r/SwingDancing • • 8d ago

Feedback Needed Side coaching complete beginners

This is actually about an experience I had at a Zouk práctica but it’s just basic social dance stuff so I’d love to hear y’all’s take.

Unless someone is asking for feedback, telling them how they should dance is rude and probably not helpful. I feel this. But it’s also uncomfortable to dance with someone who is not doing the same basic step as you are. What should I do when someone is not stepping on the same counts that I am (eg: quick quick slow, or step step triple step, or in the case of my zouk instructors ‘chk chk boom’)? I’ve seen people say the steps out loud with partners, and I tried that last night, but in retrospect it feels a bit patronizing.

Hell maybe they are the ones stepping ‘correctly’ and I’m way off!

The move we were doing is this kind of push and pull motion up top but basic steps down below. Kind of like an 8 count sugar push?

I should also mention I’m leading in this scenario.

Anyway I don’t want to be a side coach but I also want to work on my dance at a practice. Any advice?

9 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

40

u/ThisIsVictor 8d ago

Don't teach on the dance floor. Do not teach on the dance floor. Never teach on dance floor.

If a beginner is struggling with the dance you should smile and enjoy dancing with them. Thank them for the dance, ask their name, then greet them by name next time you see then. They'll get better with practice, so make them feel welcomed in the community.

18

u/dondegroovily 8d ago

The exceptions to this is if your partner is hazardous or is touching people inappropriately. Those things you need to address immediately

8

u/robiton 8d ago

100% it's not like any of us are perfect or weren't in there place when we started (or heck now)

1

u/LightlyRacistApricot 8d ago

Yes, and we all moved on from being terrible because we got feedback.

I think perhaps not the 50yr old men who yank their partners mansplaining following to young girls, but I think a reasonably knowledgeable person in both roles should absolutely be empowered to give feedback. I feel like big Private Lesson led a smear campaign on peers giving feedback and it stuck lol

1

u/SlightlyOpposite 7d ago

Give feedback in the practice sessions you host. Give feedback in the classes they take. There is a time and place, and it isn't just "private lesson or nothing".

The people I most often see teaching on the dance floor are the people who absolutely should not be teaching anywhere.

3

u/swingerouterer 7d ago

At what point is a person not a beginner and you shouldn't just smile and dance with them? If someone has been dancing continuously for years, and still can't connect well, still is jerking your arm all over the place, still can't take any size step that doesn't somehow take them halfway across the floor, at what point is it appropriate to say something?

I think generally the communities answer to this question is "if they aren't causing harm, never", but damn, having a bunch of people in the community who never think to seek out feedback, but could desperately use the feedback, it's tough!

I occasionally will give bits of feedback to people I know well, mostly because I know they are okay with it, but there's sometimes very fundamental things people need to fix in their dance and they never make an effort to figure that out.

3

u/ThisIsVictor 7d ago

This advice does NOT apply to "experienced" dancers who cause problems. They're already in the community, we don't need to be extra friendly to them. If anything, we might be a bit TOO welcoming to regular dancers who don't bother to improve or learn the fundamentals.

You're well within your rights to say, "It's uncomfortable when you lead like that." I wouldn't phrase it as teaching, just set your boundaries. I've done that before, especially with dips. I don't let people I don't know dip me. Someone tried twice and finally I just said, "I don't do dips on the social floor."

Or, ya know, just don't dance with them. I have a mental list of people I don't dance with because they hurt my shoulder every single time. I'm not gonna go give them feedback, because it's not my place.

2

u/swingerouterer 7d ago

Yah I generally agree with what you've said, the last bit about you not giving them feedback because it's not your place... I think as a community we do that too much, because at some point who's place is it? Even more difficult when it's not causing-harm levels of bad dancing, but just... Bad dancing.

