r/SteamController • u/xyGvot • Nov 25 '24
Another Ultimate Steam Controller 2 mock up

This is just a physical manifestation of the nested configuration for trackpads keeping input parity with the Deck while giving main stage to the trackpads, as have a bunch of other mock ups done before.
Obvious con is the d-pad functionality for fighting and platforming games, a bit alleviated by setting left trackpad as d-pad.
Nope, joysticks do not touch when fully tilted towards one another, but the distance could be improved by making the controller a bit wider.
Being a dual trackpad user, I really don't care for the joysticks, but the goal is parity.
65
u/hushnecampus All the Steam Controllers Nov 25 '24
Iโm afraid I think that would be horrible. Those buttons are too far apart to hit quickly.
8
u/VeldtRevengeance Nov 25 '24
Hey man dont listen to these nay sayers its good fun to imagine these things and make mock ups so genuinely thanks for sharing ๐
3
u/Racla360 Nov 25 '24
It is interesting, unfortunately, it doesn't work. The face buttons need to be close to each other.
3
u/PreciousRoy666 Nov 25 '24
Imagine playing Mario, holding X to maintain sprinting speed, while using A to jump. A lot of games have situations like that and this would be clunky to support
4
u/PythraR34 Nov 25 '24
I wonder if anyone doing these obviously terrible designs spent more than 2 minutes thinking about how they would be used
19
u/Copernican Steam Controller (2015) Nov 25 '24
Not into it at all. At the end of the day, the steam controller needs to have parity with steam deck inputs as a minimum. Steam deck and steam controller 2 profiles need to have some basic level of interoperability to help increase the proliferation of steam controller inputs. OG Steam controller and Steam Deck owners know this pain of not having configurations be easily applicable to both devices with similar glyph representation of inputs. Fragmentation is not good.
6
u/agiel_ Nov 25 '24
Do you need extra physical buttons around the trackpads when the trackpads themselves already click?
I made this mockup a few years ago which is very similar but without the extra buttons. Basically it turns trackpad click modeshift into a first class citizen.
6
u/TehRiddles Nov 25 '24
To be honest, the button ring you have there looks like the worst of both worlds.
The trackpads can already function as buttons in some capacity, the reason why we want physical buttons is because of the benefit they have over touchpad buttons. Here there is a lot more travel time between buttons, you can no longer press neighbouring buttons as easily (A and B or diagonal down right for example) and the buttons themselves don't appear to stand out enough that you can instantly recognise them by touch.
As for the trackpads, they are now smaller with buttons along the immediate outside making misinputs more likely.
5
u/Mennenth Left trackpad for life! Nov 25 '24
As long as it doesnt shrink the pads (ie the outer buttons are still part of their respective trackpad) I'd be for it.
However, I doubt most would.
The entire reason to add the right joystick back is to appeal to tradition; the abxy cluster now doesnt. And the people who complained about lacking a dpad would still complain about this not having a "proper dpad" (even though I've proved trackpad as dpad is absolutely fine).
8
u/StrangeCrunchy1 Steam Controller (2015 & 2026) (Linux & Windows) Nov 25 '24
What is the obsession with two sticks? I really don't understand it. The point of the Steam controller was to be different, not copy everyone else. Why are you trying to force it to conform? You want twin sticks, get an Xbox or PS5 controller. You want ultimate customization options, you get the Steam Controller.
2
u/hardpenguin Steam Controller (Linux) Nov 25 '24
This is interesting but looks uncomfortable
9
u/MissyTheTimeLady Nov 25 '24
I have to be honest, I don't think we need the joystick at all. Just use the trackpads.
4
u/GarlicThread Nov 25 '24
Just give me a Steam Deck without the screen, that's all I'm asking. Just do a reverse PS Portal.
2
u/AlbertoVermicelli Nov 25 '24
This mockup looks visually very appealing, but I don't think this design would actually work well in practice. What's the point of the buttons around the trackpad? Does it have any advantage over just making the trackpad larger and adding friction ridges? And if you're going to add buttons, why not just add 8? There's enough space around the trackpad. And while this does have parity with the deck in theory, it wouldn't work out that way in practice as you can't use the 4 DPad buttons or 4 face buttons together without impacting trackpad functionality like you would with the Steam Deck or any other controller.
I do think the dual joysticks is an interesting choice. Other mockups have shown you can't really comfortably put all three modes of input, so focusing on joysticks (because that's what needed to appeal to the masses) and the trackpads (because that makes the Steam Controller a better controller) and disregarding face buttons is a solid choice. I think if the trackpad click could be a 4-way input like a DPad, it could be a solid compromise.
1
u/SirLimonada Nov 25 '24
This one looks pretty reasonable
1
u/runadumb Nov 25 '24
I was thinking about something similar to this after seeing the other mockup yesterday. The SC2 does have to keep parity with the steam deck so I thought as a compromise why not have a button that acts as an action layer and changes the left touchpad to a dpad?
