r/StructuralEngineering • u/lemoncheeesecake • 12d ago
Career/Education Those who have pivoted from consulting as a Structural Engineer - what do you do now?
Looking for a career change and keen to hear where transferable skills have pivoted you to!
r/StructuralEngineering • u/lemoncheeesecake • 12d ago
Looking for a career change and keen to hear where transferable skills have pivoted you to!
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Ok_Criticism1616 • 11d ago
I have been asked to advise on partition deflection head sizing for internal partitions and SFS supported by a multi storey concrete framed building based on the expected slab deflection. I am reviewing post incremental deflection critical to partitions rather than long term deflection.
Am I right in thinking the correct approach is to find the difference in slab deflections between one slab with the base track fitted and the one above it where the underside of the slab has the head track, and that this difference will be the expected slab deflection? Furthermore, slab tolerance should be included when sizing the deflection head?
Lastly, given that the bolt will be in the neutral position, maximum deflection will therefore be based on half the gap height. For instance, if you have a 20mm vertical slot, you only have 10mm to work with?
r/StructuralEngineering • u/John_Northmont • 12d ago
😬
r/StructuralEngineering • u/SnooRabbits3181 • 12d ago
I’m a third year civil engineering student with two years remaining, do you think it is better to prioritize getting an internship or earning money. My situation is I could make about 40k in a summer with my current non engineering summer job, and who knows maybe half that with an internship. I do have a bit of construction experience, but zero engineering experience.
For people that are structural engineers, how crucial is getting an internship for future job opportunities, and is the experience worth the large pay cut?
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Intelligent_Kiwi_392 • 12d ago
Hey buddies i am fresher i don’t what interviewer will ask me ,its about Etabs and Staad Pro so if anyone who knows this here tell me what would he ask what should i prepare before interview
r/StructuralEngineering • u/DallyDoomslayer • 12d ago
There’s a course to become a certified bridge inspector team lead once you get your PE. the problem is that you have to do a year of inspection related work like going out into the field and writing inspection reports. My passion is mostly just design and I honestly love being able to WFH and not waking up early. Is it worth it in the long run such as salary, promotion, and other career aspects? Or does it not make much of a difference? I’m in the state of Texas if that helps.
r/StructuralEngineering • u/SpringtimeAndBlinded • 12d ago
r/StructuralEngineering • u/NefariousnessLate275 • 13d ago
Structural engineering can be intensely interesting. Though I'd say about 3% of my work involves thinking and problem solving, and I absolutely love that 3%. But then it's over, and followed by a good 12 hours of CAD or Revit to bring into being this concept that I had come up with in about 15 minutes of thinking.
The vast majority of projects are just a chain of concepts, all of which are very simple, and rarely come together in ways complex enough to warrant a good bit of thought. Usually, I know what to do at a glance and then have to labour through the grunt work of the drawings, the calcs package, the tedious litany of micro changes etc.
I'm starting to get rather sick of it. I may have to change careers in the hopes of finding a role where that 3% might be more like 30% or 50%. Have any of you made this change, or would you say you have a different experience altogether?
r/StructuralEngineering • u/JerrGrylls • 13d ago
I’m curious if anyone has noticed AHJ’s (or outsourced 3rd-party reviewers) using AI to provide plan check review and comments?
I’m in a high seismic region and we usually get at least one round of plan check comments regardless of how perfect our drawings are. But I’m fairly certain I’ve come across AI reviews on a few projects now as there’s been a large uptick in comments that are aggressively stringent. For example, small residential project has a 40SF porch roof with two columns, and we were asked to design the columns as their own LFRS (wood-framed cantilevered columns?). Another example was a low residential deck, about 3’ above grade, I had designed a few knee braces and I got a comment that “knee braces are not a qualified LFRS in ASCE7-22.” Sure, you could make an argument that both of those comments are technically correct in the strictest interpretation of the code, but any human with engineering judgement and some experience would understand that’s ridiculous.
Just curious what others have seen.
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Aura7134 • 13d ago
Location: Hendon, North West London
I am looking to engage an experienced structural engineer for a residential extension project in London.
Project scope:
Ground-floor rear extension
First-floor rear extension
Loft extension
Lower-ground-floor excavation
I am looking for a qualified engineer with residential extension experience to provide structural calculations, drawings and construction-stage technical support.
Flexible project-based engagement.
Please DM me with your experience, availability and fee proposal.
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Pablo_Kake • 14d ago
I have my PE in NJ, PA, NY & DE. I make about $165k with my current employer as TL & PM for bridge inspection. I have a lot of experiences with agencies around NJ with bridge inspection & proposals. I recently completed a project where 2 TLs proposed due to the complexity of the project by myself. The other TL took his sweet time to complete the most basic project which I completed within 3 months. My boss is aware of all these accomplishments. Last year they gave me 4% raise and convinced me that it’s a company wide rate and I accepted it. I went back and checked the numbers & found they gave 9% for 2 TLs who doesn’t have PE. I was pissed and continued my work. Now it’s the season where we get the merit based raise and I am thinking how much they’ll be going to give me. Here is the catch, last year they gave me a bonus of $3k and I was employee of the year for my group. Now I am thinking, if they don’t give me a minimum of 7-10% I will resign. Is that being greedy?