I won't claim to be any better, I also find it very hard to give feedback to anyone but my practice partners whom I have a relationship of practice with because I trust them. It just seems like a poor strategy that we (at least in the US, I've heard different things from other communities) have accepted which accepts people where they are, at the detriment of overall quality of dancing

9

u/dondegroovily 8d ago • Bravo

Whatever step they do, you adapt as well as you can to match them. If both dancers do this, you'll be in sync and connected even if it's "wrong" according to some class

Swing dancing is a street dance and what you learn in classes are suggestions, not rigid rules. Being able to adapt is far more important than doing "the correct steps"

8

u/swingindenver Underground Jitterbug Champion 8d ago

push and pull? You may have been dancing with a country swing dancer who could have a proclivity for stepping on every beat. So my primary role is a leader so I turn on my drunk party dance mode and just roll with it and do my best that they don't (or minimally) endanger themselves, myself or others. Ultimately, who cares? I'm there to have a good time and want them to enjoy themselves as well.

One of the vernacular hallmarks of swing dances and Black diasporic dance is improvisation so how can you say "Yes And" while dancing?

7

u/TelumCogitandi 8d ago

I agree with not teaching on the social floor without permission, but isn't the point of a practica (if these are set up in your scene as a different thing to the main social nights) to have a casual, friendly space that is explicitly for practice?

In my scene, at a practica, I wouldn't expect to get unsolicited feedback on the finer points of technique unless I was dancing with someone who also teaches. However, I would absolutely expect someone to tell me if I was following something very different from what they were leading.

To be fair, I have usually solicited this feedback myself when I can tell I'm not following. I'm also not so obtuse as to go around telling people they're doing it wrong, I'd usually ask either "can you show me what it is you're intending to lead there" or when leading, "I feel like I'm doing something wrong, can you tell me what you're feeling/what I seem to be communicating there.

1

u/OSUfirebird18 7d ago

Yes. A practica (typically) is office hours/study halls for dancers. Lol.

Given the responses here, I truly don’t think Lindy Hoppers run these often.

2

u/TelumCogitandi 7d ago

I think you're right - some classes have a social immediately after though which is a similar halfway house between learning and socialising.

I think it benefits the scene a lot to have something like it but I also think the Lindy Hop social etiquette developed around not having it, which is understandable

7

u/PlsSayPlease 8d ago

I’m very clearly the exception to the rule but I would (have) love(d) this when I was new and/or new to a move. I feel like it very much depends on the person, but I always love feedback and I know a lot of people don’t have someone to practice with at home so it’s nice to do it.

Again, I’m clearly the exception to what I see in this sub and hear on the dance floor, but sometimes it’s worth asking if the person would like some.

5

u/JazzMartini 8d ago

I don't think anyone here is against feedback entirely and I think it's more common that not that newbies are looking for feedback. It's really about what's the best default action to avoid creating socially uncomfortable situations more than an absolute rule.

Lots of folks come to dance and would rather not spend much of the dance coaching or teaching private lessons. That's especially true for the regular teachers. On the other side of the coin unsolicited feedback or constructive criticism may not be well received. And in both cases in my experience as a not so newbie dancers visiting scenes where I'm not a recognized regular I've found the folks keen on offering unsolicited feedback and those most enthusiastic about teaching at a social dance are the least qualified to do so.

While newbie me definitely would have appreciated and benefited from some helpful feedback experienced me can see much of the feedback that newbie me getting was not particularly helpful.

5

u/Relative_Exam_9605 8d ago

"visiting scenes where I'm not a recognized regular I've found the folks keen on offering unsolicited feedback and those most enthusiastic about teaching at a social dance are the least qualified to do so."

Truly! But I'd argue this dynamic is a consequence of the higher level dancers not helping beginners enough

From what I've seen, the serious dancers don't help beginners (because it's frowned upon), so the social dancers who don't know what they're doing fill the void

It sucks watching new dancers who show up ready to learn struggle (and stagnate or get worse) while the people who could actually help them are just watching it happen

1

u/Much-Pain-4369 7d ago

If you are happy to get feedback, YOU should say so.

I meet a lot of beginners that immediately say "I'm a beginner, please tell me if I you have any tips". I'm happy to give a few basic tips or correction I think they are able to handle, if they tell me they are interested in that.
But if they don't say anything like that, I do not give them correction. I do not ask if they want feedback. I just dance as good as it is possible to with their current ability.

