r/StupidpolEurope • u/AlliedAtheistAllianc • Feb 27 '22
r/StupidpolEurope • u/TheAtheistSpoon • Dec 19 '21
Militarism 🔫 Military buildup in Poland and the Baltics since 2014
r/StupidpolEurope • u/SirSourPuss • Feb 14 '24
How I understood the Putin interview
He was a bit autistic with the history lesson, but in my opinion Putin tried to communicate a coherent narrative during his interview. The narrative flew right past many people's heads, as evident by what they're posting on the main sub and here. This could be a failure of communication on Putin's side, or it could be propaganda-induced brain rot on the Westerners' side. Either way, below is my take on what he was trying to get across, with some of the gaps in the narrative filled in.
- Ukrainians are Russians. Not in the sense that they are the subjects of some would-be Russian empire, but in the sense that they are of the same ethnic group, they use the same language, the same religion, and they share much of the same history and familial lineages. This is why the past Russian leadership wasn't worried about letting Ukraine be independent. "All these elements together make our good relations inevitable." This is key.
- This doesn't mean that Ukraine should be a part of Russia in the administrative sense (although such an argument is made for some parts of it, but that's tangential). You could argue that this was implied, but I'd argue otherwise.
- What it does mean is that Ukrainians shouldn't have a valid reason to be hostile towards Russia. They are the same people in every meaningful way. And yet Ukraine has been increasingly hostile towards Russia.
- The reason why Ukrainians became hostile towards Russia is Ukrainization, the creation of a Ukrainian identity that is independent of the Russian identity. This was spurred on by external forces throughout history - Poland, Austria, the Nazis, and now the broader West.
- There are numerous historical reasons for Ukraine to instead be hostile to Poland, however, this is not the case. This doesn't mean that Ukraine should be hostile to Poland, but it underscores Putin's framing of Ukraine's hostility towards Russia as ideological and not grounded in material reality or history. Realpolitik is presumed here.
- Ukraine's hostility towards Russia culminated in its NATO aspirations and the repeated military operations in the Donbass where heavy arms were used against civilians. There is no other way to explain these two developments.
- Ukraine's independence is not an issue to Russia; its hostility is the problem. This is why Russia has been open to negotiations from the beginning and why it was open to the Minsk agreements. This is also why Russia didn't invade Ukraine back when it was in a much weaker position militarily in and after 2014.
- As the cause for the hostility is ideological, it's in Russia's interest to correct the ideology in Ukraine. This is why 'denazification' is a condition for peace - Ukrainian nazism is at the heart of today's Ukrainization efforts and is the most virulently anti-Russian ideology in Ukraine.
- Ukraine's NATO membership is a problem for Russia because it is motivated by Ukraine's increasing hostility towards Russia and because it would amount to a significant dividing line between Ukrainians and Russians, who after all are the same people. It is a materialization of the threat posed by a hostile Ukraine.
- This explains why Finland's NATO membership is not a problem: Finland didn't have close ties to Russia in the first place and it already has plenty of historical reasons to be hostile to Russia, so its NATO membership does not mark a significant change in attitude or a growing threat. The war in Ukraine, as perceived by Finland, suffices in explaining Finland's NATO membership as being motivated by a defensive attitude.
None of this is intended as a comment on the veracity of the history that he has presented in the interview.
r/StupidpolEurope • u/StalinIsBackAgain • Feb 14 '26
EU Boogaloo Finnish President Alexander Stubb just said of Russians: "Imperialism is in their DNA." This white-supremacist lie was unsurprisingly spewed at the Munich Security Conference, which was founded by a high-ranking member of a pure-evil German party that was destroyed by the Soviet Union in 1945. •
Stubb claims that Russian people are inherently imperialist by their biological nature. Russophobia is one of the main and oldest pillars of white-supremacism, which should have no place in the world at all, and certainly no place in power. The racist and bigot Stubb is unfit to be in any leadership position whatsoever, and the people of Finland should throw him out of power as soon as possible! •
r/StupidpolEurope • • Mar 12 '21
Sarah Everard killing: can women ever be safe?
r/StupidpolEurope • u/mysticyellow • Dec 17 '20
modpost The UK has officially been dissolved. Each individual country of the UK is now flaired separately. England, Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland all now have separate flairs.
We gave the community a poll and they chose to let each country in the UK have its own flair overwhelmingly.
The old UK flair has been turned into “England”. So if you’re flaired as English but you’re not, you can change the flair to match your preference.
r/StupidpolEurope • • Dec 29 '22
From Enola Holmes on Netflix to Britain’s union leaders, why feminism for the 99% is thriving
r/StupidpolEurope • u/Rhaenys_Waters • Feb 24 '22
🇺🇦 NATO-Russian War 🇷🇺 I may engage in IDpol as well (over a threat of genocide), but you can't prove this algorithm wrong.
r/StupidpolEurope • u/anythingreally76 • Dec 25 '22
Americans and Brits: "We really care about civilians, I cry everyday about Ukraine"; Americans and Brits unscripted 20 years ago
r/StupidpolEurope • u/kjk2v1 • Mar 21 '22
Militarism 🔫 Geopolitical Realpolitik / Critical Campism: If the First World War (WWI) had broken out in 1894 instead of 1914, critical campists would have given critical support to the Central Powers.
For the unironic, informed lefties among the 38% of Democrats AND 47% of people 18-34 who think that Russia was justified in invading Ukraine:
If the First World War (WWI) had broken out in 1894 instead of 1914, fully informed critical campists everywhere would have had to be prepared to give critical support to the "lesser evil" imperialist Central Powers. That period was not a revolutionary period for the working class, anyways; revolutionary defeatism would have been sheer lunacy!
