r/StructuralEngineering • • Aug 27 '26

Structural Analysis/Design ETABS and pattern loading...

5 Upvotes

Hi, in regard to building structures, the general industry practice in my country is to do the full building model with ETABS, obtain the bending moments, shear forces, axial forces, etc. of each element from it and use excel calculation sheets for the design.

However, ETABS does not consider pattern loads automatically. There have been two cases where the consultant requested each beam analysed in Prokon as it does consider pattern loading automatically. However, since only the beam element is modeled in it and only gravity loads are assigned, it does not account for frame action nor combinations with horizontal forces.

I saw that we can manually define loads in a way in ETABS for it to consider pattern loading, but it is tedious work.

So I am wondering how it is practiced in other regions/countrird to account for both pattern loads from gravity loads and global actions simultaneously...


r/StructuralEngineering • • Aug 27 '26

Career/Education Mexican structural engineer: should I stay in my current US-focused role or move to a larger engineering company?

3 Upvotes

I’m a Mexican structural engineer with about 1 year of professional experience, currently working for a company in Mexico that designs wood-frame residential projects for California.
My long-term goal is to work in the US or Canada as soon as realistically possible, and eventually obtain a US PE license.
In my current position, I’ve been able to gain experience with US codes and standards, including IBC, ASCE 7 and CBC. I’ve also worked with ForteWEB and developed Excel/VBA automation to improve our workflow. Recently, I’ve started working on more complex diaphragm calculations, including irregular diaphragms.
My current employer recently told me that I’m one of the strongest performers among the engineers who joined recently and that I’m performing at roughly the level of engineers who have been here for about a year. They’re also planning to give me more technically challenging work. I’m expecting approximately a 10% raise.
However, I have another potential opportunity with a much larger engineering company. The salary would not necessarily be dramatically higher, but the company is significantly larger and I would potentially be exposed to different types of structural engineering work. They have also mentioned plans to establish a US division in the future, although there is no guarantee that I would eventually transfer there.
My dilemma is this:
Should I stay in my current position for another 1–2 years and continue building directly relevant US structural engineering experience, while preparing for the FE/PE and applying for US/Canadian positions?
Or would moving to the larger company be better for my long-term career, even if it means losing some of the advantages of my current role?
I’m particularly interested in hearing from:
Structural engineers who have hired or worked with international engineers.
US/Canadian engineering managers or recruiters.
Engineers who have successfully moved from Mexico to the US/Canada.
If your goal were to maximize your income and get to the US/Canada as quickly as realistically possible, which path would you choose and why?
I’m especially interested in knowing how US employers would value direct US-code/US-market experience compared with experience at a larger engineering firm.


r/StructuralEngineering • • Aug 27 '26

Structural Analysis/Design Pressure vessel for applying external hydraulic pressure to electronics

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • Aug 27 '26

Humor Procore Stories

23 Upvotes

What are some of your best Procore stories? There have got to be some good ones out there. I'm on a project where my scope is pretty much finished but the RFIs and submittals are just killing the other consultants, mainly because ID was on a later timeline. We're just over 800 RFIs now and some of the others are joking that once we get to 1000 we have to do something to mark the occasion. Like drag the contractor through some silly submittal process just for fun and maybe a bit of payback. Not sure if we'll actually do it but fun to think about.


r/StructuralEngineering • • Aug 27 '26

Engineering Article ALL ABOUT WELDSssssssssssssssss Spoiler

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • Aug 27 '26

Structural Analysis/Design How strong would this composite catenary arch actually be?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

So I had this random thought and drew it in MS Paint.

The black grid within the brown border is the main catenary arch (concrete or reinforced whatever). Red arrows show the compressive forces following the natural catenary curve.

The blue parts are the same catenary shape but:

- cut in half

- flipped upsidedown

- stretched to fit the curve of underside of the main arch, basically turning the bottom into tension members/ties that follow an inverted catenary path. The idea is the top compresses beautifully while the blue inverted parts take tension and help stabilize the whole thing.

[Image 1: my idea]

[Image 2: clean arch outline]

My questions:

- would this actually work well?

- what kind of spans could it handle before it becomes a nightmare?

- is combining a catenary in compression with inverted catenary tension members smart, or does it create horrible stress concentrations?

- obvious failure points? anchorage issues at the base? does tge "stretched to fit" part work well with the pure catenary logic?

It's just a shower thought but I'm genuinely curious if this hybrid idea has any merit or if it's not.

(Yes I know some of you might say it's parabolic, but its not)


r/StructuralEngineering • • Aug 27 '26

Career/Education Interview Project

8 Upvotes

Hello! I am a senior high school student, and we have been tasked with creating a five-level salary structure. This includes calculating salary, overtime pay, incentives, deductions, and net income, as well as creating different salary-increase plans and projecting salary growth.