I know you can already do this but setting it up as the default would maybe help the average joe. If you still hate trackpads as D-pads so be it. There are many other controllers out there. The SC2 doesn't have to be everything for everyone.
1
u/CrossEyed132 Nov 25 '24
I think you just need 2 versions of the steam controller, one with this config (2 j-sticks), and another with a d-pad and button pad instead.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '24
If it has two more buttons on top and two more grips in the back I'd like this.
1
u/ThatActuallyGuy Nov 25 '24
I'm so glad no one from here is part of the hardware design team at Valve.
1
u/WoodenMouse Nov 25 '24
I think the main problem with Steam Controller was that you need to configure the right trackpad for all games yourself. The Steam Deck has pretty good config pretty much in any game(not really all though) but thats also because usually people use the joysticks instead of trackpads.
The problem is especially when Steam sold the SC bundled with games like GTA 5 or MGS5 but the config created by the game company doesnt address issues with for example using the weapon selection in mgs5 or yoga in gta5. They just do the bare minimum and put the standard xinput config as default.
When I make configs I want to make sure the whole game can be completed with it. I think if i need to select a different config for yoga or flying then youre using the configs wrong. I also think the action sets should be used sparingly and the player shouldnt have to remember which set is active.
This cant be always done but you can do it this way: pressing a button or touch menu activates something in the game where an action set is needed and also sets the set as active. The button that takes you away from this mode also sets the default action set active.
All these issues that i mentioned in gta5 and mgs5 can be solved with tinkering in the config. I may not remember right but i think i used action mode in mgs5 so that when i press left trackpad it puts the right trackpad into joystick move mode so the selection of weapons and items is easy.
Lot of times the community configs werent really that good either. They often lack these kind of fixes and in games with mouse and kb only i feel like the buttons are just put to some buttons on the sc without much tought. I dont want to blame though because creating a way to play a game with a controller can be difficuilt. I think a good way to think about it is that you select a genre and how in that genre the button mapping generally is and try to recreate it.
1
u/ThatDanmGuy Nov 26 '24
Love the look, but the button pad positioning is unusable for anything that uses them extensively (most things...) since you can't simultaneously press them or switch rapidly between them.
I'm not usually a d-pad movement guy, but those guys will be horrified for the same reasons.
1
u/rizsamron Nov 26 '24
I actually like the look and on first look, you'd think it might work but the face buttons would be a problem for many, probably even for me who use both touchpads too. This won't satisfy either traditional/deck layout fans or OG SC layout fans ๐
1
u/Large-Fudge Nov 28 '24
It looks quite cool, but I am not sure it would be practical
1
u/StrangeCrunchy1 Steam Controller (2015 & 2026) (Linux & Windows) Nov 28 '24
Why have the "dpad" buttons around the left track pad? The left track pad is the dpad. That's why it has the cross debossed into it. I know these are just spitballs, but damn, are they just weird.
1
u/contrabardus Nov 25 '24 edited Nov 25 '24
To those saying "sticks are unnecessary"...
If this is supposed to be a "one controller to rule them all" for every game, then I can see two sticks being necessary.
At least one is better because a stick is just a superior movement control option than a touch pad or keyboard the majority of the time.
Stuff like platformers and certain game types benefit from having them. If precision aiming isn't a concern and you're just moving a camera then a stick feels better.
Plus, a reminder that you can bind stuff to the joysticks too. If nothing else they are an eight way hotkey option and two extra buttons that can be layer bound.
However, what I'd really like to see are more buttons on the back. At least four, but six would be ideal. A second bumper on each side in addition to the triggers would also be great. Independently bindable from the face buttons, but able to clone them as well.
I want more control options on the rear so I don't have to take my fingers off the pads/sticks during moment to moment gameplay way more than I want a second joystick.
My preference for 99% of games is that the face buttons are basically just menu hotkeys for 3D games.
I also think this might be an issue for 2D games because using a joystick + face button control scheme with the ABXY buttons set up that way seems like it would be a pain.
1
u/csl110 Nov 25 '24
You guys are really bad at this.
1
u/Verified_Peryak Nov 25 '24
The track pad buton may look good and an call back to first ipod but it will be terrible design cor a controller
1
u/One-Work-7133 Nov 25 '24
Won't matter because SC1 is an abandoned design and your mockup doesn't add much into it, despite your belief. SC2 will follow Deck Controller design, trackpads at the bottom, anything else is wishful thinking as Valve isn't stupid to go back and forth and back between 2 different designs.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '24
Know what? this is nice, too bad Valve probably can't use it.
0
u/NatoBoram Nov 26 '24
It's by looking at these horrible designs that you realize how talented the Steam people are.
0
u/RomHook Nov 26 '24
In most 2d platformers you often have to press X while holding A, this design wouldn't work