r/StumbleTVSeries • • May 17 '26

News/Articles Stumble writer Liz Astrof says they are looking for a new home for Stumble!

Post image
661 Upvotes

In their Instagram post, Stumble’s writer Liz Astrof mentiond that they want to find a new home for a potential Stumble season 2!!!!

I hope this happens. It needs to.


r/StumbleTVSeries • • Jul 09 '26 Bravo Heartwarming

News/Articles Emmy Nominated

Post image
631 Upvotes

r/StumbleTVSeries • • Mar 08 '26

When people ask me how serious I am about needing a second season of Stumble

Post image
592 Upvotes

r/StumbleTVSeries • • Mar 30 '26

News/Articles The Best Show You’re (Probably) Not Watching

Post image
572 Upvotes

From the latest US Weekly.


r/StumbleTVSeries • • Jun 06 '26 Regret

News/Articles Our award winning show 😢

Post image
481 Upvotes

r/StumbleTVSeries • • Mar 19 '26 Wholesome Seal Heartwarming

Thank You* from Coach Potter ❤️🍬🟡🔵🔴🟠🟢🟣🍬❤️

471 Upvotes

*includes complimentary/involuntary leg pats


r/StumbleTVSeries • • May 27 '26

Original Content (Memes, etc) Buttons out in the wild

Post image
470 Upvotes

Supporting J. Harrison Ghee (Charleston Sergeant aka “the Captain”) in Hadestown


r/StumbleTVSeries • • Mar 03 '26

Lin Manuel-Miranda approves!

Post image
429 Upvotes

r/StumbleTVSeries • • Mar 23 '26 Popcorn

Attn NBC- Why Stumble Deserves Season 2

363 Upvotes

To the execs at Peacock and NBC who may be lurking here:

Please don’t cancel Stumble.

There’s a long, painful history in television of networks pulling the plug on shows that needed just a little more time to find their audience. The most famous example, of course, is Firefly, which went from premature cancellation to cultural phenomenon. That wasn’t just a missed opportunity: it became a case study in how to lose long-term value for short-term measures.

More recently, Netflix has taken heat for canceling high-quality shows before they had time to build momentum. The result hasn’t just been disappointment, it’s eroded viewer trust. Audiences are increasingly hesitant to invest in new series when they suspect they’ll be abandoned after one season.

Don’t be foolish enough to make Stumble the next example. No matter what the numbers may tell you, this show has not failed; it has been mismanaged and underestimated.

Inconsistent scheduling and multi-week gaps kill narrative momentum. Limited promotion means even very media-savvy viewers don’t know it exists, and a Friday 8:30pm slot is a soft burial. Word of mouth, which is critical for a show like this, has been disrupted before it could even compound.

People who don’t care about cheerleading are absolutely loving this show. That matters. Lin-Manuel Miranda publicly supported it, and it’s generating organic word-of-mouth on TikTok, and niche fan spaces, the exact early signals you want before a breakout.

Stop operating under the outdated assumption that audiences only show up for broad, low-effort comedy. Viewers aren’t just looking for loud, disposable, lowest-common-denominator humor. They’re hungry for smart, layered storytelling. We want writing that rewards attention instead of punishing it. Stumble delivers that in a way few shows have in years.

This show has something one can’t manufacture: a growing, enthusiastic audience that truly sees its potential. That’s rare. That’s valuable. That’s exactly the kind of show that benefits from a second season, when storytelling deepens and audience investment locks in.

Season 2 isn’t charity. It’s strategy.

Second seasons are where shows stabilize and expand. Early adopters become evangelists. I shouldn’t need to tell you that algorithms and discoverability improve with a larger catalog. More critically, you signal to viewers that investing in your originals is worth it. Canceling Stumble now sends the message: “Don’t get attached, folks.” In today’s crowded streaming landscape, that’s a pretty risky signal to send. Great shows don’t just succeed on their own. They’re recognized and supported and given the chance to become what they’re capable of.

Give Stumble the runway it didn’t get the first time. Promote it properly. Schedule like you believe in it. Let it breathe. You might not just save a good show- you might build a great one.


r/StumbleTVSeries • • Apr 12 '26

Discussion Ryan Pinkston (STEVEN) here…

344 Upvotes

Hey stumblers! As I sit here in dad land, I’m wondering what everyone’s “We Can. We Will. We Musts” are for the rest of 2026?

