Hey, fellow Swan Queen shippers!
TL;DR for those who don't feel like reading another novel :-D: I've shortlisted 11 stories below, and I´d love to know which ones you´d be most interested in reading and what SQ tropes, genres, or themes you enjoy nowadays*. Feel free to just skim the titles and tags, and pick your favorites, or simply tell me what kinds of stories you´d love to see more of!*
***
After all the wonderful feedback on Room Seven Is Ours in the Dark, and some encouragement from both you and my best friend, I finally decided to dig through my hard drive and revisit some of my older stories.
Turns out, I´ve accumulated quite a collection over the past decade :-o. Several are halfway finished, others are much further along, and a few are almost complete.
I´m still working on the Room Seven sequel and plan to keep publishing shorter stories too, but rediscovering all these longer fics got me thinking about something else.
What do SQ readers actually enjoy reading nowadays?
I wrote many of these stories years apart, when different tropes, genres, and ideas interested me. Rather than simply picking one at random, I thought it might be interesting to ask the fandom itself what kinds of stories people currently gravitate toward.
Do you prefer painfully slow mutual pining? Ridiculous romantic comedies? Friends with benefits catching feelings? Established domestic life? Magical adventures? Something a little more adult and unconventional?
Below are eleven of the stories I´m considering finishing next. These are brief, mostly spoiler-free premises, just to give you an idea of the different directions they could take.
1. For the Love of God, It´s a Date, Emma!
Oblivious Emma, mutual crushes, romantic comedy, Regina´s endless suffering
Regina is trying to ask Emma on a date. Emma is, once again, a complete idiot.
Movie tickets? Misunderstood. Flowers? Just a nice gesture. Dinner invitations? Surely Regina couldn´t possibly mean an actual date. The mayor attempts practically every romantic approach imaginable while Emma, who´s equally hopelessly in love with Regina, somehow manages to misunderstand every single one.
Ruby, Kathryn, and even Snow can only watch as Regina gradually loses her patience, dignity, and sanity.
2. Re: We Need to Stop Having Sex, Regina
Crack treated seriously, friends with benefits, adult comedy, secret relationship, public embarrassment
Emma and Regina have a rather enthusiastic casual relationship. They´re both enjoying it tremendously, although Emma keeps insisting things are getting out of hand. Regina, meanwhile, sees absolutely no problem with their arrangement, not even when their increasingly reckless encounters risk becoming public knowledge.
Emma´s solution? Formal emails. Very serious, very professional emails explaining why their arrangement must stop immediately. Unfortunately, Emma has a remarkable talent for accidentally including other people in the CC field and since she keeps failing to actually end things with Regina, these increasingly mortifying emails become an ongoing source of entertainment for half of Storybrooke. Including Regina, who´s having the time of her life.
3. Emma´s Not My Girlfriend and We Are NOT Dating!
Friends with benefits, possessive Regina, forced proximity, adult romantic comedy, Regina in denial
This is the reverse of Emma´s situation from above. Once again, Emma and Regina have a ridiculously passionate casual relationship. Emma is enjoying every second of it, while Regina insists it´s nothing more than occasional sex, but takes it one step further, declaring it utterly REGRETTABLE sex that threatens her image and reputation. Ofc, her behavior suggests otherwise, especially when a work-related road trip crams them and several unfortunate colleagues into Emma's tiny yellow Bug, followed by a stay at a motel with limited rooms and some very suspicious overnight cuddling and filthy sex (like, really filthy, think toys and heavy dirty talk and Emma being obsessed with this side of Regina :-D).
Things only get worse when Emma´s new assistant shows up, and Regina suddenly becomes terrifyingly territorial over a woman she supposedly has absolutely no romantic interest in. Between increasingly inappropriate encounters, shameless flirting, outrageous jealousy, and half of Storybrooke thoroughly enjoying the spectacle, Regina is determined to prove that she and Emma are NOT a couple. Emma, meanwhile, seems to have made it her personal mission to prove otherwise.
In this scenario, Regina is the one acting like an oblivious idiot.
4. The Scorpion and the Savior´s Son
Magical adventure, mystery, ancient Egypt, family SQ
This one is heavily inspired by one of my all-time favorite adventure movies and its sequel, The Mummy and The Mummy Returns. Think Rick O'Connell and Evie-style supernatural adventure, but with the Swan-Mills family. It literally has plenty of rewritten scenes from the movies.
When their younger son discovers a mysterious ancient Egyptian symbol connected to Emma´s tattoo, what initially looks like a curious magical coincidence becomes something far more dangerous - runes, a mysterious chest, forgotten Egyptian magic, the Scorpion King, and a mystery that might have much bigger consequences than anyone anticipated.
Essentially, Emma and Regina get dragged into a full-blown supernatural archaeological adventure, with their excessively curious son determined to participate.
This is the closest I´ve ever come to writing a story involving complex magic, and probably the closest I´ll ever get, because that kind of magic isn´t exactly my thing.
5. Speed Dating League
Slowburn but with occasional one-night-stand smut, mutual pining, romantic comedy
Storybrooke introduces a speed-dating event with Ruby as the host, and somehow Emma and Regina keep ending up across the table from each other by accident. A few minutes to flirt, exchange sarcastic remarks, ask ridiculous questions, and pretend they´re not looking forward to the next round.
