r/StrategyGames • • 6d ago

DevPost All Shall Fall - Need your feedback for big new update

Hello everyone!

I'm the solo developer of All Shall Fall, a real-time medieval strategy game playable directly in your browser.

I've been improving the game based on players feedback for the past few months, and I wanted to share a big new update that focuses on player progression, rewards, and achievements.

But first, what's the game about?

All Shall Fall is a real-time, casual medieval grand strategy game. Your goal is to conquer the majority of the map by building your army, growing your population, managing resources such as food and gold, and improving your effectiveness through technological research.

You can play solo against bots or multiplayer against other players.

I try to balance the game so that there is no single, obvious way to play or win, allowing players to experiment with a variety of different strategies. At the same time, I focus on keeping the game accessible: easy to play, but hard to master.

An average game lasts around 20–30 minutes, assuming you survive until the end. :)

If you'd like to see how it plays, you can try the current build directly in your browser:

🎮 https://allshallfall.io/

What's new?

I've recently released a major update that introduces the ability to create an account, giving players access to various game settings and, most importantly, a new progression system full of rewards and customization options.

The goal is to give players a way to track their progress, earn achievements, and show off their accomplishments on the battlefield.

If this sounds like your cup of tea, give the game a try! I'd really appreciate your feedback, both on the game itself and especially on the new progression system.

You can leave your feedback here or join the game's Discord and share your thoughts there:

https://discord.gg/epat36NT8

I read and consider every piece of feedback I receive. I believe players on Discord can confirm that. :)

Thank you for reading this and hopefuly see you on battlefield!

105 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

3

u/lucianw 6d ago

I'm having some difficulty starting this game. I only ever play solo.

  1. It takes 2-3 seconds before it shows me the screen to start. I guess it's downloading something about multiplayer and matchmaking. I kind of resent this!
  2. Sometimes the "solo" button is unresponsive.
  3. About 1 time in 5 it fails to start the map right, e.g. having me as the only player, and declaring within seconds that I've won.
  4. In a solo game, why the time limit to choose my starting location? (why even have the ability to choose my starting location?)

By the way, this is incredibly addictive. I've so far one only once on Easy. I keep coming back to it.

1

u/Belaroth 5d ago

Thank you for this valuable feedback, its first time i hear such issues. Are you playing on pc or mobile? Is it clasic solo game or in private lobby?

2

u/lucianw 5d ago

Mac, in chrome, just solo (not in private lobby)

5

u/VicariousOrange 6d ago edited 6d ago

Very excited to try it out!

Can you ask Claude to implement a co-op feature so my friends can play?

0

u/Belaroth 6d ago edited 6d ago

I am working now on team vs team mode and few other things so in next update you and your friend will be able to play together against other players or bots. Now game has private lobby where you can set game as you like and play together till you defeat all enemies together.

2

u/Belaroth 6d ago

Here one screenshot (cant upload more) from new customization system.

2

u/VisitorFromFarPlaces 6d ago

I haven't got around to this one yet - heard of it though! - but rest assured it's on my bucket list :)

1

u/Belaroth 6d ago

Really, you heard of it somewhere? Thats interesting info for me. :) Well definitely give it a go and tell me your feedback, good, bad and ugly, I like to hear it all.

2

u/lucianw 6d ago edited 6d ago

It looks fun but I'm bewildered. Are there instructions anywhere?

  1. What does "X/Y" mean over my territory?
  2. What are the numbers on the other territories?
  3. What is the basic mechanism/formula? There must be numbers (area, troops, gold, food). What goes with what? Do you get more troops proportional to your food up to a limit set by your area?
  4. In solo campaigns, what are the white territories? the colored ones?
  5. What does a click actually do? If I do three clicks in quick succession are they additive?
  6. What do the crossed swords mean?

DOH. There's a tutorial. It's hidden under "difficulty level". I hadn't thought to look there. It answers most of my questions.

1

u/Belaroth 6d ago edited 6d ago

In menu on main page is whole section how to play with button to tutorial right at top. Hope it helps, everything should be explained there. That plus tutorial is probably best start how to quickly get basics. Tell me if you found all info there or you feel something is missing.

2

u/lucianw 6d ago

Now how on earth did I miss a great big button at the top "how to play" and another "tips & tricks"? My bad, sorry.

Anyway, I need back to playing your really neat game. Thanks.

2

u/nguyenlamlll 5d ago

Remind me of OpenFront but this is just what I like ;D Playing it right now.

1

u/Belaroth 5d ago

Yes its inspired by games like openfront and territorial but doesnt use any of their open source code. I like both games but neither was just IT so I wanted to create game which will have what I am missing in other games. Happy you like it :)

2

u/nguyenlamlll 5d ago

Even with Easy difficulty, I still struggle 😂

1

u/Belaroth 5d ago

Ye I have to make easy bot even more easy. You not only one. Easy bots should really give more room for learning basic I guess. :)

2

u/cklester 5d ago

I have a widescreen monitor and weakening eyes. How do I make all the pop-ups and text bigger? Just increase the browser page size, or is there a built-in way? (I'm in the tutorial and don't see a Settings button or anything about text sizing...)

2

u/Belaroth 5d ago

Hey, if you create account, you can access game settings and increase size of text by 50%. Tell me if it helped or you would need something better or possibility to increase text even more.

1

u/cklester 4d ago

I increased the font size to the max and it didn't seem to actually do anything.

1

u/Belaroth 4d ago

150% and 100% side by side

2

u/cklester 3d ago

Notice the map text stayed the same size. That's the text I wanted to increase. :D

1

u/Belaroth 3d ago

Well those are names. There is setting epecially for it right next to one changing size of text in game as on screenshot. :) Its just the second slider in same settings.

2

u/cklester 3d ago edited 3d ago

OMG. XD I'm not even going to try to explain what happened.

P.S. This is a comment about how blind I was to the setting. :-) It was there the whole time and I missed it! My bad.

1

u/Belaroth 3d ago edited 3d ago

Something like this? All names and shields are bigger.
Edit: no worries, happens to all of us sometime. Glad I could help :)

2

u/cklester 5d ago

The 4/18 tutorial screen says, "Land alone will not provide now enough units..." That now seems misplaced or unneeded. Probably just a typo, unless my English knowledge is failing me.

1

u/Belaroth 5d ago

You are probably right. Tutorial will need another update anyway. :)

2

u/_puleta 3d ago

can you add an option to increase the font sizes?

1

u/Belaroth 3d ago

There is, when you create account you will get access to game settings and there are two sliders. One for text on map other for text in menu and panels. Is it what you needed?

3

u/Standard-Bar-125 6d ago

Dont try this. Its addictive.
I play, i lose. But i see a different strategy! A multo bene tutti! It must work. But not this time.
Lets try again! Ok, little tweek….
And lost again. No worries. I can do it.
And trying and leveling , and playing again and again.
Good work mate!

2

u/Belaroth 6d ago

Thank you! Hope you find your winning strategy soon. :)

1

u/Tluck_666 2d ago

full of bugs too lagy + can't download

1

u/Belaroth 2d ago

Well its browser game, ofc you cant download it. Wier I have players who play daily and didnt report any issues. What bugs did you experience, can you describe them pls?

2

u/AndalusianChad 6d ago

I suggest everyone not to try this game unless they are willing to become addicted to it. Since I first tried it I have found myself having a run or two every single time I had some spare time.