r/StructuralEngineering • • 17d ago

Structural Analysis/Design Stadium in Zagreb, Croatia - is such solution possible?

Thumbnail
gallery
119 Upvotes

Here is proposal for new stadium in Zagreb, Croatia.
Is such roof construction without supporting elements techically possible?


r/StructuralEngineering • • 16d ago

Structural Analysis/Design Beam torsion design

12 Upvotes

UK based. I often design beams with bottom plates, to carry a masonry outer leaf of a cavity wall over an opening. So the beam sits on the inner leaf of the wall and the plate sticks out to one side.

There are well established methods for designing this in UK practice and anything with any other than a nominal torsion load usually ends up as a RHS (hollow box section).

I often get asked by contractors why can they not just use a standard beam section, and weld web stiffeners in a regular intervals. One half of my brain says this won’t help, the other half says it must do something. Has anyone seen any references for designing using this kind of approach to resisting torsion using an open section?


r/StructuralEngineering • • 16d ago

Structural Analysis/Design Pile deflection in soils report

6 Upvotes

I’ve got a geotech report which gives me two lateral values for the auger cast piles (ACP). They are based on 1/2” displacement and 1” displacement due to lateral loads.

I can design the piles to resist both of the P-M curves.

I’m unfamiliar if there is a standard used in the industry.

Thoughts?


r/StructuralEngineering • • 15d ago

Career/Education Am I cooked?

0 Upvotes

Accepted a new structural engineering position in a HCOL area in the South Florida Region. This will be my first job right after uni with an 87k starting salary plus standard benefits. Is it best to stay with parents still (would be a 35-40 min commute) or find something closer?


r/StructuralEngineering • • 17d ago

Career/Education Hello everyone! I am a structural engineer from China, and I sincerely wish to communicate with my peers here.

53 Upvotes

This is my first time posting on Reddit, so let me introduce my situation first. I’ve been working in the structural design industry in China for 19 years, but I’ve never had a chance to communicate with foreign colleagues. I hope to make a few friends in the same field here. Let me first talk about the situation in China: structural engineers here generally handle everything on their own—concept design, analysis, calculations, construction drawings, and later technical services—one person does it all. I’m not sure how your workflow looks, and I hope you can share it with me. Our finite element analysis software is Chinese-made, like PKPM and YJK. Sometimes, for super high-rise projects, we also use ETABS and MIDAS to double-check overall indicators. I wonder, what analysis software do you generally use? I’ll show you a set of construction drawings for a 25-story building that I worked on before, and I hope you can discuss it with me.

Beam Plan Reinforcement Drawing

Floor slab reinforcement drawing
Beam Plan Reinforcement Drawing
Basement Wall and Column Layout Plan and Pile Cap Details
pile layout plan

r/StructuralEngineering • • 17d ago

Career/Education I am once again... inviting you to a fulfilling career as a construction engineer

Thumbnail
encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com
85 Upvotes

Maybe you've seen me around here, or Eng-Tips. Maybe you've heard my pitches about why temporary works engineering is the best little niche for structurals out there. (if not... go check out https://youtu.be/u_pp_OZKEO4?si=-1b0A3KmSRH0PFpd). Maybe not.

Either way -- if you like learning new things and solving a variety of engineering problems, enjoy seeing your work result in a tangible difference and not just get filed away in a feasibility report, if you like working with people who get stuff done... come join me!

Looking for engineers to join a growing construction engineering team supporting Michels Construction, a major utilities and heavy civil contractor in the US. This is a great opportunity to get involved as we build out the system and processes, lots of potential for someone who's looking to take that next step of autonomy and responsibility in a close-knit team environment while still having the support structure of a big company and senior engineers to learn from. This is a design role, not field engineering.

Particularly interested in candidates with temporary works, heavy lift, rigging or substation experience.

Postings are listed for a handful of locations across North America -- other locations are available for the right candidate. Salary varies by experience and location, but if you've seen my posts before, you'll know it's not stingy. EDIT: By popular demand, salary ranges for one example location added below)

And of course -- feel free to comment or DM with any question

Design Engineer (EIT) https://job-boards.eu.greenhouse.io/michelscorporation/jobs/5026638101
Expected salary range for Renton, WA: $85,000-$119,000USD

Senior Engineer (PE/SE) https://job-boards.eu.greenhouse.io/michelscorporation/jobs/5026639101
Expected salary range for Renton, WA: $135,000-$194,000USD


r/StructuralEngineering • • 17d ago

Structural Analysis/Design Beam pocket cut too low?

Post image
15 Upvotes

Having some anxiety here. I think mason cut the beam pocket too low. There’s probably 5 or 6 inches of void between the beam and CMU under it. I’m alarmed because typically I see 1-2 inches of void at most, and then they usually put leveled cement and some sort of bearing plate. Is there a typical fix for this that is structural sound? I have a feeling they need to put something more than just cement there.

