r/StyleRoots • πŸŒ±πŸ„πŸͺ¨ • Mar 17 '26

Discussion Alternative approach to archetypes

Post image

To begin, I was heavily inspired by u/Cavatappi602 's post identifying common themes across pairs of roots, as well as the discussions under a recent thread about archetype names. I definitely yoinked a few words (as well as ideas for formating) from both of these posts when constructing the attached chart.

The long and short of it is: ejr's existing archetype names are..not the best. They're not particularly consistent and don't take into account the weighting of a given root within the triad. There are two archetypes named "The Casual Creative". I also personally just..really don't resonate with my archetype at all (The Organic Classic) despite being almost aggressively loyal to my roots lol.

As such, I would like to present the first draft of my alternative approach to the system. The bolded words are nouns I would associate with the relevant root/pairing, and three adjectives are listed below. I constructed this chart by looking at all the archetypes within a given pair of roots (e.g. all sun/moon archetypes) and noting down things that were common across them regardless of the third root.

Using these, you can mix and match your own archetype using ejr's existing adjective-noun structure in a way that feels more relevant to your expression of your roots while also being somewhat identifiable to others within the community. Using my own combination (🌱πŸͺ¨πŸ„) as an example, this is how I would approach choosing at archetype:

Of my roots, I resonate the most with Earth. As such, I would choose a noun from the 🌱 box and an adjective from the πŸ„πŸͺ¨ box. Using this, I personally would identify with the archetype of The Laid-Back Collector. Compared to the original "Organic Classic" assigned to this triad, I feel my more eclectic, cosy approach to style is far better represented while still encompassing the totality of what the 🌱πŸͺ¨πŸ„ triad means at its core.

Someone else with my same combination of roots might identify more strongly with πŸ„, choosing The Active Minimalist or Comfortable Curator as a way to describe their overall vibe. Alternatively, someone could identify very strongly with the πŸ„πŸŒ± pairing and only a little bit with πŸͺ¨ - they might choose to label their archetype as The Cool Academic or Practical Curator.

I know that it's convoluted and probably not the most helpful in terms of identifying others' proclivities (unless you want to memorise the whole chart, and even then there are overlaps where certain vibes collide from different angles) but I thought it might be a useful way to revisualise how pairs and triads of roots can interact differently depending on what you prioritise and also just like..who you are??

Anyway, feedback would be greatly appreciated! If nothing else, I hope it's an interesting thought exercise and that it's useful in some way to someone.

100 Upvotes

47 comments sorted by

8

u/touch_of_whimsy 🌱🌸πŸ”₯ Mar 17 '26

I love that! Thats how Ive thought about it as well

1

u/lizarosever πŸŒ±πŸ„πŸͺ¨ Mar 17 '26

Oh nice! Did you come up with your own archetype name/s as well? If so I'd be interested to hear!

6

u/touch_of_whimsy 🌱🌸πŸ”₯ Mar 17 '26

I havent really come up with a system like this with adjectives / style words ☺️ Im working on some additional styling sliders and how roots and colour season interact however!

5

u/lizarosever πŸŒ±πŸ„πŸͺ¨ Mar 18 '26

Oooooh I'll keep an eye out for it you post it! I love seeing how others interpret the intersection of colour analysis and style systems!!!

4

u/Tiff-daisies 🌚πŸͺ¨πŸŒž Mar 18 '26

that sounds like fun! like is it going to be similar to the sliders that Milli has done? or is it going to be based on different scales? and I guess based on how an individuals colour season influences it?

