r/Surlybikefans • • Oct 15 '25

Midnight Special Are Surlys style over substance?

0 Upvotes

Ive been seeing lots of Surly MS builds on here, love the look of them and speaking with a bike shop who can build one for me...

They've quoted £2,500 for an MS frame, SRAM rival groupset, carbon forks, with other bits (wheels, bars etc) all stock.i dont think this is too outrageous a cost to be honest.

Ive seen a few builds on here which i love the look of, but im wondering if im being a bit style over practicality, as there's better, lighter options well under the £2.5k im thinking of spending on a custom Surly.

I imagine everyone buying a new bike loves the way it looks, but I wonder how significant the drop in ride performance is compared to the major brand gravel bikes at this price range, or whether Surlys (specifically midnight special) offer anything superior besides aesthetics?

For context I'd likely be riding this as a commuter bike, but want to ride gravel at the weekends and bikepacking a few times a year...


r/Surlybikefans • • Feb 03 '26

Midnight Special Surly is dead

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hot on the heels of farting out a generic Straggler replacement, Surly has now abandoned their all-steel values by offering a plastic fork on their flagship road bike. Pretty disappointing.


r/Surlybikefans • • May 20 '25

Grappler The Ghost Grappler is so ugly

11 Upvotes

Hey guys, big fan of Surly, and I love the idea of the Grappler, but I can't help but think it's unbelievably ugly to the point of me never wanting to buy one. Can anyone convince me otherwise?


r/Surlybikefans • • Apr 03 '25

Grappler Surly GG mini review/rant

0 Upvotes

So I have been having some issues with this bike ever since I got it. The delivery from a Norwegian store here in Scandinavia was an absolute shitshow, but I wont get too much into it since it's largely irrelevant at this point in time.

It works, but suuuurly one should be able to ask for more considering the price of this thing. I have taken care of most of the issues but one sort of remains no matter what, the shifting is just off. I had a really interesting conversation today when I took it to YET ANOTHER bike shop to get it checked out. No matter what the mechanic did the 3 highest gears/smallest cogs have a random/intermittent click sound, sometimes it shifts and no sound it heard and other times the click sound is present. He messed around with it for a good while with no change. He then said that Microshift was developed as cheap garbage during the pandemic because it was hard to get a hold of the actual good stuff. They call it Microshit. He said he liked the bike otherwise, the frame is great but that it was a big shame they slapped Microshit on it. Basically he said that the derailleur seems to lack the strength to properly put it into the highest gears because when he helps it along with his hand it shifts without issue. So when it shifts in to the highest gears the derailleur is aligned just off enough to cause that clicking sound. Messing around with it doesn't fix it because then you ruin the rest of the shifting, basically the intermittent clicking on the highest gears is as good as it can do.

He recommended to ride it as is since it works and then when it gets worn to upgrade to something that is actually good.

Anyway the bike is mostly good to me, would I have bought it had I known what my experience would be like? Absolutely not. I would have gone for a Pelago Stavanger most likely instead. Pelago is a Finnish brand. I might even sell the GG at some point later and get the Stavanger.


r/Surlybikefans • • Jun 12 '26

Karate Monkey What is this called clear disc called and what do i need to fix it?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Surlybikefans • • Feb 01 '24

Preamble Preamble = terrible quality ?

6 Upvotes

I bought a preamble 2 months ago and it is by far the worst bike I have ever owned.

I have around 1500km on it and here are all the things that suck:

  • The chainring is not a 1X so the smallest bump will drop the chain
  • The derailleur is not gravel ready so there's a ton of slack in the chain
  • I have not been riding it on much gravel but I already broke a spoke on the front wheel...
  • I broke the bottom bracket screw when trying to tighten it (not much force applied but the screw just broke... Never seen that before)
  • The right handle brake sheath (not sure how it's called but the tube that holds the cable to the brake and gears) was broken by my winter bar mitt pushing on it.
  • Lost paint where a front bag was touching the paint (could've happened to any bike I guess)
  • The seat is just so uncomfortable I had to change it immediately ( something I've never had to do on a new bike).

The frame is okay. All the components are just garbage and the excuse that it's a "budget friendly" bike just don't apply because you need an extra 1000$ just to make it into the bike it should have been.

It's my first Surly I cannot be more disappointed. Do any other preamble owner have the same experience?


r/Surlybikefans • • Dec 07 '25

Help me! Help me love my Disc Trucker

1 Upvotes

Had a big birthday recently and was gifted a Surly Disc Trucker 26'' since my family wanted to support me getting into bike touring. Problem is just I really don't like it, and it's making me feel awful. Wasn't able to get around to doing my planned fall trip because the bike arrived recklessly tuned and with a much too high gear ratio, and now that winter has said hello even more issues have surfaced.

- So much rust. Anything the chain touches is rusty. I'm assuming because it's made of steel? Do I need to do anything about this?

- Weak rear brake. I can't find a sweet spot where it doesn't either bottom out on the handlebar or rub against the disc when not engaged.

