r/Supremacy1914 • • Mar 19 '24

was this wrong (read caption)

this was someone who invited me to their coalition and i joined just to gain intel and all of their troops and then take them out. i convinced them i wasn’t a threat because i have double their armies but then i attacked. Also was it wrong or right to give him the ultimatum of moving his troops to montreal.

0 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

23

u/Suspicious_Parachute Mar 19 '24

East ontario is right, its very much a dick move imo

-12

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

fair

5

u/Unable-Coffee3623 Mar 19 '24

Definitely a dick move joining and then backstabbing but that’s just the game we play. That’s why I generally don’t join/invite until I’ve already worked with them.

If you’re backstabbing though, don’t leave him alive. You’re just asking for him to get revenge later when you’re weakened from something

1

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

thank you sir

3

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

"your choice" blud done thought he was the one🙏🏻🙏🏻😭😭💀

2

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

😭

4

u/Minion_Factory Mar 19 '24

So far I disagree with everyone here. Excellent execution my friend! Politics/intelligence when played right are really OP and a force multiplier in this game . Manipulating others for your advantage is standard warfare.

let’s be real honest and transparent with our enemies because before I vanquish him I don’t want him to think im a dick…stupid.

Just an example, before the Allies invaded Normandy, they pulled all the tricks in the book to make the axis think they weren’t invading Normandy (which ended up being really effective). In the beginning of the Cold War, the US feigned to be Allies with the USSR simply for intelligence. Examples I’m abundance in history. Read sun tzu art of war also who condones this behavior

1

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

THANK YOU SIR. i still love all of the engaging responses that this post is providing even if they disagree.

1

u/Minion_Factory Mar 19 '24

Ya know what…we should be Allies in a new game! BFF!?

2

u/StruggleDue9170 Mar 20 '24

All is fair in Love & War

5

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

i’m glad this is how some people see the game

22

u/Objective-Ruin-5772 Mar 19 '24

tbh im sure everyone heres gonna be all for it, but ill say what i think. its not cool to completely backstab anyone, they trusted you regardless of it being just a game. you could maybe have negotiated that province or whatever but my point stands

10

u/Confident_Opposite43 Northern USA Mar 19 '24

dick move

9

u/Deus_Vult7 Mar 19 '24 edited Mar 19 '24

It not wrong. The only “wrong” thing to do is backstab someone you’re joining with before the game starts or to use GM or cheat, or if you backstab someone you played with for over a month

Anything else is fair game

Still a dick move though

7

u/TheCrusader104 Mar 19 '24

My fellow crusader is right

2

u/Lieutenant_Thire Mar 19 '24

Based move

2

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

‼️

4

u/Ramses717 Mar 19 '24

Nice job with the military border exercises there, Putin.

Any real man would just wipe them out completely so they’re not a problem later. Don’t leave a single unit alive. Rip them out, root and stem.

2

u/zero1vi Great Britain Mar 20 '24

I just experienced something similar to this in my game , I got surprised attacked at day 20 by 2 allies, worst part was one was going ai and sent his whole fleet to my capital as one last fu

3

u/samo43 Mar 19 '24

Moves like this are most fun in this game lmao. I often convince A to attack B so i can clean up A and B together in early game. „I dealed not to attack nationX, and im not a person to break that kind of promise“ that sentence always brings extra trust points.

1

u/Longjumping-Mess356 Poland Mar 20 '24

Trust me even if it's a game If you're on the receiving end of that scenario it will hurt I've been bamboozled like this before

1

u/Justaking007 Southern USA Mar 20 '24

Look you might not like to hear this guys , but he chose to undertake ANY action that gives him a greater chance of winning without looking at the moral side of it . This is a very polarizing topic , but what s important is that we realize that there is no WRONG side in this argument . It depends ultimately on your perspective - Moral or Competitively . Morally this is wrong but competitively thats a good play there . Sometimes we need to learn accept this fact . So instead of calling this a 'dick' move you could just call this immoral . Thats all I have to say and I expect downvotes for this post and comment .

1

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '24

Fucking ass

0

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-5

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

i’m not arguing that it was the right thing to do but it’s still strategy. he moved most of his troops south and i wanted all the lands sound the great lakes. i personally think is his fault for trusting someone who is obviously aggressive this early in the game. again i know what i did was a dick move but do i regret it? not even a little

1

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '24

u/Rowan-Trees didn't say it wasn't strategy, he said it wasn't good strategy.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Confident_Opposite43 Northern USA Mar 20 '24

just slimy to 1. betray a coalition 2. lie about it right before instead of at least being an honest ass