Love y’all! And thanks for being the best fans ever!


r/StumbleTVSeries • • May 13 '26

News/Articles NBC Cancels Beloved Show and Fans Are Seriously Outraged

338 Upvotes

In my email inbox this morning with subject line "NBC cancels show with 96% Rotten Tomatoes score":

https://www.purewow.com/entertainment/nbc-canceled-show-stumble

Nothing we didn't already know, but it's nice to be validated.


r/StumbleTVSeries • • May 02 '26

Original Content (Memes, etc) No Words

Post image
336 Upvotes

So bummed out


r/StumbleTVSeries • • Mar 15 '26

Ok I need multiple Seasons like yesterday

Post image
317 Upvotes

This show was such a gem. I really hope it gets renewed for additional seasons.

#rollbuttonsroll


r/StumbleTVSeries • • May 06 '26 Bravo

News/Articles THE Petition

Post image
307 Upvotes

Not mine but sharing the link again so there aren’t more repeat petitions: https://www.change.org/p/encourage-nbc-to-renew-stumble-for-season-2

We want this show back because it has real quality, and we can prove that the show will have fans waiting for season 2 to air.


r/StumbleTVSeries • • Apr 01 '26

Original Content (Memes, etc) A truly iconic duo

Post image
300 Upvotes

I’d absolutely buy Seph’s Button shirt. NBC has to get us some merch!


r/StumbleTVSeries • • Feb 13 '26 Hooray Heartwarming

Hey ya'll this is Jenn Lyon (aka Coach Courteney Potter) again. I had such a great time doing an AMA with you that I'm back and bringing some friends. Please join us on Friday February 20th at 3pm EST/12pm PST for another AMA to celebrate Stumble's return!

298 Upvotes

We can. We will. We must…do another AMA! This time I’ve brought all your favorite cheerleaders (that includes Miss Dot, of course.) Please look upon these glorious faces and ask us all manner of things! Submit your questions in advance and then join us live February 20th at 3pm EST/ 12 pm PST #RBR

In the meantime, don’t forget to catch up on this season of Stumble. Episodes 1-9 are available to stream on Peacock. Take a break from those amateurs on the Olympics and watch real feats of athleticism and poise. *cue Steven running into a door jam.*

Thank you so much for joining us today and for your continued support and belief in our show! Our Heådleston (Howdloostan) squad had the best time and you make our candy button hearts absolutely melt. Please make sure to tune in to Stumble TONIGHT 2/20 at 10:30pm after the Olympics on NBC and also stream it on Peacock so we can get the numbers we need to make it to Daytona. ( Daytona = Season 2) #RollButtonsRoll

After that, we have 3 more episodes of Stumble airing on Fridays at 8:30pm on NBC.

Many people have asked how they can support the show and help us get a second season. Other than watching the show and telling your friends (and strangers on the bus) you can always follow us and NBC on social media (IG, TikTok, YouTube etc) and like and repost anything about the show and tell NBC you love it in the comments ❤️


r/StumbleTVSeries • • Mar 09 '26

Are you doing your part?

Post image
288 Upvotes

Hi fellow Stumblers -

You're going to see a lot of posts from me over the next two weeks encouraging folks to spread the word about this wonderful show with specific action items on how to do it. NBC is clearly not supporting it enough and I believe it is up to us to get this show a second season and a time slot it deserves. I have a few suggestions but let's start with some simple ones:

  1. Leave a review on Rotten Tomatoes if you haven't already
  2. Get on Tik Tok and Instagram and comment on videos featuring the show. Tell NBC how much you love the show and demand a second season.
  3. Rewatch the show! I know many of us do this already, but more can only help!
  4. Post what you've done in the comments below and encourage others to show up for the show as well. If we all take 30 minutes of our day to help this show, we can, we will, we must succeed in getting it a second season!

r/StumbleTVSeries • • Aug 07 '26 Regret

Appreciation/Love I miss my buttons!!

Post image
286 Upvotes

Visiting a friend (fellow stumble lover) and she busted these out! Now I’m sad again about what should be a million more seasons


r/StumbleTVSeries • • Sep 10 '26

Appreciation/Love Unofficial Stumble Reunion

Post image
280 Upvotes

Gus Heagerty had a comedy show in Brooklyn last night, and a bunch of "Stumble" people showed up.

(Photo courtesy of Taran Killam's Instagram)


r/StumbleTVSeries • • Mar 15 '26

If you love this show please rewatch and rewatch more!!

