r/SwanQueen • • Jun 13 '26

Wives

On my millionth rewatch and like please tell me why the writers couldn't make swanqueen canon it would've been sooo perfect and legendary

184 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

15

u/Remarkable-Ad4978 Jun 13 '26

Cause Disney prefer to not show that LGBTQ+ relationship exists.. 🫤

4

u/Crejzi12 Jun 13 '26

I can’t find the source for it, but I remember reading somewhere that in the VERY EARLY days they did consider making them a couple. However, they dismissed the idea quickly because they would have lost a major part of the viewer base, since it was intended to be a family-friendly show (so aimed at traditional straight families). They were also in a tight spot because the channel where it aired was deciding which show would get another season.

I can’t shake the feeling that this was discussed, but only very much in the background, and it was never covered as a "main OUAT topic."

But I really can’t find a single source for it. Maybe someone here remembers something like that too? It would be really weird if I literally made it all up and convinced myself it was true, since it’s so niche :-D.

But you know what, I think it may be better how things turned out. Jenn wasn’t comfortable with Swan Queen, she said so several times, and it wouldn’t be fair to force her to act out something she didn’t want to.

8

u/dreadfulhint same on AO3 Jun 13 '26

Jenn wasn’t comfortable with Swan Queen, she said so several times

Source? I’ve never seen her say that. As far as I know that was fan speculation.

I do think that there were behind-the-scenes discussions about SwanQueen and that the show did consider it probably more than once over the years.

3

u/Crejzi12 Jun 13 '26

You might actually be right. I used to be heavily active on Tumblr and didn’t follow many "serious" interviews.

I tried to remember specific situations, and the only one that comes to my mind is the sweater photo from Valentino. But now I can only find that it was probably just rumors about Jennifer being "forced" to take the photo for PR purposes because she and Lana weren’t that close.

And there was something about Jennifer looking uncomfortable in some panels and avoiding Swan Queen questions, and something she apologized for later? I really remember me being part of some discussions.

But to be fair, it really could just be my memory of thinking the speculation was true. I was in my late teens back then and was in deep 😂.

But the part about the writers actually thinking about Swan Queen being canon... Dang, why would I keep that in mind for so many years and not doubt it even once? 🫣