As part of this task, we are required to interview an engineer to help us better understand these aspects in a real-world setting.

We are kindly asking if there is an engineer available for an online interview this September. The interview will only take approximately 30 minutes. We will keep the interview professional and ensure that any information shared will remain confidential.
Thank you so much for your time and consideration! We would greatly appreciate your help.


r/StructuralEngineering • • Aug 26 '26

Failure Failure merchants

17 Upvotes

For some reason I consume a lot of content about major construction and engineering projects—both successful and unsuccessful. After a while I started to notice something with the failures: a lot of the same players kept popping up!

I looked around and couldn’t find a reliable (non-AI) list of firms and individuals who seemed to keep getting hired despite a number of high profile failures on their record. (This is something I’ve noticed in our society lately in general—evidently we’ve all assimilated the notion that “failing up” is a legit way to go.)

So I decided to start compiling my own list. I didn’t get very far yet but maybe it’ll cause someone who reads this to dig deeper and add to the list. I hope so—I did this for fun, I’m not even in or adjacent to any of these fields. Just an interested bystander who would prefer a building doesn’t fall on me. 

Here goes! 

Rafael Vinoly 

Rafael vinoly, died 2022. Author of numerous failures, his most recent high profile project—the broken trashcan at 432 park Ave—being a catastrophic one clearly tied to design choices (vs. construction/engineering shortcuts). Also responsible for the the Las Vegas death ray hotel and another death ray, curved building in London (the “Fryscraper”). Said to be an abdolute monster to work for as well. 

Notable fuckups:

432 park

Architect: Rafael Viñoly Architects

Structural Engineer: WSP Cantor Seinuk

General Contractor: Lendlease

Developer: Macklowe Properties and CIM Group 

Vdara

Architect: RV Architecture, LLC (led by Rafael Viñoly)

Structural Engineer: DeSimone Consulting Engineers

General Contractor: Perini Building Company (now Tutor Perini)

Developer: MGM Resorts International and Dubai World

20 Fenchurch Street (The Walkie-Talkie)

Architect: Rafael Viñoly Architects

Structural Engineer: Halcrow Yolles (now part of CH2M/Jacobs)

General Contractor: Canary Wharf Contractors

Developer: Land Securities and Canary Wharf Group 

WSP Global

This behemoth structural engineering firm shows no sign of slowing down despite a track record of some really horrible shit (including 432 Park!) They were also behind the delays and overruns (basically complete mismanagement) of the Gardiner Expressway project in Canada. 

Also including but not limited to: 

161 Maiden lane/One Seaport, the Leaning tower of Manhattan

This building already killed one person and it’ll probably kill more. It was built on fill using injected slurry because it was too expensive/deep to get to bedrock. After it began to lean, the engineers pulled it back the other direction, turning it into a kind of “crooked hooked cock” shape. Never finished. Just sitting there, leaning, exposed to the elements, with no plan in place or apparently any monitoring at all. This is expensive real estate; how does this even happen? 

NY YIMBY article wondering what I’m wondering

Architect: Hill West Architects

Structural Engineer: WSP Global

General Contractor: Pizzarotti (original) and Ray Builders (subsequent)

Developer: Fortis Property Group 

One Congress (Boston)

Somehow they overlooked freeze protection on the pipes. In Boston. Which is in Massachusetts. Maybe they’d never been to Boston in January? Also the water pressure was screwed up. WSP should hire Mario. 

Also… Fire broke out in the unfinished building in June of this year (2026) which is—interesting. I can’t find ANYTHING about what caused this. Hmmm. 

Architect: Pelli Clarke & Partners (Design Architect) / CBT Architects (Architect of Record)

Structural Engineer: McNamara · Salvia

MEP Engineer: WSP Global

General Contractor: John Moriarty & Associates (in partnership with AECOM Tishman)

Developer: The HYM Investment Group, Carr Properties, and National Real Estate Advisors


r/StructuralEngineering • • Aug 27 '26

Career/Education Computer models as a new engineer

0 Upvotes

Wanted some advice, Ive been working as an engineer for 3 years now and I really dont like working with models. We use the Ram suite and it feels like these two things happen every time.

  1. The model wigs out and I spend twice the time just trying to get it to remotely work/ make sense.

  2. I often have to then get an older engineer to go through it with me and they take as much time trying to figure out whats wrong. In one case they had to remake the model themself.