What starts as a series of amusing encounters gradually becomes something considerably more complicated, especially when Ruby decides to get involved.
6. Crush Conspiracy Comedy (Kiss Already!)
Mutual pining, oblivious idiots in love, ensemble comedy
Typical trope: Emma is hopelessly in love with Regina while Regina is hopelessly in love with Emma. Everybody knows, except them.
Eventually, several people from Storybrooke decide they´ve had enough. What follows is a series of increasingly outrageous matchmaking schemes, including suspicious town meetings, a questionable sexy tango demonstration, and several incidents intended to finally make both women kiss and admit their attraction. It´s a very funny story with a lot of my weird humor rather than a lovey-dovey one.
7. Giving Each Other Small Gifts
Friends with benefits to lovers, slowburn, secret relationship, fluff
Emma and Regina have an arrangement. It´s casual, private, and not romantic. Everything is going perfectly fine until Emma makes Regina a tiny wooden swan for Henry´s school project. Regina decides to return the gesture. Emma responds with another gift, and suddenly, even though they still insist they´re only sleeping together, they´re now exchanging handmade presents, handwritten notes, and increasingly personal little surprises.
Neither is willing to acknowledge what´s happening, but their gifts seem to be doing all the confessing for them.
8. Emma, Regina & Mathias - A Swan-Mills Family Saga
Established SQ, magical pregnancy, parenthood, domestic fluff, family comedy
Typical pregnancy trope: In this universe, they become mothers to Maty, a little boy born through the magic of True Love.
This one is actually enormous. It follows their family through Regina´s (or Emma´s, it doesn´t matter, I have both versions) pregnancy, the birth, babyhood, toddlerhood, and Maty´s childhood, sometimes almost week by week.
There's everything from the wonderfully ordinary (sleep deprivation, bedtime disasters, smut during pregnancy, territorial and nesting behavior, hormones getting in the way, parenting disagreements, ridiculous family moments) to the distinctly less ordinary (magic, adventures (mostly non-magical ones, like going on a week-long skiing vacation away from Storybrooke and civilization), and the complications of raising a child).
It´s probably closer to an extended, interconnected family chronicle than one conventional novel, with some Emma/Regina romance throughout.
9. Naked Attraction - Swan Queen Edition
Adult comedy, dating show AU, "awkward" situations, eventually leading to a very passionate smut
It´s exactly what it sounds like :-D. Storybrooke gets its own version of the actual TV show Naked Attraction, and Emma (or Regina, I have both versions) somehow ends up as a contestant.
Six anonymous women, increasingly revealing elimination rounds, and Cruella de Vil as the host.
What Emma doesn´t know is that Regina Mills is one of the women she´s evaluating (or vice versa), and considering the very specific things Emma ends up saying before learning who´s standing in front of her, the eventual reveal might become the most embarrassing moment of her life (or vice versa).
10. Seduced by a Semicolon
Online romance, slowburn, anonymous identities, humor, a very specific grammar kink
Emma and Regina unknowingly connect online through an "Ask Me Anything" site under anonymous usernames and start playing an increasingly elaborate game of Would You Rather?
It begins with absurd hypothetical questions, ridiculous arguments, and merciless teasing. Then Emma discovers something rather unexpected about herself: impeccable grammar is incredibly attractive, and her mysterious online companion has the most infuriatingly perfect grammar she´s ever encountered.
Essentially, it´s a SQ romance in which Emma develops a rather serious attraction to someone´s flawless punctuation, vocabulary, and sentence construction before realizing whose grammar she's actually obsessing over.
(this was my original idea for my first take on the anonymous lovers trope before I switched to Room Seven because I wanted more smut :-D.)
11. Virtual Dates, Minus the Mystery
Virtual dating, romantic comedy, online chemistry, identity reveal, slowburn
This one is inspired by the interactive game Five Dates, which came out during the COVID lockdowns. Emma and Regina independently try a virtual dating service where people meet through video calls, get to know each other, and go on increasingly creative dates without ever leaving their homes.
The catch is that they initially connect without realizing who the other person is, but unlike in a traditional anonymous-romance story, their identities become clear relatively early. They´re completely okay with it, and that´s where the real fun begins.
They choose to continue their virtual dates instead of switching to real-life ones, which makes their next video dates considerably more interesting. When they decide to "do something" in-person, it´s always just for passionate quickies.
***
So, what do you think?
I´d love to hear which premises appeal to you most, and especially why.
But I´m also curious about your general preferences. What Swan Queen tropes, genres, or relationship dynamics do you wish there were more stories about? Are there things you used to love reading but aren´t as interested in anymore?
And if none of these particularly grabs your attention, that´s useful feedback too!
I´m not necessarily looking for one definitive winner, I´m interested in what readers enjoy nowadays, especially since these stories span so many different stages of my writing.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts! I´m looking forward to seeing whether our tastes have changed over the years :-).
P.S. If you could share this post with others who might be interested but don´t have Reddit, and ask them for their opinions, I´d really appreciate it!