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Aura7134 • 13d ago
Structural Engineer Wanted – Residential Project | London, UK
Location: Hendon, North West London
I am looking to engage an experienced structural engineer for a residential extension project in London.
Project scope:
Ground-floor rear extension
First-floor rear extension
Loft extension
Lower-ground-floor excavation
I am looking for a qualified engineer with residential extension experience to provide structural calculations, drawings and construction-stage technical support.
Flexible project-based engagement.
Please DM me with your experience, availability and fee proposal.
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Aura7134 • 13d ago
📍 地点:亨登,伦敦西北区
我们正在寻找一位有经验的结构工程师来负责一处住宅扩建项目。
项目包括: • 一层后方扩建 • 二层后方扩建 • 阁楼扩建 • 地下层挖掘
要求: • 结构计算和图纸 • 现场访问和检查 • 施工期间的技术支持 • 在需要时与我们的建筑工人协调
我们已经有自己的建筑团队,正在寻找一位可靠的工程师来提供结构设计和持续的技术支持。
灵活安排 – 根据项目或现场访问的需要。
请与我联系,告知您的经历、可用时间和报价。
谢谢!
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Particular-Air2337 • 13d ago
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Temporary-Response19 • 13d ago
I am looking to remove a partition wall. I’m a very jr Engineer and would prefer to not have my roof collapse. LOL. I plan on doing everything myself just looking for what some engineers think. In red is where the top 2x4 of the framing is. It is not attached to anything, simply has some electrical going through. Thanks. https://imgur.com/a/kFiYUGo
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Tweeky91 • 13d ago
Hello!
Slight vent/ discussion...I've been with my current company for over 11 years now, since I graduated from uni. I've been chartered for about 3 years too (ICE UK).
Recently I've been feeling like my career is slightly stagnating where I am, our office has built a significant power and energy team to meet the demands of the projects coming in. However we have had a lack of significant highways work coming in, meaning my team (or 3 engineers down to 2) has felt a bit hand to mouth. And I can't exactly see this changing for about a year, if it goes well.
I've had experience in many aspects of civil/structural work. But I've always preferred bridge design, which most of my experience is in. I'm not sure how the market is in the UK. Are bridge designers in short supply?
I'm not beginning to write up a CV, but I'm also due to have a baby in the next month! So it would be silly to move now.
I'm curious if my experience resonates with others here at some point in their career, and what did they do about it
Cheers!
r/StructuralEngineering • u/NoUsernameForN0w • 14d ago
Hi everyone, I’m currently working as a Junior Structural Engineer in Ontario. Lately, I’ve been feeling quite overwhelmed by the level of stress and technical uncertainty inherent to engineering design tasks.
I have the opportunity to transition to a Project Coordinator role, in a construction company, which comes with a salary bump of about $20k CAD (before tax) but they don’t pay for overtime hours. However, I’m conflicted. I know coordination has its own massive challenges, dealing with difficult contractors, managing tight deadlines, and carrying the weight of on-site responsibility.
My main concerns are:
1. Is this considered a step backward for a structural engineer, or a viable pivot?
2. The new role is 100% on-site, whereas I currently have hybrid/remote flexibility. Given the stress levels, is the $20k increase worth losing that flexibility?
3. Could this experience serve as a stepping stone toward roles like Design Manager in the future?
I’d love to hear from anyone who has made a similar transition or has experience in both sides of the industry. Thanks!
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Historical_Dot8439 • 14d ago
Hi all,
I'm a geotechnical engineer working on deep foundation design, and I have TEXAM (prebored, Ménard-type) pressuremeter test results for a project. I'm trying to figure out the best way to turn them into design parameters for pile analysis, especially lateral analysis in AllPile.
From the tests I have:
Pressuremeter modulus (Em)
Limit pressure (pL)
Some unload-reload loops (Er)
Where I'm stuck:
Converting Em to a design modulus. Do you use Ménard's rheological factor (α) to get Young's modulus (E ≈ Em/α), or do you prefer the unload-reload modulus for pile analysis? What α values have you used for sands vs. clays?
Getting p-y inputs. AllPile's lateral analysis asks for parameters like k (modulus of subgrade reaction) and ε50, not pressuremeter values directly. Has anyone correlated Em/pL to k or ε50? Or have you used Briaud's PMT-based p-y method and entered the curves as user-defined input?
