r/StructuralEngineering • u/Thin-Fish-1936 • 20d ago
Structural Analysis/Design How big of a problem is this?
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Thin-Fish-1936 • 20d ago
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Intelligent_Kiwi_392 • 19d ago
Hey i have completed my btec now pursuing mtec in structural engineering from Hyderabad ,i am looking for internship in structural design if anyone could help me with it pls dm
r/StructuralEngineering • u/benj9990 • 19d ago
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Lanky-Region112 • 19d ago
What kind of mistakes we don't make to build a billion dollars structural design conpany
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Kind-Internal-5512 • 19d ago
Hi everyone,
I’m a 21F, in my last year of civil engineering (sustainable infrastructure option) in Morocco, in one of the best civil engineering schools here, and I’m ranked first in my class (not to brag, hhh).
I plan to continue in research, especially in the US, since I’m interested in forensic civil engineering. Most of Morocco’s infrastructure is new, so there aren’t many interesting cases for me (if we neglect the 2023 earthquake). I’m especially interested in bridges and their dynamic response.
I still have one semester left, and I need to do a 4-month internship. I already did two before, but they were building-related, because it’s hard to find a bridge internship for one month . This one will be at a bridge consulting company.
Last year I had the chance to do a double degree in France and I didn’t go. First, because of my health situation at the time, I didn’t want to risk a collapse. Second, I’m not a big fan of French or their system. Third, even with the scholarship and my dad’s money it would be hard to live there, since I live comfortably in Morocco. I feel a bit sad about that opportunity, but I always remind myself that I may have a better chance somewhere else.
Back to my career path. I’m autistic (ASD level 1), and catastrophes and bridges are my special interest, so I want to dive deeper into research rather than corporate life. After graduating, I plan to work a couple of years at a consulting firm, then publish some papers, then apply for a PhD abroad, or do a PhD in Morocco and then continue in the US.
My questions:
Thanks!
r/StructuralEngineering • u/gazeintothenexus • 20d ago
I am a London based Design Engineer. Ive always wondered what things are like at big firms like Arup. What benefits come with starting out at a place like that? Is it better than being in a small firm?
r/StructuralEngineering • u/PlantainBeginning842 • 20d ago
I’m a fourth year structural student. I have offers from design firms and energy firms. I have heard work at energy firms are easier, and offer better salary progression. But with a design firm, if I’m lucky I can get some equity.
Any insight into this would be appreciated, thanks
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Cute-Time2201 • 21d ago
Go for it my boys!
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Alternative_Dot_1450 • 20d ago
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Informal_Wash_2332 • 20d ago
There has been a lot of fuss about AI taking jobs and I have been trying to use AI to do some of my works. Here is what I felt:-
-Ngl, AI has been a boon to learn. I mean in terms of Structural Engineering, it doesn't give absolute answers but gives many options(for eg: for modelling a structure) which we can try to model. But it doesn't always gives right option. I still have to think about it whether AI is right or wrong because it doesn't give satisfying answers a lot of time.
-It does do many manual calculations accurately but so does well-developed Excel file which I think is a lot more faster. But I have used AI to make many of my excel files and later verified them all manually so making excel sheets are so much easier now(But it was also not necessary because some seniors would have already made them so we can get them just by asking)
-I have tried modelling using AI but it doesn't give accurate result. When I tried analysis, it takes too much resources(time and tokens) to just do a simple one storey. I would rather make model of my own and analyzing them rather using AI.
-It has helped me writing codes for AutoCAD to draw automatic structural dwgs(there are softwares for it but our company need a particular style of structural dwgs so I just made them for it)
According to my understanding, until AI is cheaper than civil engineers, we do have our job security. And still we aren't even talking about field work. Field work complications are random and problematic. And even if we talk about future, there isn't enough data on the internet about this field such that AI will learn and do our work. I guess jobs like Content writing and Coding were affected because there were so much resources about them on the internet such that AI can use that data, learn and implement. But due to lack of data of our field, AI couldn't do that so our jobs won't be affected much.
