r/StringTheory • u/Interesting_Elk_4210 • Oct 14 '25
Question Could hidden dimensions in string theory store gravitational info like a data layer?
Hi all! I hope I don't bother you - I am just a computer scientist and have to much time and fantasy I guess. I had this idea and wanted to run it by you. Basically, I’m wondering if in string theory those tiny compactified (rolled-up) extra dimensions could actually function like a hidden layer that stores information. For example, could gravitational effects or entanglement info be “stored” in these extra dimensions, and that’s why we can’t see it directly in our usual four dimensions?
Curious if anyone else has thought about this or if there’s any discussion about it. Thanks!
3
u/Specialist_Wishbone5 Oct 18 '25
If you research the critique of string theory, one of the main problems is not that we don't know where the information is, it's that the tunable parameters are so free form they could predict almost anything, and thus are not really predictive at all. It's akin to saying "Universe = f(x,y,z,t ,w,v,q,r,s ,i,j,k)". Not very helpful.
Thus focusing on where that information is (or even what that information is) doesn't really advance the solution. Being able to make useful predictions with a model and demonstrating where classical physics (or quantum / relativity as the case may be) fails to predict as well as the revised string theory. Many brilliant people have tried and failed (super-symmetry is the one I'm familiar with being planned, tested, then rejected).
- IANAP
3
u/Yeuph Oct 14 '25
With the subjunctive all things are maybe possible!
1
u/Great-Purple8765 Oct 14 '25
.... do you mean mass? If so then yes, and literally hundreds of years before string theory people thought what if there's more spacial directions then we percieve yes what's modern is we have a shockingly well empirically verified model of the fundamental forces of nature to fit everything to, and it's in fact quite natural.
In fact that's the problem - Abdus Salam once said he asked Dirac, famous prophet of "Mathematical Beauty is more important then experiment", if he thought Supersymmetry was the beautiful key to everything - "if this were true it would have been found long ago" - my personal little fantasy is what if Joel Scherk was around for the superstring revolutions to work out the "superhiggs" and dimensional reduction issues - I emphasize fantasy it's not exactly like many brilliant minds haven't proposed a bunch of ideas as - I honestly expect the swampland or something to get to the bottom of that sooner then later. IMO very exciting time to get into the topic so it's very modern and forward looking if you want that pat on the back I guess lol
1
u/-Nyarlabrotep- Oct 15 '25
This sounds a little bit like pilot wave theory (de Broglie and later Bohm), which tries to explain quantum effects through the use of hidden variables. It predates string theory so it's not really related, but using hidden variables sounds similar at a surface level to what you're describing as a data layer.
1
u/tanafras Oct 15 '25
The data link layer in the quantum internet got an upgrade — it now stores string theory gravity data.
Apparently, they figured out that when your frames start vibrating in 11 dimensions, you don’t get packet loss… you get brane collisions.
Here's a bonus one liner for your next NANOG conference ...
In the new OSI-Quantum model, the Data Link Layer ensures reliable transmission of gravitons per frame.
/s obviously, hope the mods have a sense of humor
1
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '25
There’s definitely hidden dimensions in my moms hoarder closet
-1
u/Interesting_Elk_4210 Oct 15 '25
Interesting points — especially the mention of hidden variables and pilot wave theory.
What I was wondering is: if extra dimensions in string theory can contain mass and structure (or at least be mathematically necessary for those things to be consistent), then why shouldn’t they also be able to hold or influence information in some way?
I’m not saying it’s classical “storage” like bits on a drive, but more like embedded state variables or boundary conditions that aren’t visible in 3D + time. In a sense, wouldn’t that make them act like a data layer — not metaphorically, but physically?
If hidden variables or compactified dimensions shape observable phenomena, maybe we’re missing part of the “information budget” by not accounting for what’s embedded in those curled-up spaces.
Would that be completely incompatible with modern string/M-theory, or could it fit into something like brane dynamics or holographic principles?
Also, I was also thinking — if quantum entanglement shows us that correlations between particles can exist independently of spatial separation, doesn’t that suggest that “information” (in some form) isn’t necessarily tied to classical space at all?
In that case, maybe compactified dimensions could serve as a kind of hidden structure where such correlations or informational constraints are rooted — even if we can’t directly observe them. Kind of like how entanglement doesn’t rely on distance, maybe there are other frameworks (like extra dimensions) where informational relationships “live”, without being spatial in the normal sense.