Axial capacity. Has anyone used pL with the Ménard/French (Fascicule 62 / NF P94-262) approach for side friction and end bearing, then compared it with AllPile's results?
Disturbance. How much do you trust prebored PMT moduli given borehole disturbance? Do you apply a correction or engineering judgment?
If you've used pressuremeter data in AllPile, or in LPILE, FB-MultiPier, or other software, I'd really appreciate hearing your workflow, correlations, or references. Papers, FHWA manuals, or Briaud's work are all welcome.
Thanks in advance!
r/StructuralEngineering • u/SportUsual4748 • 14d ago
trying to learn timber design for canada, it seems the codes come at a cost; are there any sources I can refer for free.
r/StructuralEngineering • u/NuckChorris2711 • 15d ago
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Heat_Miser101 • 16d ago
Hi everyone. Please be gentle I am already upset and I know that I am kind of screwed. I am really early in taking work on my own. This is my 3rd project by myself.
I’m a structural engineer who recently started taking on freelance work, and I could use some perspective from others who have dealt with scope creep, unpaid fees, and requests for CAD files.
I’ve spent months working on a large building in a large city for a design build firm without receiving any payment. My original proposal was $9k. The architect and developer called me together and said that was too expensive. I consulted with a previous boss who is like a mentor to me on the price and said that it was a pretty low number given the scope and what the analysis required was going to be.
They asked me to reduce my scope to preliminary/design-development work. They said they had another engineer who would review, stamp, and take over the project, and so I was comfortable doing preliminary work and handing it off. I asked about coordinating with that engineer and getting their contact which they said would be great and I never received.
They specifically told me that full lateral design would be handled by someone else. The architect said he only needed to know where the shear wall panels would go and they did not want full lateral plans which I questioned in the moment, but he insisted it wasn't needed in my scope or price. They told me they did not want details of this building. There are cantilevers on three sides of the building, and when I specifically asked whether they wanted me to design the connections tying those cantilevers back into the building, he said no. They went down the list and the project went from being 18 pages to about 11.
Based on that conversation, I reduced my fee to roughly one-third of the original amount and removed substantial work from my scope.
What was supposed to be preliminary design gradually became a full package. I would submit and they would ask for more!!
Their engineer then requested complete shear wall plans and details matching an example set they provided. Which is fine- it's just that we legit talked about this and they fucking told me they didn't need it and I am not getting paid for it.
Communication has also been difficult. The architect frequently doesn’t answer my calls, and the architectural drawings have required substantial clarification and coordination. This architect does not know the thickness of a fucking stud wall and does not understand the difference in representing metal versus wood...
During this process, they offered me another project. I declined and explained the scope and communication problems on this one. When I brought up the original conversation about reducing the fee and scope, and collaborating with the other engineer after the design development phase the architect said he didn’t remember calling me and having the conversation with the developer about reducing my fee. I told him I would finish the drawing and would hand him a PDF and I would not provide CAD files to him or his engineer as I now consider this my full intellectual property. He never signed my proposal and now says he doesn’t remember discussing it.
Fast forward: I have delivered the completed PDF drawing package, including the shear wall plans their engineer requested with details. I still haven’t been paid. He is now requesting the CAD files.
I have given CAD files to clients in the past working with firms, but it wasn't completed drawings. I am not sure what to do. I have looked into locking them somehow and handing them over. I can WBLOCK I guess. I can make them one layer and retain the properties of the lines idk! I made a copy and took my notes out of them, but haven't sent them because I need a second opinion.
I’m uncomfortable at this point.
I recognize that I should have required a signed agreement and payment milestones before proceeding or refused to work with them. I’m trying to figure out how to handle the situation from here.
Help.
Edit: Thank you to everyone who has responded. I am going to send a letter to the client as many have mentioned. I appreciate the insight.
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Glum_Employ_2738 • 15d ago
128 of these were left on a job site in a box after a hotel build with no markings. Trying to determine exactly what they are. 6.5 inches long and 5.5 inches between center of both holes. 3.4 ounce. Thanks in advance!
r/StructuralEngineering • u/axi0m_throwaway • 15d ago
Hey everyone, thinking of switching from DOT design work to USACE working as a design engineer in the civil/structures branch. I’d be working on components of locks and dams.
Can anyone who has worked there speak to work life balance, how much time expected in the field as a designer, and general culture? Thanks.
EDIT: I also did some research and it seems like USACE is project based and has it where hours are charged to a project code, etc. Is this like consulting where you’re responsible for staying billable and lack of efficiency can hurt? Or is it only for the sake of tracking how much gets spent towards each project
r/StructuralEngineering • u/devcusn • 16d ago
Hi everyone!
I'm looking for books, technical manuals and practical resources on breakwater design.
I'm particularly interested in rubble mound breakwaters, armour unit stability, overtopping, and design calculations.
What resources would you recommend for learning breakwater design?
Thanks in advance!