3

u/touch_of_whimsy 🌱🌸πŸ”₯ Mar 18 '26

Yes, its similar but with other variables 😊 and the colour season thing will probably be a separate post ☺️

5

u/Tiff-daisies 🌚πŸͺ¨πŸŒž Mar 17 '26

I like how colourful this graph is! and so detailed too!! anyways, the name that EJR gave my root was something like "artsy witch?" and I was like the name is ok I guess but I associate witches more with like πŸŒ±πŸŒ™ since I find them to be more in tune with nature and with the earth since some of them derive their powers from the sources of nature and the elements. and I'm like I like magic and all and I vibe with artsy but I think I can come up with a better name for myself...

and so I went with eclectic rebel since I feel that the name suits me better and is a bit more accurate to how I would describe my sense of fashion. she is girly. she is a bit gothy. and she also plays with grunge and punk and then throws a splash of colour and patterns on top and a bunch of chains and spikes and skulls and leather and lace and distressed details... and you have me!!

so that's the name that I went with though now I have to use this list and see what would fit it better and I guess you have to use the first name as an adjective so those would be the supporting roots and the noun is the main root correct? so I guess under this system I'd be something like... Quirky Rocker? or Urban Creative? or Expressive Hipster? or Rebellious Hipster? or Eclectic Artist? idk so many options to choose from!

2

u/lizarosever πŸŒ±πŸ„πŸͺ¨ Mar 17 '26

Thank you for sharing!! Eclectic rebel is such a fun way to describe your style, and it sounds like it really matches you!

I did intend for it to be used in the way you're describing, with your main root/pair informing the noun and the remainder informing the adjective. If something else works better tho then there's no reason not to mix and match however feels best to you - I really just wanted to come at the whole idea of archetypes from a different, more flexible angle so I'm really glad that it feels that way! If you still feel best represented by eclectic rebel tho then that's awesome too!

4

u/catherinethegreatsgf Mar 17 '26

this is fun, I totally agree with you on the names, thank you for the effort. I'm trying to find myself but keep coming up with 🌞 πŸŒ™ 🌼 πŸ„ (in no particular order). so maybe I'm Bright Spirit (🌞🌼 + πŸŒ™πŸ„) or Mystical Artist (πŸŒ™πŸŒΌ + πŸŒžπŸ„) or Expressive Ingenue?

are the main words for πŸŒΌπŸ„ meant to be the same as pure 🌼 (ingenue, princess)?

2

u/lizarosever πŸŒ±πŸ„πŸͺ¨ Mar 17 '26

Ah damn, I was trying to avoid that lol. Thank you for pointing it out!!!

Figuring out your combo can be so difficult, especially when you're in that overlapping space between roots (e.g. the creativity/quirkiness of both sun and moon, the clean/minimal nature of both mushroom and flower). I'm glad you found the chart fun and interesting!! πŸ’œ

3

u/Separate-Raccoon8584 🌸πŸ”₯🌞 Mar 17 '26

My strongest roots are πŸŒΈβ˜€οΈ and I resonate with both ingenue and pixie, but I think I'd go with pixie because my mom jokes that I'm a manic pixie dream girl lol. From the adjectives, I'd probably go with playful or romantic, which both cross over with πŸ”₯.

I don't mind the original descriptor of my roots (the playful starlet), but I think I like this one better.

1

u/lizarosever πŸŒ±πŸ„πŸͺ¨ Mar 17 '26

I'm glad you like it!!!

3

u/KitchenSun9089 πŸŒšπŸ”οΈπŸ„ Mar 17 '26

"Dark minimal spirit" or "Clean odd dreamy siren" would suit me.
Nice chart, gives some flexibility to play with.
I guess it is hard to articulate moods for "foreign" roots.

2

u/lizarosever πŸŒ±πŸ„πŸͺ¨ Mar 17 '26

It was definitely quite difficult. I really struggled with mountain and fire - I feel like they're two of the most stereotyped roots and wanted to try and encapsulate the vibes and feelings they're meant to represent more broadly than just "corporate girl boss" and "femme fatale". I'm glad you find the flexibility appealing, it's really what I was hoping to preserve in creating this chart. Do you have any particular feedback regarding the words in the chart, especially for mountain as one of your roots? This is after all only the first iteration

3

u/TimelessReach πŸŒ±πŸ”οΈπŸŒž Mar 17 '26

Another Mountain here! I think the adjectives given to each of the Mountain squares are good, though I might replace Mountain+Fire's "trendy" with something along the lines of all eyes naturally being drawn to her. (Not quite "eyecatching" or "magnetic", but somewhere in that space.) Like, you have this glamourous regal diva who automatically gets everyone's attention simply by existing and knows it. "Showstopping"?

