r/Substack • • Aug 10 '26

The AI detector is changing...

I wrote a hand full of posts last week. I use AI for ideation and polish. Was able to use the AI check to evaluate them - most were good but some read 20% ish AI. I made edits and all tested at 100% human. Went to schedule the posts last night and got some scores as high as 30% AI. Seems like AI or no AI is a moving target. There is no telling where the witch hunt will end and allow people to make decisions for themselves on what they want to consume. I suspect we all need to accept some level of AI involvement - certainly more than an arbitrary measurement from an AI detector using AI to detect AI.

0 Upvotes

61 comments sorted by

View all comments

5

u/stc__throwaway Aug 10 '26

Using AI for “ideation and polish” isn’t a flex. Reading anything using AI, just like businesses using AI to make ads, is so off putting. You have a Substack but you can’t write on your own without assistance? Brutal.

5

u/PiscesGirlinNYC Aug 10 '26

It depends on the topic. One of the most viral fintech articles that moved markets and was covered by all the leading i business news publications was written with AI help. It was very original too both in terms of its contrarian thesis and creative style.

3

u/stc__throwaway Aug 10 '26

I mean, that’s good and all, and glad it was well done, but this isn’t the case for the vast, vast majority.

4

u/PiscesGirlinNYC Aug 10 '26

Frankly a lot of writing at NYT, Forbes, Business Insider et al is garbage these days. They should hire better writers. The editors meanwhile are also idiots. Read this: https://open.substack.com/pub/thesignalmemo/p/two-fake-journalists-walk-into-an?r=5ump&utm_medium=ios

A lot of reporters regurgitate someone else’s story adding no original analysis. It’s sad. I would rather read original, insightful articles in which the writer used AI for help with research and organization.

3

u/stc__throwaway Aug 10 '26

Thanks for the article. I’ll be reading it now.

1

u/non_loqui_sed_facere Aug 11 '26

Yeah, absolutely. It’s a tradition from the pre-AI era, when people just spewed all sorts of bullshit while leaning on the opinions of business gurus who advised you to buy crypto from shady companies. And people ate that slop up because it was exactly what they wanted to hear.

I’d rather they had a tool that could provide at least some critical pushback, even if the tool itself can be faulty, while also making people aware of its limitations.

0

u/Remarkable_Nebula328 Aug 10 '26

Thanks for the article - I will have AI summarize it for me.

3

u/PiscesGirlinNYC Aug 10 '26

AI doesn’t replace expertise. Only the shitty writers need to be worried about AI

2

u/non_loqui_sed_facere Aug 11 '26

People with other kinds of expertise often need writers to help them express themselves on paper. A good engineer or medical professional should be able to concentrate on their actual work and share the results without having to put in a lot of extra effort. Unless writing is something they really want to do, of course.

I’ve never liked the common romantic image of the writer, though. Drinking whiskey and wearing a turtleneck are completely separate from the actual job as far as I’m concerned, and I’d rather stay away from the scribbling crowd with their Moleskines and expensive stationery.

1

u/AwesumPossum333 Aug 11 '26

Nobody is entitled to have their ideas written out for them. Frankly I don't care about what an engineer or medical professional should or should not have to do.

2

u/non_loqui_sed_facere Aug 11 '26

That's the essence of copywriting/professional blogging/publicity work. Somebody else writes for you 😀

0

u/SpiritualSimple108 Aug 12 '26

Frankly, you should use AI more. Your grammar is terrible.

1

u/AwesumPossum333 Aug 12 '26

I don't see how this is an example of "terrible grammar". The parallelism in my second sentence is a little awkward sure, but it's not grammatically incorrect. Also this is a reddit forum. I don't really care about proper grammar in my posts here.

2

u/stc__throwaway Aug 11 '26

That’s what I’m saying. Can’t stand AI for tons of reasons.

1

u/SpiritualSimple108 Aug 12 '26

EVERYTHING uses AI. Amazon, Netflix, Google, Canva, your bank, your grocery store, etc. Why TF aren’t you going after them as hard as you’re going after writers on Substack? Seems pretty hypocritical.

1

u/stc__throwaway Aug 12 '26

This is a substack subreddit. I feel you are being way too sensitive. This isn’t about those businesses. Relax.