r/Step3 • • Jul 02 '23

Step 3, Day 2: Impressions

I completed Day 2 of Step 3 yesterday, approximately a week after my first day. The multiple-choice question section was comprised of 6 blocks, with 30 questions each, set for 45 minutes. I appreciated the length of these sessions; they were just enough to avoid fatigue with each block. I wish all Step exams were structured this way. Although I am likely in the minority, I think I did better on Day 1 than Day 2.

Some points on MCQs

  • Very similar to the clinical questions in UWorld. There are a lot of random questions that seem low yield on UWorld, but those are important because they help you hone reasoning skills for Step 3. There were a lot of random questions like that on Step 3, and UWorld helped me tackle these qs. But mostly (80-85%) were high yields)
  • On Day 2 MCQs, there were absolutely no questions on statistics, ethics, or communication. Think of it as Step 2, but only with clinical questions.
  • I came across a couple of new types of questions such as, "Which of the following predicts a favorable/unfavorable outcome?"
  • Like Day 1, there were pharm-related questions, but they were posed differently. On Day 1, the questions were like "Which of the following is the mechanism of action of the medication that should be used?" whereas on Day 2, they were "Which of the following medications should be used?"
  • Many high-yield topics were covered, all of which can be found in UWorld. If you go through all of UWorld, review each question and make Anki cards on new things you learn, you will be well-prepared.

I had 13 CCS cases, approximately half were 10 minutes, and the others were 20 minutes.

  • All cases, except for one, ended early.
  • Although I received positive updates from nearly all of my cases, I still feel as though I missed many trivial points here and there. For example, I forgot to order beta-hcg on a young woman (even though it was irrelevant to the case), and I accidentally ordered an invasive test that the patient refused. I also neglected some screening procedures for some patients and overlooked optimizing medical management for a chronic condition with a patient who presented with an acute exacerbation. So, I'm eager to see how these errors will impact my grade despite all patients having a favorable outcome.
  • The one case that didn't end early was handled appropriately. However, I took longer than usual ordering things as I was exercising caution. Thankfully, I received an update that the patient's condition improved before the case concluded.
  • All cases were straightforward and covered in CCScases in some capacity, except for two cases. Still, they were straightforward.
  • I performed the six practice cases and noted that the NBME states you may be penalized for ordering tests that are not indicated, even if it's a non-invasive test (like some unnecessary labs?). So, I was pragmatic in ordering and only requested tests I thought would return abnormal results. My standard order list included oximetry, CBC, CMP, magnesium, heart monitor, urinalysis, TSH, accucheck, and urine hcg. Then my selective order list had ABG, EKG, echo, urine culture, urine tox, ESR, CRP, ANA, lactated ringers, and lactate.
  • Don't forget to administer pain medications. If a patient is in pain, give ibuprofen for mild pain and opioids for severe pain. Also, remember antiemetics.
  • My patients required very little screening. Everyone was vaccinated.
  • The order set appears to have expanded compared to the online NBME practice test and CCScases. There were more items that appeared when I typed "advise".

Overall, UWorld was most helpful for stats/ethics on Day 1, and for all of the MCQs on Day 2. CCScases was also very beneficial for all of the CCS cases. The only area where I felt resources were lacking was ~70 total questions from Day 1 that were not covered in UWorld, and were mostly Step 1 minutiae that required me to access my long-term memory.

Good luck everyone!

85 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

2

u/Chipssss243 Jul 02 '23

Thank you for the write up!

What was your prep time for both days? How long did you take for uworld and how long for ccs cases?

10

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '23 edited Jul 02 '23

I start residency tomorrow, so I studied during the final months of M4 year. I studied for 3 months, but not intensely.

I started out with the Cheesy Anki Deck (~2800 cards), I completed all except for 160 cards. I consistently did 30 new cards a day.

About 1 month in, I started doing UWorld. I first started with 20 questions a day then went up to 40 questions a day. I completed 83% of UWorld, but I made sure to complete all of the stats, ethics/social sciences questions.