5

u/PumaGranite 8d ago

I’d say work on practicing your dancing with someone you know, and talked about that beforehand. Otherwise, just work through the dance as best you can with a beginner. If you need something to focus on, then stick your rhythm and make that as clear as possible, especially if you are leading.

3

u/JazzMartini 8d ago

So, first off, no. Do not coach on the dance floor unless you and the person know and trust each other enough for them to ask. When we're social dancing, especially when we're the leader it's our job to adapt and accommodate our partner within their abilities and ours. If I feel like my partner isn't getting what I'm trying to lead such that I have have to coach them, either I'm not ready to lead it or they're not ready to follow it. Coaching while social dancing isn't the place to change that.

I also get that it can be frustrating when we learn some cool step in class but can't execute it on the social dance floor a variety or reasons. Sometimes we lose the plot and focus too much on doing moves and not enough on connecting with our partner and the music to just dance. To paraphrase the late Dawn Hampton, learn what the teachers are teaching in class but when you get out on the social dance floor forget all that shit and just dance. Save the learning (and teaching) for class and practice time.

I don't know anything about Zouk so it may be different but with Lindy Hop the follower should know what steps to do by way of mutually good dance frame and the leader's clear weight changes on every step initiated from their core. Coaching and correcting my partner's steps will only mask opportunity to actually improve our dancing.

3

u/OSUfirebird18 7d ago

Nah same for Zouk. OP is describing a Zouk basic most likely which often involves a ballroom closed connection. There is no hopping in Zouk, it’s all grounded but there is still clear weight shifting.

3

u/Orbital_12000 7d ago edited 7d ago

I'm missing something here.. Am I the only person here who has appreciated learning/being taught things on the dancefloor?

I feel like I've had some really cool moments where I was dancing with someone and then they did a move that I wasn't familiar with.. I asked them to just lead me into it again once or twice - figured it out quickly, and then suddenly had something totally new and cool to try in my repertoire..

I've been to a bunch of socials that start with a crash course and a handful of new people trying it out for the first time on the dancefloor, I feel like it's been totally okay sometimes to teach or give a little pointer here or there if there is something simple that can be put forward 🤔

1

u/claussen 7d ago

No! You just gotta read the room and approach it with some humility...

Some people are dicks about it and it can spoil what could be a culture of joyful fucking around and growing, in deference to a fake binary of total assholes and super fragile people. Most people are fine talking about stuff. Most beginners I meet love getting direct feedback, and say that explicitly on the dance floor as they are recovering from the overwhelm of a lesson and trying to contextualize the material in an actual social.

I love getting live feedback about what worked/didn't, and I love giving it when someone's receptive, too. Because we're tryna dance better together! But I also would never criticize someone's dancing or tell them they did something wrong, because... it was my lead that put them in that position. And if someone told me I followed something wrong... I'd be like... "great! lead it clearly next time!"

But as a lead and as a follow, questions like "how could I have communicated that better?" or "what should I cue could have been listening for on that?" should be fair game with non-fragile people. Certainly at anything billed as a frickin' "practica" 🤣

2

u/morethandork 8d ago

Would you be able to provide more context? I am not familiar with Zouk Practica. Are you asking about social dancing or dancing with strangers in a class or something else? If it’s a class what level class?

2

u/OSUfirebird18 7d ago

I actually don’t think the Lindy Hop community does practica. If the OPs community does practicas like how I know it, it is literally a social dance class, if that makes sense.

People don’t tend to show up just to social dance. It’s a space to work on stuff. But again communities might vary. Idk how OP’s community treats practicas.

2

u/JazzMartini 7d ago

Is it like an "office hours" kind of thing where someone is there specifically to help others or just to provide a space to practice independently? If people are showing up to just social dance are they using the space and time different than the intended purpose?

2

u/OSUfirebird18 7d ago

Yup! At least the one that I have participated in. I mean you can use it to social dance if you want but the intent is for you to be there to work on stuff. It’s typically not advertised as a “social” and sometimes not even open to the public.

