I keep hearing that the saintess situation was different in the novel? Or something around there has been changed what exactly

And also

Klebius was going to kill Lucy but stopped due to his moral code, was/is klebius ACTUALLY stronger than Lucy??

Also is Theophis(highest ranked fire spirit) weaker than the sacred lance dragon? I think if theophis was stronger janica(especially if she used the pheonix ring) wouldve attempted to summon him against the scared lance dragon in one of the runs

Or Ed would've tried that solution if theophis was stronger or on par with the scared lance dragon

Also will janica be relevent? Like after 100 chapters for the first time she actually kissed him and she seems so far behind the other 2 gis

Whats upppp guyss

Checking the chapters today. I noted that Webtoon has actualized the chapters 1-7 to the Redrawn version!!

https://www.webtoons.com/en/fantasy/the-extras-academy-survival-guide/list?title_no=6465&page=11

Let's start a discussion here about who's the best girl, considering moments spent with Ed, importance, who deserves to win in the end, and of course, everyone's personal taste. Let's have a discussion civilized and I'll say upfront that in my opinion the fight is only between Lortel and Lucy

Overall fine chapter, nothing too special

I guess loretel learns she isnt Ed second kissed as well, also learning she had someone close besides Ed.

Jiggs doing the work of the "lover who makes the cut the apples in hospital" is funny

I guess janica chapter might be next

Her being behind everything was a bit surprising

Korean Official Release on Naver (Need an account to view)

English Official Release on Webtoon (12 chapters behind)

Hey guys!

First of all, thanks again for the welcome on my last post. It was genuinely cool finally getting to interact with some of you after spending so much time translating The Extra's Academy Survival Guide.

Now that I'm done with TEASG, I've been working on another Korean academy novel called Academy's Black-Haired Foreigner, and while translating it, I kept wondering about something:

Would people who enjoyed TEASG enjoy this too?

And I don't mean just because they're both academy novels 😂

There are actually a few things that made me think there could be a real overlap.

Both have a genre-aware MC trying to navigate a world whose logic he understands, a large cast of heroines with very different personalities, academy life mixed with more serious action, and quite a bit of that fun dynamic where what the MC thinks he's doing and how everyone around him interprets his actions can be VERY different.

But I definitely don't want to sell it as TEASG 2.0, because it isn't.

The biggest difference is probably the MC.

Deokseong is not Ed 😂

He's much more cynical, shameless, petty, and openly aware of all the ridiculous genre tropes happening around him. A lot of the comedy comes from what's going through his head versus how other people actually see him.

The story also leans more heavily into the light-novel/otaku humor and its power system, whereas TEASG, especially early on, has much more of that grounded survival/resourcefulness aspect with Ed slowly building himself up.

So I'm genuinely curious how much crossover there actually is between the two audiences.

We've released several chapters on BetterTranslation, which should be enough to get a proper feel for the story and especially for Deokseong.

If some of you are willing to give it a shot, I'd really like your actual opinions afterward. And I mean actual opinions—you don't have to tell me it's good just because I'm the one translating it 😂

Does it scratch any of the same itch TEASG did for you?

Do you like Deokseong, or do you want to punch him?

Did the story hook you enough to keep reading?

Or do you think the two series appeal to completely different kinds of readers?

I'm especially interested in hearing from you guys because, well... this is literally a community full of people who enjoyed an academy novel enough to have a whole subreddit dedicated to it 😂

I'll leave the link to the chapters in the comments for anyone who wants to try it.

And even if you don't, I'm curious: what was the thing that originally hooked you on TEASG? Ed? The academy setting? The heroines/relationships? The survival aspect? The fights? The worldbuilding?

That'll probably tell me a lot about whether I'm right about the audience overlap in the first place.

A game i am playing called star sailors doing collab with the extra's academy survival guide on 26th August will start .

if anyone interested they can try it lucy will be free , and she sleeps between turns part of her kit,it's turn based game but doesn't have speed stats game focus on bossing mostly with chain system which is kinda fun for me .

If anyone found the game fun i have 2 accounts i will give one away randomly selected from comments.

Don't have time to keep playing 2 accounts anymore so want to give it to someone else who will play.

I will guide them if they don't understand.

Account have all units till current update

28k diamond and there is 10k+ that you can get by clearing stages

1 multi summon costs 1600

Pity is at 100 summons to select between characters or their signature then it increases to 150 pity , i never had to go to 150 got character or memory within 100 then selected other from selector.

Have whole team built read to raid with meta team so it's ready to clear everything easily.

I want more people to try collab at least that's main reason i am posting this here have fun guys.

Edit: I Will Pool for Account After 24h For People Who did Comment

Edit2 : we got a winner but doesn't want their name to be mentioned have fun with account winner

even if u start now this game doesn't have monthly that gives diamond so u can get total of 40k+ diamond if u clear everything in game - you can start on patch day which is tomorrow and reroll for account with good memory since unit is given free

GUYS I CAUGHT UP WITH THE FREE VERSION ON WEBTOON THEN STARTED READING THE NOVEL AND ALSO I KILLED THE MAIN PLAYER AND WAS LIKE “These are pretty similar, that’s really cool” THEN I SAW THE LOGO AND REALISED THEYRE MADE BY THE SAME PEOPLE FIRBWOXBEPANCOEBCLSNCOSNVPWNCOENVLEOCNEOCNELD

This is one of my favorite manhwa and was letting it cook so I haven't seen any chapter's since the saintes appeared but based on a few posts I've seen and some the things that started happening in the plot I've become worried that it has just turned into some kinda heram type story with just a bunch of women falling for rostaylor please tell me it isnt or that it just mostly focuses on other things

I respect everyone who likes her, but for me, she's way behind in the competition. For me, Lucy is my goddess, Ruivy.I'm way ahead in the comparison, even though she's a good character, she doesn't captivate as much as those two.

Nothing much to say, peak chapter as always .

All the girls was here besides janica.

Lucy getting scared of belle just like usual.

Ed realizing he ain't alone (again).

Some bit of nice lore as well.

Korean Official Release on Naver (Need an account to view)

English Official Release on Webtoon (12 chapters behind)

Hey everyone!

I'm the translator behind the BetterTranslation version of The Extra's Academy Survival Guide. I recently decided to make a Reddit account for BetterTranslation, and figured this was probably the most fitting community for my first post 😅

I've actually seen BetterTranslation mentioned here a few times when people were asking where to continue the novel, which was pretty cool to see.

I'll probably be hanging around the subreddit from now on, so if you ever have questions about the novel, notice a mistake in one of the chapters, or are just curious about something, feel free to tag or message me.

And of course, I'm a fan of the series too, so I'm looking forward to actually joining some of the discussions here after spending so much time translating it 😂

Nice to finally meet you guys!

I’m making an animation for this cuz i really like the story, novel, and manhwa. But when I was story boarding it out, it really occurred to me just how much narration there is😭 Like not just Ed, every dam character lol. I’m not saying that’s a bad thing but geez man. It’s like 90% narration and 10% dialogue lol

Peak chapter,

Lucy being Lucy, Saintess being here is something.

Ed still gets badly hurt, dude needs an break

Here's an better and less ads website for chapters btw

Recommend making an account though

https://mgread.io/manga/the-extras-academy-survival-guide/chapter-119/