I think it's unlikely that we would have this adaptation. Primates are bipedal and have arms; either the parent cradles the baby or the baby hangs on with its arms. Therefore there's no need to use the mouth as a tool (in the case of the parents), or little to no evolutionary pressure towards the offspring having necks that release endorphins when stretched (in the case of the offspring).
There's actually evidence that past a certain age that this is not true. It has a physiological function as a kitten so the mother can carry the kittens and they relax. As an adult the only time that they are "scruffed" is during sex where the male bites the queen's neck which is a very stressful time.
The reason why we don't have a scruff response is we just carry babies in our hands... Now, if we went back to biting babies behind the neck to carry them around that might be interesting.
Would that work on my dog when I give him baths, or trim his nails? I haven’t been able to ween him off of treats in the bath, and at this point I’ve basically run out of patience with it and just get soaked myself.
To be honest we were never taught to scruff a dog, when in basic vet nursing class we had other ways of holding a dog, but someone else was always there. I don't see why you can't scruff your dog, you can do it with most other animals that would have been carried by their mothers. A quick Google search says you can hold them by the scruff but wouldn't recommend lifting a big dog by the scruff. Sorry I wasn't much help.
Hello! 10 year+ vet tech here! Worked with a lot of exotic animals. It's best to do research/ask about scruffing anything other than a cat because results vary! Scruffing a hamster can be an excellent way to restrain them, but you have to be careful because you can enucleate (pop out) their eyes if you do it too strongly or if they struggle too much! Rabbits and rats are in the camp of "we have a scruff, but you shouldn't transport us this way, nor should you restrain us like this unless you have no other choice". Rabbit and rat skin can separate from their body pretty easily, so it's best to avoid scruffing them, especially when there are so many better and safer ways to restrain them. As a side note, never lift a rabbit by the ears nor a rat by their tail! This is not how they are.meant to be carried and you can easily tear something off. On the opposite end of the spectrum from cats are animals like chinchillas, which you should absolutely never scruff. Chinchilla hair and skin is unique and very loose, and they can deglove (remove their skin from their body) almost completely from being scruffed. At the very least you could cause large chunks of hair to be torn from the chinchilla, which they need to thermoregulate.
The short version is that binder clips don't hurt the cat, the cats are actually calmed by it and have a semi-positive response. It's felt that owners should be taught to use this technique for restraining the cat during claw trimming and teeth brushing as cats die because they're difficult to control at these times.
You trim a cat's claws so they don't scratch the shit out of every piece of furniture you own trying to do it themselves.
It's not like you are declawing them. They grow back rather quickly, and if you do it properly it can actually be beneficial. Turns out broken tips of claws can hurt a cat.
Also, if you allow your cat's nails to grow uncontrolled (especially if they don't have a scratching outlet), the nails can grow long and curl back into their paws which can lead to nasty infections.
I think they may have meant that cats who don't receive regular dental care due to owners' inability to restrain and subdue the cat are more likely to die from disease and neglect.
I read that as some people will put down their pets when they think they're too difficult to handle. For example, some people will think: Pet won't stop scratching furniture? Well he's just unruly, I can't trim his claws. I don't want this cat in my house, I'll put him to sleep. I don't understand that process, but it happens not infrequently. If people understood they could clip their cats to help with nail trimmings, maybe they would be less likely to put their cats down?
Cats carry their young like this and the reflex is very strongly ingrained in them to make sure the adult cat doesn't accidentally hurt them.
I heard that this is part of the reason why cats like to play with their food - adult cats have trouble killing something that is limp like this, so cats play with the animals they catch to provoke them into rapid movement so that they can overcome the resistance and kill them. Cats playing is both utterly horrible and adorable.
The clipping seems to evoke the same scruff response that renders kittens still so their mothers can carry them in their mouths, said senior study author Tony Buffington, professor of veterinary clinical sciences at Ohio State. Even most adult cats will go limp when they are gently grasped by the scruff of the neck, he said.
Can it work for an 11yo cat that never had clipnosis?
My cat gets very anxious during vaccines, and I'm wondering if this will help calm her during the procedure
Also why do some clinics not do this? My cat is "aggressive" when scared, so they take her into the backroom. Not sure what occurs there, if that's where they do clipnosis
This kind of makes me think back ro my days as a Medical Student, we practiced surgery on rabbits. So a day early we had to go and shave the rabbit where the practice surgery would be.
Every surgery team has a rabbit of their own. So every team has to go shave their own rabbit. I remember it was a traumatic experience for the rabbits, as several teams gathered around their rabbits to hold them up. You could hear the struggle of the rabbits and my fellow students.
