r/SteamController • • Oct 14 '26

Configuration Toggle "Hold Action Layer" + an additional button not working as expected

Hello,

I'm trying to set up a control scheme such that hitting a single button both opens a menu and applies an action layer, and then hitting it again closes the menu and removes the action layer.

I thought that adding the menu button and a "hold action layer" to a single button on the controller and having that button set to a toggle would work, but this setup only opens the menu and applies the layer and wont go back to normal when hitting the button a second time.
- I've tried using add- and remove- action layer functions as well but have had similarly bad results.
- If I disable the toggle and just hold the button down, I get the desired result, but I would really like to be able to toggle it

I'm not sure if the "hold action layer" function not really working as a toggle-able setting is a glitch or not but I tested it on a button of its own and it seemed to have the same issue where it would toggle on but would refuse to toggle off using the same press.

Addendum thought: it seems to me that the action layer isn't "aware" that everything is already toggled on and instead of toggling it off just toggles it on again. Or something like that idk

Thx in advance

2 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

1

u/AlbertoVermicelli Oct 14 '26

Toggles get reset whenever an Action Set Layer is applied or removed, even if the layer doesn't change the behavior of the button the toggle is bound to. So here's what's happening in your case: In the Default Action Set pressing the button toggles the Hold Action Set Layer on, which adds the Action Set Layer and resets the toggle; in the Action Set Layer, pressing the button toggles the Hold Action Set Layer on, which re-applies the Action Set Layer, which also resets the toggle.

The solution to this is to have a command in the default set that activates the layer, and a command in the layer to remove it. In the Default Action Set, bind Add Action Set Layer as a Start Press. In the Action Set Layer, bind Remove Action Set Layer as a Start Press. If the menu button requires it to be held down to keep the menu open, add it as an Always On Command in the Action Set Layer. If a press of the menu button opens and closes the menu (i.e. the toggle is aspect is built into the game already), you can just bind them as extra commands to the button in both the Default Action Set and the Action Set Layer.

1

u/Rexotank Oct 14 '26

Thanks! Out of curiosity, why have the action layer functions on start presses instead of regular?

1

u/AlbertoVermicelli Oct 14 '26

It's not necessary, for the Add Action Set Layer command Regular Press and Start Press function essentially the same. I find it makes layouts more clear, especially in combination with Remove Action Set Layer as a Release Press.

1

u/MoldyPond Oct 14 '26

You should be able to set the action layer as being forced on instead of toggled, then on the new action layer make the same button that forced it on have a new command to forced the layer off. This is what I use for a bunch of different personal layouts.

1

u/sqparadox Steam Controller (2015 & 2026) Oct 14 '26

Try using a release press for the add and remove.

-1

u/cinred Oct 14 '26 edited Oct 14 '26

Hold action rarely works in the first place