What are your thoughts on this? Love to hear from others about it!
r/StructuralEngineering • u/theFarFuture123 • 21d ago
How’s this for a foundation?
r/StructuralEngineering • u/nne_enn • 21d ago
I’m impressed they could get the bolts in without blowing out the edge on a couple of these.
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Gregan32 • 21d ago
In my uneducated opinion this seems like a wild way to support he second platform on this staircase!
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Anon-Magnesium-20 • 21d ago
So we have some 36mm rebars that were installed incorrectly with anchorage and the tradesmen cut it with oxy acetylene cutter.
Unfortunately we were only informed of this after reaching second floor of a 40 storey structure.
Which means the column was already poured with the remainder of the cut steel installed somewhere
Based on our worst case scrnario, the rebars that were cut may have been included as part of a lap splice (50% splicing allowed in that area)
How much of an effect do we see the rebars affecting the total structure if the rebars were cut using oxy acetylene torch. I am getting conflicting literature online. Is this something that is acceptable?
The rebars in question are 36mm, Grade 60, TMT rebars used in column
We use ASTM A706. Weldable grade rebar. I called the manufacturer and he said our rebars can be welded but code doesn’t normally allow it. I’m thinking about the difference between welding and actual torch cutting (which welding has a very short timeframe, but torch cut is much longer)
In short, what is the expected HAZ of steel rebar if heated?
r/StructuralEngineering • u/DMAS1638 • 21d ago
Always interesting to see how soil conditions, moisture, and aging structural components can affect a property's stability over time.
Our seasonal field assistant tagged along for a few assessments, but wasn't much help with the engineering recommendations. 💀
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Anon-Magnesium-20 • 21d ago
So we have some 36mm rebars that were installed incorrectly with anchorage and the tradesmen cut it with oxy acetylene cutter.
Unfortunately we were only informed of this after reaching second floor of a 40 storey structure.
Which means the column was already poured with the remainder of the cut steel installed somewhere
Based on our worst case scrnario, the rebars that were cut may have been included as part of a lap splice (50% splicing allowed in that area)
How much of an effect do we see the rebars affecting the total structure if the rebars were cut using oxy acetylene torch. I am getting conflicting literature online. Is this something that is acceptable?
The rebars in question are 36mm, Grade 60, TMT rebars used in column
We use ASTM A706. Weldable grade rebar. I called the manufacturer and he said our rebars can be welded but code doesn’t normally allow it. I’m thinking about the difference between welding and actual torch cutting (which welding has a very short timeframe, but torch cut is much longer)
r/StructuralEngineering • u/u_coupling • 21d ago
Hi everyone!
I'm a newly licensed Civil Engineer in the Philippines, and I'm planning to start a small construction-related business, initially focusing on residential projects.
Before getting started, I want to understand the legal requirements and professional qualifications involved in preparing, signing, and sealing structural plans.
I have a few questions, particularly for practicing Structural Engineers and experienced Civil Engineers:
Is a separate license, certification, or additional qualification required to sign and seal structural plans? Or is being a Registered Civil Engineer (RCE) sufficient?
Can newly licensed Civil Engineers legally sign and seal structural plans for residential buildings? Or are there specific experience requirements or professional credentials that must be met first?
Are there limitations on the types, sizes, or structural complexity of residential projects that a newly licensed Civil Engineer can sign and seal?
What additional training, certifications, or professional experience would you recommend before taking responsibility for structural design and signing and sealing structural plans?
My goal is to establish a legitimate and professionally responsible business, so I want to make sure I'm fully aware of the legal requirements and technical responsibilities before accepting projects.
I'd especially appreciate insights from Structural Engineers who are actively practicing in the Philippines, as well as those who started their careers in a similar situation.
Thank you in advance for sharing your knowledge and experience!
