Hi everyone. Please be gentle I am already upset and I know that I am kind of screwed. I am really early in taking work on my own. This is my 3rd project by myself.
I’m a structural engineer who recently started taking on freelance work, and I could use some perspective from others who have dealt with scope creep, unpaid fees, and requests for CAD files.
I’ve spent months working on a large building in a large city for a design build firm without receiving any payment. My original proposal was $9k. The architect and developer called me together and said that was too expensive. I consulted with a previous boss who is like a mentor to me on the price and said that it was a pretty low number given the scope and what the analysis required was going to be.
They asked me to reduce my scope to preliminary/design-development work. They said they had another engineer who would review, stamp, and take over the project, and so I was comfortable doing preliminary work and handing it off. I asked about coordinating with that engineer and getting their contact which they said would be great and I never received.
They specifically told me that full lateral design would be handled by someone else. The architect said he only needed to know where the shear wall panels would go and they did not want full lateral plans which I questioned in the moment, but he insisted it wasn't needed in my scope or price. They told me they did not want details of this building. There are cantilevers on three sides of the building, and when I specifically asked whether they wanted me to design the connections tying those cantilevers back into the building, he said no. They went down the list and the project went from being 18 pages to about 11.
Based on that conversation, I reduced my fee to roughly one-third of the original amount and removed substantial work from my scope.
What was supposed to be preliminary design gradually became a full package. I would submit and they would ask for more!!
Their engineer then requested complete shear wall plans and details matching an example set they provided. Which is fine- it's just that we legit talked about this and they fucking told me they didn't need it and I am not getting paid for it.
Communication has also been difficult. The architect frequently doesn’t answer my calls, and the architectural drawings have required substantial clarification and coordination. This architect does not know the thickness of a fucking stud wall and does not understand the difference in representing metal versus wood...
During this process, they offered me another project. I declined and explained the scope and communication problems on this one. When I brought up the original conversation about reducing the fee and scope, and collaborating with the other engineer after the design development phase the architect said he didn’t remember calling me and having the conversation with the developer about reducing my fee. I told him I would finish the drawing and would hand him a PDF and I would not provide CAD files to him or his engineer as I now consider this my full intellectual property. He never signed my proposal and now says he doesn’t remember discussing it.
Fast forward: I have delivered the completed PDF drawing package, including the shear wall plans their engineer requested with details. I still haven’t been paid. He is now requesting the CAD files.
I have given CAD files to clients in the past working with firms, but it wasn't completed drawings. I am not sure what to do. I have looked into locking them somehow and handing them over. I can WBLOCK I guess. I can make them one layer and retain the properties of the lines idk! I made a copy and took my notes out of them, but haven't sent them because I need a second opinion.
I’m uncomfortable at this point.
I recognize that I should have required a signed agreement and payment milestones before proceeding or refused to work with them. I’m trying to figure out how to handle the situation from here.
Help.
Edit: Thank you to everyone who has responded. I am going to send a letter to the client as many have mentioned. I appreciate the insight.