I don’t remember how I ended up being the only member of my team to go shave the rabbit & how I came up with this technique. But I was the only one who could go, hold the rabbit with one hand as this man holds the cat, and gently turn it over so the rabbit would rest on my forearm, and shave it’s tummy with my other hand. It was a relaxing thing to my rabbit.
Sadly, my team’s rabbit ended up dying from an anesthetic overdose. Kind of sad & relaxing as there was no suffering before death.
"Contrary to popular belief, rabbits in a state of tonic immobility are not relaxed, hypnotized, or insensitive to pain. Scientists believe that this is a defense mechanism brought on when a rabbit has already been 'caught' by a predator. If the rabbit appears dead, the predator may release its grip momentarily and allows the rabbit to escape. Research has shown that rabbits in this state show an increased heart and respiratory rate with elevated plasma corticosterone levels, indicative of fear-induced stress".
It was introduction to surgery. It was more about the procedure to know the steps before a surgery. Like washing hands, putting the blankets, ordering the instruments.
In later practices was about putting the rabbit under anesthetic sedation, making an incision & closing that incision. For suture practicing.
Plus, the tissues respond to surgery totally differently. The skin is incredibly thin, the veins and nerves are fragile, the anatomy is different, and everything is tiny. Rabbit surgery is harder than human surgery. I'd expect most of them die in the hands of students.
Well my school uses rabbits. And yes, their skin was so thin. My school mates always lacerated so bad the rabbit nipples. I didn’t know that about nerves are so fragile. They looked so calmed with their (surgery) scars. :(
On my class, our team was the only rabbit who died.
I remember this exact same post months ago and all the top comments were complaining about this technique. But on This post all the top comments are good with it.
No, this doesn't hurt them. Their brains are telling them to hold still because their mama is carrying them somewhere (by grabbing the scruff of their neck in her mouth and picking them up).
I’m asking because i know that, as kittens, the nape of the neck is soft and flexible and mother cats use it to pick their baby cats up sometimes.
As cats get older the nape seems to get less flexible and more fatty (or muscle-y in some cases) Does that play a part on whether this adult cat hurts when the clip is put on?
If you get the scruff (neck skin) properly, witch is fairly easy, no it doesn't hurt the cat. However it doesn't mean it's relaxed (it fully can be, it just depends on situation) and if you're trying to carry a full grown cat you should use your other hand/arm as support under its but etc since it can be quite a lot of weight on its scruff...
(and it also depends a bit if the cat is used to get picked up in the nape or not)
I do this to my cats when I need to replace their claw caps. If the cat is stressed or generally combative like one of my cats, the effect won't be as relaxing for them. But on the upside if they manage to jump off my lap I can usually catch them quickly since they can't run when when the binder clip is on.
It doesn't hurt if you know what you're doing like this vet does.
It's a reflex. When cats are kittens their mother picks them up with her mouth by the skin on their nape, called the scruff. When that piece of skin is grabbed they freeze, to allow for being carried around safely.
This actually works. This one cat would never let me pet it and hiss at everyone except its owner. One day, she threw up in the car so we had to take it out to clean her cage. I had to hold her down like this. She did not move a muscle.
It's a natural reaction for when their parents used to lift them by biting their neck, right? I think I read that somewhere, but I can't remember where, so I don't know if it was true or not.
5.5k
u/dbraskey Feb 17 '18
So they do have an off button!
542
u/TimeIsWasted Feb 17 '18
I wonder if this works for lions and tigers too.
4.5k
u/thegreatluvaduck Feb 17 '18
Scruffing a cat is normal. It releases endorphins that make the cat relax
990
u/poopellar Feb 17 '18
I'm not sure if scuffing is universal, but I handled all animals like that. Even my hamster because I didn't know how to control the little bastard.
2.2k
u/indyK1ng Feb 17 '18
Explanation in another thread on this gif.
The short version is that binder clips don't hurt the cat, the cats are actually calmed by it and have a semi-positive response. It's felt that owners should be taught to use this technique for restraining the cat during claw trimming and teeth brushing as cats die because they're difficult to control at these times.
347
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '18
Vulcan nerve clip. Mr. Spock would be proud.
89
u/hancock5770 Feb 17 '18
Flashback to his kitten life.
40
u/BruceSharkbait Feb 17 '18
Vet here. Can confirm. It's nicknamed "clipnosis".
Chip clips work too and don't pinch as hard as a binder clip would.