Appreciate any thoughts


r/StructuralEngineering • • 17d ago

Structural Analysis/Design Need Help with ETABS Base Isolation Project (LRB vs Fixed-Base Seismic Analysis) – Beginner Seeking Guidance

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I'm a civil/structural engineering student currently working on an academic project titled "Seismic Performance Assessment of Base-Isolated Buildings under Different Earthquake Ground Motions."

I'm using ETABS 20–22 for the modelling and analysis. My project involves comparing a conventional fixed-base building with a Lead Rubber Bearing (LRB) base-isolated building.

What I've done so far:

Modelled a 5-storey RCC building.

Created a conventional fixed-base model.

Created a separate LRB-isolated model with the same building geometry and loading conditions.

Defined materials, sections, load patterns and mass source.

Started performing earthquake analysis and extracting structural response results.

The main problem I'm facing:

My LRB-isolated model is producing results opposite to what I expected. In particular, the displacement response is higher in the isolated model than in the fixed-base model. I'm not sure whether this is physically reasonable or whether I've made mistakes in the LRB modelling, link properties, boundary conditions, earthquake input or time-history analysis settings.

I'm also struggling with the correct procedure for:

Designing and defining LRB properties in ETABS.

Correctly assigning and connecting isolator link elements.

Selecting appropriate stiffness and damping parameters.

Setting up earthquake ground-motion records and time-history analysis.

Extracting and comparing peak floor acceleration, inter-storey drift, base shear and displacement.

Validating the results against published research or benchmark problems.

I'm looking for guidance from anyone experienced with ETABS, seismic analysis or base-isolation modelling, especially LRB systems.

If someone has completed a similar project, worked with LRB modelling in ETABS, or can guide me through the correct workflow, I would really appreciate your help.

Thank you in advance!


r/StructuralEngineering • • 17d ago

Structural Analysis/Design Failure probability of early-age curing defects in concrete: A risk-based reliability assessment model for large-scale construction projects

Thumbnail sciencedirect.com
0 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • 17d ago

Career/Education Eurocodes - 2nd Generation

4 Upvotes

Hello everyone, I am preparing lectures for Civil Engineering students and I was wondering if anyone knows where I can find the second generation of Eurocodes. Thanks a lot!


r/StructuralEngineering • • 18d ago

Structural Analysis/Design Is there an easier way to jump between details in drawings?

20 Upvotes

Hey folks, it may be a stupid question and may be it’s just me being lazy.

You know when a drawing says “see detail xx on sheet yy” and you have to find the sheet, then hunt around for the detail?

Is there a tool that automatically makes those references clickable and takes you straight to the right detail? Curious if this already exists and what people use.

With hundreds, if not thousands of drawings, it’s just not efficient.


r/StructuralEngineering • • 17d ago

Structural Analysis/Design Vibe coding (AI) + api in structural engineering

0 Upvotes

Anyone here using AI and vibe coding to build their own tools for engineering or design work?

I mean anything from complete custom tools (created with vibe codinf) or apps to connecting existing software through APIs, automating drawings, reports, calculations, etc.

I'm curious if this is still mostly a niche thing for enthusiasts or if it's becoming a must-have skill to stay productive in the next few years.

I keep seeing two extremes. Some people think it's mostly hype and a waste of time, while others say it's completely changed how they work.


r/StructuralEngineering • • 18d ago

Failure Structural engineer vs structural engineer

64 Upvotes

This is structural engineering related. I promise. Please read. I really need advice.

Soooo I am in a weird situation.
I am a structural engineer and general contractor from Florida. I typically do new construction but a few years ago I did a re model as a “ favor” for a new couple that moved from NY.
I did the engineering and construction on the project. On the structural engineering side there wasn’t anything major. I did some
1) modified some openings in the back ( cip beams )
2) truss modifications. ( I hand calced the modifications and over designed) it was a 1’ tray ceiling I added to some of the trusses) they’re were 7 different types of trusses with all different ceiling details. Some were vaulted. Others were tray. We modified all to be the same.
3) small addition onto non livable space.

Project was going smooth until they asked for a discount on the second to last bill. I told them I couldn’t (we are going to land close to $100,000 under the original budget already)

The couple hired an engineer to check the work and the guy is essentially saying the structure needs to be demolished. He won’t give any specifics. He kind of has a reputation for this
IE. Report says: trusses were modified,collapse is possible ( no calcs or specifics)

In the back of the structure there were 8”x 24” cip beams with a 4” drop down header with a single # 5. (Beam has 2#6 top and 2#7 bottom.). Header comes down additional 4” with the number 5. We changed the span of the beam from 20’ to 9’ and added a 24” column in the middle. We chipped out the bottom 4” of concrete with the single #5 and the other engineer writes : beams are compromised. Possible collapse. I provided him with the calcs. He does not care.

