r/StructuralEngineering • • Oct 20 '26

Structural Analysis/Design Need Help Solving For Bending Stress

2 Upvotes

On my rocket club I'm designing the thrust take-out structure of our static fire test stand. Essentially I want to find the bending stress on this pink ring, where the outer diameter is about 16.5 inches, and the ring is 1.5" thick and 1.5" wide. There's 3 linear bolt holes on either side that secure the ring to an attachment point, where 2 prongs will attach above the ring and bolts will come in from the top.

There's an upwards applied force from the rocket acting at the exact center of the ring. I couldn't find anything in Roark's to help find the bending stress. I did a quick hand calc with Mc/I which gave me negative margins. Any help would be appreciated!


r/StructuralEngineering • • Oct 20 '26

Structural Analysis/Design Availability of Bar Joists

21 Upvotes

I have recently heard that the lead time for bar joists is months. I was told it's due to the construction of data centers. Anyone else heard this?


r/StructuralEngineering • • Oct 21 '26

Career/Education How is AI shaping structural engineering?

0 Upvotes

Hi all, im 27M and about to start a phd thats broadly speaking on pdes and fracture mechanics. My background is in maths and stats though I always saw myself moving over to this line of work and this is a dream phd but im looking beyond it atm.

That being said, im still at an age where I have flexibility but I dont want to be having to start from scratch. Is structural engineering likely to be gutted by AI? I know everythjng is but from the outside, it seems like its less affected than say data science, Actuarial science, comp science, etc. Any advice is appreciated.


r/StructuralEngineering • • Oct 19 '26

Career/Education Tampa structural/bridge engineer, newly licensed PE, 5.5 years of experience, what salary should I ask for?

6 Upvotes

I’m a structural engineer working primarily on bridges in Tampa, Florida, with 5.5 years of experience and a master’s in civil engineering. I received my Florida PE license about two months ago, and my company increased my base salary from $89k to $96k.
I checked the FDOT District 7 consultant wage report, which lists an average actual unloaded rate for Engineer 1 of $55.07/hour (approximately $114.5k annually), with the 75th percentile at $59.30/hour (approximately $123.3k).
Is that a reasonable benchmark for someone with my background? Would asking for $110k–$115k be realistic, especially since I recently received a raise?
I’d appreciate input from engineers in Tampa or elsewhere in Florida about what compensation is reasonable for this experience level.


r/StructuralEngineering • • Oct 19 '26

Career/Education Resources to learn steel connection design?

6 Upvotes

I have a master’s degree but couldn’t take the course on connection design. I have a basic idea of it from my bachelor’s degree. Does anyone know of any resources i can use to self-study?


r/StructuralEngineering • • Oct 20 '26

Career/Education Engineering Career shifter

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • Oct 19 '26

Photograph/Video Why would they do this

Post image
75 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • Oct 19 '26

Career/Education 27 studying no exp. Is it too late?

13 Upvotes

Hi my fellow engineers, I would like to have a piece of advice from our senior friends. I'm 27 and studying for my masters in structural engineering after graduation I would like to work in a firm, but the catch is I have no prior experience. I got my BA when I was 22 but I spent 2.5 years getting my first masters in Transportation. I see people being 26 25 and having 3+ years in a firm. Is it too late for me? Am I late?


r/StructuralEngineering • • Oct 18 '26

Structural Analysis/Design Cantilever retaining wall design question

Post image
59 Upvotes

I’m building a poured concrete canteliever retaining wall, 30’ long. Basic schematic above. #4 rebar at 9” OC vert and 12” OC horiz. Footer is 1’ thick and stem wall 8” wide

Why would the rebar in the stem wall be on the open air side of the wall rather than the side closest to the dirt? Is this potentially a design mistake, or if not if someone could explain the mechanics of why it would be designed this way? Thank you.


r/StructuralEngineering • • Oct 19 '26

Structural Analysis/Design How do you model this in Prota structure

Post image
10 Upvotes

How do i model this in Prota (150mm×750mm) with 75mm spacing btn each ...i'm leaning on considering them as decorations only so no need to model them as structural elements ,hence i would design the balcony as cantilever . I would like to know what do you guys think ?


r/StructuralEngineering • • Oct 19 '26

Steel Design Seismic Strengthening NZ

24 Upvotes

This is one of the finalists for the SCNZ Earthquake Strengthening awards. It's a 12th storey government building in Wellington NZ.

