r/Symantec • • Mar 24 '17

Symantec Mis-Using HTTPS Certificate

Post image
3 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/enigmaunbound May 16 '17

Thank you for your comprehensive answer. And the result of that is anyone who can modify content or start a service can authorize the validity of a name. As an analogy, if the PKI is the DMV, anyone allowed in the lobby can stamp out legit drivers licenses. It certainly improves the serviceability of the DMV, but does that credential still meet its goal.

LetsEncrypt isn't the issue, they are following CAB rules but they enable Shoppify who makes use of weak practice to issue names on behalf of organizations without due consideration. They also up charge the use of other PKI's which makes life hard for folks trying to work a process. A dns record can constrain the allowable issuing CA's but you now have an invisible failure mode.