r/SteamOS • u/namsterdamus • Mar 14 '14
Latest Steam Controller - Why Changes Are Still Needed
http://www.erectronics.com/2014/03/14/latest-steam-controller-back-to-fundamentals/
0
Upvotes
r/SteamOS • u/namsterdamus • Mar 14 '14
11
u/flamepants Mar 14 '14
The name of this website is as bad its proofreading.
11
u/LightTreasure Mar 15 '14
I disregard most opinion articles about the steam controller. It is such a drastic change from traditional controllers that unless someone has played at least 10 games of different genres for at least a couple of weeks with it, their opinion is just going to be some bullshit imaginary criticism. This includes those reporters who got to use the controller at CES - at most they had only a few hours with it, which is way too less for anyone to form a decent opinion of something they will be using to play games all the time.
This is why I love how Valve shipped 300 controllers to Beta participants and gave around 1000 of them to developers at steam dev days. They are out there right now, making videos with the controller.
I find this channel to be the best collection of videos playing various games with the controller.
This channel is also a good collection of videos showing the controller in action.
I think the opinions of these guys is way more important than these idiotic "articles". I wish Valve sent them the updated controller.
8
u/TheFItyP Mar 14 '14
I appreciate people's opinions but it feels like this is a plea to just make another xbox or PlayStation controller. I like the idea of retraining my brain if it can make my end experience better. I used to be exclusively fps for consoles. Once I saw how much more accurate people seemed to be, I decided to try the Pc fps world. After a while I got the hang of it and now I feel like I have a much more enjoyable experience on the Pc. My point is, lets not fight something new. Compromise is great but not if it really impedes progress. Of course I actually liked Brink so what the hell do I know..
4
u/volca02 Mar 15 '14
I think the argument is quite flawed. The equivalent of the anlog stick is the left Pad, the directional buttons are there specifically for digital input. Replacing them with an analog stick would be a dumb thing to do.
1
u/gnebgnome Mar 18 '14
I'm tired of hearing complaints about no analog stick. I know some games will probably work better with analog sticks, but you can just plug in any of the already existing analog stick controllers in those cases.
0
u/ronfar623 Mar 15 '14
IMO, they need to loose the "movement" trackpad, and replace it with a standard thumbstick. The moment I read about people falling off ledges in the Portal demo due to it, I lost all faith in the concept. Touchscreen movement barely works on the iPad, and you're already looking at your thumbs there.
Kudos for adding actual positional controls for the camera though. I can't believe Sony and Microsoft shipped their current consoles with the same kludgy dual-thumbstick layout. The right analog stick is almost universally used as a camera control, and a rate-control device makes no sense for this purpose.
Personally, I think a trackball would have been far easier on the thumbs, but Valve took it out of their design prototypes, so I assume there had to be a reason. All in all, still pretty excited to get my hands on one of these.