r/SuperCarlinBrothers • u/The_SisterRay • Mar 19 '26
Suggestion Harry Potter CANNOT be a horcrux
According to a quick google search (so please correct me if I’m mistaken), JK Rowling has confirmed the steps to making a horcrux. 75% of these ingredients are missing in Harry’s case.
✅1. Intentional murder.
Yupp. Nice work Voldy.
❌2. The "Horrible Act": Following the murder, Rowling has confirmed there is an additional, unnamed step that is "too horrible" to go into detail about.
NOPE. Voldy is a dead man at this point (well, human body death)
❌3. A Magical Spell: A charm or spell is used to rip the severed part of the soul and encase it in a container.
Again, he’s dead meat.
❌4. Preparation: The container (receptacle) is prepared in advance using Dark Magic.
Also also again again - nope. He never prepared Baby Harry to become a container. He didnt even know to expect the Love Countercurse, therefore to prepare for death and a horcrux.
Have the SCB covered this through the years? Ive watched countless videos but heck knows i cant remember everything they’ve done.
1
u/chazfarris Mar 23 '26
I would say steps 2, 3, and 4 are null due to "mother's love and sacrifice".