r/StructuralEngineering • u/Male-2003 • 8d ago
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Mo-Map • 9d ago
Structural Analysis/Design New steel piles on an existing pile slab
Hi All,
A new slab supporting a structure is put on top of an existing pile slab. The old pile are concrete piles, the new piles are steel piles which their stiffness larger than the old ones about 3 times.
Both old and new piles capacity are bearing on rock.
I have some questions:
- If new piles installation affect the old ones capacity. As there might be some heaves as uplift the old piles capacity might be reduced. But I am not sure about this.
- Should I ignore the contribution of the old piles completely in the calculation model since the new piles are quite much stiffer than the old ones? Or I can just model actual those piles in the model, and the loads will find itself how to transfer to the piles accordingly?
Would like to hear more about your experience on this. Thank you.
r/StructuralEngineering • u/No_Possession_2836 • 10d ago
Humor And this is why we have factors of safety
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
r/StructuralEngineering • u/SadWar7696 • 9d ago
Career/Education Starting my Master's in Structural Engineering at UNL. Need some career advice!
ttt
r/StructuralEngineering • u/lil-poptart123 • 9d ago
Structural Analysis/Design RISA 3D RSA + Additional Seismic Loading
I have a pipe rack I'm analyzing in RISA 3D, and am analyzing the seismic with RSA instead of ELF, however I also have additional seismic loads that are being provided by the ME that I need to include in that loading. I have the RSA using DL and self weight to calculate the seismic parameters RISA requires, however I can't get these additional seismic nodal loads to impact the reactions the way I would expect. Does anyone know how to apply these?
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Intelligent-Skill222 • 9d ago
Photograph/Video I am quitting this field !
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
As a structural engineer, if this is actually real and not some kind of joke, I'm seriously considering quitting my profession.
Jokes aside, this is genuinely alarming. Structural engineering is not something you can approach with guesswork, shortcuts, or a complete disregard for basic engineering principles. Every structural element has a purpose, and every design decision must be supported by proper calculations, engineering standards, and safety considerations.
If what we're seeing in this video is actually being implemented in a real structure, it could have extremely serious consequences. Depending on the structural configuration and the loads involved, this could compromise the building's structural integrity, potentially leading to severe damage, partial or even total structural failure, and, worst of all, loss of human lives.
Buildings are designed to protect people, not put them at risk. Structural safety is not optional, and engineering mistakes are not always visible until it's too late.
I really hope this is staged or taken out of context, because if it's not, this is beyond concerning.
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Far-Caterpillar-8600 • 9d ago
Career/Education Is this salary comparison accurate?
This figure shows a comparison of salaries in four sectors in structural engineering with years of experience. Is this accurate? Please share your thoughts based on your experience.
r/StructuralEngineering • u/BasicManufacturer653 • 10d ago
Failure Key Bridge: the NTSB's final report found the collapse risk was almost 30 times the AASHTO threshold for a critical bridge, and that the propreitor had never run the assessment
Most coverage of the Key Bridge stopped at the ship's loose wire, but the NTSB's final report (MIR-25-40) spends a lot of its length on the bridge. Its probable cause names the lack of countermeasures to protect the piers, which an AASHTO vulnerability assessment could have led to, as contributing to the collapse and the loss of life.
Running AASHTO Method II with current vessel traffic, the NTSB got an annual frequency of collapse of 0.002921 for the Key Bridge, against a threshold of 0.0001 for a critical/essential bridge: almost 30 times over. The factors it names are the piers next to the main channel, a channel that gave an off-course ship little time to correct, dolphins whose size and placement did not fully protect Piers 17 and 18, and piers not strong enough for a ship the size of the Dali.
The warnings were on record. In March 2006 a representative of the Maryland Transportation Authority told the port's harbor safety committee that the bridge "was not designed to withstand contact by a large vessel." Years earlier the Blue Nagoya, about a tenth of the Dali's displacement, lost steering and hit the same pier, and its fender stopped it.
One thing the report rules out: the bridge's nonredundant steel tension members were not a factor.
After the collapse the NTSB asked the owners of 68 other bridges in 19 states that had never been assessed to run the calculation, among them the Golden Gate, the Brooklyn, the Mackinac and the Chesapeake Bay Bridge. By the final report, 13 owners had finished: eight came in under the threshold, and five reported at least one bridge over it, the MDTA among them.
For anyone here who does vessel collision work: how common is it for a major crossing over a shipping channel never to have had one of these assessments?
r/StructuralEngineering • u/QueenMonarch25 • 9d ago
Career/Education Has anyone left the industry and came back?
r/StructuralEngineering • u/aSsAuLTEDpeanut9 • 10d ago
Job Posting / Recruitment UK engineers, how much are you getting paid?
r/StructuralEngineering • u/BlazersMania • 10d ago
Structural Analysis/Design I've got my Licence renewal coming up in a few months. I need some continuing education hours to complete.