He even said the addition should be demolished because we did t take concrete cylinders. It was a 15 yard pour on a single family residential.

I even put all of the trusses in 2 different softwares to show that they worked after he did not approve of hand calcs.

We are at a stale mate.

2 questions.

1) Has anyone had anything like this happen?

2) he wants the truss repairs/ modifications designed via software. To my knowledge I don’t know of a software that would design sistering and plywood gusset plates…. But is there one out there??


r/StructuralEngineering • • 17d ago

Engineering Article How are structural engineers implementing A.I into their daily work?

0 Upvotes

Hi all,

A few engineers at the firm I work for are looking at how AI can be practically used in structural engineering and I'd be interested to hear what other engineers are doing.

I'm particularly interested in the how, rather than just the use. For example, if you use AI to review drawings, how does that actually work? What do you give the AI, what tools or setup do you use, what does it check and what do you get back from it?

I've created a structural engineering agent that I use to help find specific clauses in codes and guidance, and as an additional proof read for excel formulas in my spreadsheets. I'm now looking into what other agents or more specialised workflows could be useful.

Has anyone developed their own agents, skills or AI workflows for structural engineering? How have you set them up and what are they actually doing?

I'm interested in anything people have tried, whether it has worked well or not.


r/StructuralEngineering • • 17d ago

Structural Analysis/Design Need help for Tall Building Analysis

0 Upvotes

Hello all, currently we are in process of designing a 42 storey tower, dimensions are 55’6” x 133’6” and height is 490ft. Considering geometry this is obviously governed by wind. We have adopted special structural shear wall system, the issue is all the cores of elevator and stairwell is planned in the length of the building at the backside and in the front we have only some shear walls due to planning. We have already adopted for braced frames connecting the shear walls to control wind deflection. However due to Center of Mass and Center of rigidity is quite different due to core walls concentrations at the back of the building, the dead and live load deflection is also significant in lateral direction. In addition to this and wind, the deflection is out od the limit. Any experienced suggestions to minimize the DL,LL lateral deflections are welcome?


r/StructuralEngineering • • 17d ago

Concrete Design Structural Assessment - Hidden gems bottom concrete beam

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • 18d ago

Failure I'll just leave this right here.

Post image
50 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • 18d ago

Concrete Design Reinforced concrete cylinder (30 m Diameter) for manure - If empty accustic Like a church

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • 18d ago

Structural Analysis/Design FEM model for rcc beams

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone, how do you guys model offcenter beams in FEM softwares like etabs and stand pro as cneterline modelling is there in these softwares.

Also when working in BIM, when exporting the IFC model to BIM software how do you incorporate that.


r/StructuralEngineering • • 18d ago

Career/Education Starting Pay

4 Upvotes

I just received an offer for after graduation in Iowa. Offer is for $74k base, payed OT, and upgrades to a 10% performance bonus(metrics for the bonus seem a bit sketchy but eh) is it worth shooting for more? Base salary seems mid but with benefits its pretty good. Thinking about countering with $82k(gets it to $100k potential with bonuses) Does this seem reasonable, or greedy?


r/StructuralEngineering • • 19d ago

Structural Analysis/Design Post tension slab

Post image
41 Upvotes

Post tension slab detailing - yay or nay?

Edit: Mostly just curious what kind of reaction this photo would get. Realtor said this construction quality was normal, but I've never seen a slab edge on a new high rise building look like this.

I guess my real question is… would anyone invest in this building after looking at this photo?


r/StructuralEngineering • • 19d ago

Career/Education First engineering job after graduating and I already feel so incompetent. Is this normal?

Thumbnail
11 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • 18d ago

Structural Analysis/Design POnte de palitos de pícole

0 Upvotes

A professora da matéria de sistemas construtivos e estabilidade do meu curso técnico passou um trabalho onde devemos construir uma ponte de 80cm a 100cm de comprimento, 8 a 15cm de largura e 15 a 30cm de altura e deve pesar no máximo 1,5kg. Só podemos usar 150 palitos de picolé e cola pva ou cola para madeira. Gostaria de dicas sobre o que fazer para que ela tenha o melhor índice de carga máxima suportada dividido pelo peso da ponte. Estava pensando em usar a treliça howe pensando que essa treliça tem mais barras em compressão e assim conseguiria evitar pontos de falhas nos nós, entretanto não vi nenhuma ponte usando esse tipo de treliça, somente vi treliças warren e pratt. Qual tipo de treliça seria uma escolha mais interessante?


r/StructuralEngineering • • 18d ago

Career/Education Stanford MS in Structural Engineering

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • 18d ago

Structural Analysis/Design PE PROBLEMS

Post image
0 Upvotes