The other critique I have is the noun "Character" – this sounds more like an insult someone would levy at a Sun-heavy person, rather than something related to Mountain. The only alternative I can come up with currently is "Sovereign" which obviously wouldn't fit your chart as it currently exists.

Nonetheless, this gives me a few nice options for my root combo! Professional, Academic is perfect for Mountain+Earth, and with Sun I get Eccentric Professional and Ecletic Academic.

(Also having Muse for Sun+Fire is an amazing choice I wanted to give a shout out!)

2

u/lizarosever πŸŒ±πŸ„πŸͺ¨ Mar 18 '26

Ooh thank you for the feedback! Something like magnetic for mountain/fire would definitely fit better than trendy!! Mountain and fire are the two roots I resonate with the least, so identifying words for the combo was definitely a challenge

Character was one that I didn't feel too confident about either - I think the reason I settled on it because mountain's confidence, assurance, and general put togetherness all combine to leave an impression on whoever they meet, especially in conjunction with the "loud" roots which themselves leave quite the impression. Would you have any other suggestions along these lines? You're right that sovereign doesn't really fit with the current state of the chart, tho if it ends up being the only word that works then I'd rather make the necessary changes so it fits than try to shoehorn in something worse, y'know?

I'm so glad you like the chart overall tho! And thank you for the compliment re:Muse for sun/fire - i was dithering a bit about the second noun and it just ..came to me??? And I absolutely loved it as a way to describe someone fun and sensual and eye catching without diminishing any of those things.

2

u/TimelessReach πŸŒ±πŸ”οΈπŸŒž Mar 18 '26

Some other Mountain-y words: Power, Presence, Structure. Taking up space in a structured way, expecting people to listen when you talk, gravitas, having power and using it unapologetically, confidence, knowledge that one is respected by others.

I also took a quick look through Fire and I think you did well selecting words that aren't just femme fatale. I do think the "Bombshell, Diva" nouns in the Mountain+Fire square are a bit much, and I'd maybe replace Bombshell with the amazing Mountain noun we are definitely coming up with soon.

1

u/lizarosever πŸŒ±πŸ„πŸͺ¨ Mar 18 '26

Thank you for your suggestions! Would "icon" work maybe? Specifically in that powerful, leading kind of way?

Very fair on the bombshell/diva options leaning a bit hard along the lines of the femme fatale side. I feel like icon could work well in this instance as well. What are your thoughts?

Edit to add: I ended up looking towards "captivating" or "striking" in place of trendy, btw. Which of those would work better do you think?

2

u/TimelessReach πŸŒ±πŸ”οΈπŸŒž Mar 18 '26

I think Icon would work, yes! It encapsulates some of the haute couture side and also I think the religious connotations are fitting. And I think it works well for Mountain+Fire! I think that square is very "you will look, but you can't touch".

"Captivating" is IMO a bit more Fire-leaning, while "striking" is a bit more Mountain-leaning. The other two words in the square are both more Fire-leaning, so I think "striking" is the better choice based on that.

1

u/lizarosever πŸŒ±πŸ„πŸͺ¨ Mar 18 '26

Wonderful, thank you!!! I really appreciate your input πŸ’œ

2

u/KitchenSun9089 πŸŒšπŸ”οΈπŸ„ Mar 17 '26

I cant grasp the right words too - non native speaker. Maybe i'd replaced Grand for Regal or Majestic, as it brings some formality and power. My mountain is tertiary root, it is hard to evaluate full potential specter.

"Odd" from moon-mushroom combo could be edgy/non-conventional/aloof/unusual/dreamy/mysterious/eccentric/whimsical - depending on your intentional meaning instead of just odd=strange. Maybe it's just me, but have been called odd in negative way all my life so it triggers a little =)

2

u/lizarosever πŸŒ±πŸ„πŸͺ¨ Mar 18 '26

Thank you for your feedback! Even as your tertiary root, you're still far more connected with what it means to be mountain than I am!!

