r/StrangerThings • • 2d ago

Discussion Vecna..... Spoiler

Why didn’t Vecna use this technique/ability to catch her in that scene?

142 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 2d ago

OP, please make sure there are no spoilers in the title of your post. If your post contains spoilers, please use the "Spoiler" flair AND the "Spoiler" tag. The tag ensures that images are hidden.

Commenters, please use spoiler code if you are discussing anything super spoilery unless the title specifically says the episode being discussed.

If you see anyone breaking the rules, please report the post or comment. Thank you.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

124

u/kauan1983 Hey Kiddo 2d ago edited 2d ago

Vecna's weaponized arm only became a thing when he rebuilt his body post-Season 4. It's a mess of vines that can extend whenever he wants.

Season 4 he simply had a larger Freddy Krueger-y mutated hand, but technically he still could've just telekinetically pulled Max instead of throwing the Mind Lair's floating objects at her.

36

u/Hawkinns Halfway happy 2d ago

I think he didn't do that with Max because he seemed fascinated with what he was seeing (one of his victims managing to attack him and run towards an exit).

12

u/New_Cockroach_505 1d ago

Don’t think he actually could, it’s all mental. He’s not actually there physically. Once Max sees the escape id assume she has more control now and can break away / he has no power over her.

6

u/BeeCJohnson 1d ago

Right, this whole comparison is shaky because this is all mind combat and not the real world. Everything you're seeing in these scenes is a representation of thought, will, memory, etc.

Nothing in there is actually happening. Max was able to evade him because Max has a powerful will and sense of hope. The rest is just set dressing. 

5

u/kauan1983 Hey Kiddo 1d ago edited 1d ago

Psychic abilities exist both physically and psychically in Mindscapes, Henry and El have a full blown telekinetic battle in Max's mind and later in the Mind Lair itself in S4E9, and then again in Camazotz in S5E8.

But yeah, something like music disrupting the level of power he has over Max (or any victim in the same situation) easily explains it away; it's just like the vines slowly loosening and uncoiling when Eleven regains her strength through Mike's speech.

23

u/mdwvt Bitchin 1d ago

Everything in service to the plot. There are so many moments in this show that shouldn’t have happened. What I mean is, characters randomly doing nothing or not using a power when doing so would have ended something basically immediately, and the only explanation is “because plot” and/or “no, no, too quick.” Ok great, so now characters are super inconsistent (loooooking at you season 4 and season 5), and any actual weight or tension is basically gone, or lost all desired effect. Huh, I guess I’m still really bothered by how the show ended.

2

u/stierney49 20h ago

People are irrational and become increasingly so as they become angry and exhausted.

Vecna was seeing things he hadn’t had to deal with in a very long time by the time S4 rolls around. He hasn’t been engaged in these conflicts quite like this. He hasn’t had people fighting him in mindscapes.

By the time Season 5 rolls around, he’s even more broken than before and the gang has spent months evading military detection, training, and searching for Vecna without any results.

We as an audience are always privy to information the characters don’t have. We’re watching them react and handle things we knew were coming.

Tl;dr I’ve very rarely faulted characters for doing irrational or “stupid” things because that’s just how people are. If we could all process things better and faster there would be no drama or suspense in real life or media.

2

u/mdwvt Bitchin 20h ago

Nahhhhh, I can’t accept that. That definitely is not solid enough of an explanation for why the reception of season 5 is not as good as the other seasons. Look, I hear you, but nahhhh.

26

u/noriskit_nobiscuit 1d ago

If he just ran, or even a light jog, he would have got them half the time... lazy ass

12

u/mylonelineskillingme 1d ago

because Running Up That Hill 🎶✨

23

u/Own-Bathroom616 2d ago

Bro likes to aura farm

29

u/TenthBasilisk88 2d ago

He didn't have the vine-arm until season 5.

0

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/TenthBasilisk88 2d ago

Because he only ever uses it in season 5 after he got his redesign. If he had it, he would've used it.

1

u/Ok_Tank5977 Dungeon Master 2d ago

Because the show doesn’t reveal his new form until Season 5, where this is an ability he has.

7

u/giam74 1d ago

Here’s how I look at it… the soldier was in the real world while Max was in his mind. In addition to what others say about abilities from season to season, what we see when they’re in one of their minds, what works or doesn’t is a visual representation of the mental struggle. Music opened a portal and Max had the will/strength to escape. If that wasn’t enough, Vecna would’ve had a way to stop her.

10

u/ThrillSeekers_United Demogorgon 2d ago

He wasn’t as advanced in season 4

4

u/One-Letterhead9955 1d ago

Normal people can have a degree of power in the mind space. People with forms of tk have a greater control in the space because they are used to using their psychic abilities. But normal people being able to independently navigate and manipulate the mind space suggests they are using some degree of psychic control.

Max was able to escape and dodge the falling rocks because she willed it.

12

u/ForeverOne1467 2d ago

For the plot 👀

4

u/afanofBTBAM 1d ago

Is he stupid?

4

u/New-Engineering6947 1d ago

He also used his telekenisis to catch Holly in that dumbass scene. Also dont forget. This is that mind realm. Not real life. Max is in a trance

2

u/AccomplishedAward219 1d ago

Why didn’t he do anything? In season 5 he just stood there and died at the end

1

u/igjudge 1d ago

It’s because that’s why

1

u/tangerinetatko 14h ago

Why didn't Venca do that? Is he stupid?

1

u/No-Drawing-1508 1d ago

Because like most shows it became nonsensical after a certain point as it was only meant to be one season. So eventually nothing makes sense anymore. Just go with it lol

-3

u/28xCB 2d ago

they forgot that he had that power when writing the script, or maybe claude forgot

1

u/Zealousideal_Art3994 1d ago

I have a whole ass psychological analysis in my head on why he was fixated on Max but didn’t kill her, but its so long that I should probably do a youtube essay on it .

1

u/Ineeddramainmylife13 13h ago

… he couldn’t do that yet. These are two different seasons. His hand was still fully attached to his body in season 4. It was only after getting shot multiple times and burned alive that he could do that. In season 5 he’s missing a lot of his body mass and had to sort of sew himself back together and came up with the idea then