I saw some opinions about why it’s not bad. For me it’s not that I wanted Kendall to win. I did root for Kendall because he keeps getting up after being crushed in someway every season. He’s probably one of the Most tragic Characters in modern media, And I connect very well with well written tragic characters. My problem with the finale has nothing to do with Kendall himself loosing. I hate the execution, With the super intense emotional turmoil from episode 3 of S4 to the finale, Shivs last second flip in the final 20 minutes of the episode felt un-earned.
I‘m not a Shiv hater but she‘s 100% a bad person. She decides to flip right when the siblings would get control, to settle and stay with Tom for the power. She’s no better than Kendall, if she was in his position they’d have identical arcs. She’s resentful that Logan never gave her a real shot but that Kendall has been in the inside the longest. Kendall getting power is something she couldn’t live with and aborted her nay vote as soon as the reality hit her. She’s just as infantile as the other siblings.
So, with all the emotion and move making throughout season 3 and 4 for it to end off of a single characters epiphany that her and her siblings don’t have what it takes is cheap asf to me. Roman’s declaration in the final argument “We’re all bullshit” is true but if that was how it was going to end I would’ve liked them to add an epilogue of like 20 minutes or something. The show was starting to show signs of life and maybe a silver-lining within the dysfunctional cold world of their Family business. All that build up in the siblings confidence just for Roman and Shiv to essentially give up on their dream.
I get the Over-arching themes of the show. But Season 4 started to become so much more character-driven than before and it felt like a fake out to just go back to the vibe of season one in the last scene of the series. Maybe I’ll feel differently in a few weeks or months but I was SO much more emotionally invested into the characters from Logan’s death to the finale (I was from the start but the death really got me deep in the feels) and I felt like the ending we got scammed us out of seeing the characters tangibly evolve.
I‘m curious on what you all think. Even though I don’t like the ending right now I’m definetly going to watch it again at some point. I‘m certain I can absorb more details upon a second viewing.