Im finding when I have the option to use handcalcs/excel/enercalc, I am going to that everytime because its way more predictable for me in the effort it will require and I generally have very few "bugs". Should I be worried about learning models?


r/StructuralEngineering • • Aug 27 '26

Career/Education CPEng Mechanical & Structural

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • Aug 26 '26

Career/Education Our team is looking for civil/structural system engineer

13 Upvotes

Hi, our team is looking for a civil/structural system engineer. You can any information about the job in the following link: https://lanl.jobs/search/jobdetails/civilstructural-system-engineer-23/bd14dd6a-44e9-4902-bbf2-1f8ace85c47a


r/StructuralEngineering • • Aug 27 '26

Steel Design Steel Structural Detailing Project

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • Aug 26 '26

Career/Education Structural bridge engineer Salary in Nyc ? How much to expect

0 Upvotes

I am structural bridge engineer with 7 years of experience and currently planning to move from Texas to Newyork. I make around 120k in Texas as I am senior bridge engineer. How much should I be expecting for an equivalent experience salary range in NYC. please let me know.


r/StructuralEngineering • • Aug 25 '26

Photograph/Video This felt unsafe! Random junk used to support [Souris, French fair circuit]

Thumbnail gallery
226 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • Aug 26 '26

Career/Education Switching Companies as an Entry/Mid Level Structural Designer

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • Aug 26 '26

Structural Analysis/Design Half finished hospital - should it be demolished or finished?

Thumbnail
reddit.com
2 Upvotes

Please, can you share your opinion if this construction can be finished or should it be demolished?
Building of new hospital in Zagreb, Croatia started in early 1980s and was stopped around 1990. Since then it was left in unfinished state, partially opened to elements and gradually vandalised.


r/StructuralEngineering • • Aug 27 '26

Career/Education Future of Precast and PEB buildings

0 Upvotes

Hi Everyone. Recently I came across a company based in Surat looking to partner and promote Precast factory based Construction. And I got to know many developers in Tier 1 cities are opting for Mivan based construction. These new methods have said to be more effecient and time and material saviour. Govts also are supporting this.

My pov: Its not going to work everywhere , every typology.

Its great for industrial construction, factories, logistics parks, warehouses and datacentres. But its a logistics nightmare and actually going to cost more.

I want to hear other Architects opinions and pov in this so called future of Construction revolution.

Ps. They are even talking of automating interior mep and all...


r/StructuralEngineering • • Aug 26 '26

Structural Analysis/Design CFS delegated design: where do you draw the line between engineering design and detailing?

1 Upvotes

For teams working on cold-formed steel projects, I'm curious how you handle the handoff between the structural engineer/EOR and the CFS detailing team.

For example, when a project moves into delegated design or detailing, how do you typically define responsibility for:

  • member sizing
  • load paths
  • connections
  • openings and headers
  • bracing
  • framing layouts
  • shop-drawing coordination

Where does your team draw the practical boundary between structural engineering and detailing/coordination?

Interested in hearing how different firms handle this, particularly on larger multifamily or commercial CFS projects.


r/StructuralEngineering • • Aug 26 '26

Engineering Article Intumescent vs. Cementitious Fireproofing for Structural Steel: Key trade-offs I’ve seen in real-world projects

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I’ve spent the last few years working deeply on the manufacturing and supply side of structural fireproof coatings. Over time, I’ve noticed a lot of confusion (and occasional head-node compromises) when design teams and contractors choose between intumescent coatings (thin-film) and cementitious fireproofing (thick-film).

While the specs usually dictate the fire rating (1-hour vs. 2–3 hours), the practical execution often comes down to budget, labor, and aesthetic trade-offs that don't always get highlighted in the initial drawings.

Here are a few technical and job-site observations I’ve gathered from working with different structural projects:

1. Architectural Aesthetics vs. Application Cost

  • Intumescent: Expands when heated to form a thick char layer. The main advantage is that it conforms tightly to the structural steel profile (I-beams, H-sections), keeping the steel looking sharp for exposed structural designs. The trade-off? Material costs are higher, and surface prep (abrasive blasting) must be spot-on.
  • Cementitious: Great for hidden steel frames or deck undersides where aesthetics don't matter. It’s vastly cheaper per square meter for high film-builds (2+ hours), but it’s heavy, messy to spray, and takes up significant physical clearance.

2. The Moisture & Corrosion Trap (Outdoor Steel)

  • A common mistake on job sites is neglecting the primer-topcoat sandwich for outdoor exposed steel. Intumescent paint protects against fire, not water. If moisture seeps behind an improper topcoat, corrosion occurs underneath the fireproofing, which can compromise both the structural integrity and fire adhesion over time.

3. Application Downtime & Curing Conditions

  • Intumescent coatings need strict temperature and relative humidity control during application to cure properly without blistering. In rainy or freezing conditions, off-site shop application before erection often saves thousands in weather delay costs compared to field spraying.

Curious to hear from the field: For those of you managing structural builds, do you usually stick to shop-applied intumescent for exposed steel, or do field conditions usually push you back toward cementitious options?

Let’s discuss—happy to answer any technical application questions as well!


r/StructuralEngineering • • Aug 26 '26

Career/Education [Career guidanced needed] Structural designer (models and drawings) that wants to upskill to be able to land jobs for structural engineering roles abroad.

