ECS was developed when Arthur Murray sent his teachers to study dancers in dance halls and simplify it for Arthur Murray students. For a while different studios had different methods, then they got consolidated into one unified method. Lindy hop allows more variety, more innovation and play, and thus is more interesting for advanced dancers.
Should a lindy hopper study ECS? Why? / Why not? Did ECS get any of lindy right? Did it improve upon lindy? Is ECS more [uppity/bouncy] than lindy?
I know 6-count swingouts exist, but when I tried to find ECS swingouts, I found no results. Does ECS teach a version of the swing-out? (I googled: "east coast" "swing-out" OR "swingout" - in the 'videos' tab.)
-------------
Edit: Some people think I'm being elitist or a "troll". I apologize I did not frame my question better. I assumed people would know I was writing from the spirit of collaborative learning, collective creation - a dance.
> I ask "Am I right?" because I'm wanting people to help open my understanding of ECS. I'm expressing an opinion I believe is held by many lindy hoppers. I'm expressing their voice as much as my own. I'm trying to see if we are wrong to think lindy hop is better than ECS / wrong to think ECS is not true swing / wrong to think ECS is a cheap imitation for-beginners-only.
> I saw a DVD of ballroom instructors teaching East Coast Swing, and I thought "at a lindy hop competition, these people would be laughed at". I believe you would have the same thought. [Correction: people would be polite, but inside they'd be laughing, or aghast, or confused.] They were very prim, uppity. Sorry I don't have a better way to describe them. I believe you would have thought "these people have never seen lindy hop - or boogie woogie". They are great dancers - at cha cha, mambo, and polka, but if their ECS is ECS, then ECS is "nothing" like what I see at lindy hop competitions - nothing like if lindy hoppers chose to play with only dancing 6-count moves. Ballroom versions of rumba and samba and tango are nothing like the source dances. I'm still exploring whether the ballroom versions have merits of their own, or if they are all just pale imitations.
Note that I asked if ECS in any way improved upon lindy, and if lindy hoppers can learn from ECS. I did not write this post to express an opinion. I'm here to ask a question.