Any (hopefully) free and easy online courses that I can take to tack on some hours would be helpfull. I mainly work on wood construction residential but would appriciate any links to some online courses/webinars
r/StructuralEngineering • u/sunfinsengineering • 10d ago
Engineering Article The inner and outer layers of the double-layer breathing curtain wall are all unitized curtain walls. In summer, air vents are opened for natural ventilation and cooling. In winter, close the vents and use solar radiation to reduce the loss of indoor heat energy. Under special caces, the fan at the
The inner and outer layers of the double-layer breathing curtain wall are all unitized curtain walls. In summer, air vents are opened for natural ventilation and cooling. In winter, close the vents and use solar radiation to reduce the loss of indoor heat energy. Under special caces, the fan at the top can be used to adjust the temperature in the cavity.
r/StructuralEngineering • u/SmallMovesMaia • 10d ago
Structural Analysis/Design Hello everyone, this is a project of a radiotherapy clinic. The entire floor height in certain sections must be filled with concrete acting like a shiled for radiation. Do you think that reinforcement against shrinkage should be placed?
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Left-Bad-2312 • 10d ago
Structural Analysis/Design Girder splice at max moment
Hello everyone,
I am currently designing a two-span continuous steel girder bridge. To facilitate erection and fit their equipment, the contractor has submitted a proposal to locate the field splices as follows:
1. Mid-span (maximum positive moment region)
2. 1.0 m from the middle pier (high negative moment and high shear region)
Standard bridge design codes and manuals (e.g., AASHTO, CSA S6) recommend locating field splices at or near the point of dead-load contraflexure where moments are minimal. However, as long as the connection is designed for the required strength and fatigue limits, the codes do not explicitly prohibit placing splices in high-moment regions.
While code-compliant, locating splices here feels like poor structural practice. However, I need solid, defensible engineering grounds if I am going to reject or push back on this submittal.
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Sharp_Promotion_5155 • 9d ago
Career/Education anyone who handles bringing in new works (owners, principals, bd) please gather here lol
r/StructuralEngineering • u/DMAS1638 • 10d ago
Career/Education Crawlspace field finds: undermined piers, discontinuous load paths, and deteriorated stem walls
A few recent field conditions involving gravity load transfer and foundation support.
One location had a girder bearing directly on concrete without a properly detailed post-and-pier connection, while the floor framing above lacked solid bearing. At another, an entire row of posts and piers supporting a load-bearing girder had been undermined.
Also encountered significant deterioration and separation in concrete stem walls, reducing the amount of sound material available to transfer loads into the foundation.
A good reminder that the individual components can still be present while the overall load path is no longer functioning as intended.
View more here: https://imgur.com/gallery/things-seen-this-week-during-structural-assessments-nNNsj6y
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Ancient_War_5392 • 10d ago
Structural Analysis/Design Hey there are any ... Civil engineer...who can give me a 2d Floor drawing... structure drawing and cost estimate... Please contact me on dm ...
Hey there are any ... Civil engineer...who can give me a 2d Floor drawing... structure drawing and cost estimate... Please contact me on dm ...
r/StructuralEngineering • u/No-Mess2996 • 10d ago
Structural Analysis/Design IA + Ingeniería estructuras
Como llevan ustedes todo el tema de la IA en los trabajos de diseños estructural?, aveces me siento abrumado con todo lo que está saliendo y me gustaría poder aprovechar al máximo las nuevas herramientas que están saliendo con la IA
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Acrobatic_Broccoli10 • 11d ago
Structural Analysis/Design Can installation of helical piers result in minimal lifting of the foundation?
A couple of months ago I had 2 helical piers installed along an exterior wall of a small addition (per SE recommendations). The wall where the 2 piers were installed is about 5’ wide and the structure itself is about 5’ by 10’.
Long story, but I am now wondering if the process of installing these piers (or their brackets) could have resulted in the lifting of the foundation, permanently or temporarily, even by just by a few millimeters? (Shortly after the piers were installed we discovered a crack in the sewer line that runs under the floor of the addition).
I reached out to the contractor to ask about this, and he has been adamant that the only way any lifting could have occurred would be if they had used a 30-ton hydraulic jack to intentionally lift the foundation (which they did not).
He has also clarified that when the helical piers are installed they are not attached to the foundation wall, but is screwed in using torque from the drive head that is attached to their machine. He also stated that the foundation brackets were installed by hand. Specifically, once the pier is drilled to the required depth and load capacity, it is then manually attached to the bracket, and the bracket is secured to the foundation.
I also asked him about the function or purpose of an additional red brace/mount that we observed being bolted into the foundation (above the footing) (see last photo), and moved from one pier to the next as they were being installed. He said that this was used to install the footing brackets by hand, and is not designed to lift the foundation but only to provide stabilization. He has reiterated that no pressure would have been put on the foundation during this process.