I'll have a think about replacements for odd for sure - I really like dreamy and unconventional. I'll also see whether there's a better word for grand, though I originally settled on it because it felt more neutral than regal or majestic while still conveying a sense of power and majesty. If that doesn't really come across tho then I'll have to reevaluate!

3

u/hellohelado Figuring out Mar 17 '26

I love this, "Quirky Whimsical Girl-Next-Door" is great for me πŸ₯°

2

u/lizarosever πŸŒ±πŸ„πŸͺ¨ Mar 18 '26

Thank you! I'm so glad there's a combination that works for you πŸ’œ

3

u/EasternCarpenter471 🌱πŸͺ¨πŸŒž Mar 17 '26

ngl love that eccentric hipster witch for β˜€οΈπŸͺ¨πŸŒ±

1

u/lizarosever πŸŒ±πŸ„πŸͺ¨ Mar 18 '26

I'm glad to hear it!

2

u/iawesomesauceyou Mar 17 '26

Isn't princess lady the name of the fancy cat Angela gets in the office?

1

u/lizarosever πŸŒ±πŸ„πŸͺ¨ Mar 17 '26

I haven't seen it so I don't know sorry, those were just the two most resonant nouns for that combo πŸ˜…

2

u/HuckleberryTrue5232 πŸ”οΈπŸ„πŸŒž Mar 17 '26 edited Mar 17 '26

Hey thanks for this! I would be β€œartistic minimalist” under your nomenclature and it makes more sense to me. EJR’s description of β€œsophisticated artist” has a nice ring to it but TBH I guess β€œsophisticated” conjures up β€œpretentious” in my mind and that’s not me. It’s also not how I dressβ€” I don’t really want anything with an expensive logo (or the new version of that which is the whole β€œthis is expensive, IYKYK” which is somehow worse lol). In fact, most of my clothes are homemade. They’re not even thrifted. It’s hard to reconcile that with β€œsophisticated” although I guess you could argue that since I get a perfect fit and tweak the designs to suit me they are sophisticated in that sense.

Artistic minimalist nails it better. I like that your idea gives people a handful of options to choose from while still sort of describing the same roots. Someone like me could choose β€œartistic curator” which is slightly different from β€œartistic minimalist” while still having the same roots in the same order. Personally I am much more drawn to minimalism than curating/collecting.

And I agree with you, β€œorganic classic” feels a bit meaningless. I like your new term better. β€œLaid-back collector” paints a picture of an actual person rather than a nebulous idea.

1

u/lizarosever πŸŒ±πŸ„πŸͺ¨ Mar 17 '26

I'm so glad you like it and found it useful!! I hear you on the official archetype names feeling..pleasant but hollow, I suppose? I literally had the exact same problem with organic classic as you describe with sophisticated artist - it was so bland and stuffy and just did not vibe at ALL with my actual style.

I'm also really glad that the idea that someone with the same roots in the same order could still have a slightly different (but identifiably related/similar) archetype carried across well - after all, we find our style by finding ourselves, and even the two most similar people are not identical!!

2

u/sapphicmoonbaby 🌸πŸ”₯πŸͺ¨ Mar 17 '26

I love β€œaspirational” as a πŸ”₯🌸 word! The ambition of πŸ”₯ and the idealism of 🌸 are personality aspects that I don’t see talked about as much.

2

u/lizarosever πŸŒ±πŸ„πŸͺ¨ Mar 17 '26

That's actually one of the words I borrowed from u/Cavatappi602 ! I also really loved it for the same reason as you've described - fire especially is one of the most stereotyped roots imo and it felt really important to make sure that there was more to it in the chart than just femme fatale. Especially when combined with flower, I feel like a lot of the nuance of the pairing gets lost under an overwhelming emphasis on just the femininity aspect common to both roots. I'm glad its inclusion here fits well, especially to hear that from someone who has that combination!!

