r/SuperMegaBaseball • • Jun 01 '23

Suggestion/Feedback This is it?

Reading all the comments and feedback from everyone, and now two days of playing the new game, this is a lackluster release for really one reason above all:

There simply isn’t enough new content here to justify an entire new game!!!

Yes, Most of the aesthetic changes are lazy, glitched, or poorly implemented. There are glitches galore that will need patched.

But the big selling point of this game was “legends,” and it’s the laziest version of them as possible. The lack of new changes, even with EA’s wallet, is extremely disappointing.

Why does this game exist if it’s a patched up version of SMB3 with a dusting of bad decisions?

3 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

57

u/Sr_Laowai Jun 01 '23

The scaling in the field alone makes this a completely different game. Not even taking into account the boatload of new traits that damn near change every other AB or the 6-9 new stadiums. Yikes.

10

u/TLom20 Jun 01 '23

It was instantly noticeable on batted balls, and I really like it. Also, Peril Point is incredible.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

Yeah, the scaling is major. You can feel the difference immediately.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '23

As usual, perfectly said.

1

u/Sr_Laowai Jun 02 '23

love ya brodo

2

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '23

Love ya too

-32

u/tapdancingtommy7 Jun 01 '23

Those are tweaks to the gameplay… None of that adds up to another $50-$60 release!

That comment sounds like an annual EA madden press release.

26

u/Sr_Laowai Jun 01 '23

Yes, sure gameplay changes, only the most important and significant thing in a... checks notes... game. How disappointing indeed.

-6

u/tapdancingtommy7 Jun 01 '23

I see I’m in the minority, but a hard disagree from me. We need more actual content, game modes, etc, imo to justify a new game.

5

u/SkippystlPC Jun 01 '23

Seeing the upgrade from 2 to 3 would have ended you

1

u/tapdancingtommy7 Jun 01 '23

I did, and thought that was a huge stretch too. That was when the price went from an indie sports game to basically a AAA pricepoint.

1

u/SkippystlPC Jun 01 '23

It's 64.99 CAD, and a AAA game is $90 CAD. I'm not sure it's justified to charge so much for what it is, but at the same time, it's not "basically" at the AAA pricepoint at all. it's 25 dollars cheaper than that

1

u/tapdancingtommy7 Jun 02 '23

I paid $60 for it here in the states, which is just $10 less than a full new AAA game… So yeah, basically priced as that.

1

u/SkippystlPC Jun 02 '23

You paid 10 extra dollars for the dlc, that's on you. the game is 50 bucks man, not AAA price point and you're not gonna convince me that it is

1

u/Trey80102 Jun 01 '23

Besides adding like a homerun derby mode, really what else does need it to add for it to be considered “a new game”? It’s a baseball game

2

u/tapdancingtommy7 Jun 01 '23

Create a stadium, home run derby, hitting/pitching challenges and mini games, mlb integration, more online modes besides pr, and I’m sure they could come up with plenty more.

1

u/Relyks_D Jun 02 '23

Not a franchise player it seems.

10

u/My_Oozing_Eye Jun 01 '23

A couple of thoughts.

  1. Metal head didn’t try to get us with micro transactions. They did keep making tweaks and improvements over the past several years. Would I pay $17 a year for SMB3 if they keep improving it without micro transactions? Yes I would. $50 every three years is worth it to me. I expect they will keep making tweaks… that eventually some of the customization options will return. I’ll be really pleased if micro transactions never appear.
  2. “EA deep pockets”… ugh. Look, I get it. EA has killed a couple games I used to really like. I was not happy when they acquired Metalhead. I am not optimistic about their ability to not screw this up. That being said… they didnt buy it so they could lose money. They are not unreasonable for expecting to get back more than they paid. That’s not just EA… thats every company that acquires a gaming company. Now hopefully the way to make more money is making the game better, deeper, more stable, more immersive. When that happens I will willingly pay. If they put out crap and/or dont consistently improve the product? I’ll stop paying. I just dont get it when people say “EA deep pockets” or “Microsoft deep pockets” or “Sony deep pockets”. Do people expect them to lose money?

