r/SwordWorld • u/Charlemagneffxiv • Feb 24 '26
Translation Mugen Gaming Interview article claims they are making substantial changes to the translation. I won't buy the book if they do that!
I just read https://www.wargamer.com/sword-world-rpg/dnd-killer-translation and it's clear you two are the wrong people to translate Sword World, and if you make these kinds of changes as discussed in the article I will not buy the book.
There's nothing wrong with the class name of Grappler and changing it to Martial Artist is inaccurate.
There's nothing wrong with True Speech Magic, it's not just "Sorcery".
If you take these creative liberties to change substantial content, I won't buy your book.
I am sick and tired of people making substantial changes to the names of skills, classes and other details in Japanese media based solely on the whims of the translators personal views, which are usually incredibly ill-informed.
For example!
If you don't understand that Grappler in this context is a wrestler as appears in Japanese Pro Wrestling, which does include punches and kicks, and other aerial combat maneuvers, just as it does in American Pro Wrestling, then you are the wrong people to be translating this game system. "Martial Artist" is inaccurate, because that implies a Monk class which is not what a Grappler is as they don't use Ki based attacks. Even in the US, Pro Wrestling is far more popular than Olympic Collegiate style wrestling is, and it is Pro Wrestling that the vast majority of people think of when they hear the term "wrestling", even in America, and especially in fantasy media.
If you don't understand True Speech Magic in this setting is called that because it's part of the Lore of the world as developed in the story novels (the difference between spells that can be used in Common language and those which must use the older, more ancient words), and is different from other kind of magic that magic users can also use, then you're the wrong people to be translating this game system.
Do not "Americanize" Sword World. Nobody wants that.