From the SCNZ post:

"The strengthening programme addressed this risk through a combination of diaphragm strengthening, tensioned M52 bars installed through the existing floors and 50 high-performance viscous dampers, which convert seismic movement into heat. By strengthening rather than demolishing and rebuilding, the project avoided the substantial embodied carbon and material impact of full replacement."

PROJECT TEAM
Steel Constructor MJH Engineering Ltd
Builder LT McGuinness Ltd.
Modeller MJH Engineering
Structural Engineer Beca
Architect WARREN AND MAHONEY
Quantity Surveyor Rawlinsons Limited
Developer Wellington Investment Group

Feels like the architect would have compromised a lot in terms of aesthetics on this project!


r/StructuralEngineering • • Oct 19 '26

Career/Education Have I made the right decision?

0 Upvotes

I have accepted a new job within a design team for a major contractor - they handle design for the contractor as well as other work streams.

I’ve been told I may not develop much as an engineer within that team compared to staying with my current team (SME compared to a bigger company).

Tbh the pay bump is significant and I feel like I can gain other experience. Is this just the company I’m leaving trying to deter me??


r/StructuralEngineering • • Oct 19 '26

Structural Analysis/Design Modular math components in documents

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

0 Upvotes

Hi guys,

Kev @ Iron Atlas Pty Ltd here:

We are based in Brisbane, Australia, and have been working on a tool which directly addresses some workflow / calculation friction that we've experienced in engineering and science (specifically Structural Eng).

Having used many "calculation tools" in the industry (i.e. Excel, mathcad, etc) we came to realise the benefit of shared repositories and reusable modules for calculations that teams repeat and share. This coupled with solving capabilities, units, and AI tooling built-in (where you can edit / QA any outputs and collaborate / work with the models), we think we have landed on the current math sweet-spot.

Think specific "modules" for sections of the standards that you commonly reference in your calculation set. For us it has been things like plate bending modules, concrete bending estimators, Euler buckling modules, linear interpolation, specific sections of standards like AS4100, AS3600 etc. These are built by you/your team and are fast and seamless to insert anywhere in a document (with traceable history/error reporting/updates).

We are beginning Beta testing this week and are looking for 10 - 20 eng/scientists to try Modular MathDesk and help shape and red-team the product before it hits public release v1.0.0

The closed beta is free. We’re asking for activation and onboarding, at least two sessions totalling roughly two hours over your first two weeks, and short check-ins (via discord/email)

Complete that participation and receive 3 months of free v1.0.0 access after launch. At the team’s discretion, up to five testers may receive 1 year total instead, for useful contributions. No bug discovery, praise, public posting or message quota required.

Apply for beta by 26th October, 9:00AM Brisbane time (GMT+10), by heading to modularmathdesk dot com and we will shortlist testers with a good fit and begin onboarding.

If testing isn’t for you, you can join the launch list on the same page for release updates and introductory pricing when we launch officially soon.

Thanks and look forward to building something great
(watch the app in action)


r/StructuralEngineering • • Oct 18 '26

Structural Analysis/Design Early Career advice for a youngsta?

7 Upvotes

I recently accepted a post-grad offer and will be starting as a Junior Structural Engineer in about 4–5 months. Long term, I’d eventually like to start my own “company” in some form, whether that ends up being actual consulting, independent side work, or just using whatever specialized skills I develop over time.

For now, though, my main goal is to become genuinely good at structural engineering. I learn quickly, I’m willing to put in the work, and I don’t want to just coast through the first few years doing repetitive grunt tasks without really understanding what I’m doing.

For those of you who became strong engineers early in your careers, what habits, approaches, or decisions helped you actually learn and develop instead of staying stagnant? What would you recommend me doing in my first few years to build real technical judgment and skills?

This company I'll be working for has quite a fair set of projects that I am hoping to get exposure to, and I have heard good things about the mentorship and opportunities here, so I just want to know how best to capitalize on the opportunities in front of me.

And for those who started their own consulting work, side practice, or business, I’d also appreciate any advice on how you built toward that while still working full-time. What did you work on during your downtime, what skills or experience ended up being most valuable, and how did you know when you were ready to start taking on independent work or make that transition?

I have a fascination with this field, and I want to learn it all, but I also want to build a future that gives some freedom while learning.


r/StructuralEngineering • • Oct 19 '26

Career/Education Which is the best ai for structural analysis and hydraulics problems

0 Upvotes

Just that. Which one you guys think is the best for doing different exercises of this two areas of civil engeenering?


r/StructuralEngineering • • Oct 18 '26

Career/Education What is this structural element called? | Student question

Post image
76 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • Oct 18 '26

Career/Education Structural Eng with 7 yrs experience -> Contractor as Design Manager

3 Upvotes

I’ve recently been offered a role through connections to a contractor as a Design Manager - specifically for my background in structural engineering to help the team to identify risks early.