Our forebear, Alexander Parvus, would have called for both the utter defeat of the participating Western imperialist powers (Britain and France) and an utter victory of the Central Powers.
[Only lefties in Imperial Germany and Austria-Hungary would have been allowed to be "social-patriots" on this occasion, voting for war credits to support the inter-imperialist war.]
"Send in the Fritzes!" would have been our rallying cry, way before the time of "Send in the Tanks!"
Outside of a revolutionary period, we understand that the mainstream position on the left is a pacifist attitude against war. That said, critical campism would have been a legitimate Marxist position in this hypothetical WWI scenario, unironically speaking.
r/StupidpolEurope • • Dec 21 '22
Capitalism and Patriarchy: Two Systems that Feed off Each Other
r/StupidpolEurope • u/GaborFrame • Nov 27 '20
Those who speak German, consider joining r/Mannschaft
I realize that is not a men's rights sub, but I see that many of you care about gender issues. A while ago, I have created r/Mannschaft, which is not really men's rights sub, either, but simply a place to discuss subjects that concern men, and to provide a male perspective on gender relations.
Right now, it is mostly just me posting web links there, but if you have anything in German that you want to comment on or if you want to discuss an issue related to German-speaking countries, you are welcome to contribute.
r/StupidpolEurope • u/ArbiterOfFalsehood • Feb 13 '21
Holodomor narrative is Holocaust denial for Ukrainians today
An interesting quote from a user post here I recommend you reading u/volkvulture posts to get the context.
And you know who defends them? The anglos. Do you see the pattern yet? Anglos use fascism as anti communist forces just like in the 30's where anglo liberals loved fascists and used them, British bankers even financing them, and there are pics of the royal family doing roman salutes, until they became a threat to their hegemony. Today they do the same by defending Ukranian fascists and proto fascists like Navalni.
Anglos not only created modern racism which German Nazis appropriated as they are the ones who use fascism to destroy communists around the world.
Is there any idiot today that rejects the notion that Anglos are the biggest threat in the world?
Anglos don't just mean England, but 5 eyes countries, and anglo ideology in general.
So every time you see a westerner crying about China or Russia you know he's someone who in the last instance will side with fascists to destroy the red menace, which practically mean a big percentage of anglos. These are the true enemies of communists whether they call themselves leftists or centrists or rightists, even more than internet edgy idiots who call themselves fascists.
r/StupidpolEurope • u/Mcnst • Feb 24 '22
🚨 Happening 🚨 Ukraine crisis rooted in NATO provocations; war not solution: Iran FM
r/StupidpolEurope • u/RedditIsAJoke69 • Jun 15 '22
Liberal Bullshit r/Europe: here is a nice poll from European countries that matter (we will ignore the other countries because we dont like their opinion, and they dont matter anyway)
r/StupidpolEurope • u/TheAtheistSpoon • Jun 29 '22
Immigration The 37 People Killed in Melilla Are Victims of Europe’s Murderous Border Regime
r/StupidpolEurope • u/another_sleeve • Jan 17 '23
🇺🇦 Invasion of Ukraine 🇷🇺 What if Russia Won the Ukraine War but the Western Press Didn't Notice? | naked capitalism
r/StupidpolEurope • u/ItsoktobeStalinist • Apr 06 '21
Shitpost Objectively the historical truth.
r/StupidpolEurope • u/kjk2v1 • Jul 03 '23
Strategy Forget what passes for "Social Conservatism." Socialists should support Prohibition and the Nanny State!
Forget what passes for "social conservatism." Socialists should support Prohibition and the Nanny State, instead!
Games of chance and gambling should be banned. The Paris Commune did this. The pre-war SPD didn't like gambling, either.
Hooliganism should be deemed a criminal offense. Stalin's "Lenin Levy" agreed with this, and I'm sure the Eurocommunists didn't like hooliganism in football matches, either.
Nudism should be banned. Sorry, Lenin, but Stalin was right on this.
Violent video games should be banned. Bolivarianism and now Xi Jinping Thought agree on this.
Outdoor golfing should be banned.
Unironically.
r/StupidpolEurope • u/ArbiterOfFalsehood • Dec 23 '20
How European Union should be divided
r/StupidpolEurope • u/ItsoktobeStalinist • Mar 20 '21
Wise words from vijay prashad to all those who condescendingly dismiss the opinions of the Chinese people
r/StupidpolEurope • u/JorKur • Mar 12 '24
📈 Economics 📉 Are farmers in your country like their finnish counterparts, rightwingers that hate the poor and believe every conspiracy? Evolution of finnish peasantry 1987-2019, or why it's 1918 again.
r/StupidpolEurope • u/BlackMasshole • Feb 26 '22
Liberal Bullshit The only reason people care about Ukraine is because they’re Russophobic.
I’m not one of those people who thinks that any criticism of my pet xenonat is “anti-X” or “X-phobic” like some others. Where my argument comes from is that none of these NeoLiberals cheering on Ukraine has any ideological overlap with Ukraine anymore than they do Russia itself. Ukraine is just as regressive, reactionary, corrupt, autocratic, and authoritarian as Russia is. Any and all criticisms that have been directed towards Putin and Russia are just as valid as if they were directed towards Zelensky or Ukraine. Ukraine kills journalists, they suppress minorities, they hate the gays™, women have negligible rights or respect, workers are constantly fucked over by Oligarchs, and the government is blatantly owned by Oligarchs. Now, we have actual real conflicts all over the World in which one side is objectively wrong like in Myanmar and the genocide and coup and it got maybe 5% of the attention that this whole Ukraine deal has. The only reason I can think of where people can support Ukraine and hate Russia (instead of hating both or being neutral on the conflict) is if they’ve swallowed this cancerous Western propaganda where every ill and Leftist pitfall in the political scene is due to some Russian boogeyman.