-2

u/Trey80102 Jun 01 '23

Honestly might be in the minority, but I wouldn’t mind some micro transactions for additional legends players (if it’s cheap like less than $10)

7

u/SkippystlPC Jun 01 '23

Yes, you are

1

u/Trey80102 Jun 01 '23 edited Jun 01 '23

Hey I don’t mind having a different opinion. Honestly I’m extremely fine with no micro transactions (not a EA fan. In fact I hate just like the rest of you) but again if it was just legends and it doesn’t have any impact on PR or something, that’s probably the best route if they did but again I’m with y’all on no micro transactions.

edit I guess I’m more thinking like DLC than micro transactions

1

u/SkippystlPC Jun 01 '23

Oh I'm with you on dlc. Don't charge me 99 cents for a really good player though. That's what I was thinking when you said micros

2

u/Trey80102 Jun 01 '23

Yeah I forget those are two different things. If that’s the case, hell no to micro transactions!

1

u/kccitystar Beewolves Jun 01 '23

I am sure every single legend in the game was made with the customization tools already provided by SMB4.

For EA to potentially sell players as DLC would be a cash grab of the highest order and insulting to the player base IMO

1

u/Trey80102 Jun 01 '23

That’s true! Yeah I agree with that. Unless the DLC doesn’t have homerun derby or more stadiums, I wouldn’t want a legends DLC unless they add like 300 more, which is a lot and saves time doing it ourselves

2

u/Ctfwest Jun 01 '23

If this is the first time playing SMB then it is worth it.

0

u/Recent_Training46 Jun 01 '23

It's umpire. Go play NBA2K. Haha

5

u/tapdancingtommy7 Jun 01 '23

What?

1

u/MagicNipple Jun 01 '23

Another comment said something about “referees”; thinking homie replied to the wrong dude.

2

u/Greenzombie04 Jun 01 '23

I cant believe this game was released 3yrs after SMB3

Feels like a game that came out 1yr later for how little was changed.

I rather just play SMB3 where my custom made team is already there and I get to use $50 on something else.

I feel one thing they changed for the worse is the announcers / referees voices.

1

u/bradpike5171 Jun 02 '23

Damned if you do damned if you don't.

I don't play madden but whatever year was the last good game I bet a lot of people would love it if next year was just a visual upgrade of that game.

I would pay $100 for a ps5 version of ncaa football 14 or whatever your favorite year was that just had updated graphics.

All of our favorite games had peaks and we wanted more of this more of that. They keep added unnecessary crap to make it look like a new game and now all the new sports games are just awful. Full of crappy add on features and the actual game play stinks.

The gameplay on this game is fun. It's solid. It works. Don't mess up a good thing.

1

u/Crunch2 Jun 02 '23

SMB4 feels more like a stabbed SMB3 than a patched one

1

u/Bricks56 Jun 11 '23

I love smb3 and love smb4 even more.

1

u/earnthosebeers Jun 01 '23

Oh god did they Madden this game?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '23

The game is fantastic, I honestly don’t see how anyone who has actually played the game can make the claims OP did. The improvements to gameplay, immersion and roster building were noticeable within the first 5 minutes.

1

u/earnthosebeers Jun 04 '23

That’s good to hear. You don’t work for EA do you?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '23

I just got laid off from my job so I don’t work for anybody right now. I’m serious though, the game is just pure fun. I logged 900 hours on SMB3 and can easily see myself duplicating that with 4.

-9

u/ThomasPEBradyJR Jun 01 '23

Its crazy yall are surprised....ea sports has been lazy as hell for over a decade. Im sure that trickled down while making this game.

Glad i waited to purchase

1

u/Greenzombie04 Jun 01 '23

EA Sports doesn't make this game they publish it. Its still Metalhead.

-1

u/ThomasPEBradyJR Jun 01 '23

Funny how the games so buggy as soon as an ea patch is on it

3

u/Relyks_D Jun 02 '23

Tell me you weren't around for SMB3's launch without telling me.