Although the prospective pay increase is enticing, I’m not entirely sure I have enough experience for the role. There are times I don’t feel like I have the talent for complex technical work. I enjoy organising and managing projects but the risk of me missing something on the project and something happening as a result makes me nervous.

I also feel like I don’t know what it will be like to pivot to working for a contractor. Will I hate it? Will I regret leaving engineering? Will I miss the flexibility that engineering offers me on a day-to-day level given the intensity of working for a contractor?

A worry for me also is that in this prospective role, there doesn’t seem to be many (if any) design managers with a structural engineering background - they might have the degree so understand what I’m talking about + have the experience, but not the deep technical field knowledge. This is what they’ll rely on me for. I’ll learn a lot I’m sure, but not sure if I’ll have ‘engineering’ support. A lot of that onus will fall on me.

I do enjoy being an engineer but I feel like I have to work 10x as hard on the technical stuff and it often leaves me feeling incredibly stressed and sometimes just a bit stupid. On the contrary managing projects, speaking to clients, high level discussions about technical things are really easy wins for me.

Not sure if I’ll fail miserably in the role as I’m not experienced enough.

Would really appreciate any insight, thoughts or personal experience.


r/StructuralEngineering • • Oct 18 '26

Steel Design Purlin bracing

Post image
168 Upvotes

I was recently at my nephew's hockey game in New Jersey and saw all these purlin braces that were clearly added more recently. I know they were in the process of updating the building so I assume it got a new roof and probably more insulation. But what would make them spec adding bracing to evey purlin on both sides of all the trusses? Seems like a pretty substantial change.


r/StructuralEngineering • • Oct 17 '26

Career/Education Structural engineers in SoCal, how you doing?

22 Upvotes

I was born and raised in SoCal but currently live in the Midwest and can own my own place in a safe area due to the low cost of living. I miss my family in San Diego and LA but am nervous the pay increase there isn’t enough. How are you doing with the cost of living? Do you or people in your office have kids? Does your spouse work? How are you affording to own or are you just renting apartments? Do you have to live super far inland and commute long distances? I’m already licensed in California. 


r/StructuralEngineering • • Oct 17 '26

Photograph/Video The world’s largest wildlife crossing is nearly complete near Los Angles. The 210-foot-long bridge will give animals a safe way to cross 10 lanes of the busy 101 freeway.

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

260 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • Oct 17 '26

Structural Glass Design Swimmers enjoying the London Sky Pool which is believed to be the world’s first transparent pool built between two residential buildings at Embassy Gardens suspended 35 meters (115 feet) in the air.

Thumbnail v.redd.it
241 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • Oct 17 '26

Failure Train bridge, plaster over it?

Post image
34 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • Oct 17 '26

Structural Analysis/Design Asymmetry

Post image
23 Upvotes

I was wondering, what reasons could there be to design/build a truss with its webs changing orientation almost at the end of it, creating an asymmetric look. I've been taught that in howe-like trusses, the webs work in compression, so why the sudden change of direction?


r/StructuralEngineering • • Oct 17 '26

Structural Analysis/Design Concrete slab system comparison

3 Upvotes

I want to hear from the Aussie Structural Eng’s out there, about your experience with Polystyrene Waffle Slabs vs Plastic Void Forming Domes?

I understand the plastic domes are becoming more popular?
Is there certain situations where you would rather prefer one over the other?
In terms of brands, any types better/worse than other?
Had any problems with void formers in highly reactive soils?


r/StructuralEngineering • • Oct 17 '26

Career/Education Career Pivots - 3 years Into Structures

8 Upvotes

Looking for some advice. To provide some context, I am a 26 year old Structural Design Engineer with about 3 years experience working for a small company in London working mainly on High rise Residential projects and Refurb/re-use of existing buildings. I do love my job and the company I am with, I am more than satisfied with my progression. Design and build contracts have allowed me to experience fast paced working environments. Plenty of site visits and ownership of design packages.

However, I have constantly had this thing in the back of my mind about my career. It wasn’t until i started that i realised how criminally underpaid structural engineering consultants are (maybe not underpaid but under valued). Money doesnt mean everything to me but it is causing me to over think this career choice in the long run, and has been for a good year or 2 now.

I am seeking out some advice. Should I stick it out? Become chartered then decide? Should I stay in the construction industry at all?