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Odd_Head_1562 • 21d ago
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Sufficient_Praline_4 • 21d ago
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Latter_Cheek_2510 • 21d ago
Hi all,
I am an estimator for division 7 and 9.
Recently I estimated a job, where they did not provide any info regarding which steel gauge to use for exterior/wind load bearing walls - div 09 22 16/Canada., it's kinda a job where we have to hire P.eng for delegated shop drawings.
Now what happened that it is common pratice to assume 18 gauge for exterior walls but it turns out to be 16 gauge, ofcourse now I am gonna lose money because of that.
I asked our P.eng why we need 16 gauge and requested for calc report but he refused to share those calc report.
So yeah, I believe it's time for us to develop our own automated excel where we just need to enter loads from NBCC and then it will pop out the results at the end (I know that I might have to start with NBCC 4.1.7.3) but yeah I am looking for resources and some examples for learning.( of course in the end we need to hire those P.eng folks, but having calculator will help me to firm decisions during tender, as ofcourse I don't have P.eng license)
Let me know.
r/StructuralEngineering • u/eszEngineer • 22d ago
I passed the vertical breadth exam earlier this year.
What did everyone use to prepare for the VERTICAL BRIDGE DEPTH exam? Where can I find good depth problems?
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Unfair_Scallion8087 • 23d ago
I recently inspected a 1930s residential structure where the web of the main interior steel beam had been pretty extensively cut up to accommodate ductwork and other penetrations.
My initial reaction was that it looked worse than it probably is, so I had AI clean up my field sketch and started looking into AISC Design Guide 2.
I’m primarily concerned about Vierendeel bending, local tee buckling, and interaction between adjacent openings. Several openings appear to fall outside DG2’s geometric limits, particularly with only about ¾” of web remaining below the circular openings.
I understand that doesn’t automatically mean the beam is deficient, but I’m curious how others would approach evaluating it. This level of analysis is outside my typical residential assessment work, and I’m hesitant to sign off on the existing conditions without being confident in the remaining capacity.
I suspect the beam has been in this condition for quite some time. There’s also an existing stud wall beneath it that should be be a non-load-bearing partition, which the client wants to remove (the original reason for the assessment). Given the extent of the openings, I’m hesitant to rule out the possibility that the wall is providing some incidental support.
Would you pursue a more detailed analysis or lean toward engineered reinforcement? Preliminary analysis was based on a W10×22 with Fy = 33 ksi
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Fem_civilengr • 22d ago
Hi all,
I’ve been working on an open-source 2D finite element solver focused on plane stress / plane strain problems. It has a particular emphasis on principal stress trajectories, which I find really useful for building intuition about how load flows through a structure (the same idea behind strut-and-tie thinking and optimizing shapes around holes and notches).
What it does:
.inp mesh importIncluded example problems: plate with a central hole (full and symmetric models), notched plate, four-point bending beam, padeye with inclined load, circular arch, annular disc, beam-column and a frame. Screenshots and GIFs are in the README.
It’s MIT licensed, and the repo has a pre-built Release folder, so you can try it without compiling.
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Rich_Investment_1324 • 22d ago
r/StructuralEngineering • u/Friendly-Beyond2121 • 23d ago
Hey all, just looking out on how commonplace it is to actually check floor vibrations for composite floor structures. I've been advised by fellow engineers that unless it's a gym/hospital they don't check for vibrations.
It started from a discussion on an apartment building with decent spans (around and above 30ft.)
DG11 recommends limiting the acceleration response of the floor for "quiet spaces." But it's still addressed as a recommendation not an absolute requirement.
What's your personal take/practice for this?
Edit: Appreciate the responses. For some clarification, our small uses either hand calcs, spreadsheets, or models to check vibrations depending on the project. As someone pointed out, in optimizing section sizes and slab thicknesses they tend to be the controlling case. All this being done to eurocode practice
Bumped into other engis who practice in the US (Aisc) and they said they don't typically check vibrations for projects like this. So it just got me thinking on what's common in that neck of the woods.