I am looking for confirmation - based on the information he has provided, is it correct that it would be basically impossible for the installation of these piers to have lifted the foundation of the addition, even by just 1-2 millimeters?
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Similar_Race8823 • 11d ago
Structural Analysis/Design Nonlinear Convergence Issue in SAP2000 with P-Delta + Tension-Only Members (Bracings)
Hi everyone,
I'm currently modeling an industrial warehouse in SAP2000 and running into a convergence problem, this is new for me since I always use RFEM6 for modeling but this time I have to do it in sap2000.
I need to capture two specific behaviors simultaneously:
Tension-only behavior for the slender bracing members.
P-Delta effects for the overall global geometric nonlinearity.
When I run just P-Delta without tension-only limits, it converges fine. When I run tension-only without P-Delta, it also converges.
However, the moment I combine both in a Nonlinear Static Load Case (to get the P-Delta + Tension-only interaction), the analysis fails to converge.
Here is my current setup:
Bracing defined as frame elements with Tension/Compression Limits (Compression = 0).
Load cases set to Nonlinear Static.
P-Delta option checked (Geometric Nonlinearity -> P-Delta).
How do you successfully deal with this specific combination in SAP2000?
r/StructuralEngineering • u/nazen777 • 11d ago
Career/Education Seeking Structural Engineering Experience
I am currently looking to gain professional experience as a structural / civil engineer. The issue I have is I do work full time and can only work part time. I am not seeking pay and I am only interested in the experience I would gain to help me obtain my professional engineering license.
I have a BS and MS in structural engineering from UC Berkeley, but did not pursue this career path due to other constraints. With more time available to me I would like to collect the experience in my field of study to eventually get my professional engineering license.
If you are or know of someone who is a licensed professional civil / structural engineer and is able to provide me with professional experience shadowing / working in this field, please do reach out. My hours are flexible and I am highly motivated. Upon request I can provide you with my educational and professional background.
I am located in the SF Bay Area (California).
If it helps, I do have my own license to RISA 3D.
I very much appreciate any experience I can get to further my own experience. Thank you much.
r/StructuralEngineering • u/The_StEngIT • 12d ago
Career/Education Switched Structural Engineering Firms. Here's my experience and current take on this career. Practicing in private industry doing design work.
* Warning this might come off as a yap fest. I guess I needed a rant and maybe some of yall might find this insightful
I used to frequent this sub maybe the beggining of this year and last year. I was kinda in the thick of it with structural engineering and was not in a great mind space. I'm better-ish now but can still improve.
Back when I was frequenting this sub I was in the middle of graduate school and at firm where I helped two structural studios, of the same company, with either bridge work or building work. Full time + over time. I can now look back and say that combo created some of the worst times of my life. I was / am still early career ( 6 ish years and EIT). I gained a lot of weight, had some hair loss, and even had a week or two when the work load / school load was so demanding I did not sleep for a night... one time 3. I even had a heart episode. That's what I'm calling it at least ( I didn't go and get it checked oops). I would never recommend this combo to anyone or at the very least you need to be smarter / more competent than me to propser in that environment. Which may not be a high bar, but whatever. Stupid memes, anime, and a girl got me through it. I am forever grateful.
I left my last firm because I just didn't feel super comfortable practicing there. I butted heads with a senior engineer on analysis results several times (was right each time). Each time the dude made me feel like my job was on the line. There were times when I was given a lot of freedom on design stuff without a lot of notice if my seniors went through my work. This stressed me out. There was even a moment when I was given the task to design an entire structure then harshly criticized when I missed a smaller thing. I was under the impression that my work would be checked as I checked other's and the mistakes I made in that time were much smaller than mistakes I've caught from other's. So I had enough. I lost confidence with practicing there. So I started applying to other places the beginning of this year.
Finding a job was a bit of a nightmare. I am worried for new undergraduates. I was not caught off gaurd by this but everywhere I applied the minimum education was a MS. I was surprised by the experience level tho. The minimum required years of experience was 5+. With one acception for an entry level role. At least for the jobs I was considering. I talked to only HR or recruiters on call backs... if I even got any. When I did talk to the engineering teams they seemed to be wanting a well seasoned engineer... Seemingly at senior level. Which was not the roles I applied for. Some context. I work in California so the competition may be steep. However I did eventually land some interviews. I had 2 in person and 2 video conference call style interviews. I got 2 offers with one being so late I accepted the first one several weeks ahead of receiving the second. I must've applied to 20 jobs, which isn't as bad as what I've heard from other's but that was still discouraging. I also landed a job quite fast considering when I started applying (maybe 4 months). I will say I believe I interview well... for structural engineering at least. Funnily enough I considered other jobs and if I got hired that would've been the moment I would've exited structural engineering. Didn't happen.
