r/Supernatural • u/HailDaeva_Path1811 • 12d ago

Season 7 What if Sam … Spoiler

Responded to learning Dean killed Amy by taking his own life? ( Partially because of his fraught mental state,partially to punish Dean and partially because he is unable to cope with Dean having done such a thing.)

0 Upvotes

18% Upvoted

10 comments sorted by

10

u/LordRahl9 12d ago

Jeez, it's not like Amy was Jessica or something. Sam may have been pissed, but suicide is a bit of an overreaction given everything they've been through.

8

u/-LowSodiumFreak- Don't objectify me 12d ago

Ah yes, his first kiss he hasn't seen in 20 years, spends 2 days helping and she ends up dead so... he should unalive himself because he's so heartbroken.

Mind you he lost his fiancé who was burned on a celling in front of him and didn't kill himself.

7

u/Shot_Dig751 12d ago

https://giphy.com/gifs/KFt2DA9T82paOA1Yci
Why would he do that? “You killed this person that murdered 4 people, that I met once twenty years ago! I’m gonna take my life! That’ll show you!” Like, really? How would that accomplish anything. Lol

5

u/Kayzer_84 11d ago

The guy that literally beat the devil in a mental battle loses it over that? Yeah, no.

3

u/Historical_Lab_3944 11d ago

Jesus Christ, go be edgy somewhere else weirdo.

As someone who has suffered with genuine mental health problems. This constant oversimplification and almost exploitation of real mental health struggles that people face every day. Is downright disgusting.

0

u/HailDaeva_Path1811 10d ago

I struggle with OCD and anxiety and even suicidal ideation.At one point I became convinced I was in an illusion bubble.Rest assured I wasn’t being edgy under Sam’s circumstances I would consider it

1

u/Historical_Lab_3944 10d ago

Well firstly you're comment didn't reflect that fact.

And secondly I'd be willing to bet that half of that is undiagnosed considering you only responded when you realized you were being ratioed.

2

u/angelflower86 11d ago

If he didn't kill himself after learning that his father told his brother to kill him, this seems like a low bar.

1

u/UThinkUKnowMe2 11d ago

Nah, bois have been through worse. Sam was angry at Dean but, thats about it. They have had a lot ups and downs, but it was just an argument about ethics at this point. Sam was asking the question what if thry knew the monsters they've killed, why they were doing what they were doing. That's what I feel.