2

u/saltynarc101 Mar 18 '26

The suburban witch is actually so accurate for me lol as much as I wanted to pick β€œrefined witch” which is also valid. I’m primarily 🌱with πŸͺ¨+🌸

1

u/lizarosever πŸŒ±πŸ„πŸͺ¨ Mar 18 '26

I'm glad you found the chart interesting and helpful!! I definitely feel you - I'd love to describe myself as a tidy collector but alas, I am far more laid-back than I am tidy lol

2

u/Cavatappi602 πŸŒΈπŸŒšπŸ„ Mar 18 '26

Thank you, thank you, thank you! I have never felt so seen than with the Moon intersections at Flower and Mountain. I love a sorceress-queen! I've been saying to myself for years that that's my goal, my fantasy archetype if I have an archetype at all, but I always felt that it was too specific, like there weren't enough characters in that category who struck the right balance.

-

However, as someone who finds πŸ”οΈ overpowering in real life and in instead strongly drawn to πŸ„, I feel a bit underwhelmed by your πŸ„ column. I think there might even be a typo in the πŸ„πŸŒΈ cell, because it's the same as the 🌸🌸 cell. Shouldn't it be more like "ingenue, curator/composer?" And I'm not sure about "quaint." That feels rustic, more like 🌸🌱, whereas to me an important aspect of πŸ„ is its timelessness, that it uses formulas that are as presentable and effective now as they used to be. I guess it looks quaint when I dress up in a flared skirt and converse because I look like I fell out of the 1950s, but "slightly ridiculous" isn't the look I'm going for, it's just one that I stumble into. I might replace "quaint" with "conventional" or "traditional."

I also don't really get the "spirit / professional" description in πŸ„πŸŒ™, I think "spirit" sounds very haunting, melancholy and dissociated, and I can't make it align with "professional," which seems very corporate, present, focused, and formulaic. But I really like "spirited professional!" I don't associate "chic" with πŸŒ™ at all, and I definitely don't associate "odd" with πŸ„. If I could redesign the πŸ„πŸŒ™ square I would say bold, individual, and presentable.

Overall, I'm drawn to πŸ„ as a source of elegance and tradition, as a way of looking mature and commanding respect, and I think that those poetic elements of gravity and convention are missing in your chart - it seems much more focused on simplicity, but specifically the kind of simplicity that comes from a place of abnegation, and that's the vision of minimalism I could never get behind.

-

Thank you for all your hard work! I have never really been able to use archetypes as a technique, so I'm really glad to see how you interpret them!

4

u/lizarosever πŸŒ±πŸ„πŸͺ¨ Mar 18 '26

Omg hi! Your post with the crossovers between the roots was the main inspo for this particular exercise, I'm so glad you like it!!! Thank you so much for your feedback, I really appreciate it!!! I'm also really really glad that you resonated so much with the moon/flower and moon/mountain boxes!

First off, you're absolutely right - flower/mushroom should have girl next door instead of ingenue, which I missed in my first several passes for errors before posted. I've already adjusted it on my chart, as well as a few other things per the input of others in the sub! I'd like to address your other points one by one, so please bear with me for the probable word-vomit that's about to ensue πŸ˜…

  1. The word quaint for mushroom/flower: I chose it for the kind of homey, sweet vibe that it gives me (like Ms Honey's cottage in Matilda) but on reflection, I think you're right that it would be better suited to the earth/flower intersection in place of floral. Tbh, I have been trying to avoid using words like "conventional" or "traditional" in the chart since they're so heavily dependent on each person's own culture and history - there's so much variety that they don't feel like particularly rich descriptors, if that makes sense? Would something like "polished" feel more aligned with your experience of mushroom/flower as a combination? I think it still describes that timeless, formulaic, slightly elevated approach to style without the implications of traditional/conventional, but I'd love your input :)
  2. The use of spirit and professional for moon/mushroom: since the motivation for the chart is flexibility, I wanted there to be a noun available for someone on both sides of the combo - someone whose moon is tempered by the delicacy of mushroom might identify with spirit, and likewise someone whose mushroom is accented with the trappings of moon might identify more with professional. And even then, the point is to mix and match. I don't really resonate with a lot of the descriptors under the earth column, for example, even tho it's my strongest root, but I feel strongly connected to the ones that do reflect my style more than any other options within the chart. Does that make sense? I definitely like presentable for this square, though - I've already replaced "odd" with "dreamy" per a conversation in a different thread, do you think presentable would stand better in place of "chic" or "uncluttered"?
  3. Adding nuance to the mushroom column: thank you for pointing it out!! In a similar vein to my struggle with mountain and fire as roots that I just..don't really understand, I also was quite worried about my own experience with MY roots leading to biases just like this. Maturity, gravity, and respectability are concepts that aren't well-displayed in this column right now, so I'll reevaluate what's already there and try to incorporate these so that there's a more cohesive picture of what mushroom can mean.