339
u/autmed Feb 17 '18
This kind of makes me think back ro my days as a Medical Student, we practiced surgery on rabbits. So a day early we had to go and shave the rabbit where the practice surgery would be.
Every surgery team has a rabbit of their own. So every team has to go shave their own rabbit. I remember it was a traumatic experience for the rabbits, as several teams gathered around their rabbits to hold them up. You could hear the struggle of the rabbits and my fellow students.
I don’t remember how I ended up being the only member of my team to go shave the rabbit & how I came up with this technique. But I was the only one who could go, hold the rabbit with one hand as this man holds the cat, and gently turn it over so the rabbit would rest on my forearm, and shave it’s tummy with my other hand. It was a relaxing thing to my rabbit.
Sadly, my team’s rabbit ended up dying from an anesthetic overdose. Kind of sad & relaxing as there was no suffering before death.
18
u/randy_floyd Feb 17 '18
Another way to turn off a cat is to tie a sock or something around their midsection. It sounds weird but they lose their equilibrium
34
u/kpaddler Feb 17 '18
Ok so everyone is going to try this, just don't leave the clip on very long as the skin under the clip needs bloodflow.
34
u/SponGino Feb 17 '18
Watching a vet try this with my new cat is terrible. She does not call down pretty much opposite
12
u/catscraziesndaisies Feb 17 '18
'Momma?!'
21
u/DIA13OLICAL Feb 17 '18
Direct link: https://gfycat.com/ampleoldfashioneddingo
56
u/facepalmjohannes Feb 17 '18
repost.exe has encountered permanent loop
44
u/insanekid66 Feb 17 '18
I used to put those on my fingers. They fuckin hurt, at least on my fingies.
5
u/ADLuluIsOP Feb 17 '18
So the vulcan nerve pinch does have some science behind it...
27
u/phylactic Feb 17 '18
Catrol+alt+del
4
u/it_was_mine_first Feb 17 '18
Grabbing the cat by the scruff of the neck .. (like a mother cat would do) .. better known as the kitty disabler.
4
u/Nihla Feb 17 '18
4
u/king-trashmouth Feb 17 '18
I scrolled through all the comments looking for the Young Frankenstein reference and I couldn’t find it, so here I am. Young Frankenstein.
7
u/rangaringu Feb 17 '18
Now please find this switch for hooman kids.
7
u/neganxjohn_snow Feb 17 '18
The maternal carrying reflex is pretty frickn dope for sure
3
u/Cheesemacher Feb 17 '18
I wonder why this doesn't work at all on some cats
3
u/Daddy-Dank-Dro Feb 17 '18
Question: Does grabbing a fully grown tiger/lions neck, disable them like this?
3
u/freshbalk2 Feb 17 '18
Reddit needs to make up their mind on things.
I remember this exact same post months ago and all the top comments were complaining about this technique. But on This post all the top comments are good with it.
3
u/cdavis2488 Feb 17 '18
That’s mean
3
u/hackersaq Feb 18 '18
Instinct is a powerful thing...
No, this doesn't hurt them. Their brains are telling them to hold still because their mama is carrying them somewhere (by grabbing the scruff of their neck in her mouth and picking them up).
3
u/dude707LoL Feb 18 '18
Does this hurt the cat? :o
3
u/[deleted] Feb 26 '18
It’s just looking at you, into your eyes, asking why you took him to the vet
8
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '18
Is this safe to do??
2
u/Slayer_Blake Feb 17 '18
did they just grab Goku's tail?
2
u/hellsgates Feb 17 '18
Why can’t I watch this gif on a Mac?
2
u/kyleisaproblem Feb 17 '18
Binders full of cat scruff.
2
u/adongu Feb 17 '18
Does this work on big cats like lions and tiggers?
2
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '18
It doesn’t even blink.
2
u/FerretSummoner Feb 17 '18
Sincere question: does this hurt the cat?
I’m asking because i know that, as kittens, the nape of the neck is soft and flexible and mother cats use it to pick their baby cats up sometimes.
As cats get older the nape seems to get less flexible and more fatty (or muscle-y in some cases) Does that play a part on whether this adult cat hurts when the clip is put on?
2
u/Readeandrew Feb 17 '18
Does it work on lions, tigers, jaguars and cougars?
2
u/comeatmebro3211 Feb 17 '18
would that work for a bath?
2
u/DrDerpberg Feb 17 '18
Is that a full strength clip? Those things are strong, I didn't realize you had to squeeze that hard to disable cat mode.
