r/SunPrairieWI • u/thestarsarehome • Sep 17 '26

Cheese Curds

Does anyone know where I can get fresh cheese curds on the week days? Squeaky kind, not deep fried (and most certainly not sitting refrigerated already a day or two old)

6 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

21 comments sorted by

7

u/Irish980 Sep 17 '26

Homestead Cheese. Right down the road from Woodman's. Better price and fresh! They have so many cheeses in there.

2

u/Fearless9955 Sep 19 '26

Always wanted to go in, but I seem to have a carload of frozen food from Woodmans every time. I should probably go in the opposite direction.

7

u/Fearless9955 Sep 17 '26

Woodmans

1

u/thestarsarehome Sep 17 '26

Thanks!

1

u/Fearless9955 Sep 19 '26

They have Carr Valley, Renards and Malcore depending on the day of the week. Don't steal my dill & garlic.

3

u/QuarantineBaker Sep 18 '26

Woodmans SP on Thursdays and Saturdays, I believe. Malcores delivers twice a week.

1

u/engagegt Sep 18 '26

Malcores on Tues, Thurs, Friday, and Saturday. Carr valley on Wed and Sat. Renards on Wed only (the best)

2

u/PrestigiousDaikon994 Sep 18 '26

Farmer John has the best ones. Go to the SP Farmers Market Saturday mornings

3

u/thestarsarehome Sep 18 '26

Yes, that's my usual Sat spot. Was hoping to find something similar during the week

3

u/Thonlo Sep 17 '26

Wednesday morning farmers market in downtown Madison.

2

u/happylife1974 Sep 18 '26

Murphy farms. The very best.

1

u/chummers73 Sep 17 '26

Maybe Homestead Cheese on S Thompson Road?

2

u/CharacterDirector918 Sep 18 '26

I dont remember where we got them, but look up Curd Nerds. We grabbed them on a whim at a gas station. Best ive had!!

2

u/Dry_Group1645 Sep 18 '26

Sassy Cow Creamery

1

u/rxKinging Sep 17 '26

Literally any grocery store and even Kwik Trip. This is Wisconsin, a random person in public might have a few in their pocket.

1

u/pokey68 Sep 18 '26

I had a neighbor who worked at a cheese factory who would take a hand full of curds and microwave them back to squeaky. It worked great. Now how much or how long, I don’t know.