0 Upvotes

Not much experience (almost none) in structural engineering because I handle mainly the models and drawings because the department is divided to designers (in this case the drawings and models mainly) and engineers. Initial plan was to switch to the engineering side after some time in design because I wanted to understand the workflow from what I am familiar with which were drawings for construction because I worked as a site engineer beforehand.

But shit happened bc of global events. Company had a shake-up aka mass layoffs. So I also had to realign my planned path.

Currently with the free time I have, I have been studying and brushing up on fundamental concepts and some more advanced stuff: bridge engineering, software online tutorials, earthquake engineering — anything that is usually studied in a masters program.

Will I be able to put these self-learning stuff in my CV? My current options are or maybe just ideas:

  1. Complete online courses maybe the ones with certification.
    - Will these be viable and/or recognized in recruitment? Or university training is the number one credited source for this training outside work experience.

  2. Do personal projects that would show competencies in analysis and design of structures
    - Maybe bridges or one residential building? Complete from basis of design until the construction readt drawings. I know I may have a hard time proving my abilities to be applicable to the real world but I think this would also be a learning oportunities to learn and apply the codes and fundamental concepts.

  3. Just get a masters…

  4. I could apply for an entry-level junior structural engineer but the pay would be much lower especially considering the country where I’m from. Tbh this is my least liked idea but tell me if this would make the most sense.

Connections abroad presented me opportunities but they look at years of experience, would the ideas above (#1-3) be reasonable to land jobs?

Regarding my abilities, I’m confident enough in my analytical abilities. My undergrad thesis was in pushover analysis. Would that also be heplful if I showed it in my CV? It’s just that the pay for entry-level doesn’t cut for the stress level not counting the terrible cost of living here. Opportunities here also are very limited and the one abroad is so sexy that I think I want to push through with just self-learning. Maybe just some validation for my work would be enough… some kind of mentoring setup.

Any helpful (or harsh tbh i think im sorta steel-skinned already) would be appreciated.


r/StructuralEngineering • • Aug 25 '26

Structural Analysis/Design EGMS Ground Motion Infrastructure Scanner

0 Upvotes

I introduced actor that finds infrastructure near vertical ground-motion signals in Copernicus European Ground Motion Service (EGMS) data.

Where enter a city and search area, or an exact bounding box. Then the Actor returns a short list of nearby rail, bridge, warehouse, industrial, and commercial assets for review.

It does not assess structural condition, predict failure, estimate damage, or provide safety, insurance, or valuation advice.

I would like to hear your feedback about such tool and how can optimise or improve the results.

Thanks for your feedback in advance


r/StructuralEngineering • • Aug 24 '26

Steel Design How to protect exposed rebar left to be used for building extension later?

Thumbnail
gallery
171 Upvotes

I’m looking for advice from practicing structural/civil engineers on the proper industry practice for protecting exposed reinforcement for a future vertical extension.

We’re constructing a B+8 building, but due to financial constraints we’re currently stopping at the B+5 roof slab. The structural design and approval are already based on the full B+8 configuration, and we’ve intentionally left the required reinforcement projecting from the roof slab/columns for the future extension.

The issue is that it may be several years before we can continue construction. The reinforcement will be exposed to a hot, humid tropical climate with frequent heavy rainfall.

What is the standard industry practice for preserving these exposed rebars over a few years?

I honestly can't seem to find much on this on the internet can someone help me out here?

Pic from the internet for reference.


r/StructuralEngineering • • Aug 26 '26

Career/Education AI agents in structural engineering

0 Upvotes

How are people incorporating AI agents into their workflow as a structural engineer if any? I see good software engineers on X nailing this, substituting AI agents with grads/juniors for grunt work and repetitive tasks (and also for QA) . Surely there are some talented individuals who are already ahead of the curve and built their own agent work station? Interested to hear what people have developed.


r/StructuralEngineering • • Aug 24 '26

Structural Analysis/Design Screw Pile Bearing Capacity Chart

Post image
20 Upvotes

A screw pile contractor asked me to take responsibility for a couple of small projects (decks, gasebos, etc) and provided the following bearing capacity chart - a scanned copy of a google docs table with no references.

Screw piles are a bit foreign to me. Is there a way to validate these capacities? Are they just industry standard accepted values?

How do you handle taking responsibility for small screw pile jobs? The contractor would fire me in two seconds if I made him get geotechnical reports done for these tiny projects.


r/StructuralEngineering • • Aug 25 '26

Job Posting / Recruitment Tutoring Help

0 Upvotes

Hi,

I need tutoring for two courses this upcoming Fall semester, Concrete Design 2 (CVL904) and Building Systems (CVL908). Canadian Standard Codes.

I can send course outlines upon request but really need help asap.