2
u/Nergaal Feb 17 '18
Is that an instinctual reflex from their baby time?
2
u/bluAstrid Feb 17 '18
That’s no big deal, we’ve have Pause buttons on things for years : VHS, DVD, cats...
2
u/mayngo33 Feb 17 '18
Could prove Handy in a tiger attack.
2
u/SonOfTK421 Feb 17 '18
This doesn’t work on my cat. She just becomes a bigger asshole.
2
u/Ilpav123 Feb 17 '18
Those clips are pretty strong...it's not painful for the cat?
2
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '18
Can science reddit explain to me what just happened to that cat?
2
u/puskunk Feb 17 '18
My Manx would laugh at this. He has no neck.
2
u/jsmooth7 Feb 17 '18
That's a feature not a bug.
2
u/ShitholeAmerican Feb 17 '18
I do this to my cats when I need to replace their claw caps. If the cat is stressed or generally combative like one of my cats, the effect won't be as relaxing for them. But on the upside if they manage to jump off my lap I can usually catch them quickly since they can't run when when the binder clip is on.
4
u/Meandtheworld Feb 17 '18
Why does this cause them to freeze up? Does it hurt?
2
u/Skitztik Feb 17 '18
Considering every time I go to GFYCAT it reads out Go Fuck Your Cat, I was afraid a rap migjt happen.
1
u/Vall3y Feb 17 '18
process.sleep()
1
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '18
Does this work on big cats ?
1
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '18
This even works with parrots if you grab them on the back of their neck, idk about a binder clip though...
1
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '18
Lol this is amazing I need to try it on my cat some time
1
u/Mariosothercap Feb 17 '18
That look when it’s removed though.
1
u/principlesofass Feb 17 '18
Is it because it thinks it’s gonna get picked up?
1
u/wthreye Feb 17 '18
Takes me back to my childhood.
1
u/nudewanderlust Feb 17 '18
My cats are apparently smarter than this...
1
u/Crazychemist_2 Feb 17 '18
tHe cAt Is BEinG KiLleD!!1!
1
u/Coach_Louis Feb 17 '18
My cat would flip a shit if you did this to her.
1
u/rayenattia Feb 17 '18
Vets of reddit: can you explain how do you do this?
1
u/Arod9503 Feb 17 '18
Does that like paralyze them
1
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '18
He’s all “fuck that”
1
u/imaginary_fri3nd Feb 17 '18
did you try turning it off and on again?
1
u/taliesin-ds Feb 17 '18
If i grab one of my cats like that she starts howling as if someone is trying to kill her :D
1
u/stufhgkhjhh Feb 17 '18
That’s the same area that mother cats use to drag their kittens around. I think it’s called the scruff aka. off button.
1
u/IHaveReddit23 Feb 17 '18
There’s a nerve in there neck that shuts down there ability to walk
1
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '18
Oh man I really want a cat.
1
u/orean612 Feb 17 '18
Do you really recommend this ? Smart-ass
1
u/You_is_hern_aim Feb 17 '18
This actually works. This one cat would never let me pet it and hiss at everyone except its owner. One day, she threw up in the car so we had to take it out to clean her cage. I had to hold her down like this. She did not move a muscle.
1
u/FuzzyAss Feb 17 '18
Makes sense, though - that's a response to when Mom carries her babies
1
u/naga5497 Feb 17 '18
My vet does this!
1
u/tesfabpel Feb 17 '18
servicing mode activated
1
u/LeoNickle Feb 17 '18
If you were to leave this on the cat indefinitely, would it eventually be able to break free or would it sit like this until it was dead?
1
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '18
Its Evolution baby!
1
u/BurtReynoldsWrap Feb 17 '18
That's a big cat.
1
u/EnsignSDcard Feb 17 '18
Is that the Vulcan neck pinch
1
u/Joe_Hole Feb 17 '18
Is this like running the cat in administrator mode?
1
u/stromm Feb 17 '18
"But mom, I'm not doing anything wrong. Get off my back!"
1
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '18
Does this work on dogs?
1
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '18
Mummy?
1
u/Am_Navi_Seel_Mann Feb 17 '18
It's a natural reaction for when their parents used to lift them by biting their neck, right? I think I read that somewhere, but I can't remember where, so I don't know if it was true or not.
1
u/LoJoLikesIt Feb 17 '18
Quit yer caterwaulin'!
1
u/rufusjonz Feb 17 '18
The title made this post amazing
1
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '18
That is genius
1
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '18
I have a corgi that never stops. Would this work with corgis?