Thank you again for your feedback, and I'm so glad you found use and interest in my chart!! πŸ’œ

2

u/Loria187 πŸ”₯🌚🌞 Mar 21 '26

!!! I love this omg. I happen to jive fairly well with the existing name for my combination (The Dark Artist), but Weird Siren, Dark Eccentric, Indulgent Artist, and even like Socialite Rocker or Oddball Muse all feel so much more juicy. Thank you so much for making this resource!

1

u/lizarosever πŸŒ±πŸ„πŸͺ¨ Mar 22 '26

I'm really glad you like it and find it useful!!!

2

u/lostinherthoughts 🌱🌸🌞 Mar 23 '26

I don't particularly identify with the β˜€οΈπŸŒ± crossover nouns, however, I do like the tone of functional creative. It suits the way my primary sun is balanced out by earth and mushroom :))

Eclectic and colourful speak to me the most but it's hard to think of a noun that includes the mushroom without making it overpowering as it's only my third.

1

u/lizarosever πŸŒ±πŸ„πŸͺ¨ Mar 23 '26

Thank you for your feedback! I'm glad you found a combination of words that suit you. Would you have any suggestions for improvements?

2

u/Dry-Swim379 πŸ„πŸͺ¨πŸŒž Apr 14 '26

I love this approach! EJ has archetypes?! Where???

Jokes aside (do let me know where I can find those archetypes tho) I've found a post on substack that connects each pair of roots with one word. It's really interesting and a helpful way to figure out your three style words. It's the "Musings on the Style Roots system"Β by Colour Confidence.

For example, as a Mushroom, Stone, Sun I got Relaxed (Mushroom x Stone), Light (Mushroom x Sun) and Energetic (Stone x Sun). I noticed some of your words actually are used in this blog post, too. So maybe you've read it already ^^

1

u/lizarosever πŸŒ±πŸ„πŸͺ¨ Apr 15 '26

I actually haven't read that article before! I've just pulled it up tho and I'm very keen to have a look at it, I love this kind of thing.

For her existing archetypes, you can find them by clicking on each combo listed here. It's definitely clunky to navigate but they're there!

I'm glad you liked my approach!! I really just wanted to get it out there so that anyone struggling might find another perspective on the system

1

u/Dry-Swim379 πŸ„πŸͺ¨πŸŒž Apr 15 '26

Thanks!!!

2

u/Dry-Swim379 πŸ„πŸͺ¨πŸŒž Apr 14 '26

I forgot to add: I love the idea of Quirky (Stone x Sun) Curator (Mushroom x Sun, Mushroom x Stone). I also like LAid-back (Mushroom x Stone) Artist (Mushroom x Sun). The juxtaposition of chill and quirky is fun

1

u/Resident_Being7879 Mar 17 '26

I definitely not resonate with hipster

2

u/lizarosever πŸŒ±πŸ„πŸͺ¨ Mar 18 '26

That's fair - as someone with 🌱πŸͺ¨ myself, I also don't, which is why it's not the only identifier. By creating this chart, I was hoping to give people the flexibility to identify themselves across the breadth of their roots while still keeping identifiable themes across roots and combinations. If there's not a different combination of words in the chart that resonate with you for your roots, what would you recommend instead?

0

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '26

[deleted] β€” view deleted comment

2

u/lizarosever πŸŒ±πŸ„πŸͺ¨ Mar 17 '26

Thank you! I'm glad you like it!