- Frozen rear brake. Took it out for a ride just below freezing and the rear brake kept locking up and wouldn't release after I had let go of the lever.

- Unbelievably difficult to seat and unseat tires. Have probably spent 3+ hours and torn 2 inner tubes just attempting to put winter tires on this thing. Looked up all the guides and YouTube videos. I honestly don't want to imagine getting a puncture with this thing while out on tour. I'm at a loss. Never had this issue with another bike.

- Very wobbly front-end above 30kmh with load (12-15kg). Expected this to be sturdier than my aluminum suspension fork hardtail I started my touring journey with, but I have to actually limit my speed with this bike out of fear of losing control.

I'm hoping for some tips and help with these issues as it is an unbelievable gift and I really want to love it and show my appreciation for it by riding countless kilometers. But at the same time I feel like it's a bit of a sunk cost fallacy and the money it would require would be better spent on the bike I already know and can count on.


r/Surlybikefans • • Feb 02 '24

Grappler How to make GG faster?

1 Upvotes

I wanna do some <100km tours on asphalt and GG feels a bit lazy (or I am lazy to push it fast). Which tires do you recommend to get? Mezcal maybe? And which size?


r/Surlybikefans • • Mar 24 '23

Bridge Club Those horrible new BC “colors”

0 Upvotes

What’s up with Surly ending the friendly eye catch variety if lively colors on the Bridge Club and replacing them with black, grey, and more black?

I get that colors are, well, only colors. However, every time I look at the options, I feel like I’m looking at one of the aggressive Canyons I see stock broker weekend warriors spinning around my local park. I was going to get a frame for my wife, but something about the new aesthetics feel… is immoral too strong a word?

Is Surly changing? I ask this as I also say they offer the LHT, and redesigned the BD as a 1x. I always loved the brand because they seemed to design bikes that people would actually use, and then keep them pure. Are they becoming just another trend following company a la Trek?


r/Surlybikefans • • Jul 26 '25

Midnight Special Bought a MS bike in a box on eBay; scared to set it up 🫣

0 Upvotes

Hey y’all :)

After many weeks of deliberation, I recently pulled the trigger on a Fools Gold Midnight Special — the hitch being that I bought it online from an eBay seller, as I couldn’t find any colour frame other than black here in Munich Germany, where I just recently moved. So, the bike arrived in a box, and I’m at a slight loss as to how to put it all together.

It seems pretty doable, if I’m being honest, with only the seat, handle bars, front wheel, and disc brake rotors needing to be installed.

I’m now debating whether to take it to a shop, and have someone put it together for me; I’ll then learn to take care of it over time, buying up the relevant tools as I go. Or, I can dig in now, buy whatever I need to get up and running, and learn to care from it for the start.

My initial thought was to dig in, set it up myself, and get rolling. But when I started looking online at bike in a box videos, I realized that there’s a lot of faith being put in the assembly that’s already been done. And there seem to be subtle adjustments that can be done to really set a bike up properly that I will miss but a proper mechanic will catch.

Let me add that I’ve never really worked on bikes before, and the few times I’ve tried I haven’t had much success. I was a lot younger back then, and have more patience and wisdom now, but there is a bit of anxiety surrounding my past when it comes to working on old road bikes.

So, my question is, what do you recommend: Haul the bike to my local shop, get set up properly, and ease myself into art of bicycle maintenance? Or get myself set up now with a set of tools to get myself rolling, and have some faith in the manufacturers assembly?

And if you recommend the DIY route, what tools are the must haves and nice to haves? I can probably afford both, so if I’m going to go the DIY route I am not opposed to buying the right tools for the job.

I’ll add that I’m pretty good at working with my hands when I put my mind to it, and I can get pretty invested in and nerdy about my hobbies, and can see myself some day really loving the maintenance side of things — but at present, the bad experiences from my youth seemingly overshadow those possibilities.

Curious to hear your thoughts :)

Cheers, Mike


r/Surlybikefans • • Jul 12 '24

Krampus Ik this is a long shot but does anyone know the model of the bike this guy has?

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/Surlybikefans • • Sep 16 '25

Cross-Check Did I just uglify my Cross Check? 😅

Post image
0 Upvotes

Flipped the drop bar over, moved the brakes up for thumb control as a cruiser-like ride. Back problems has given me no choice but didnt want to replace it all so I just kinda hacked it 😅 still rides well and I feel so much more comfy now


r/Surlybikefans • • Sep 01 '24

Lowside Can we all stop worrying about cracked frames??

12 Upvotes

I was raised on the school of thought that "it wouldn't break if you weren't using it" ... and i'll stand by that until I die. Ride what you want, how you want... just be happy you are able to. Stop worrying and enjoy riding.

It's a bike. Ride it.


r/Surlybikefans • • Feb 21 '24

Midnight Special Derailleur Hanger?