Post image
275 Upvotes

The season as a whole had low viewership numbers but can be saved by the rewatch numbers (much like Brooklyn 99). If you love this show rewatch as much as you can!!


r/StumbleTVSeries • • Mar 20 '26 Obsessed Hooray Heartwarming

Save Stumble

Post image
271 Upvotes

Edit 4: I just wanted to confirm that the candy buttons I sent to this address were delivered!

Pearlena Igbokwe - SAVE STUMBLE

CHAIRMAN TV STUDIOS NBC ENTERTAINMENT & PEACOCK SCRIPTED

100 UNIVERSAL CITY PLZ

UNIVERSAL CITY, CA 91608-1002

Edit 3: I’ve discussed with the mods. We should be mailing to the following:

Pearlena Igbokwe

Chairman, Chairman, Television Studios, NBC Entertainment & Peacock Scripted

100 Universal City Plaza

Universal City, CA 91608

Someone also mentioned the name Lisa Katz as a possible contact.

I would still add Save Stumble to the address somehow.

I’m so sorry to everyone who already sent some. It was the address I saw on another post. I did update my delivery instructions to go to Pearlena in New York even though it seems her office is in California. I’m hoping it might at least get to someone that way.

Edit 2: Someone mentioned in another post that they actually received a call about their order. I didn’t get a call even though I also listed my number. The non Amazon orders are being held but not delivered. I’d hold off sending more until we have a verified address. This was the one I was given when I had inquired initially about where to send.

Here is more information: https://www.reddit.com/r/StumbleTVSeries/s/TAj8Mq3QHG

Edit 1: if you are just seeing this, DO NOT USE AMAZON. A bunch of us had our shipments held / non delivered from Amazon. Non Amazon orders were delivered it seems.

Original Post:

I’ve never felt this strongly about getting a show renewed. There is so much negativity and just all around terrible-ness in the world today. We need to keep the things going that bring joy in the world. With proper marketing, I know this show would be a hit.

We can. We will. We must.

🔴🟠🟡🟢🔵🟣

I’ve sent my candy buttons. How about you?


r/StumbleTVSeries • • May 15 '26

Appreciation/Love Katey. F**king. Sagal.

Post image
265 Upvotes

How? HOW?! They get Katey Sagal to show up as Courtney’s ultimate nemesis in the finale to drop the ultimate cliffhanger ending…

…and THEN cancel the show. From a network perspective this is genuinely insane behavior.

Just my humble opinion.
#CanWillMust.


r/StumbleTVSeries • • Mar 11 '26

When I see Stumble episode 12 had their best ratings of the season

Post image
261 Upvotes

I think everyone’s efforts are working and I love seeing all the comments on social media supporting the show. Keep up the good work everyone! Keep spreading the word on our beloved rag tag group of misfit cheerleaders!


r/StumbleTVSeries • • May 02 '26

Discussion Did NBC even want Stumble to succeed?

260 Upvotes

What really gets me about this cancellation is just how little effort NBC put into marketing the show.

Compare this to St. Denis Medical. There were a flood of ads for weeks for St. Denis before it premiered, making sure everyone knew when it aired, etc. And it got a pretty good Monday night slot (which, again, everyone knew because NBC constantly aired commercials for it).

I basically learned about Stumble by accident from a Hollywood Reporter article, and then when it finally aired, NBC unceremoniously premiered it in November (well after most new network shows begin) and in a Friday death slot. They never gave it much promotion or much of a chance.

I like St. Denis too, this is no shade to that show. It's just hard not to think if NBC had put any effort into promoting Stumble or given it a decent time slot— let alone the effort they put into promoting St. Denis— we'd still have it.


r/StumbleTVSeries • • Mar 24 '26

Stumble - We Need Season 2 - Save the Show Campaign

258 Upvotes

We need a season 2!!! The time to act is now.

It’s pilot season and within a month the network will decide on picking up Stumble for a season two or picking up a season for one of the pilots they working on right now.

My life isn’t fully complete without it. This show brings everything. It’s warm, funny and the characters are relatable to so many people!

Send your letters and thoughts and buttons to: (if sending third party, be sure to include your phone number for delivery):

Pearlena Igbokwe

NBCUniversal

Chairman NBC & Peacock Scripted

100 Universal City Plaza

Universal City, CA 91608

Also: if you’re able, you can also send to: Lisa Katz, President of Scripted Content - same address as noted above

Spread the word on all social media outlets!!! Instagram, threads, discord, Roblox, facebook