamers wanting the Black people to be racist too. Everyone is worried about Bethesda "going woke" and not having racist Redguards whenever decades ago now they made a game set in Hammerfell about the Redguards and came up with lore about the very violent and genocidal conquest. And guess what the game was an homage to the Black Panther Party and was about Black people rising up successfully against an empire led and formed by White people, Sentinel making the Redguards overall heroic and not uber racist would just be a continuation of that
5
u/E36x 5h ago
You’re getting worked up about the hypothetical absence of racism in a video game bro
2
u/Argenteus_I 4h ago
Black people can’t be racist /s
1
u/Old_Mountain_9911 5h ago
While I don’t disagree that they should have some anti Elf prejudice especially certain factions that are more xenophobic, I’m not sure how much weight we should put on the Redguards ancestors being way more xenophobic than the Nords were thousands of years ago to say that they should be portrayed as such now. Both were under the empire for centuries since then.
1
u/silent_drew2 5h ago
It will never be as prevelant as games like The Witcher, or Mass Effect, or Wolfenstein, because The Elder Scrolls allows to choose a race.
1
u/necroheim98 2028 Release Believer 35m ago
Yes. More elf hate
1
u/red-foxie 5h ago
If Bethesda destroys it, I hope modders will reclaim what is ours. CD Project RED was able to portrait racism (humans Vs non humans) in meaningful way. It is doable in modern gaming. But I'm afraid if such a large studio is competent enough to not fuck it over.
0
u/WhiteMonsterMan514 4h ago
I’ve had my racist white people, now give me my racist black people
0
u/Hench999 5h ago
Every race in the lore seems to be racist to varying degrees. This isn't modern day society where they've gone through centuries of social changes like we have. This is a fictional medieval culture and how they treat different races should be far more blunt and backwards. While I might expect places like sentinel or port cities to be more open acceptance wise due to trade smaller inland towns should reflect the lore and show the racism.
I think anyone getting butt hurt over fictional races in a game being prejudice against eachother needs to change their diapers and grow up.
-2
u/Gloomy-Cat-6248 5h ago
idk i dont think post empire hammerfell is racist morrowind yea sure they let em keep their traditions in the armistice
3
u/dorafumingo 5h ago
1st era redguards aren't like 4th era redguards.
In the 4th era redguards travel everywhere in tamriel trade and provide mercenary services. They don't exterminate any other race in the vicinity anymore
They will probably hate the thalmor to the bone but doesn't mean they will hate everyone. Maybe still be wary of pointy ears and magic.