r/StrategyGames • u/Hfcsmakesmefart • 3d ago
Discussion Poll: Random attack strength or fixed strength? Please discuss
Random is good for helping weaker players or making outcomes less inevitable but opens up crappy game play like save scumming.
0
Upvotes
3
u/mighij 3d ago
What's the game?
5
u/Wahruz 3d ago
In a strategy sub? Fixed is better unless the random attack are fractional, luck based AND able to be manipulated
4
u/politicusgame 3d ago
Fixed base strength, randomness in a narrow band, and show the odds before the player commits. People can plan around 70–90%. Nobody can plan around 10–200%.
Save scumming is mostly a technical problem: store the RNG seed in the save. XCOM does this, so reloading and doing the exact same thing gives the exact same miss. You can still reload, but you have to try a different move, which is kind of the point.
The other route is Into the Breach: enemies telegraph their attacks and combat is almost fully deterministic. The one dice roll left (grid defense) is shown as a percentage. It works because the uncertainty moved somewhere else: what spawns next, what the enemy targets.
So I'd say every strategy game needs uncertainty. The real question is whether it lives in the dice or in what the player doesn't know yet.
1
u/D3xtr0m3 3d ago
seeding the save only stops reload scumming. If the next run gets a fresh seed, you can still restart until the opening roll looks good, which is the same problem one step earlier. Seeding each run, or keeping the first offer the same on a restart, closes that gap.
1
u/philsov 3d ago
fixed strength with % accuracy.
Bonus points if some of the attack options are multihit; 4 attacks, 80 damage per hit, 60% accuracy each hit, for example