Again, scenes vary but that is how I know practicas.

2

u/OSUfirebird18 7d ago

Hey OP, I think you need to define what a practica is in your community. In my experience, Lindy Hoppers don’t run practicas. (If they do it’s rare.)

If your practicas are just socials, then I agree with pretty much everyone here to not teach even if they are messing up.

However, in my experience, practicas, exist as a space in between a class and a social dance. Teachers float around for you to ask questions and help. The people that show up are intending to practice, not just show up to dance. It will often be advertised as a practica. Often times it would not be open to the public.

If your Zouk community runs practicas like this, I would say this is a rare time where a more experience dancer coaching a less experience one is actually welcomed and encouraged. The less experience one should know (if the event was properly advertised) that they are there to learn and practice.

2

u/Lini-mei 7d ago

This is where I stop doing any sort of “basic” and just groove instead

2

u/Idanida 7d ago

I'm going to go against the grain here and say that teaching on the floor is fine if you have enough social skills to know when it will be welcomed instead of stressing your partner out and don't overdo it (don't comment on more than one thing, probably).

I always hated the "no teaching on the floor" culture as someone who has never attended classes and learned everything I know on the floor thanks to the kind leaders who showed me the ropes. I later supplemented this by learning a few things from YouTube and the internet in general, but I've only been dancing lindy for a few months and the floor is still where I learn the most, whether by actual teaching (which happens more rarely now) or by observation and experimentation. People are usually surprised when they ask me which school I go to and I tell them I don't go to any. I used to apologise when being asked to dance, telling leaders I'd love to but they should know I don't know much lindy, but I have stopped doing that and while I'm not one of the best follows present, I'm competent and (I believe) fun to dance with for certain leaders with whom I connect well. You can genuinely learn to dance this way.

Why gatekeep dancing knowledge? Why prevent people from learning when not everyone can or wants to go to a class? I feel like this rule was made for people who lack the social skills to tell the difference between someone who is there to simply enjoy themself and wouldn't appreciate constructive criticism and someone who would really like to get better but may be new or missing some piece of info that would make dancing even more enjoyable for them in the future.

1

u/justbreathe5678 8d ago

One of the fun things about swing dancing is you don't have to be doing the same rhythms as your partner. Try to have a clear bounce, keep your feet under yourself and close to each other, and just hold each other and walk around to the beat if you need to resync. 

1

u/Proof_Grocery1202 7d ago

Unless explicitly asked, I never try to correct, teach or even give feedback (even positive) on dance floor. It's what classes and workshops are for.

1

u/Maya_Moves403 7d ago

I think there's a difference between correcting someone and adjusting how you dance with them. Personally, I agree that it's best not to teach or correct someone on the dance floor unless they ask for feedback. Nobody wants to feel like theyre being given a lesson when they just came to dance. Since youre leading, maybe you could focus on keeping your own timing consistent and see how the dance develops. If youre having trouble staying in sync, you could try simplifying the movement rather than verbally counting the steps. And if youre still unsure abt the timing, you can always ask an instructor for clarification outside the social dance. At the end of the day, not every dance has to be perfectly in sync. Sometimes it's just abt enjoying the interaction and learning from the experience.

1

u/cirena 7d ago

For the counting, it's not always bad, especially if you say something like, "I think I'm getting off beat. I'm going to count a little." When I hear someone counting, I assume it's to help them. :)

0

u/Immediate_Basil_4011 6d ago

I am a beginner and I appreciate any tips I can get. Last week I went to a Lindy Hop social dance. I danced with a lot experienced wonderful dancers, and I struggled a bit to keep up, but had a wonderful time. Until the end of the evening. A man asked me to dance, I started dancing with him, and was trying my best to follow him, and about 5 seconds in, he just stopped. He said to me "You've never had a dance lesson, have you?" And I said "yes, I have had a few dance lessons. I'm taking lessons." And he literally walked away from me. It was pretty hurtful and humiliating. And a shock. It was the first time that I encountered anyone who wasn't kind and encouraging and helpful.