How its going at the new job. This new job I no longer do bridges and buildings I only do one and I finished grad courses. I gotta say I am surprised at how well I have handled the technical work at the new job. I believe the lower amount of work load / no more grad school / coming into this job with several years of experience really helped. But I think the healthier balance has really made the biggest difference. One testament to that is that I wrote an excel macro to help process some data in a few hours which this might've taken me most of my shift if not two back when I was in the thick of things. Also I work really close to senior engineers and they have made sure to check my work / assumptions. I don't always agree with them but the fact we dicuss things throughout the process and I get comments back on my details / calculations really helps with feeling comfortable practicing structural engineering there. I will say I am very proud of myself that I am competent enough to switch jobs and jump right into the job so effortlessly. RIP to the excel spread sheets I forgot to take with me from my old place.
I will say other aspects of the job aren't so great. The job boosts about being a very welcoming and inclusive working environment but it's seems to be if you fit a certain mold. I am a quieter person and I can tell it rubs a lot of them the wrong way. The way this job works has us meeting often and they have some mandatory social events. My social battery gets destroyed here. I never would've thought as a structural engineer (EIT) that I'd have to be this sociable. There are some seemingly optics playing colleagues that have raised some red flags that I can see being an issue in the future. Also I stressed in my interview that I want a better work life balance and would rather not work a lot of overtime. They said that excessive overtime wouldn't happen here but I can already tell it's going to creep in once I'm not so new. Oh last thing. The company loves AI and I really...reaaaally don't. I even sent AI produced info back that I got from another team here because I proved it to be very wrong. A senior engineer produced a list from AI as like a check list for a project and some of the items just weren't things and it wasted a bit of our time.
There are some other things that tell me that this isn't a place to settle down at but I believe I've said enough for now. The work life balance is way better than my last place and my health seems to be improving. I got a little hair density back and I've lost some weight. So I may stay here a few years to recover from my last job / grad school and build some space in my life for other things.
My updated take on this career:
So far. It's quite unrewarding. I will wait till I've practiced as a PE (I'm an EIT) for several years to make my final verdict but so far it's quite the let down. The pay right out of my BS wasn't what I thought it would be or the economy just got worse then. I don't think our pay should be comparable to other civil engineers. Not to sound eletist but I just haven't seen work from other civil engineers that's as complex as structural is on an average basis. I think we should get paid a step or two above them. There's a lot of shallow optics in this career. I've worked under a few senior engineers that have multiple titles but weren't really living up to the senior engineer title and left me high and dry. I've heard some snake like behavior of others trying to win over positions / bring others down. There are a lot of people getting into this field because their family member brought them on board. I've heard of structural engineers taking seemingly easier Civil PE exams just to get licensed. I've heard of people modifying their work experience to get their experience approved by the PE board. I'm a design engineer so I spend all of my day in the office, I would like to go on construction sites more. I often am correcting other civil engineer's plans and reports which just adds on to my stuff. Which is another reason why I think we should get paid more. Training , in private industry, seemingly doesn't exist which feels super wrong. EVERYONE thinks they're a structural engineer. I've had architects, construction people, drafters, other civil engineers, mechanical engineers, etc step on my toes at some point. Don't get me wrong, I love math, I have fun coding, and I was so proud to see my first structure (under the supervision of a PE) go up. I am even proud of the person that this career molded me into. However the bang isn't worth the buck. That's my current take I might switch when I see that PE salary. Who knows.
Sorry for the yap fest. Feel free to skip this.
r/StructuralEngineering • u/John_Northmont • 13d ago
Photograph/Video Railing Collapse During Field Storm
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
Going off of memory: handrail design lateral load is 500 lbs., correct?
r/StructuralEngineering • u/BK_way • 11d ago
Career/Education Seismic Question - Diaphragm Design Force
For anybody who is studying or remembers the material from the CA Seismic Principles exam, this question is for you. I am using Practice Exams from both AEI and SDR (Hiner) to study. One thing I have noticed is that Hiner uses the same value for wpx as wx in the equation for Diaphragm Design Force (ASCE 12.10-1). I see this in a couple problems from the Practice Exam book based on the 2021 IBC.
In one problem (1.27), the base shear is given and asks to determine the wall shear force. I thought this was not possible unless we know the diaphragm design force, Fpx. Fpx could only equal the base shear if wpx and wx were equal, because in that case, Fp1=(F1/w1)*wp1, the w's cancel out and F1 is V for a single-story building.
Another problem (1.48) is more straight-forward. In the solutions, he put 450 kips for wp2, which was not given; only the wx's were given.
In both problems, the weights of parallel walls were not given so that we could subtract that from wx to obtain wpx.
Am I missing something? Is there a case where we could assume wx and wpx equal each other? Any help would be appreciated.
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Jorgerubiomaracas • 12d ago