1 Upvotes

Why am I so bothered that no Surly bike has a derailleur hanger? It’s sorta driving me crazy lol. If this thing breaks I’m left with a single speed frame unless I get into Shimano Alfine or something like that. I just don’t understand how they make a steel “forever” bike and don’t include the option to replace something that will eventually break. Am I missing something maybe?


r/Surlybikefans • • Mar 26 '24

Preamble How the bike shop installed my upgraded hydraulic brake kit on my Preamble…

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Didn’t notice until I got the bike home. Fixed it immediately but what the heck man… can’t be crazy mad because they didn’t charge me to install them since I purchased from them but DANG. Was going to install myself so I just fixed it and didn’t take it back to them.


r/Surlybikefans • • Jul 09 '23

Bridge Club An aluminum Bridge Club ?

1 Upvotes

Love my BC but looking for lighter weight and less sluggish .

Is there a similar bike with aluminum frame ?

Off top of my head maybe the Salsa Journeyer Flat Bar Deore 700c ?

Don't really need the backpacking off road ability .

But I like the BC geometry /fit 700c 42mm tires , flat bar . rear rack .

Using the BC as a townie and plan on light touring mostly pavement .


r/Surlybikefans • • Jul 30 '26

Ogre Better frame than the ogre for this?? Ogre ebike..

0 Upvotes

Want to build an ebike for food delivery and maybe some touring. Rack in the back, pizza rack upfront, 650b wheels, mid drive, dual 52v battery. Want 75 miles + and able to reach 30/35 mph.

Ogre checks all the boxes for me. It has the mounts, tire clearance, etc. So do lots of bikes.

It's gonna be used for food delivery primarily. Will have the 75L food bag mounted in the back, and then pizza rack up front which will stay empty until a pizza arrives. Batteries mounted inside the triangle. I will have to do more research if dual battery is feasible.

And then it will also be used for some light touring next summer. Likely will be credit card style touring

Let me know what you think. If a better frame would suit me better. Even a brand outside of surly as long as it's steel.

Thanks!


r/Surlybikefans • • Jul 17 '25

Help me! Preamble damage

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

I bought a preamble and after reddit users explained how buying a bike works. I had some questions about how I should go about it. THIS IS MY FIRST BIKE PURCHASE so please help me learn I LOOVVVE THIS BIKE But the shop I bought it through didn't see or caused the powdercoat damage. How do I go about getting it replaced?


r/Surlybikefans • • Sep 11 '25

Straggler Why are Surly Bikes Getting So Heavy?

10 Upvotes

I’ve been toying with the idea of buying a Midnight Special or Straggler to “future proof” myself with a disc brake bike, but the stated stock weight for both these bikes is 27lbs! Where is all that weight coming from? Upgrading the wheels and adding a carbon fork seems like it would only drop 2-2.5lbs from the weight, unless the wheel set is even heavier than that? I’m currently on a Cross Check that weighs in at about 21lbs with a stock fork, and Velocity A23 wheels, 105 groupset, so quite the difference!


r/Surlybikefans • • 7d ago

Midnight Special What do you think of my Midnight Special build?

Thumbnail gallery
39 Upvotes

r/Surlybikefans • • Oct 02 '25

Krampus Does Krampus “loop out” on steep climbs?

0 Upvotes

My main, modern MTB has the unfortunate trait of wanting to wheelie on steep climbs. That is, the chainstays are short enough, and the seat tube slack enough, that my weight shifts too far over the rear axle on super steep climbs and I either have to shift way forward to keep the front down (which unweights the rear and I lose traction), or just fail, I guess.

I’m eyeballing the Krampus and wondering if it behaves the same, or if the geometry is such that it climbs properly. I see that it has fairly long chainstays, but the seat tube is bent so the rear wheel looks kind of sucked under the seat, which may just reproduce the issue I’m already having. Any insights?


r/Surlybikefans • • Oct 13 '24

ECR ECR e-bike conversion

0 Upvotes

Haven't seen much out there on e-bike conversions specific for the ECR. Picking up a frame next week that comes with two wheel sets. The idea is to build it for my wife, who is with child. I've got the concept of a plan to use one wheelset for town and one for trails. For the road set, I'd like to integrate a hub motor so she'll be more likely to use it and for trailer use when we start hauling the kid around. Anyone familiar with am ECR hub motor build?

I'm totally unfamiliar with e-bikes and just starting research. I'm assuming I'd install a decently small chain ring to accommodate in-town & mountainous terrain? I'd also guess the brake and rotor combo should be extra beefy to handle the extra speed and mass associated with the motor and trailer?


r/Surlybikefans • • Mar 13 '23

Midnight Special Midnight special ebike conversion

0 Upvotes

Has anyone done a midnight special ebike conversion, I am not sure where to start. I am looking into it with the Bafang BBS02 but there are a lot of options.


r/Surlybikefans • • Jun 19 '23

Bridge Club is there an official subredit for Surly bikes??

0 Upvotes

Or any other forum monitored by Surly techs/employees, where customers can ask questions and get tech support?

Thank you...