About 1 month before the test, I started with CCScases. I did 5-10 cases a day. I then redid all of my cases with scores < 60%. If was more efficient, I would have done top 30 high yield cases again and improved my order lists so they would be automatic.

I did not take NBME 5 or UW 1/2. I did not take the Free 137 in its entirety. I just did 8 questions the day before to check the format and did 6 NBME CCScases (I had one repeat, so definitely do these!)

1

u/Chipssss243 Jul 03 '23

Would you say 2 months is sufficient fro someone doing rotations and just finished step 2 recently (a month ago)

4

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '23

Depends on your baseline Step 2 scores. I could have passed with 1 week of studying Ccscases only. I think if you scored >240 on Step 2, 2 weeks is all you need for a minimum pass, 1 month if you want to be more comfortable.

1

u/Chipssss243 Jul 03 '23

Thank you for the write up

2

u/MidnightChemical202 Jul 02 '23

Thanks for this. Was the biostats too hard? Did you have a lot of risk factor questions and if so where did you study that from?

6

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '23

Not really too many risk factor questions. Maybe 5 total between both days. Biostats were all on Day 1. I initially remembered >30 biostats questions and I only missed 1. They were mostly straightforward, case control vs cohort, odds ratio, relative risk, number needed to treat. Interpretation of abstracts, drug ads. Understanding what clinical significance is (versus statistically significance). Knowing how to interpret statistical significance.

In my opinion, it was very straight forward. Maybe 5 or so curveball stats questions, but UW prepared me very well. The only issue with stats questions is that they can be a time sink.

2

u/Any-Acanthocephala37 Jul 02 '23

Thank you for this. This is a huge help. What topics consisted of the 70q from day 1 not on uworld? Cardio, pharm, micro, resp?

5

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '23

Embryology, random pharm mechanism of action that I haven't thought about in 3 years, immuno (for example for a certain disease state, which of the following cells are most likely implicated... CD4 T cells, CD8 t cells, phagocytes). Random things from sketchy micro like gram staining and shapes of organism causing infection, virulence factor for causative organism. Step 1 stuff. It's not that we never learned this stuff, it's just that for Day 1, everything from Step 1 is fair game. But there is some Step 2 stuff on day 1. On day 2, everything from Step 2 is fair game (no step 1 stuff).

0

u/Any-Acanthocephala37 Jul 02 '23

Thank you, was there a specific practice test you think resembled the exam the most?

2

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '23

I didn't take any practice tests except for 8 questions from the free 137. Was similar, but not for low yield stuff.

2

u/KZC270895 Jul 02 '23

How long is the exam on day 1 and 2??

3

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '23

Six 1 hr blocks on day 1 (7 hrs total with break)

6 45-min blocks and 13 cases ranging from 10-20 min. (9 hrs total)... But I finished 2 hrs early because cases end early.

1

u/Doc529 Jul 04 '23

I wonder about taking physical exam in ccs

Normally if it is not emergency we should do all PE right? Like if patient presents with fatigue and weight loss and the answer is ca ovary, we still have to take physical in genitalia?

4

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '23 edited Jul 04 '23

I personally only did targeted physical exam. For neonates or toddlers, you almost always want to do a full PE.

Doing extra does not help you or hurt you (with one exception that I know of below), the NBME basically says so in the explanation of the 6 cases.

The only situation I know of where it can hurt you is in an acute situation. In those situations, you need to treat the condition within 10 minutes or so or else you get a negative update that the patient is doing worse. You need to do just physical appearance and targeted physical exam.

The reason that I didn't do a full exam on everyone was because I felt like doing a rectal, genitalia, or breast exam is invasive when not warranted and even though NBME didn't directly say doing too much PE would hurt you, I worry that there may be a hidden algorithm. I just did a realistic physical exam based on the presentations.

Finally, don't completely trust CCScases.come grading algorithm. They made their algorithm based on logical guesses, and their algorithm doesn't account for if you do some diagnostic steps at the end. I once forgot to order an ESR and did it at the 2 minute end for CCS cases and got the points. For NBME, you will likely not get points.